14 ms·
Red Dead Redemption 2 fan with 6k hours on Stadia begs for character transfer
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI imagine some fat cat google exec smoking a cigar and laughing maniacly at the article. Similarly an exec Rockstar shrugs and moves to the next tweet.
- tksiden 4y agoWhoa sounds like a classmate of mine. He loved loved loved Stadia. It was absolutely perfect for a university campus. You could get some gaming on the go in between classes pretty easily.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago
- BrandoElFollito 4y ago6k hours is about 8 years at 2h/day. I spent at least twice, if not three times more coding for fun at home, as a hobby. I could have been reading, or running. 6k hours devoted to a hobby is not that much for an adult.
- bazhand 4y agoThe real travesty is sinking so much time into Red Dead Online. It's a quite average experience that's been neglected by Rockstar.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhat are the odds he did this deliberately for exposure, expecting Stadia to be cancelled? It's hard to imagine somebody doing it otherwise, particularly considering he's a 'semi-pro' gamer trying to make a name for himself with online video content. Does he really not have a gaming PC of his own? And if he does, why was he using Stadia instead?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NickC25 4y ago>And if he does, why was he using Stadia instead? Wasn't one of the big features of Stadia that you could essentially play it on any device anywhere as long as you had a fast internet connection? Perhaps he was dedicated, but put a lot of time in while not at his home setup - playing on the train, long uber rides, hotels, etc...? Just speculating....
- Telemoto 4y agoHe has a good internet connection and the latency in a Google Datacenters was probably really good. If he just played around with stadia and just kept playing, I think it's easy to accept this as normal. I was very close to start playing cyberpunk on stadia due to GPU issues. I wouldn't have switched in the middle just to save a few bucks per month
- Jweb_Guru 4y agoYou think he played a game for 6000 hours because he thought the service he played on would be canceled and he would have one day of exposure someday? That seems pretty unlikely.
- least 4y agoI hadn't even considered this as a consequence of Stadia shutting down. I naively thought, "Well, everyone is getting refunded for everything they spent, so it's fine." Clearly I was wrong. Of course there are folks that have actual game saves that they're heavily invested in on the platform that aren't easily portable. I feel sorry for this person and hope that Google and its partners like Rockstar work together to create solutions to ensure that people's saves and earned content like game unlocks and achievements aren't lost. I hope that any cloud streaming service that still exists learns from this and ensures that player's data is more portable so in the event that they must shut down, this same problem doesn't crop up again.
- hotpotamus 4y agoI saw mention that you could get your save games out via Google Takeout, but I don't know if that's verified or if it would even be in a format that's usable to someone.
- wingerlang 4y agoIt is mentioned in the article itself, it also implies that it is not useful for multiplayer saves.
- bass3l 4y agoUnfortunately you can't, because Red Dead (((Online))) locks your account on the platform you play, his account on Stadia will simply be erased into oblivion.
- lake_vincent 4y agoI think Google's biggest flaw in this regard is their own denial of the pattern of shutting things down. If they just acknowledge that's how things go, they can prepare better off-ramps for people who adopted their product. Doing this to your users is a slap in the face because it shows no gratitude for the fact that those people took a chance on your product. They believed in it, and it's not their fault your project failed. Why should they suffer? But because of Google's hubris, they seem to never admit that failure is an option. Of course they shouldn't say it publicly, but they should have much better internal plans in place for euthanizing products humanely. Failure to do so repeatedly, on a scale like this, reeks of organizational dysfunction, and the absence a moral compass. I was not a Stadia user, but events like this reinforce my motivation to drop all the Google products I possibly can before they drop me.
- danso 4y agoI'm assuming this guy's hours were mostly on Red Dead Online. I know that RDO doesn't have crossplay between PC and consoles. But did RDO also not have crossplay between PC (Steam, Epic, R*) and Stadia? Stadia players were on their own little instance? edit: to answer my own question: No https://www.reddit.com/r/Stadia/comments/hrsypo/does_read_dead_redemption_2_on_stadia_have_cross/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Stadia/comments/hrsypo/does_read_de... But it's still a rhetorical question: like, I'm surprised the infrastructure between Stadia and regular PC was so different that Stadia was effectively its own console. I assumed it was just a somewhat thicker version of something like Nvidia's GeForce, which let you (for the most part) access your own Steam library.
- faller_slive 4y agoAn issue that Stadia had with cross play is that controller and KB/M were both very common ways to play. Controller players would not want to play against PC users with keyboards. And Keyboard users would have an unfair advantage against console players with controllers. I think one game changed which you were matchmaked against depending on which input method you were using.
- sofixa 4y ago> I'm surprised the infrastructure between Stadia and regular PC was so different that Stadia was effectively its own console. I assumed it was just a somewhat thicker version of something like Nvidia's GeForce, And Nvidia is being stifled by that. Their UX is bad and leaky (you see Windows components and errors, and you have to login into launchers, with MFA, every time when starting a new session), and they probably pay a fortune for Microsoft licenses. Meanwhile Google had full control of the stack and could do whatever they wanted with it, including optimise it to hell for latency.
- rvz 4y agoAll your digital 'cloud' games, save games, and data (on Stadia) gone.
- Goz3rr 4y agoIn this case the fault lies somewhat with Rockstar. When you decide to move from playing GTA V on console to PC for example, you still lose your online progress with no option to transfer after Rockstar shut down transfers in 2016.
- bjt2n3904 4y agoRDR2 released on Stadia in 2019. 6000 hours / 4 years is about four hours a day. That's dedication. But man, I feel embarrassed to admit I have 1200 hours in CS:GO. I can't pretend that was a good investment.
- frakt0x90 4y agoIt says he's a youtuber so it may be his job.
- shmatt 4y agoRemember everyone: not your GPU, not your character
- haliskerbas 4y agoDepends, if you play fortnite on GeForce Now for example, you keep your character on your account across devices.
- pdntspa 4y agoYeah, but that's at the pleasure of the game developer
- bartread 4y ago5907 hours spent playing RDR2? Assuming he spent 12 hours a day playing that's 492 days spent doing nothing but playing RDR2 (the 246 days quoted in the article assumes he didn't sleep, eat, go to the loo, shower, etc.). He's literally spent 33% of his waking life in the ~4 years since release doing nothing but playing RDR2 or RDR Online? That seems... perhaps unhealthy, certainly unbalanced - it's definitely a lot of time invested in one game which, given the profusion of other excellent games available, seems maybe too limited? Each to their own, I guess.
- mynameishere 4y agoSome people spend that much watching sports, so... Also if you look at steam reviews they say the number of hours played. Some people have 10k+ for some games.
- navigate8310 4y agoI believe some buy games to farm trading cards and artificially increase their playtime. How skewed this data is only Valve knows as they have capabilities to identify farmers but don't do much.
- Xeoncross 4y agoIt sounds terrible, but losing his save could possibly be the thing that saves his life if this is true.
- smt88 4y agoPeople with uncontrolled obsessive behaviors aren't typically "cured" by losing the thing they obsessed over. Sometimes it's the opposite, and they become suicidal.
- chillfox 4y agoAssuming he played since the launch of RDR2 on Stadia then it's about 6 hours a day, and considering we are talking about a YouTuber it could be work.
- 4y ago
- chihuahua 4y agoLet's look on the bright side - this guy has certainly gotten his money's worth out of Stadia.
- PedroBatista 4y agoAlthough the angle of: Losing his characters is the best thing that's happening for him due to wasting a very significant part of his life in video games has some merit (but could be worded differently), this is yet another example on why you shouldn't depend on these platforms for anything of value, specially Google. The immense pressure to transform/re-frame everything as a service, aka: "You'll own nothing and be happy" leads to these situations. Now it's "just a video game", but this is starting to happen to most walks of life.
- hintymad 4y ago> "You'll own nothing and be happy" leads to these situations. I was wondering if how many people buy into the vision "Welcome To 2030: I Own Nothing, Have No Privacy And Life Has Never Been Better". https://www.forbes.com/sites/worldeconomicforum/2016/11/10/shopping-i-cant-really-remember-what-that-is-or-how-differently-well-live-in-2030/?sh=65b973a11735 https://www.forbes.com/sites/worldeconomicforum/2016/11/10/s...
- Entinel 4y ago> Although the angle of: Losing his characters is the best thing that's happening for him due to wasting a very significant part of his life in video games has some merit It has no merit. Do you look at your hobbies as wasting your life? I certainty don't. My alone time playing video games is just as important to me as when I'm going hiking or camping with friends.
- ElCheapo 4y agoI don't beg for my hobbies, that sounds more like an addiction
- sirsinsalot 4y agoIf I spend 6k hours coding a project and was making noise because I was about to have access to my source code taken away ... would you say i'm an addict?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vrykoul 4y agoRDR2 was released in November of 2019 on Stadia. If he played every day, it would be about 5 hours a day. Assuming he took 2 days off a week: 152 weeks since release 152 * (5 days per week) = 760 days 24 * 760 = 18240 hours 6000 / 18240 = ~0.33 .33 * 24 = ~8 hours every day. That's not a game, that's a job.
- lloydatkinson 4y agoIf this was any other game company I could see it happening but this is Rockstar who would probably see this and choose not to do it not because they can't but because they don't want to.
- karaterobot 4y agoI haven't played RDR online, but I'm pretty surprised. I would have assumed it used your Rockstar account, not your Stadia account, and that you could use that same account on any platform. On the other hand, this is what you have to accept as a possible outcome when you invest yourself in someone else's service. Stadia's existence has been shaky from day 1, so it's not like he couldn't have seen this coming.
- norwalkbear 4y agoPeople need to understand corporations dont care about people. So we shouldn't trust them. I know remember the pitch meeting Google gave to a studio I worked at. Sleazy as hell.
- howaboutnope 4y ago> Because we're so out of our minds with desperation, we don't know any better. All we know is fake fodder and buying shit. That's how we speak to each other, how we express ourselves, is buying shit. What, I have a dream? The peak of our dreams is a new app for our Dopple, it doesn't exist! It's not even there! We buy shit that's not even there. -- The Black Mirror
- maerF0x0 4y agoThis is a risk of and why do you not pour your life into someone else's project. (without a commensurate return that you can own fully) He chose (knowingly or unknowingly) to be meat for a giant machine. Now he wonders why he got ground up and spit out. It's one thing to play a video game and end up grateful for having enjoyed and spent the time on a hobby, and walk away with good memories. It's another thing to end up begging/pleading to a soulless machine for their mercy and consideration.
- throw7 4y agoCan someone explain how you play rdr2 for 6k hours? what exactly is he losing in game when stadia shuts down? so if he had played rdr2 on his pc, then stadia shutdown wouldn't affect him at all right?
- alt227 4y agoRDR2 has an online component just like GTA online. In this online mode you play your character as long as you like, building up assets and stats as you complete missions/raids/races etc. This game mode is open ended, so if you spend enough time you can build up an enormous amount of in game assets and currency. Rockstar locks multiplayer to specific platforms, so if you buy a game on xbox and level up your character there, you can never use that same character on any other platform. In this way you are correct, if he had played on PC all this time then his game save would be in the PC platform cloud not the Stadia cloud. The guy is a youtube/twitch streamer, so to him loosing this character probably feels like loosing his job.
- throw7 4y agoThanks. I understand much better now. I find it strange and leaving a bad taste that your character is tied to your platform, but what do I know.
- import 4y agoIt’s all explained in the article
- danhon 4y agoFor everyone having opinions about how many hours this person has spent playing RDR2, you should probably note that he's an RDR2 Youtube and Twitch content creator/streamer. So at face value, it has been his job for the last 2.5 years.
- tinus_hn 4y agoI’m surprised Stadia was good enough to play live on stream!
- refracture 4y agoYeah that blunts my immediate reaction of "This is blessing in disguise", that said I'm really hard pressed to understand how this person doing this for a job thought Google's streaming service would be the best choice.. at a certain point dedicated hardware is a very sensible business purchase.
- vintermann 4y agoWild guess, but maybe he took a deal to promote it? Not exactly unheard of for streamers.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoStadia had built-in support for streaming directly to Youtube. Very easy, completely integrated and heavily advertised. Setting up your own hardware streaming build in 2019 was more difficult and expensive. So this user "bought" (or accepted) a product from Google that promised to make everything easy for them and, until now, it was fulfilling that promise.
- refracture 4y agoTrue, I hadn't thought of that. Thanks.
- AyyWS 4y agoThank you for the context. Imagine being criticized for spending 6000 hours in Visual Studio.
- CodeWriter23 4y agoSomeone needs to warn those outside of tech about Google's obsession with ruthlessly killing unprofitable or deemed useless projects.
- password321 4y agoSo for that many hours Google must have spent more than he did at the game right? How does a business model like this ever become profitable when it is not subscription or usage based?
- r3trohack3r 4y agoWell, it didn’t because it’s shutting down. But there exist business models that operate like this. Usage usually follows a Pareto distribution. At one end, you spend almost nothing on usage, on the other end you spend more than you charged on usage. Assuming your long tail is long enough, and your power users few enough, you take a loss on one end of the Pareto and make your money on the other. Where these models fail is when you can convert a resource fairly directly into value I.E. compute. Once your customers realize they can put $10 in and get $15 back out, you have a problem.
- standardUser 4y agoAn excellent object lesson on why you never, ever rely on Google. We're all just pawns in their ongoing quest to create and destroy entire online systems, seemingly at random.
- A_D_E_P_T 4y agoI'll just chime in to say that logged hours don't always translate to hours spent playing. I'll often launch a video game, play for 20 minutes, and then alt-tab into my browser and get back to work, with the game paused in the background. At this point, Steam thinks that I've spent 500 hours playing a game, where the actual value is closer to 40. The same effect might be in play here.
- neoromantique 4y agoI don't know about Stadia, but GeForce Now would kick you out after a minute or so.
- smileybarry 4y agoNot really, I've had Control paused for ~20-30 minutes sometimes as I did something in another window. I think it was even on a free account (because I kept thinking about the 1-hour limit).
- rjakobsson 4y agoGoogle is terrible.
- Calamitous 4y agoAnother person learns a hard lesson about trusting Google.
- xerxesaa 4y agoI remember when I spent a couple hundred dollars buying albums on Google Music only to have the service "migrated" to YouTube music. Except now my music is only available with ads whereas before it was ad free. That's not what I paid for. After that, it became clear to me Google could not be trusted. Any service I use with them today, I do so with the expectation of them pulling the rug at any time.
- invalidname 4y ago100% Google is an ad company. Nothing more. Nothing less. They aren't very good at that one either, they just have a monopoly.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt probably won't happen. But FWIW... I had one of the early Nintendo battery-backed carts break on me once. Sent it in for repair. About a month later got a new copy of the cart and a note that apologized for the delay, because their technology allowed them to scan my save file but not to upload it back into the cart. So they'd had a Game Counselor play the game back to where my character was, which delayed the repair. Neither Rockstar nor Google likely have the scale to fix this issue for everyone, but that kind of customer service is how you get customers for life. (To be clear, 6k hours is a lot of time and I don't mean to imply it'll be feasible to solve this user's problem that way. But if they can spend a fraction of that time doing even a one-off import into another data format, wouldn't that be cool.)
- ztjio 4y agoI had several experiences with Nintendo customer service from the NES timeframe through the GameCube timeframe and every single one was amazing, legendary even. I don't know if they're still like that, but, the past, apparent "severity" of their mandate to please customers who had issues leads me to find this story plausible.
- wahnfrieden 4y agowhat was the game that they paid someone to play for you?
- ideamotor 4y agoHow do you spend that many hours on a game? It boggles my mind. I spent a couple hundred hours on DOTA2 in one year and look back at that year as being a year fruitlessly spent playing DOTA2.
- dcdc123 4y agoMan that sucks. Just to point something out, the nvidia solution uses your steam account and syncs save files with steam for supported games just like it does when you install it locally.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoMade me wonder how many hours did Stadia exist for, 25K apparently so this user played for 23% of the consoles entire lifetime.
- Temporary_31337 4y agoSo many people here focus on the guys addiction and not enough focus on how Google screwed everyone over again.
- blockwriter 4y agoRed Dead Redemption 3 will follow a solitary Stadia fan as he roams from town to town in search of those that pulled the plug on Stadia.
- BrainVirus 4y agoThey deserve it for supporting shit like Stadia. It's one rare case where smug, annoying assholes who are cheerleading the destruction of personal computing (and, if you pay attention, the slow abolition of private property) are facing some negative consequences. I used to think that politely warning people about obvious consequences of their bad decisions it a reasonable way to go. That if you are eloquent enough and logical enough they will see the dangers. ("If you use this service right now, Google will control your games in the future.") That was a naive and stupid view. Most people have no imagination whatsoever. They are physically incapable of imagining a shitty situation directly caused by their own decisions and actions. They need a real-life example. Well, this is it.
- NoGravitas 4y agoThe concentration of private property in a few hands is not at all the same as the abolition of private property, my dude. Kind of the opposite.
- Closi 4y agoThis makes a whole lot of negative assumptions about someone who I assume you have never met.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm honestly very surprised Rockstar doesn't provide a way to migrate your story/online character between platforms. At least when I upgraded Xbox versions of GTAV, there was a process to save to Rockstar's servers and then re-load from them, and it worked like a charm. Migrating consoles/platforms is such a common thing to do -- so this is really a Rockstar problem, not a Google one. (I mean purely financially it seems like a no-brainer -- it incentivizes people to buy a new copy of the game, and keep playing to keep those microtransactions rolling in...) On the other hand, if this was a professional gamer, I'm truly confused as to why they sunk 6K hours into the Stadia version? Seems like they'd want to run it locally on an Xbox/PS/PC simply for performance -- and the guarantee that it couldn't be shut down. I always thought Stadia was meant for more casual gamers, and everybody knew Stadia always had the risk it might be shut down, so I really do wonder what this gamer was thinking...?
- sofixa 4y agoRockstar apparently removed cross-platform save migrations due to people cheating on PC and selling accounts for consoles. > Seems like they'd want to run it locally on an Xbox/PS/PC simply for performance Having played RDR2 extensively on Stadia, i assure you there were no performance issues and the visuals were good (not the same as a 4090 RTX gaming PC of course, but still good).
- crazygringo 4y agoUgh, that sucks. You'd hope they could have at least preserved console -> console and console -> PC even if PC -> console was ruined by bad actors.
- aequitas 4y agoThis problem is already leaking into the world of physical consoles. Afaik the only (legal) way to backup your savegame data on a Nintendo Switch is to transfer it directly to another Switch (and deleting it from the first) or get an online account (which was only available 1,5 years after the Switch launched). No saves can be stored on cartridges or the SD card. So if your Switch goes broken for some reason and you didn't want to pay for online backups every month your out of luck.
- esalman 4y agoMy wife is on Google Fi. She got a good deal on a phone that she liked, so we went with it. But I need to figure out how to end the contract gracefully any transfer to another carrier.
- d23 4y agoA lot of critiques here of how this individual chooses to spend his free time by people who choose to spend _their_ free time looking down on others on a web forum.
- 60secs 4y agoYou're going to have a bad time if your business model depends on Google services or APIs.
- rufius 4y agoAs always, don’t use google for anything you care about. News at 5.
- ajxs 4y agoWithout even addressing what it was this guy actually did with his six thousand hours, after investing only six hundred hours of your time in any productive pursuit you'll definitely be showing real results, let alone six thousand. 600 hours invested in learning a language, or improving your physical fitness, or learning an instrument is a serious positive investment in yourself. It's common to hear people wishing they could play piano, or speak French, or many other things. An hour a day is all it takes to do something awesome with your life.
- sly010 4y agoAssuming no technical obstacle, this would be a very cheap PR move. They should definitely wait until last minute though :)
- moralestapia 4y agoSucks to see this guy being criticized so much here. If he just really likes the game, what's wrong with that? Why does it have to be justified as "his work" for it to pass as a barely acceptable thing. I would've expected some empathy for the guy in here of all places. I'd dare to think that most people here spends most of their time in front of a screen anyway, and have done so for years. Whether you're coding or playing a game makes literally no difference to your body and your health. Yet you still have the nerve to pick on a guy who is literally doing no harm to anyone, pathetic.
- ternaus 4y agoSad story. Computer games is a dopamine that you get, but did not earn in the real life. I played computer games since 1992, if I spent all this time on writing code, it would be better. But when you are stressed out or in pain, it is better to play computer games, rather look at alcohol. P.S. When Witcher 4, Stalker 2, or Fallout 5 will be released I will play again :) P.P.S. This story is a great example of why NFTs in the game industry has some value.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> with all 5,907 hours (approximately 246 days) going to waste Well, I sympathise with the player's predicament, but I have to snarkily point out the irony here.