5 ms·
Hurricanes are a fact of life in the gulf and southeastern atlantic coasts. There is no area that has not have been hit twice already in the past century. So al
by SoftTalker 4y ago
Hurricanes are a fact of life in the gulf and southeastern atlantic coasts. There is no area that has not have been hit twice already in the past century. So all this coastline should be dunes and park spaces?
- michael1999 4y agoCalgary did this after the 2013 Bow river flood. They bailed out the homeowners. But if they choose to rebuild on those lots, next time they get zero. They are on their own. If catastrophic hurricanes are really going to happen every 10 years, should the federal government be subsidizing the coastal lifestyle and building you a new house each time? Consider: 100B/100M taxpayers = $1000 per person. Can you really say that the average citizen of Wyoming should pony up $100 a year so Floridians can build up against the unsheltered sea instead a few miles inland?
- trynewideas 4y ago> Calgary did this after the 2013 Bow river flood. They bailed out the homeowners. But if they choose to rebuild on those lots, next time they get zero. They are on their own. If you're talking about the town of High River/the Highwood River/the Beachwood estates and Wallaceville, it was about 102 houses out of 250 eligible and a couple hundred more affected. All but 14 lots were explicitly not up for development, at any risk; Beachwood and Wallaceville are being renaturalized as a floodplain and High River's removing infrastructure. The houses that weren't destroyed, demolished, or auctioned off to be moved are still there and uninhabited.[1] Other damaged neighborhoods that were bought out got tossed around between provincial governments for eight years until High River bought them back for redevelopment.[2] There are regulations - the Floodway Development Regulation in particular - against developing floodways, but haven't been promulgated to prevent, or even disincentivize, development.[3][4] (If they had been, parts of Fort McMurray rebuilt after the 2016 wildfires that then flooded in 2020 wouldn't have been rebuilt in the first place.)[5] The province also wouldn't fund buyouts of other flood-risk properties downstream of High River.[6] (Indeed, the High River bailout was OVERfunded, and High River sent money back to the county in January.)[7] [1] https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/beachwood-naturalization-moving-ahead-in-high-river https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/beachwood-naturaliz... [2] https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/province-and-high-river-nearing-deal-for-14-homes-in-the-northwest https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/province-and-high-r... [3] https://www.evabogdan.ca/uploads/8/1/4/0/81403352/bogdan_bennett___yumagulova_accepted_manuscript_with_figures.pdf https://www.evabogdan.ca/uploads/8/1/4/0/81403352/bogdan_ben... [4] https://era.library.ualberta.ca/items/5da26123-e3df-45b8-a928-ee65ca3b2e50/view/ca6c43a2-de0e-4bd4-a2f5-f3ce94a1c7bb/Bogdan_Eva_Angelyna_201906_PhD.pdf https://era.library.ualberta.ca/items/5da26123-e3df-45b8-a92... [5] https://theconversation.com/fort-mcmurrays-flood-disaster-was-foreseeable-and-preventable-137850 https://theconversation.com/fort-mcmurrays-flood-disaster-wa... [6] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/foothills-county-flooding-houses-1.6021413 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/foothills-county-floo... [7] https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/high-river-excess-flood-funding-to-go-to-foothills-county https://www.highriveronline.com/articles/high-river-excess-f...
- throwoutway 4y agoI don’t think the money goes to the homeowners does it? They have home insurance (which I’ve heard is double what I pay for an inland city in an area unaffected by hurricanes). FEMA helps the area (utilities, essentials, shelter) but doesn’t rebuild their homes from what I’ve heard
- sokoloff 4y agoIs the federal government paying out $100B for Ian damages from taxes? Or is most of that being paid by private insurance (or even if paid by federal flood insurance, you have to credit back the flood insurance premiums paid rather than assume it’s all coming from taxes).
- akiselev 4y agoLiterally no one wants to insure those homeowners. They get insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program - it’s subsidized by the Federal government and it’s still incredibly expensive because the NFIP can’t refuse to insure a property thats going to be destroyed once a decade, so they end up being subsidized by all the properties in the NFIP that weren’t built in insane locations.
- peterangular 4y ago> If catastrophic hurricanes are really going to happen every 10 years, should the federal government be subsidizing the coastal lifestyle and building you a new house each time? No. Unlike other subsidies there is no greater economic/societal good created from people having their costal homes. And, unlike other disaster situations, hurricanes in that region are an outright guarantee. Also, this is just going to keep getting worse with climate change. I agree with Calgary. People are free to live there, but not on my dime.
- polynomial 4y agoDidn't Key West do this also, or something similar?
- whywhywhydude 4y agoYeah
- nemo44x 4y agoClearly they aren’t fit for development.
- LadyCailin 4y agoOr privately funded to keep rebuilding, yeah. Why should the rest of us have to keep paying for you to rebuild your house because you picked a stupid location and/or didn’t build strong enough in the first place?
- SantalBlush 4y agoRight, this is a textbook case of moral hazard. When a person engages in some risky activity but offloads some of the risk onto others, they'll continue doing that activity more than they otherwise would.
- hackerlight 4y agoIf the irresponsible people who insist on living in hurricane prone areas pay for their own repairs, then I have no problem with them living there. If they ask for me to pay for it, then that gives me moral buy in into whether they should be allowed to live there.
- smabie 4y agoI mean is it irresponsible to live in a hurricane prone area? For example I live in Puerto Rico. Do you want everyone to just leave?
- hackerlight 4y agoI want you or the polluters who are causing climate change to pay the cost. Leave me out of it.
- sokoloff 4y agoYou should decide to stay or leave based on whatever mix of factors are important to you. That’s your decision, which is distinct from whether other Americans should subsidize the economic consequence of your decision.
- peterangular 4y ago> I mean is it irresponsible to live in a hurricane prone area? Climate change really doesn't have an opinion on this. Here's a paper from the EPA: "What Climate Change Means for Puerto Rico" https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-09/documents/climate-change-pr.pdf https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/sites/production/files... As someone who believes climate change is fact, if I had the economic mobility to move my life away from such an area I would. Sorry if this seems harsh, but people much smarter than me agree that these areas are going to be prone to worse and worse conditions in the coming decades.
- coryfklein 4y agoPublic funds should not pay to rebuild the same property more than 1-2 times within N years. You either: a) Build the property to withstand all but 1-2 statistically expected hurricanes within that N year period. This is possible, it's just costly. b) You don't get public funds c) You get private insurance d) You don't build
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoNo problem, so long as you pay for your own college, health insurance, and unemployment.
- CabSauce 4y agoAren't those for everyone? Not just people not in Florida?
- adrienthebo 4y agoHaving people educated, healthy, and protected from the damages of homelessness all have positive externalities. Paying people to return to areas that are regularly ravaged by massive storms only benefits them until the next storm and doesn't represent a long term good, especially in the face of climate change.
- adventured 4y agoShall we apply this moral rule globally then? Say goodbye to Pakistan. I'd love to see the HN crowd that is championing the premise stand up and proclaim all the areas of the globe that people should no longer be allowed to live, huge swaths of which will be in hyper impoverished areas of India, China, Pakistan. They won't dare.
- solveit 4y ago> no longer be allowed Who's talking about allowing anything? The debate is about whether these people will be subsidised.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> So all this coastline should be dunes and park spaces? If they cannot be safely built upon, sure. Same reason no one builds houses on the edge of Kilauea's active craters. Hurricane-resistant construction is possible, it's just more expensive. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/14/us/hurricane-michael-florida-mexico-beach-house.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/14/us/hurricane-michael-flor...
- softcactus 4y agoHuman brains are funny. Obviously the absurd part of all of this is people (literally) building their houses on the edge of the ocean and expecting this to not happen. However because it's all we know, it seems that the real absurdity would be the government designating these sites as 'no-build' zones-- or at least FEMA washing their hands of any damage that should happen to these sites. This should be a wakeup call that many aspects of our current way of life are unsustainable, not that it's just standard operating procedure to rebuild from the ground up every 20 years only for everything to be washed away again.
- tpmoney 4y agoI would wager a majority of the final costs are from damages to houses not "on the edge of the ocean". Hurricane damages stretch for miles inland. Heck pick any east coast state and check out the areas covered by flood warnings and watches. They're hours from the coast in places. If it was only the houses on the edge of the ocean, this would be relatively cheap.
- softcactus 4y agoThat's a good point, I decided to do some napkin math: Sanibel Island has 7,821 housing units at an average density of 454.6 per square mile. Median sales price of the homes in 2021 was $1.64M, average price was similar. So a rough approximation of the value of the homes on the island alone is $12Bn. I am not sure how you would translate that into damage costs, but in a scenario of total destruction then $12B would be lost. I have no real evidence other than visiting Ft Myers and Naples a few times, but I can tell you there is (was) a lot of very valuable property right next to the ocean. I don't doubt that if you look at the total distribution of damages that there is a long tail of less severe damage as you go inland, but the conservative estimates from my napkin math shows that it's likely a significant number (over ten billion) occurred just from properties on the small stretch of coastline. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanibel,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanibel,_Florida https://sanibelrealestateguide.com/average-price-homes/ https://sanibelrealestateguide.com/average-price-homes/
- 4y ago
- anm89 4y agoExactly. That's the idea. They should be allowed to live there as long as they want to fund it.
- jeffbee 4y agoPeople who live on Cape Coral are going to have to internalize the fact that they fell for a real estate swindle, they are partly or mostly at fault, and their own personal financial situation will be impacted. People in the Pacific states and the northeast are going to need to internalize that it isn't OK to use the Sun Belt as a relieve valve for their NIMBY policies, and the federal government might even need to take measures to disincentivize those states from exporting their populations to Gulf Coast swamps.
- cpurdy 4y ago"So all this coastline should be dunes and park spaces?" Yes. That makes sense to me. What's the downside?
- vkou 4y agoIf you want to live in a deindustrialized society, there is no downside. If you like things like international shipping, gasoline, diesel, and having food on your table, there are a few downsides.
- ericd 4y agoWe can still build hardened ports and port cities. If you want a coastal vacation house, that’s going to be an (even more) expensive luxury.
- rootusrootus 4y agoHow many of the critical workers who maintain port facilities live in beachfront houses? Approximately none. We can quit subsidizing wealthy beachfront home owners and limit new housing to places that are more defensible. Returning all of the current privately owned beachfront to natural habitat would be absolutely glorious. We can make exceptions for public facilities serving the greater good, like ports.
- nrmitchi 4y agoThere is a huge difference between "don't use the space at all" and "don't build buildings that are unsuited for the location". There is also a difference between "my roof was damaged by high wind" repairs and "my house and everything I own floated away due to storm surge" repairs. I'm not trying to speak for OP, but typically the style of "2 and then done" plans are for the latter style of damage (where the damage is into the low-mid 6 figures), not the former (where damage is low-mid 5 figures).
- jackattackx 4y ago
- adrienthebo 4y agoIf an area is regularly rendered uninhabitable by major weather events then rebuilding in that area is a liability for all involved. When buildings and property are destroyed their contents are dispersed or leak, representing an environmental hazard; people and animals returning are exposed to evacuation risks in following weather events; and then there's the obvious tax and insurance liability discussed elsewhere. We've been treating these areas as fit for habitation and we're watching in realtime as they become uninhabitable. While it may have been more tolerable to live in these regions in the last century when global temperatures were lower we're at an inflection point; we're going be forced to concede spaces as too dangerous for regular habitation because storms are only going to increase in severity and frequency. As a society we have a few options: 1, we continue to rebuild and pay the costs until it becomes completely cost prohibitive; 2, dramatically rethink how we build in the area and construct buildings that can cope with several feet of storm surges; or 3, accept reality and begin the process of resettling people in areas that won't be submerged in 100 years. It's likely that we're going to pursue option 1 for the next 10-30 years because collective change is hard but we ought to start having these conversations well in advance of insurance companies writing off all of Florida as uninsurable. This doesn't even begin to touch on the benefits of allowing areas to revert to wetlands, but considering that they act as excellent buffers from the storms we're observing as well as carbon sinks, but it's worth stating that retreating from these areas makes more sense on ecological and financial grounds.
- gamegoblin 4y agoTo be honest, that sounds amazing. Having those coasts be parks with hundreds of miles of low-impact infrastructure like hiking/biking/walking paths, maybe simple low-key restaurants that aren't a big deal to rebuild every decade, etc. Put all the heavier infrastructure like housing developments a few miles inland. Then everyone can enjoy these idyllic beach lands a little farther from all the buzz of cities. Everyone in the city can still easily go to the coastline-spanning megapark, but now the beach isn't lined with gaudy condos. Sign me up!
- thehappypm 4y agoPlum Island, MA is kinda like that. Nearby inland Newburyport is a beautiful town with a riverfront, but the beach is all wild.
- Lammy 4y agoThe coasts wouldn’t be returned to nature. They’d become enclaves of families rich enough to build and rebuild their beach houses without the help of insurance payouts.
- Amezarak 4y agoStorm surges come miles inland. It’s not just people on the beach. Most of the gulf coast is fairly flat and filled with other waterways. What you’re looking at is anybody potentially within 30ft of sea level where any contiguous <30ft elevation is connected to water. I’ve known people 20 miles inland to be flooded by storm surges because they lived near a river, and the hurricane pushed all the water up the river. The wind is not as big a concern, but also still does a lot of damage. During one major hurricane I evacuated 150 miles inland and still didn’t have power for a week. One person in the town I evacuated to was killed by a falling tree.
- kevmo 4y agoAs a Floridian: Yes.
- shagmin 4y agoIt doesn't have to be all or nothing. There's also probably room for stronger building codes in riskier areas. This hurricane (and others in the past) literally changed where the coastline is in some places. But from some of the pictures I've seen, you do have some neighborhoods where one side is slightly higher than the other side and thus survived much better. Maybe some of those houses shouldn't have been built, and berms strategically placed and other things. One house not being built may under some circumstances prevent multiple other houses from being destroyed down the road. This seems like a low hanging fruit kind of thing if the priorities are there, before getting into beefing up infrastructure and more expensive options. The amount of damage from hurricanes is trending higher and higher as time goes on, so something has to give and currently it seems federal flood insurance is doing all the giving.
- marssaxman 4y agoIn the small Atlantic coastal town where I am temporarily living, all recently-built houses sit on stilts - they have an open area underneath, often used as a garage, or for storage, but all the finished living space starts eight feet off the ground. Many people are also lifting their older houses this way; the owners of the house next door just moved back in after completing their upgrade. Some of this adaptation is FEMA-subsidized: anyone whose house has been flooded twice in ten years can apply for a $50k grant toward the lift. Federal flood insurance may be doing much of the giving, but around here at least it's happening in a way that improves long term resilience.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]