8 ms·
Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash
- sposeray 4y ago[dead]
- burglekutt 4y agoSuch a clickbaitey title. There were just a few.. THOUSAND.. causes that culminated in the 1929 crash, but saying one person caused it gets those clicks.
- hypertele-Xii 4y ago> "Mitchell more than any 50 men is responsible for this stock crash." — U.S. Senator Carter Glass, November 1929. [1] [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20070905000359/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,745272-1,00.html https://web.archive.org/web/20070905000359/http://www.time.c...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eesmith 4y agoIf he were one of 10,000 then he could be 50x more responsible than the next, and still not be "the banker who caused the 1929 stock crash." BTW, I stuck that phrase into Google Scholar and found https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/business-history-review/article/abs/charles-e-mitchell-scapegoat-of-the-crash/248F3E81DB4378A604DBD9AF68864B57 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/business-history-rev... > Extremely successful both as an investment and as a commercial banker, Charles E. Mitchell was identified by contemporaries as the epitome of the unscrupulous “money changers” whose speculative dealings they felt played a major role in the Crash of 1929 and the ensuing economic collapse. This portrayal has been echoed and elaborated by historians and commentators down to the present day. In this article Dr. Huertas and Dr. Silverman demonstrate that Mitchell's activities, while sometimes ill-advised, were motivated by the economic “good sense” of the day and were not attributable to either rampant immorality or ungoverned greed. At the same time, they direct the attention of economic historians to the monetary policies of the Federal Reserve system in the 1920s and 1930s—in which Mitchell also played a role—and suggest that a more potent source of the Great Depression lies therein.
- dang 4y agoYes, we've changed the title now (as the site guidelines ask in such cases: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Please let's talk about the interesting bits now.
- redkinght99 4y agoCharles Mitchell, saved you a click. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Mitchell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Mitchell
- photochemsyn 4y ago> "What Is the Glass-Steagall Act? The Glass-Steagall Act, passed in 1933, forced commercial banks to refrain from investment banking activities in order to protect depositors from potential losses caused by bank speculation in stocks. Glass-Steagall was largely repealed in 1999..." https://www.investopedia.com/articles/03/071603.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/03/071603.asp As far as this headline, it's the worst kind of nonsense, comparable to "This is the pebble that caused the avalanche!".
- melling 4y agoDidn’t repealing it make the 2008 financial crisis worse?
- onionisafruit 4y agoThat's what NPR told me.
- photochemsyn 4y agoYes indeed. Probably the best cinematic take on that is in the movie Margin Call - here's the senior partners meeting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hhy7JUinlu0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hhy7JUinlu0 Essentially, the dissolution of Glass-Steagall allowed investment banks to create complex financial packages, each one constructed out of dozens if not hundreds of home mortgages. Each individual mortgage was graded but the packages were built out of a mixture of low-grade and high-grade mortgages. Since trading (gambling) with these packages was very lucrative, the investment banks worked with shady mortgage brokers to increase the number of packages by pushing adjustable-rate mortgages on gullible people who probably were not that familiar with compound interest calcululations. These unlikely-to-succeed mortgages were mixed in with the high-qulaity mortages to create a wide variety of highly leveraged financial products, and then bets were placed on the outcomes of trading in these products (derivative markets, synthetic CDO squared nonsense, etc.). Once people realized that many of these mortgages were not going to be paid off, then the avalanche of collapse began. Glass-Steagall, if retained, would have made all of that impossible.
- bruce511 4y agoThe crash didn't happen because of 1 banker, but it did happen because of things he, and his contemporaries dreamed up. Basically bankers make money when money flows. It flows only when "there is something better". So to keep making money there always has to be "something better" and ultimately that becomes unsustainable. 1929 was a re-adjustment, where all the bullshit is cleaned away. It was perhaps the first time it impacted such a large portion of society. An education of the masses if you will. Crashes did, and will, keep happening again - as long as the myth of "forever going up" persists. In the early 2000s it was property. Today its (maybe /likely /probably) crypto. At least today society is notably, collectively, smarter. There are a lot more naysayers in general, and whole there will be crashes, they tend to be more limited in scope and reach. But greed, the root of all of this, will always be with us. Greed offers some to be winners, but most to be losers.
- bogota 4y agoReally today its crypto? The tiny market and not the massively overpriced tech stocks trading way way above earnings. They have just slightly corrected from the covid mania but many are still trading at ridiculous multiples that everyone justifies with “they will keep growing”
- bruce511 4y agoNot exclusively crypto, but when I see adverts for crypto on TV, and hear it pitched over radio, then I wonder. At that point it's appealing to the least sophisticated investors, which to me is the first signal of a bubble. The nature of a ponzi scheme is that it starts small, but then has to appeal to an ever larger group. This ends with mass advertising to reach the biggest group of all. Then what? Couple this with the tone. Crypto is being marketed as an investment, not as a utility, not as a currency. Its sole appeal is "it will go up". Crypto itself is mostly a solution looking for a (legal) problem. While the killer app is facilitating illegal activity (which has some value for moral, but illegal activity - alas a minority of the actual use case) that's a hard sell. Finding a legal killer app though is proving elusive. Most things it _can_ do are already done better/faster/cheaper/simpler another way. Of course it has some utility, but nowhere near the hype levels. Tech stocks - yes, they are high, and will likely correct some. But apple, Google, Microsoft, amazon, Facebook and friends are all generating huge amounts of revenue and profit. Their stock values are massive, but their profit levels are unprecedented. Startups get a lot if attention, but from VCs which is not public money, and not traded to the public, so is a different kind of bubble, unrelated to the 1929 depression etc.
- themitigating 4y agoHow great that he was never punished and lived out the rest of his life in luxury. When are we going to start going after these rich assholes in a serious way?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- saulpw 4y ago> Pecora was no grandstanding politician. He was a cigar-smoking, fedora-wearing New York City prosecutor who liked to call the bank executives “banksters” because he saw them as finance gangsters.
- logifail 4y ago> "The bank was just basically selling anything that came along that they could make money on, and really weren’t telling investors about what their internal investigations had uncovered about the quality of the securities." That line sounds like it could be straight out of The Big Short (2015), essentially nothing has changed in the best part of 100 years.
- sroussey 4y agoCan I interest you in an ICO?
- vaneri2007 4y agoNothing changes and nothing will ever change. Once you reach a certain level, you are above law and other sharks will see value in you. You will no matter what make money, even idiots at this level make money. Got something similar in my company, lots of big and important people joined; took all the money and either flee to other companies or stayed on the board of director while lots of people were let go! Image is more important than results.
- klelatti 4y agoOn the other side of the pond there is also Clarence Hatry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarence_Hatry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarence_Hatry Economist John Kenneth Galbraith described Hatry as "one of those curiously un-English figures with whom the English periodically find themselves unable to cope."
- gibsonf1 4y agoThe real culprit, the federal reserve and artificially low interest rates as we are witnessing yet again.