5 ms·
> When you deal with the scale that YT are operating at, automating content moderation is the only cost effective way. Why? If youtube had 30 million in reven
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> When you deal with the scale that YT are operating at, automating content moderation is the only cost effective way.
Why?
If youtube had 30 million in revenue, could they afford a couple moderators?
Their revenue is 1000x higher, so can they not afford 1000x as many moderators?
Let's take some ballpark estimates. Half a million videos are uploaded per day (probably accurate), and 10% of them reach a thousand views or are on channels that typically reach a thousand views (probably accurate), and 10% of those need a human moderator (probably way too high). Investigation takes 10 minutes with each moderator doing 40 per work day (just a guess, should be sufficient), and averaging 25 per day over the entire year.
Multiply all those numbers together, and you get an estimate of 200 moderators to handle all videos of any import. For a company with 30 billion dollars in revenue.
Am I super far off on one of those numbers? The fact that it's so hard for medium to large channels to get the attention of a human seems entirely like mismanagement to me, not a real cost issue.
- glandium 4y agoIt was 30,000 hours of new content an hour on average a few months ago. That's 720,000 hours a day. The average video is reportedly 11.7 minutes, which makes it about 4M new videos per day. You're off by about an order of magnitude. Edit: 10% of videos with more than a thousand views is reportedly acurate. That makes it 50,000 videos per day according to your numbers, and with 25 videos reviewed a day on average by person, that makes it 2,000 persons with your numbers, not 200, so you're off by another order or magnitude. For 10% of 4M, that would be 16,000 people, or, what, 10% of Alphabet's workforce? Youtube itself reportedly has 2,800 employees.
- Dylan16807 4y agoHuh, I didn't think a 2016 number would be that wildly different. Okay, 4 million videos. So if we adjust the moderation percent to 5% that would mean 800 moderators. And focusing on videos with 10k views would need 1/4 of that. Videos with 100k views would be 1/10 of that. And this is a channel that gets millions of views. There's only going to be a couple thousand videos per day at the million+ tier. A handful of people could provide white glove moderation to all of them. Edit to your edit: I think you skipped the part where most videos don't need to be reviewed. Take that 16k and divide it by 10 or 20 or 50.
- laumars 4y agoThe problem we have is that popular content creators are the most susceptible to the problems caused by YTs moderation. Your solution only reinforces that problem since you’re excluding unpopular content creators. You’re also making the assumption that humans are going to moderate consistently but that simply isn’t true. Different people will draw the line at different points and our mood will also vary the line too. Review guidelines would only only help with measurable criteria but so often what constitutes as acceptable or not is a lot more nuanced.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Your solution only reinforces that problem since you’re excluding unpopular content creators. If you're not even getting a thousand views then it's not going to be a big deal if some of your videos get messed with. Annoying but not important to your life. Just about anyone that would seriously call themselves a content creator, even as a hobby, should be above that bar. I'm in favor of good moderation for everyone, sure, but I want to hammer home just how easily they could provide good moderation to any video with traction.
- laumars 4y ago> If you're not even getting a thousand views then it's not going to be a big deal if some of your videos get messed with. I don’t think uploaders would agree with that sentiment. For starters not every video uploaded is by online personalities. A lot of corporate entities use YT. I’ve been on mental health courses that had material on YT too. These videos aren’t going to receive thousands of videos but the content is just as critical for their operations (arguments about whether they should use YT is another topic). And you’re still overlooking the injustice that the larger personalities would feel if they have content demonetised or even banned while smaller channels have the same content available. It’s a nice idea you have but it’s creating an uneven playing field so would have just as many problems as the status quo. Edit: also let’s not forget that your suggestion is easy to weaponise. If you’re a smaller channel competing with a larger one then you can abuse the moderation system by reporting the other channel. Thus any moderation system has the be universal or else it’s going to be abused.
- hvis 4y agoThe moderators only really need to review the videos already flagged by the automatic process, and the classification ML thingy can add the timestamps with positions the "objectionable content" is featured at, so the mods wouldn't need to view the video in whole. How many of the videos are flagged down, though, we probably don't have any solid statistic on that.
- MisterSandman 4y agoYou don't need to review ALL new content, just content that gets traction or is manually flagged by the uploader as being wrongly marked by the AI.
- samatman 4y agoYouTube doesn't need more moderators, they need to be compelled through negotiation or law to be fair. What would that look like? Any creator could send a classification (such as age restriction) which they disagree with to an independent moderation agency, and the party which is decided for or against pays for it. There are of course issues with maintaining the independence of those agencies, but this is a problem which has been solved successfully in the past. Also (this is table stakes, it's pathetic this isn't already done) an exact timestamp for any part of a video used to classify it must be provided by YouTube. So it's about reviewing ~5 seconds of video in context, not the whole thing. There may be two, three of those timestamps, but if someone has to look at a full minute of a video to determine if it's age-appropriate? It probably isn't.