6 ms·
> This wasn't obvious to the user because Explorer hides the 'detail' of the file path and simply shows the username I really really dislike Windows when it hi
by WalterBright 4y ago
> This wasn't obvious to the user because Explorer hides the 'detail' of the file path and simply shows the username
I really really dislike Windows when it hides paths, for example, "My Pictures". Where the heck is that?
This lunacy infects Windows applications, like Quicken and Thunderbird, which spew themselves and their data into gawd knows where hidden directories. Why can't they simply do the obvious? Create a \Quicken directory in the root, and have a \Quicken\program and \Quicken\userdata ? But noooo.
- mananaysiempre 4y ago> Why can't [Quicken and other Windows apps] simply do the obvious? Create a \Quicken directory in the root, and have a \Quicken\program and \Quicken\userdata ? Networked machines. (Aside from the obvious security problems on a multi-user installation.) The "gawd knows where hidden directories" (of which there are two, %APPDATA% and %LOCALAPPDATA%, plus, on a recent Windows version, a number of compatibility links and some sort of integrity level thing) are segregated into the part which should have an authoritative copy on the file server ("roaming") and the part that can or has to stay on the workstation ("local").
- carrolldunham 4y agoI can't believe windows doesn't offer an option "this is my laptop, nobody else is ever going to use it". I hate logging in to my own laptop and having a user folder like some loser student in a library
- navjack27 4y agoEvery OS is like this... Except Haiku. And you aren't the only user on pretty much every OS. There are many many many built in "users" for different internal operations.
- smaudet 4y agoNot relevant. Every OS also has different levels of user. Your user should be the admin, shouldn't be tied a profile etc. Linux is setup like more like this. Yeah, it makes it more complex for certain network style things (you have 4 computers and want to sync between them), but it's trivial to work around. The reason Windows is built like this is they develop first for enterprises and libraries, everyone else gets the shitty castoffs...
- Razengan 4y agoIf you were a student in a library you’d know that’s a computer literacy issue.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> I really really dislike Windows when it hides paths, for example, "My Pictures". Where the heck is that? Android has been copying Apple in that it now also has automagic folders and file managers. I also remember Google doing some idiotic A/B tests some moons ago of hiding the actual page result URL, it was one of the reasons (on top of search quality) that I stopped using it. On Android you now have to go through multiple settings to enable explicit paths as if was somehow an 'advanced' feature to show an explicit file path. I assume it is mostly driven by UX somehow it is now an agreed truth that file manager abstractions are too complex for the average user to grasp therefore must be vigourously hidden at all cost.
- amelius 4y agoThe idea that Apple are experts in UI/UX has to stop. Nobody should be copying them.
- oneplane 4y agoThat could apply to HN users as well; the idea that we are the general user population has to stop. Nobody outside of our bubble actually maintains their file hierarchy. Or to people in different age brackets: for a few years now, people have finished uni while doing all their work on phones and tables without a desktop OS involved. No files, no desktop, no actual applications. We should stop copying desktop mentalities into modern workflows. Or the other way around: nobody has desks or paper folders in file cabinets anymore, nobody needs to physically handle files and organise them, nor do their have boxes for physical mail that comes "in" and goes "out". We should stop copying legacy office concepts into software.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoI’ll take the bait: what do people do, then? Let’s say I agree with your point, genuinely: what are they doing instead?
- freels 4y ago
- wellbehaved 4y agoThis is what happens when you let non-technical people direct technical people. Really the only kind of person that should manage and direct a technical person is an even wiser technical person.
- TakeBlaster16 4y ago> Create a \Quicken directory in the root Windows has an existing convention for this, like Linux's XDG. Imagine if you looked at your Linux filesystem root and saw /boot, /dev, /usr, /tmp, and /Quicken.
- pxx 4y agoI mean, honestly, I would be somewhere between "somewhat miffed" to "laughing out loud" if I saw /Quicken. It would not surprise me in the least to see something like Quicken completely violating standards and/or good taste. You'd probably see a /Quicken/ as well as a file /Quicken-uninstall as a broken symlink to nowhere.
- SCLeo 4y agoSame can be said about linux. where exactly is "~"? And which hard drive is /etc currently on? Sure, if you have setup the system yourself or know how to use linux commands, you can figure it out with ease, but so does on Windows (Right click -> properties).
- kuratkull 4y agoI use both operating systems. I never have questions about my locations in Linux, but I constantly wonder about the abstractions Windows throws at me.
- brokenmachine 4y agoI've been using Linux for years and still don't know the difference between /etc and /var.
- d110af5ccf 4y agoNot really. May Windows programs actively obfuscate certain paths. On linux, ~ is simply shorthand for your home directory. Note that knowing what particular block device is backing a given path is not at all the same thing as being able to see the path in the first place. Beyond that, getting a full path is trivial (realpath) and figuring out which block device backs it is also quite straightforward (findmnt).
- emodendroket 4y agoWhat program does that?
- d110af5ccf 4y agoWell for starters, the example in the post at the top of this page would presumably not have happened if the paths in Explorer hadn't been obfuscated. So that's one example. There are also strange constructions that don't actually correspond to a single folder, or at least there were the last time I used Windows which was quite a few years ago now. A place that looked like a photo directory in Explorer, but actually it was a view of multiple directories and I don't know where stuff ended up if you copied into it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoOne reason for hiding paths is localisation. On modern Windows, the path will always be Pictures but it will be displayed with whatever the local translation is. On older versions (and, maybe, modern Windows on a machine upgraded from old versions?), the path was the localised name! macOS is the same.
- _ZeD_ 4y ago...and it's a mildy dumb idea
- alkonaut 4y agoThe only good way to handle user data like photos is the way iOS does it. Strictly one place for images. If there is a path then the user doesn’t see it because they don’t need to see it. The storage and directory structure is an implementation detail. The second best is a fully manual directory structure with no “surface” added. But this is not nearly as good for the average user. By far the worst one is what you get when you (correctly) like Microsoft realize you are in the second category but you’d like to be in the first. The end result is an annoying middle ground that has plagued windows for a long time now. They probably (incorrectly) assumed they could get to the iOS situation eventually. Separating the application and its binaries isn’t a bad idea though. I don’t want to back up applications, just their data, for example. And I want to be able to have different permissions for the app binaries and elsewhere. So programs\Quicken and data\Quicken would be better than the other way around. And this isn’t far from what windows does. If I create an app I put the user data in %appdata%\myprogram. The folder is annoyingly hard to find though but that’s more an explorer UX issue than a problem with how the files are stored.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoI have a folder on my computer called "Graduate School". Inside are subfolders for each of the classes I'm taking. Inside these and further subfolders are files such as: • Videos I need to watch for class. • PDFs I need to read for class. • Word documents I am writing for class. • Photos, videos, and audio recordings I will use to write papers for class. The "iOS model" would have me segment all of this data by file type. The PDF from New York State on K-12 educational standards would be next to my 2021 tax returns. My paper on single-sex schools would be next to the technical documentation for a web app I'm developing. This would be terrible. Files need to be organized by purpose, not file type. I know what my files are for. My computer does not. This is also a major reason why I hate my iPhone.
- WalterBright 4y agoYeah, I too organize my files by subject, not file type. The latter is crazy.
- system2 4y agoIf you mess with group policy a little you'd know where the files are. Right click then "location" shows the directory. In "This PC" all the links are shortcuts. Profile issues are very common, that's why companies keep them in network locations (roaming, desktop, other folders). And for the network location, daily backups (or hourly depending on the setting) then roll version backup for disasters. Also, don't use 14 years old EOL systems.
- JJMcJ 4y ago> I really really dislike Windows when it hides paths, for example, "My Pictures". Where the heck is that? I helped my wife reorganize many hundreds of images. Finding out where they really were located and where they would actually end up was a tremendous chore, and locating them again has continued to be difficult. Even doing a backup is stressful. Where are the files really located?
- rnotaro 4y agoRight click on the file, "Properties", look at the "Location" property.
- JJMcJ 4y agoYeah, but when there are hundreds or maybe even 1,000 files, splattered across who knows how many directories, it gets tiring. I suppose I could create some automation tools, and I have thought about that.
- giantdude 4y agoApple may have started this. Back in the day Ipods would ingest mp3 files and hide them with hashed names in weird folders to make sure you can't give a copy to a neighbor. Android is even worse: they create absurd views of the file system with entirely made-up structure... Well, Apple too, but I've been boycotting Apple since the 90s.