3 ms·
How is tracking all URLs half as bad as a keylogger? You understand that any ISP can see a log of which customer requested which website, right? They don't need
by freehunter 15y ago
How is tracking all URLs half as bad as a keylogger? You understand that any ISP can see a log of which customer requested which website, right? They don't need CarrierIQ to see that, it's an integral part of the function of being an ISP.
- stevelosh 15y agoYou understand that when using https an ISP only ever sees the hostname, not the rest of the URL, right?
- freehunter 15y agoYes, I understand this. I don't see your point. Are URLs sensitive information? Hiding a URL is security through obscurity, I don't expect an outrage over obscurity being revealed. At least not from anyone who understands how security works.
- bad_user 15y agoThis is not about security, this is about respecting your privacy. There's a difference between: www.facebook.com ... and ... www.facebook.com/rebecca.some.name
- freehunter 15y agoBut doesn't the carrier see "1-555-123-4567" "Rebecca S. Name" "facebook.com" "123 Fake St, Springfield Ohiyamaude" "Visa XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX" ? Wouldn't they be able to put 2 and 2 (and 2 and 2 and 2 and 2) together to know who the traffic is coming from anyway?
- rmc 15y agoIf I were to watching YouTube over ssl, the carrier would not be able to tell what videos I watched, all they could know is that I went to YouTube. With http they could know what videos I watched. There are plenty of youtube videos that you might not want everyone to know you are watching, political videos, religious videos, how to do crossdressing, etc.
- marshray 15y agoYes, URLs can definitely contain sensitive information. There are no hard-and-fast rules about it (the web wasn't designed for privacy or security), but often web servers are configured to not log query string parameters for this reason.
- Turing_Machine 15y agoThe same would apply for SMS message and phone calls. A nefarious carrier could log those without anything being installed on the handset at all. That aside, wasn't the claim that Carrier IQ can also log stuff that isn't going through the carrier's network (e.g., when you're using your WiFi connection)?
- cube13 15y ago>The same would apply for SMS message and phone calls. A nefarious carrier could log those without anything being installed on the handset at all. Carriers are logging both your SMS and phone call activity anyway. You get a copy of the log in every bill.
- rhizome 15y agoYou understand that any ISP can see a log of which customer requested which website, right? "Any ISP" for me does not include my carrier, T-Mobile. That is, why should TMo know anything about what I'm doing when I'm using my home wifi?
- Dylan16807 15y agologging anything beyond data quantities is most certainly not part of the function of a well-behaved ISP.