6 ms·
Euro zone inflation soars to a record 10%, piling pressure on the ECB
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agolol Inflation is only 10% if you try to lie about it by averaging in new TVs. When your electricity bill doubles, when your gas bill triples, when food rises by 30% you are not going to be buying a new TV. lmao
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe article specifically addresses that; it's ~5% excluding those two bits. > However, core inflation, which excludes food and energy, climbed 4.8% on the year, up from 4.3% in August, and economists broadly expect the situation to get worse before it gets better.
- lm28469 4y agoIt's waaaaay more than 10% for the average joe though, the person you replied to is right. Day to day purchase are closer to +30% than 10% but if you throw in useless gadgets no one buy in a crisis it goes down a lot. Take Germany for example: https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Economy/Prices/Consumer-Price-Index/consumer-prices-message.html;jsessionid=C859D8B6CAA7A382FBB79F34355CEBC3.live742 https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Economy/Prices/Consumer-Pr...
- ceejayoz 4y agoThat list is a specific set of - again - mostly food and energy items.
- lm28469 4y agoWell guess what people live on ? Food and energy items
- uup 4y agoYes, but that’s the OPs point. No one cares about the price of TVs. The metric (core inflation and CPI) isn’t measuring peoples experience accurately.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The metric (core inflation and CPI) isn’t measuring peoples experience accurately. Yes; that's why the number in the headline is 10%, not the 5% core number.
- UncleMeat 4y agoWhen things like used cars were driving numbers people absolutely wanted to include those in the messaging. I saw zero inflation-bugs complaining that really we should be using food and energy only when those weren't the dominant forces.
- lm28469 4y ago> I saw zero inflation-bugs complaining that really we should be using food and energy only when those weren't the dominant forces. Because it is never that clear cut. If food goes up by 2%, gas/electricity by 3% and TV/video games/cars by 2.5% you can say inflation is ~3% If food goes up by 30%, gas/electricity by 100% and TV/video games/cars by 2.5% saying inflation is 10% by using magic maths is bullshit
- UncleMeat 4y agoBut what if food goes up by 2% and cars/lumber go up by 50%? In that case will you still exclude the cars and lumber?
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoYes and yes. Lumber will come back around into people's expenses for shelter. Cars are harder to justify leaving out.
- isoprophlex 4y agoYes, the things that hurt the 50% below the median the worst. I can stomach my utilities bill going from 200 to 800 eur, I won't like it but we'll manage. The other half of the country will revolt, probably.
- amock 4y agoThe 10% includes food and energy items, but also things that people won't be spending money on when the price of food an energy goes up so it underestimates the impact of an increase in the price of food and energy.
- bcrosby95 4y agoI'm not in the EU, but this is what our family has done. Our food bill alone has gone from around 30% of our takehome pay to around 40%, and we just don't have the income to absorb that increase. So the useless crap, the things that make inflation look not so bad, gets cut out.
- amock 4y agoI'm in the US and this is what I hear from the people I know. Most of those people don't carefully track their expenses so they just know that they have less left over after paying for the necessities. A couple of them do track expenses carefully and when I was talking to them a few months ago they said that their personal inflation rates were at least 20% over the previous 12 months. I just checked heating fuel costs and they're up 36% from last year, which is less than I expected given what other people have said about their costs but it's still significant. It's definitely going to be a hard winter for a lot of people I know.
- Merciernmon 4y agoYou're describing an "income effect." There's also a "substitution effect." The fundamental idea is that people will change their purchases in response to changing prices. If there's a sale on bread, then you might pick up an extra loaf (substitution effect). But if you were a peasant mainly eating bread, then you might actually purchase less bread and more cheese (income effect). Inflation statistics should correspond to what people buy, like an average across households. That's essentially what the government statistical agencies attempt to do using some combination of (1) actual market transactions, and (2) household surveys. Inflation stats are definitely imperfect--but not so obviously flawed as you suggest (weighting TV prices the same as energy prices). Since inflation numbers are an average across households, inflation will certainly differ across households. (For some it will be higher, and for others it will be lower.) It's particularly concerning when food, energy, and housing inflation are higher than other categories (as they are today). Poorer households tend to spend more money on those staple goods. In that case, inflation will be higher for those households already less well off. For anyone interested: "The Government Isn't Cooking the Books on Inflation" https://www.discoursemagazine.com/economics/2021/07/16/the-government-isnt-cooking-the-books-on-inflation/ https://www.discoursemagazine.com/economics/2021/07/16/the-g...
- yucky 4y ago>You're describing an "income effect." There's also a "substitution effect." The fundamental idea is that people will change their purchases in response to changing prices. If there's a sale on bread, then you might pick up an extra loaf (substitution effect). But if you were a peasant mainly eating bread, then you might actually purchase less bread and more cheese (income effect). Maybe you'll substitute cheese for bread, but you're not going to substitute a TV and some extra pairs of jeans for your electricity and gas.
- User23 4y agoThis could get really bad. I mean Zimbabwe or Weimar bad. If energy shortages cause a crash in production there will be no central bank intervention capable of bringing down inflation because the problem will be on the supply side.
- causi 4y agoThis why I don't understand people who argue we're spending too much on military aid to Ukraine. The sooner Russia loses the sooner Europe can go back to buying energy from them. The paltry few billion we've sent so far is nothing compared to the costs of long-term sanction enforcement. We should be flooding Ukraine with a deluge of money and advanced weapons and vehicles on the financial merits alone.
- User23 4y agoUnless the Russians are bluffing about using their nukes, they literally can’t lose. They can only fail to win. Nuclear war will also cause hyperinflation, although at that point it will probably be academic.
- ido 4y agoFor Putin's regime, failing to win is basically losing.
- akmarinov 4y agoWhat’s win though? If his mobilization manages to keep Ukraine forces at bay and he goes through with joining Luhansk, Donetsk, Kherson and Zaporozhia to Russia - is that the win scenario? He can probably pull that together pretty easily by dumping 1-2 million russians in it. If he stalls things for 2-3 years with the new borders, the West is likely to give up and just have them be another Crimea. NATO certainly won’t send troops in.
- ido 4y ago
- daniel-s 4y agoWhat happens when you get high inflation and the central bank can't stop money printing because it would cause your sovereign to default, like we saw this week in the UK?
- fbn79 4y agoActually higher is inflation the lover is absolute value of sovereign debt
- mywittyname 4y agoIs there any evidence that this inflation is due to "money printing"? The reason I mention this is that the Euro would experience inflation even if the central bank turned to a policy "money destroying" because the USD is absolutely crushing every currency. Even bastions of stability like the CHF have lost 10% of their value against the dollar. So any produces or services that touch an American company in any capacity are going to see inflation. The subject is far more complex than money printing...If there was "one weird trick to stop inflation," then we'd never have inflation.
- andreilys 4y agoIs there any evidence that increasing the money supply causes inflation? Yes, basic logic. Central banks purchasing assets like index funds, bonds, etc. will naturally cause prices to rise. I’m not entirely sure how you can steel man an argument that printing trillions of dollars will not lead to higher inflation but I’m happy to hear it.
- mywittyname 4y agoSorry, this simple argument fails because central banks have been doing this for 15 years, and 13 of those years they were complaining about a lack of inflation. Ergo, the current inflationary environment is not the result of central bank activities. A bunch of things have changed in the past few years, which could trigger inflation. A massive pandemic that continues to kill millions every month, lock downs in China that curb the ability of the world's largest producer of goods to produce goods, a war in Europe which has caused a massive energy crisis. So where I'm sitting, basic logic exculpates central banks.
- nextstep 4y agoThis is a low cost to pay if someday we can live in a world where there are American/EU chain stores on every corner of Kyiv.
- ahtihn 4y agoWhy? Why should the average EU citizen care what kind of stores are in Ukraine? I very much do not want to sacrifice even the tiniest bit of quality of life because of whatever happens in Ukraine. I still do not understand what is so special about that country compared to all the other countries in which terrible things are happening.
- type0 4y ago> I very much do not want to sacrifice even the tiniest bit of quality of life because of whatever happens in Ukraine. Then move to Hungary, Orban promised that people there won't sacrifice anything.
- nemo44x 4y agoI think the OP was being sarcastic. They're saying this is more about EU/USA business interests and using Ukraine as a proxy to fight Russia than any type of actual humanitarian aid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PoignardAzur 4y ago- It has shared borders with EU countries. - Ex-USSR countries in the EU understandably feel a little touchy about Russia claiming a natural right to invade an ex-USSR country. - In many countries where horrible things are happening, the horrible things are internal and the result of civil war or a corrupt government. In many cases it's doubtful that outside intervention would help. In the case of Ukraine, it's pretty straightforward: other country invades -> we send lots of tanks for Ukraine to defend itself -> other country is repealed -> Ukraine is not being invaded anymore -> things have improved. > I very much do not want to sacrifice even the tiniest bit of quality of life because of whatever happens in Ukraine. Obviously people who disagree outnumber you. Telling them "No! You're wrong! Don't you see the wisdom of my cynicism?" is not going to budge anybody at this point.
- aseerdbnarng 4y agoHow exactly is the ECB supposed to provide cheap energy via interest rates? And what exactly is the thinking here? Energy bills have more than trebled and people are going to be thankful to central banks for paying 3x more for their mortgage? The best thing central banks can do is sit on their hands for now