5 ms·
I like the Onion. But some of the Babylon Bee 'satire' I see shared around is basically indistinguishable from 'fake news' since the audience has already been p
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I like the Onion. But some of the Babylon Bee 'satire' I see shared around is basically indistinguishable from 'fake news' since the audience has already been primed with fake news.
I don't really see any harm in having some kind of safeword for fake news, when no deception is intended, similar to the 555 phone numbers in films, something that tips you off if presented out of context.
I'm sure I've seen several sub-reddits where satire submissions need tagged because otherwise the conversation is derailed by people who don't understand the satire.
Almost every "this is why the libs are crazy" style comment I see here on HN is a response to a satire comment from someone who they agree with politically.
Satire is great, inventing a shared false reality by accident is less cool.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AteTheOnion/comments/rx0kbw/people_getting_stung_by_babylon_bee/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AteTheOnion/comments/rx0kbw/people_...
- revolvingocelot 4y agoYou think they're doing this by accident?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYeah, there's some trolls but the Babylon Bee folk seem to be genuine, as far as I can tell, even though I find their content unpleasant, unfunny and dangerous even as satire: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2021/06/babylon-bee-satire-from-right.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2021/06/babylon-bee-sati...
- junofan 4y agoDangerous? Come on.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYes. https://babylonbee.com/news/are-you-a-fascist-know-the-signs https://babylonbee.com/news/are-you-a-fascist-know-the-signs Is this satire or are they just genuinely angry about stuff that isn't really happening? Hard to tell. > You have more than one kid and you love being a parent: Dedication to the family is a distraction from service to the state. Just abort, you fascist – don't you want to be liberated?
- theflyingelvis 4y agoThat’s actually pretty humorous
- iinnPP 4y agoIt's very clearly satire and not dangerous. I have a very serious question for anyone pushing a limit on free speech: where does it end? My answer is that the Right will dictate the limits to speech, not the Left. Stop pushing for this. It will end poorly for everyone. The people who are already suffering will be the hardest hit.
- DoctorOW 4y agoBabylon Bee is probably among the least dangerous of modern conservatism. Babylon Bee writers themselves have been known to admit they have a really hard time writing anything decent. Their market is conservatives, not fans of humor. As such, any This is because the secret to humor is surprise. Look at the quote you used. Did anyone not see the headline and not put together it'd be the usual "The real fascism" talking points?
- refurb 4y agoI mean that's clearly satire by the very fact they are calling their readers fascists. Or do you think people read that and say "oh yeah, I guess I am a fascist!"
- swivelmaster 4y agoThis is dangerously lazy comedy writing, I’ll give it that. When it does take a turn though, it appears that they really do believe that Biden supporters are literally murdering Trump voters in the streets. Or they want their readers to believe it. The thing is, when you’re writing comedy and you break the fourth wall to say “okay here’s what I actually think,” as this article does, you’re no longer in parody territory if most of what you say is exactly what a common person believes. Mixing in satire that sounds exactly like fascist propaganda is pretty transparently manipulative.
- someguy5344523 4y ago
- nyokodo 4y ago> I find their content …dangerous even as satire This is precisely why we need strong protections for satirists from those who are so insecure in their positions and beliefs that they respond to satire like it’s threatening.
- isleyaardvark 4y agoBoth satire and free speech in general can be dangerous. edit: I don’t understand why people are downvoting a simple statement of undeniable fact. Do I need to mention that doesn’t mean I am in favor of government intervention?
- refurb 4y agoExactly. No different than "picking quarrels and provoking trouble".
- revolvingocelot 4y agoIf anyone is interested in what that means, it appears to be China's version of "resisting arrest" and "assaulting an officer": a spurious, ill-defined charge with which the inconvenient could be bludgeoned. What the parent comment means by referencing this phenomenon, which already has an Occidental analogue, is still unclear to me.
- refurb 4y agoIt's basically China's version of "free speech is dangerous". Whenever someone starts saying things the CCP doesn't like, they are "fomenting dissent". What people don't get is if you want to start censoring "dangerous speech" then you'd better have a perfect definition of what dangerous speech is. But there isn't one. So what ends up happening is you ban speech with good reason, set a precedent, then your political opponent takes power and starts banning speech as well.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI'll provide the counterpoint and say satire and speech are not dangerous. Nobody is directly hurt by it. It can be involved in a causal chain that leads to harm, but so can everything. If you contend that speech is dangerous because it can lead to harm, then language itself is dangerous because it can lead to speech. For that matter air is dangerous, because it facilitates language.
- davidro80 4y ago
- linuxftw 4y agoThat's the subtle purpose of the BB. The modern world is so ridiculous, it's impossible to tell satire from reality. How is this any different than memes? Memes are created by lots of people and spread around the internet, true or false. Don't trust things you read on the internet, how hard is that?
- factsarelolz 4y agoThen people would actually have to take responsibility for their actions or agency.
- _fat_santa 4y ago> I don't really see any harm in having some kind of safeword for fake news, when no deception is intended, similar to the 555 phone numbers in films, something that tips you off if presented out of context. The safeword is in the title: The Babylon Bee. Yes some people will mistaken the Bee for real news just like some people mistake the Onion for real news. Personally I think that calling the Onion ok while saying the Bee is not because of your political views is disingenuous.
- jacobolus 4y ago> The safeword is in the title: The Babylon Bee Yep. The Babylon Bee is sort of “double satire”: that is, it is an (unintentional) parody of a satirical newspaper, which at first glance looks like a joke before you read more closely and realize that the authors are barely literate and without a sense of humor. Like a written analog of Ben Garrison cartoons. We get such gems as Amazon Blows Entire $1 Billion 'Rings Of Power' Budget On Making It Look Like A Woman Can Hold A Sword; Russian Spy Awarded Presidential Medal Of Freedom For Being First Openly Transgender Traitor To Country; Biden Vows Next Hurricane To Hit US Will Be Named After A Woman Of Color; 'Did God Really Say You Shouldn't Kill Your Baby?' Hisses Slithering Newsom To Frightened Pregnant Woman; Pelosi Drafts Articles Of Impeachment Against New Prime Minister Of Italy; Stacey Abrams Claims Obesity Is Just Numbers Manufactured By Her Bathroom Scale; Disney Chooses Bald Actress To Play Rapunzel In Live-Action Remake; Where Are They Now? Catch Up With All Your Favorite Laid-Off CNN Employees! ... Even incompetent and tasteless parody is still clearly speech protected by the first amendment, as the Onion brief author explains.
- _fat_santa 4y ago> which at first glance looks like a joke before you realize that all of the authors are barely literate and entirely without a sense of humor You just don't find their humor funny and that's fine.
- bena 4y agoWhat's funny about the thing linked to? The satirical claim is that Applebee's is banning Greene from to go online ordering. Where's the joke? Is the joke simply a company is being mean to a Republican? This is one of those things in the realm of "I know it didn't happen but it's totally something they would do" except that it never happens. Is it commentary to the story that a completely unrelated restaurant continued to impose a vaccine mandate despite being called out on twitter by Greene? If so, how? That's the Bee's problem, most of their jokes aren't. They're really just mostly insults. And they really only insult one type of person. Whereas, I can go to The Onion and tell you why https://www.theonion.com/high-schoolers-given-detention-for-cutting-class-during-1849609270 https://www.theonion.com/high-schoolers-given-detention-for-... is funny and/or satirical without even getting into the actual article. American schools are ridiculously strict and also the subject of way too many shootings. Even the fact of considering the act of fleeing from a shooter as "cutting class" is just outrageous. It's taking things that have actually happened, slightly exaggerating them, and then combining them into something that is too absurd to be believed.
- yieldcrv 4y agoDoesn’t sound like an actionable issue to involve the government. Just like the 555 number, thats just an industry norm.
- TeeMassive 4y agoOr it may be because the people and groups they made fun of over the years have clowned themselves by doing the very thing they were mocked for. "NotTheBee" exists for a good reason. Also how being ridiculed for falling for a satire article not instructive about checking sources? It's not like The Bee is an obscure propaganda state operated website.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNotTheBee is even scarier glimpse into their psyche: https://notthebee.com/ https://notthebee.com/ Is that an official sister site? Apparently so: > Not the Bee is a humor-based news, opinion, and entertainment site from the creators of The Babylon Bee and Disrn. Like the name suggests, it'll feature some absurd and hilarious (but real) news that seems like it should definitely be satire. Hmm, this actually explains a lot about their jokes: > Yes ladies and gentlemen, abortion is now illegal in Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, and Mississippi, so Planned Parenthood is on the move, literally driving their RV along the Illinois border looking for babies to kill. ... > These people will do anything to get their hands on a preborn child
- TeeMassive 4y agoWas this parody or an actual opinion? It is no secret that the Bee has a conservative take on their satire pieces. Armchair psychoanalysis based on a single political opinion, in this case abortion, is simply sloppy. Just because you and I don't agree with them don't make them "deranged" or "dangerous". The fact that you base presumably serious opinion on their psyche, implying they are "dangerous" is more telling about your way of thinking than theirs.
- mikkergp 4y agoIt's Malcom Gladwell so take it with a grain of salt, but his episode on The Satire Paradox was great: https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/revisionist-history/the-satire-paradox https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/revisionist-history/the-sati... The premise is that despite Satire being an attempt at speaking truth to power, the people who are targets of satire will often think to themselves "I get that it's satire, but don't they make good points". I don't know that I've actually seen this in real life, but he mentioned lots of conservatives liked the Colbert Report because despite knowing it was making fun of them, they agreed with the messages. I've seen this with myself in Portlandia. I live in Portland, and while I'm not a stereotype of a hipster, I moved to Portland for the "reasons people move to Portland" and I often find Portlandia sketches manage to capture the essence of the very things they're trying to make fun of. Ultimately I don't think people taking the bee seriously is a bug, it's a feature.
- beej71 4y ago> I don't really see any harm in having some kind of safeword for fake news They address this: "Third, the Sixth Circuit’s ruling imperils an ancient form of discourse. The court’s decision suggests that parodists are in the clear only if they pop the balloon in advance by warning their audience that their parody is not true. But some forms of comedy don’t work unless the comedian is able to tell the joke with a straight face. Parody is the quintessential example. Parodists intentionally inhabit the rhetorical form of their target in order to exaggerate or implode it--and by doing so demonstrate the target’s illogic or absurdity." Plus First Amendment issues, and implementation details. If I make one satirical statement in an otherwise non-satirical essay, must I tag that sentence? Must all "it should have been clear I was joking" statements be tagged to avoid the risk of running afoul the law? It's a serious can of worms.
- daanlo 4y agoYou should read the onion pdf. It explains why the safe word would break the linguistic tool of parody. It is the initial/doubt in the readers the kind of „wait what???“-effect that is the essence of the parody.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI read it and didn't agree with it. When I'm on the Onion site or reading one of their books, I know it's the Onion. That doesn't make it less funny.