10 ms·
Privacy.com is not about hiding your identity from authorities. It's mostly about hiding the fact that the same person, you, are paying to merchant A and merch
by nine_k 4y ago
Privacy.com is not about hiding your identity from authorities.
It's mostly about hiding the fact that the same person, you, are paying to merchant A and merchant B. It allows you to easily have a card per merchant, and lock it to the merchant so that when its number is stolen, it can't be used anywhere else.
The domain name is a bit lofty, yes.
- DerekBickerton 4y agoThe name is doublespeak and not concerned with privacy as an ideal, it's really just to manage CCs in a sane way, like using a CC once and then disposing of it so you don't get unexpected charges. Also it limits the blast radius if a vendor gets breached and your legal name is not exposed. (So you need to sacrifice your privacy to privacy.com to get privacy on other vendors). They need to rebrand as 'SaneCard' or something similar.
- junon 4y agoNo, they don't. One of the main features is being able to put in any billing information you want and they'll accept it. Typically a bank will validate the name and sometimes the address against your account on file. Privacy ignores it. This IS a privacy enhancement in many cases.
- twelve40 4y agoNope. You have to go through KYC with them, give them your address, last 4 of social, dob, and yes, I got stuck on identity check too. Just because it didn't happen to you, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
- junon 4y agoYou misread my comment. When I check out on a website using a card generated by Privacy.com, I can put any billing information into the checkout form on the site.
- prophesi 4y agoHuh, I've been using privacy.com and had no idea about this. Thanks! Keeping the blast radius of leaked billing info to privacy.com instead of a myriad of merchants sounds like a good deal.
- DerekBickerton 4y agoThis. You have to waive your privacy to privacy.com to get privacy on vendors/merchants. If I lived in the US I would happily waive it to privacy.com, since I buy stuff on e-commerce sites a lot. Enough times that I would be pissed if my personal info got leaked. Also being able to manage my card and lock it to specific vendors is sorely needed and should be a feature on all CC providers.
- junon 4y agoPrivacy is not binary though. It's not "either you have complete privacy, or none".
- d4a 4y agoAuthor here. My concern wasn't that Privacy.com knows who is using their service, but with rather how they choose to know that information through a third party (Onfido) and how terrible Onfido's privacy policy is.
- junon 4y agoThen why drop a steaming pile of shit on the company who's not directly at fault via the title? For clickbait? I've used privacy.com for years. Never had an issue. Never had to validate my identity. Never had any issues with support. If used as prescribed (setting limits on cards etc) it fits in directly to where it belongs in my threat model. What a strangely charged article.
- croes 4y agoSo it wasn't privacy.com who chose Onfido? If your contractor chooses a bad subcontractor, who do you blame?
- withinrafael 4y agoNot directly at fault? Privacy.com chose to use Onfido. I don't think the author's complaint is misplaced.
- junon 4y agoUsing a company and having proper contracts and agreements with them to be properly protected is not malice, especially since the company is well known and assumedly adheres to regulation. I'm not sure what you want privacy.com to do differently.
- flutas 4y ago>It allows you to easily have a card per merchant, and lock it to the merchant so that when its number is stolen, it can't be used anywhere else. In my experience even that can fail. I had a card number stolen from them, charged to the tune of $200+, and their support refused to even entertain the idea of it being fraud, and when I mentioned a chargeback they basically said "we don't do those, because we have contracts with vendors." A payment stop at the bank sure worked though.
- jrochkind1 4y agoWoah, that is concerning. Making it harder, rather than easier, to chargeback fraudulent uses is not what I'm looking for.
- flutas 4y ago> Making it harder, rather than easier, to chargeback fraudulent uses is not what I'm looking for. Honestly I'm still confused by the whole thing. I told them that it was a fraudulent transaction that I didn't approve, they then kept asking me for tracking numbers and finally closed the support ticket, and would close any further ones instantly on me with this reply. https://i.imgur.com/EyjCGiU.png https://i.imgur.com/EyjCGiU.png Never mind the fact that it was a completely separate issue than what they would keep replying to me about, the fact that they included the line of > At this point, the only possibility is that the shipment was stolen after the delivery. This is no longer a case where the merchant is at fault. Hence, the case would be concluded in the merchant's favor. is a complete disregard for visa's rules. The fact that they wouldn't even let me open a dispute is the biggest factor of "wtf" here to me.
- badRNG 4y ago>is a complete disregard for visa's rules Visa is probably easier to deal with in the case of fraud than what it sounds like privacy.com is like. I use a single CC for everything (that I'm willing to pay with a CC for.) It's been compromised to the point that charges went through 2-3 times over the past decade and a half. CC company caught the fraud each time, automatically charged-back each of the fraudulent transactions, and overnighted me a new card. They also moved all of my recurring charges to my new card (somehow.) From what I understand, all of the big 4 CC companies operate more or less the same in this regard. This thread has eliminated the chance of me using Privacy.com in the future. If they can't make dealing with fraud at least as easy as a regular CC (which is quite painless, there's no reason to use them.
- voxleone 4y ago[flagged]
- gruez 4y ago>It's mostly about hiding the fact that the same person, you, are paying to merchant A and merchant B. What merchants out there are cross-correlating credit card numbers to deanonymize people? Can you even do it in a way that's PCI compliant? If you're actually interested in preventing random merchants from tracking you, I think credit card numbers are the least of your worries. Your billing/shipping information, which is almost always collected is much more revealing about you and can't be anonymized. Given this I do think the name of "privacy".com is misleading. At best it's stopunauthorizedcharges.com.
- junon 4y agoThat's not what it's about. It's the same reason why you use many passwords across all your sites. If one is breached, using privacy.com means your card information is not globally vulnerable to the point you have to get a new card, invalidate all your old ones, worry about personal information being correlated etc.
- wstuartcl 4y agoBack in the GPU scalping-craziness days of covid many online vendors limited purchases to 1 per household and that limit was enforced by full name, zip and billing address. With privacy you could generate one time use cards and use random names and fake apartment numbers in the billing address getting past the limit.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoYeah, my main use of Privacy.com has been with web payment portals that look old/unmaintained or otherwise untrustworthy (surprisingly common with state government sites). If there’s a better option for this use case I’m all ears, though. Reading sibling comments that Privacy won’t actually stop charges past set limits is disconcerting.