4 ms·
> Losing connection to an online Microsoft account can also result in a user ending up with a temporary account. What the fuck?! So it all but forces you to l
by marcosdumay 4y ago
> Losing connection to an online Microsoft account can also result in a user ending up with a temporary account.
What the fuck?!
So it all but forces you to link your identity to something Microsoft owns... just to refuse your identity back and throwing you into some unrecognizable woods if Microsoft fails to validate it.
I guess failing to log you on your own computer because MS is down would enrage people. So it's better to gaslight them until they give up.
- _Microft 4y agoCreating an account allows to choose between using a Microsoft account or creating a local account.
- Tempest1981 4y agoBut doesn't windows later prompt you to migrate to a Microsoft account? And there's this nagging alert that keeps popping up: "Microsoft account problem." "We need to fix your microsoft account. (Most likely your password changed). Select here to fix it in shared experiences settings." Which I assume most novice users would obey. https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/seeing-the-microsoft-account-problem-pop-up/eba096d0-752c-436c-81ca-24247e56c867 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/seeing...
- salawat 4y agoAlso, in the latest versions of the windows 11 install or OEM first boot setups, the only way you can get the local account option is to kill every network connection. The local account option is hidden otherwise. My ritual for family machine setup is locate wifi kill switch-> if not available, announce wireless going down-> kill network->setup to local account->reenable network It's patently infuriating. Throw in where I've had family members set up Microsoft accounts with only 1 form of auth (Phone number), change that, them get locked out of their Microsft account for a month because of Microsoft's daft policies. Though I didn't set up that machine. It boggles the mind that Microsoft's default flow would run the risk of such an outcome.
- tech234a 4y agoAlternatively you can enter no@thankyou.com as the username and a random password, which causes the login to fail, allowing local account setup [1]. [1]: https://www.thurrott.com/windows/windows-11/269419/tip-set-up-windows-11-22h2-with-a-local-account https://www.thurrott.com/windows/windows-11/269419/tip-set-u...
- salawat 4y ago...That is horrifying. No we won't just add a "No thanks" button, but we'll set up an undocumented magic username to serve the same purpose? And to make it even more nightmarish, where is that check? Is it extractable from the installer binary? Or is it some weird exception case implemented in server code only viewable by microsoft? For that matter, who owns thankyou.com? Is there some unfortunate sod with no@thankyou.com as an email address? There is so much wrong with this. I can't even...
- PascLeRasc 4y agoYou're thinking this through much more than Microsoft ever did. The OP was only saying to pretend that you can't log into an existing account.
- salawat 4y agoThat doesn't fix the issue. They are going dark patterm, which is the bloody issue. There is nothing about that setup that isn't an exercise in plausibly deniable forced on-ramping. No it isn't a best practice to create the illusion you can't use an operating system without agreeing to a cloud services contract. That's BS, and should be called out as such. UX is trying to gaslight the non-technical into services they don't need, and I'm willing to go out on a limb that everyone in the market is trying to converge on that exact practice.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>in the latest versions of the windows 11 install or OEM first boot setups, the only way you can get the local account option is to kill every network connection. And when you did, the next step required you to first select "I don't have internet" then next be shown some embarassing pseudo-technical propaganda appealing to your FOMO, to provide one full page of discouragement before you agree to "continue with limited setup" if you want to actually have a full regular local account. And that illusion is maintained further into the user experience, where status will sometimes be reported as "setup incomplete". With the Sept 2022 release of W11 you can't even do that any more. When you reach this point and there is no longer the option to admit your poor soul has no internet, the incantation here is to hit Shift+F10 which opens a command prompt. Click in the CMD window to make it respond to your keyboard then oobe\bypassnro. Reboots and reverts to previous "I don't have internet" option. Sheesh.
- quietbritishjim 4y agoI'm not saying you're wrong, but nothing at the link you posted (that I could see) says that that message would migrate a local account to an online one.
- Tempest1981 4y agoOk, fair enough. So what does it mean? This is seen on local Windows accounts, but it's referring to Microsoft accounts. Sure looks like an attempt to "join" the two.
- jeroenhd 4y agoNot on modern Windows 11, though you can still do so by saying you use the computer professionally, entering bad credentials in the MS login and then clicking the "local account" button. Who knows how long that'll keep working, though.
- easton 4y agoIf you click "Domain join instead" on the Azure AD login screen it gives up and asks you to make a local account, which you can then use to join the domain once you get to the desktop. Domain joining from setup is impossible (it requires a reboot, and then group policy could push something that breaks the rest of the out-of-box experience), so it's safe to assume that will always be there (unless they do a major change to how AD joining works, but they probably won't since they consider it "legacy").
- rejectfinite 4y agoOn Pro you can. https://imgur.com/a/TXNtJHy https://imgur.com/a/TXNtJHy Select "Join a domain/corparete" network and there is a button for offline account.
- marcosdumay 4y ago"Allows you to choose" is absolutely the wrong way to describe it. But yes, if you get an script with the set of actions that make local accounts possible, you can replicate them.
- _Microft 4y agoIt's easy to miss but it is/was absolutely possible to decline creating a Microsoft account when installing Windows 10.
- sbierwagen 4y agoYou can decline to create a Microsoft account but it will prompt you to make one again every time you install updates and there’s only an option to “remind me later”
- lazide 4y agoLong ago it was always the advice to never use an odd numbered windows release. Seems like it still holds!
- nolok 4y agoOriginal windows 10 offered it as an option. But the current versions of windows 10 only offer that if you don't have internet (no ethernet cable in, and answered "I don't have a wifi" in the screen before user creation), if you connected to the wifi it won't show the option for local account.
- scrame 4y agoNot any more. You can do it if you are completely offline during initial setup, but if you do the first network setup it won't let you continue until you set up an MS account. I'm sure 11 does the same thing.
- rejectfinite 4y agoOn Pro you can. https://imgur.com/a/TXNtJHy https://imgur.com/a/TXNtJHy Select "Join a domain/corparete" network and there is a button for offline account.
- d110af5ccf 4y agoWhy do people put up with this? Just use linux. KDE is amazing these days.
- pixl97 4y agoPeople don't tend to care about operating systems, but they do tend to care about applications.
- rejectfinite 4y agoIts a one-time thing on setup. Yes its dumb for sure.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoLol this is why i have a reminder at the end of every month to log in to some critical but not often used accounts just to make sure it's still there lol. I lost a yahoo account after they started their use it or lose it approach.
- autoexec 4y ago> So it all but forces you to link your identity to something Microsoft owns... If Microsoft has full access to your hard drive and can make changes to your system and files any time they want they own a lot more than your user profile. It's their system. They are the admin, and you are a peasant and the extent of your access to your(?) data and Microsoft's system can be limited or revoked at any time.
- navjack27 4y agoThat literally isn't anything. You're making up a situation that isn't a thing.
- tatersolid 4y agoThe exact same thing can be said of Debian maintainers, Ubuntu maintainers, etc. They probably “own” as many servers as Microsoft. The real-world number of linux admins who inspect all packages before applying them is basically zero. Most Linux/BSD systems likely have unattended upgrades enabled by default.
- navjack27 4y agoI could log into my latest Windows 11 developer preview update computer offline or online or I can lose connection to the internet while I'm logged in and literally none of this happens. Everything just always works.