16 ms·
The reality of celebratory gunfire
- cyberCleve 4y agoWhy is the velocity of a falling bullet > the speed of gravity?
- philwelch 4y agoGravity isn’t a speed, it’s a force.
- nobody9999 4y ago>Gravity isn’t a speed, it’s a force. Actually, it's not a force either[0]. It feels like a force, but it's just mass acting in warped space-time. [0] http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/140-physics/the-theory-of-relativity/general-relativity/1059-if-gravity-isn-t-a-force-how-does-it-accelerate-objects-advanced http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/140-physics/the-th...
- philwelch 4y agoI yield to your superior pedantry :) But seriously, thanks!
- midoridensha 4y agoOnly if you believe the theory of relativity is correct. If you believe in quantum mechanics or some other theory of gravity, this isn't true.
- nobody9999 4y ago>Only if you believe the theory of relativity is correct. https://bohring.substack.com/p/how-do-we-know-that-general-relativity https://bohring.substack.com/p/how-do-we-know-that-general-r... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tests_of_general_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tests_of_general_relativity https://www.researchgate.net/post/Why_you_think_that_general_theory_of_relativity_is_wrong_or_incomplete https://www.researchgate.net/post/Why_you_think_that_general... https://archive.ph/iVZZu https://archive.ph/iVZZu https://www.livescience.com/black-hole-image-shows-einstein-right-again.html https://www.livescience.com/black-hole-image-shows-einstein-... Und so weiter, und so weiter...
- midoridensha 4y agoI can show you plenty of tests "proving" that Newtonian mechanics are correct too. General relativity doesn't correctly predict things at quantum scale.
- vlovich123 4y agoGravity doesn’t have a speed. It creates an acceleration due to force. The bullet is accelerating over a great distance until it reaches terminal velocity (where the air resistance counterbalances any gains in acceleration). The easiest way to think about it is in terms of conservation of energy. All the kinetic energy the bullet has at the muzzle is converted into gravitational potential until velocity hits zero. At that point, gravitational velocity starts getting converted directly back into kinetic energy. If not for air resistance, the bullet would reach the ground at roughly muzzle velocity. However, air resistance on the way up zaps some of that energy and presents a velocity barrier on the way down.
- sobriquet9 4y agoThere are two components - horizontal and vertical. For a bullet fired straight up, horizontal component is negligible, as the bullet will spend enough time in flight for it to decrease due to air resistance. The vertical component is primarily determined by sectional density. Tumbling bullet spends a lot of time flying sideways, so its terminal velocity (where air resistance equals weight) is way less than muzzle velocity.
- renewiltord 4y agoIt's not. The magnitude of the velocity of a falling bullet (in the low m/s) is many orders of magnitude lower than the speed of gravity (which propagates at the speed of light)
- magicalhippo 4y agoBy "speed of gravity" I assume you mean terminal velocity[1]. If not fired fairly straight up the bullet can maintain a ballistic trajectory[2], rather than being in a vertical free fall. In that case, the higher speed compared to the terminal velocity is simply because it has yet to shed the speed it acquired[3] when it was accelerated out of the barrel. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_velocity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_velocity [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballistics [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muzzle_velocity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muzzle_velocity
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anonu 4y agoFascinating - but not really a solvable problem if I am going to be cynical about it. Too few data points spread out across different geographies means there are other problems with higher social impact.
- ajross 4y ago> not really a solvable problem if I am going to be cynical about it Seems like it's a trivially solvable problem. In fact in almost all of the industrialized world it's not a problem at all. You're just saying that you don't want it solved, which is a statement (in the US) as much about political identity as it is about practical policymaking. But it's not about "solvability" at all.
- merlincorey 4y agoWhat is the trivial solution?
- Filligree 4y agoDon’t have guns.
- Fatnino 4y agoDon't have celebrations.
- whatshisface 4y agoDon't fire guns into the air during celebrations. (Thesis, antithesis, synthesis.)
- brippalcharrid 4y agoEven not using live ammunition in the guns that you're firing into the air during celebrations would be enough to avoid this particular problem.
- sobriquet9 4y ago
- captainoats 4y agoYa, their predicted descent velocity/lethality is not right. Most ammunition will destabilize and begin to tumble long before it reaches its peak as it transitions from supersonic to subsonic. My guess would be the dangerous situation here is intoxicated people shooting up in the air but then also in other directions in a careless inebriated state.
- fzzt 4y agoThis appears to be a poorly-sourced "research" page put together by a marketing agency. There's really nothing there about the methodology of this work, and there's plenty to suggests the authors have very little knowledge of firearms (a fired bullet in the first animation is shown with a casing, there's no discussion of bullet aerodynamics which are going to be very different for most sharp-tipped rifle bullets and for handgun rounds, etc) or physics (e.g., no accounting for energy when evaluating the velocity at which a bullet can penetrate skull).
- Mathnerd314 4y agoPer https://mythresults.com/episode50 https://mythresults.com/episode50, Mythbusters found that if a bullet is fired upward at a non-vertical angle, it will maintain its spin and will reach a high enough speed to be lethal on impact. Because of this potentiality, firing a gun into the air is illegal in most states, and is not recommended by the police in the others. Also the MythBusters were able to identify two people who had been injured by falling bullets, one of them fatally injured. The non-lethal was only if the bullet was fired perfectly straight up using precision alignment. It seems to be a common disinformation tactic to take this section out of context and claim that Mythbusters said shooting up was fine.
- deltasevennine 4y agoWow thank you for this. Literally almost believed him. The amount of authority people speak with is just insane. Literally the truth was the exact opposite. Goes to show people believe the thing that's most convenient for them to believe.
- donatj 4y agoI'm pretty sure their calculations assume a perfect impossible arc. A bullet coming down is catching the wind and spinning wildly directing force in all directions and likely not getting anywhere near terminal velocity. It's like dropping a penny off of skyscraper. Mathematically it could kill somebody, but in all likelihood it's not going to. This has been shown experimentally time and time again.
- autoexec 4y ago> Mathematically it could kill somebody, but in all likelihood it's not going to. This has been shown experimentally time and time again. Yet somehow people keep dying tho don't they? Some quick examples: https://blogs.bcm.edu/2019/12/31/what-goes-up-must-come-down-the-dangers-of-celebratory-gunfire/ https://blogs.bcm.edu/2019/12/31/what-goes-up-must-come-down... https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/least-17-killed-celebratory-gunfire-kabul-reports-2021-09-04/ https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/least-17-killed-c... https://www.thetrace.org/2015/07/celebratory-gunfire-july-4-fireworks/ https://www.thetrace.org/2015/07/celebratory-gunfire-july-4-... Seems like the math says celebratory gunfire is a stupid practice that needlessly kills and injures people and endangers many others since serious accidents also occur in addition to the deaths and injury caused by falling bullets. Plenty of other things make loud noises without seriously hurting or killing people. I really don't see the point in defending this one.
- 1shooner 4y agoMath called something stupid? More stupid than flying in an airplane, or going to a hospital for surgery? Without a denominator, isn't the math basically silent on just how dangerous a given celebratory bullet is, relative to other behavior?
- autoexec 4y agoIt doesn't matter how dangerous it is vs flying in an airplane or having surgery since those activities serve a purpose and there aren't equivalent alternatives that don't involve risk. If everyone in the world suddenly stopped flying or getting surgery tomorrow deaths and suffering would increase. If everyone stopped recklessly and needlessly shooting firearms at the sky, deaths and suffering would decrease. It doesn't matter how many deaths celebratory bullets cause. Any number of deaths greater than zero is too many deaths because celebratory gunfire serves zero useful purpose beyond "I think it's fun and I care more about that than I do about human life and the suffering this activity causes" and alternative options exist for "fun" that don't cause deaths and injuries to innocent people. If people who were irresponsible with firearms only ever killed themselves I'd be much much less concerned, but the lives of others will always win out over someone who just wants to celebrate with their favorite way to make bang bang noises.
- thakoppno 4y ago> The velocity decreases to almost zero. Tiny nit, but the bullet does reach a velocity of zero at it’s apex momentarily?
- lwneal 4y agoHaving been fired at 88 degrees from the horizon, the bullet is still moving (slightly) sideways.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 4y ago
- bhaney 4y agoThis article is trying to focus on falling bullets, but the only death it mentions (the Syrian refugee in Lebanon) was killed by a stray shot fired more or less horizontally from a rooftop, not from a bullet that was fired (approximately) straight up and then fell. And that's of course the real danger of celebratory gunfire - drunken partiers continuing to fire off shots as they're lowering their guns without thinking. Shots fired upwards generally aren't lethal on the way down because the terminal velocity of a tumbling bullet (which the simulation in this article isn't accounting for) is usually rather low.
- kyleyeats 4y agoWhether or not it tumbles or remains ballistic is the biggest factor here. Surprised the article just failed to mention it.
- detaro 4y ago> While the return velocity is dependent upon a number of factors, firing angle is extremely important. Bullets fired at an angle maintain their angular ballistic trajectory and are less likely to tumble, allowing them to pick up more speed on the way down. It doesn't go into detail, but it does mention it.
- ycombinete 4y agoIt looks like you are responding to the first sentence of the article. The immediately following two sentences: "A small plane was shot down when it flew over a wedding party with guests celebrating the occasion by discharging firearms into the air. In California, five fans were injured inside the Oakland Coliseum by falling bullets fired from a neighboring community."
- bhaney 4y agoThose sentences don't mention deaths, which I specifically scoped my response to. Of course falling bullets can hurt people. I expect they would leave quite the welt.
- iJohnDoe 4y agoI’ll never forget watching the nightly news and seeing a report of a child being killed by a stray bullet that was shot into the air by someone far away. They were being held by their Dad. Broke my heart. I wish there were more PSAs about not firing guns into the air. The bullets always have to come down somewhere.
- denkmoon 4y agoReally shows how little thought people put into the consequences of their actions. Literally half a second of thinking would reveal it is a stupid and dangerous thing to do, yet here we are. The selfishness is the most galling part.
- autoexec 4y agoI'd guess that at least in America drinking is pretty commonly involved so anyone spending half a second thinking wouldn't have made it past alcohol+guns.
- Nextgrid 4y agoResponsible gun ownership should prevent anyone from bringing a gun in a situation where they will be drinking, or leave the gun in a safe place before staring to drink. Sadly, a lot of people in the US own guns to make a political statement and have little interest in safe & responsible gun ownership.
- sureglymop 4y agoWould it really be that hard to just implement some better checks/requirements for people before they are able to buy a gun? Genuinely asking. It seems it's possible to do the bare minimum for letting people drive but somehow not for letting them buy guns. I mean just a little bit of training should make sure that they know not to drink and be anywhere near their guns.. or to have their guns stored somewhere safe and e.g. unreachable by kids, etc. and not easy to grab.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe problem is that, not having a criminal record, and other easily "testable" things, is actually NOT a good proxy for having the emotional intelligence and responsibility and CONSISTENT RIGOR to never do something even a little dangerous with a gun. In fact we see the same thing with regulation around cars. It turns out being able to parallel park is a bad proxy for someone not being stupid with a two ton machine, and plenty of licensed drivers still end up driving distracted, or using their phone, or drinking and driving AND DEFENDING IT. Humans in general are very irresponsible creatures who like to blame others for poor choices they make. Why are we so confused when it comes to guns? So many firearm related incidents involve "responsible gun owners" until, oops, turns out they weren't responsible. How do you LEGALLY VERIFY someone is permanently responsible?
- vondur 4y agoIt sounds like a warzone here in the Los Angeles area every New Years Eve.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoWhy not fire blanks? One must be a real idiot to be firing live rounds into the air.
- mikewarot 4y agoJust as all guns are loaded, all blanks are real bullets. (Metaphorical truths, you live longer if you act like they are true) Blanks can kill too, by the way. Why not just use fire crackers?
- dudeinjapan 4y agoBecause firecrackers can kill too. Nothing is any fun anymore.
- Ekaros 4y agoBlanks are complicated. Many types of weapons rely on pressure in barrel to cycle the action, without a bullet this pressure doesn't go high enough. So blank firing guns are likely modified in one way or an other.
- mrguyorama 4y agoYou probably ALSO don't need to mag dump into the sky, so a blank not being able to adequately cycle your weapon probably shouldn't be a big issue?
- the_third_wave 4y agoThat is why you put a stop on the muzzle - the red thing with a hole in it you might have seen or even used if you were in the military - so that enough pressure is built up to cycle the action. Another function of the stop is to catch any small bits of plastic from the blank rounds which might otherwise be ejected at eye-piercing speed.
- exhilaration 4y agoI was going to say, where do you even find blanks and I bet they're more expensive than normal ammo but no, you can easily order them online like this random example: https://greencountryammo.com/9mm-BLANK-Ammunition-DAG-100-rounds-Bulk-IN-STOCK_p_1376.html https://greencountryammo.com/9mm-BLANK-Ammunition-DAG-100-ro... and they're only 2/3rds the cost of target ammunition.
- dn3500 4y agoWhat's with the obsession for football fields as a unit of distance?
- collegeburner 4y agomost ppl can visualize a football field as a unit of large distance because it's a large thing we've all stood on and regularly see. so it kinda makes sense and is easier to visualize than a mile. good "for scale". what's with the hate on measuring things in football fields, aside from some hand-waving about it being "unscientific"? like yeah don't use it in a research paper but i don't see a problem with it.
- howling 4y agoFootball field doesn't have a fixed length and can be anywhere between 90m and 120m. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_pitch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_pitch
- collegeburner 4y agoi said football field, not pitch. they're measured in yards and all come to 100 of them. glad to know soccer fields vary in length since that means they're obviously not a good unit of measure and there won't be any confusion :)
- mc32 4y agoTo use a pun, these are ballpark figures to give people a general idea, not an exact measure. Also about as heavy as a midsized car. Just gives people a general idea. Akin to stadia.
- function_seven 4y agoUsing “ballpark figure” to explain “football field” is my favorite thing today. I never quibble with these types of comparisons, except for Libraries of Congress when trying to convey the amount of data something can hold. I have no idea how large the LoC is. My touchstone for data capacity is MP3s (128k/48kHz, of course :) As far as football fields goes, I’d think it works best because gridirons and pitches are roughly the same size. Almost everyone has had experience with at least one of those, right?
- raydiatian 4y agoThe irony is that this doesn’t seem to be “aimed” at the celebratory gunfire community at all
- pkdpic 4y agoTODR > Logic dictates that indiscriminately firing a gun into the air is probably not a great idea. I'm sold. I'll never fire that gun I don't own into the air randomly like a psychotic toddler again. But I will feel better about staying inside on all those crazy PTSD inducing holidays to avoid stray bullet rain. Side rant, why are holidays that are oriented around celebrating events credited to military personnel perfectly designed to exacerbate some of the most common chronic psychological ailments of military personnel? Asking for a friend.
- awb 4y agoA roof might provide some resistance, but would it necessarily protect you from bodily harm?
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoBy the time a bullet comes through your roof from a steep ballistic trajectory, probably yes.
- autoexec 4y agoMemorial day fireworks are absolutely a dick move.
- NathanKP 4y agoMy personal theory on celebratory fireworks for national events is that they are specifically intended to create a long lasting association between the sounds of war and the feeling of patriotism. When war breaks out, and someone is used to fireworks already, then the sounds are a bit less scary and maybe they even feel some psychological response of patriotism, planted by the various firework shows they've been to in past holidays. Of course once someone has actually seen war firsthand then they are going to have an entirely different set of psychological responses to those sounds.
- newuwstudent 4y agoI think it’s because loud sounds and big explosions are cool to hear and see
- amitport 4y agoStop it while you can. Nice presentations and education do not work on people who simply don't care about the damage they do. You need to invest in tough unrelentless enforcement. Here (the Negev) we have these random shootings almost every evening. it quickly gets out of hand.
- autoexec 4y ago> Nice presentations and education do not work on people who simply don't care about the damage they do. I think it can help. Plenty of people in this discussion have been mistakenly under the impression that it's mostly harmless because of "air resistance" or "bullet tumbling" or whatever other nonsense they were told. I think a little education could go a long way. If nothing else, it would mean we can't say people weren't warned when we throw the book at them for needlessly putting other people's lives at risk.
- system2 4y agoPut several people in jail for 1-2 years then you will see it will stop very fast. That's how Singapore took care of their drug problem: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/singapore-is-winning-the-war-on-drugs-heres-how/2018/03/11/b8c25278-22e9-11e8-946c-9420060cb7bd_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/singapore-is-winning...
- autoexec 4y agoI don't know if we need to jump straight to Singapore levels of enforcement (not a model I'd like our justice system to take example from generally), but for a certain subset of the population there will have to be consistent and meaningful consequences for their selfishness.
- amitport 4y agoRecklessly firing a firearm is not like throwing bubble gum. It should be treated very severely IMO.
- aaron695 4y ago
- sharkjacobs 4y agoI don’t own or use guns and I’ve never done this but I would think that dangerousness is what makes it exciting and “celebratory”. Fireworks are more fun than flashing lights, because they’re explosives. They’re fun just to buy and handle, to feel the paper and smell the chemicals. It’s fun to set up them up in a backyard and light the fuses and then run clear before they go off.
- lrem 4y agoRolling the dice on maybe killing or maiming an innocent bystander is fun?
- midasuni 4y agoIt’s dangerous for others, far moreso than fireworks where the main danger is hurting yourself.
- toomanybeersies 4y agoDepends on where you live I suppose. Due to the risk of causing bushfires, fireworks are banned in most of Australia.
- thih9 4y ago> Fireworks are more fun than flashing lights, because they’re explosives. This is not objective; e.g.: fireworks are fun to me because of the light show and explosives are not a factor at all (I'd prefer aurora to fireworks).
- matt-attack 4y agoThink about the 21 Gun Salute. A tribute used at funerals for fallen warriors. My understanding is it’s an old old ceremony. Given the somber event, I suspect the “danger” of the act had little to do with it. I think firing artillery and arms has has long been associated with reflective notable events (both celebratory and depressing).
- mrguyorama 4y ago
- cat_plus_plus 4y ago"We ran simulations for five of the most common ammunition types in the U.S. at five different firing angles. The answer to the most important question became immediately and abundantly clear." - the most important step is missing between first and second sentences here.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoAnybody got a comparison chart or data for Excel handy to compare the “reality” of celebratory gunfire versus large hail thrown from the sky at our mushy little water meat bags by nature? I seem to remember a storm here in north Texas at Mayfest in the 90s turning canopies into Swiss cheese…
- guggle 4y agoAs a shooter myself, I find this behaviour completely irresponsible. Even more so when alcohol is involved. Guns have no place at a party, full stop.
- cassepipe 4y agoThanks to author of the animation to have included meter metrics (in smallprint)
- h2odragon 4y agoEvery bullet fired can, potentially, kill. Do not fire at anything you do not want to kill. First lesson I got before getting a BB gun; first lesson I give others before teaching them to shoot. Someone who can't absorb the idea that their actions will have consequences is not safe with a gun or any other weapon.
- mrbombastic 4y agoI find gun safety education and training notably absent from the gun control debate in the states. Shooting guns in summer camp and boy scouts they really drilled into you to take the thing seriously and NEVER point the barrel at anything you don’t want to kill. Now as an adult I have been around gun owners on multiple occasions who casually swing around their AR15s with the barrel passing over me and act as if I am dramatic by telling them to please not point a deadly weapon at me.
- krapp 4y agoYes, it's unfortunate that (thanks partly to SCOTUS) the Second Amendment doesn't come with prerequisites or confer responsibilities. Owning a gun should be a privilege like driving a car, IMO, not a right. Certainly not a Constitutional right.
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- Spivak 4y agoWhat you're describing is how 2A works currently, it's not like it's a wild west, the regulations around gun ownership are crazy strict. Gun owners would rejoice if guns were regulated as loosely as cars. The only thing the gov't can't really do is outlaw them completely everywhere.
- wombat-man 4y agoYou need a reality check my friend: https://www.statista.com/chart/20047/gun-carry-laws-in-us-states/ https://www.statista.com/chart/20047/gun-carry-laws-in-us-st... In all of those states you need a license to drive a car, but you don't need squat to walk into a shop or a gun show and walk out with weaponry in a lot of places in the US. https://brilliantmaps.com/buy-gun-map/ https://brilliantmaps.com/buy-gun-map/
- gadders 4y agoTIL if I drop a bullet off the top of Burj Khalifa it could kill someone.
- cf141q5325 4y agoAnyone have a source on the first graphic? 95% of incidents recorded by the gun violence archive having occurred on July 4th, December 31st or January 1st is an extraordinary claim. If that is true this puts gun violence statistics in the US into a whole other light.
- goodluckchuck 4y agoThe graphic makes the classic error of depicting an entire shell casing flying along with the bullet. However, it also shows what appears to be a pistol round flying out of a shotgun.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 4y agoThey go up as flying bullets. They come down as falling rocks. A falling rock can be deadly. Dont throw pennies off of skyscrapers. But my takeaway from this article is that the danger from falling bullets pales in comparison to the danger of just being near someone firing a gun. Lots of people are killed every day in accidental discharges. Compared to that, a billion-to-one risk of a falling bulllet isnt a big deal. How many are killed by lightening falling from the sky? At least with these falling bullets one has time enough to get under cover, or even just cover one's head, both of which would protect well enough.
- Karto 4y agoFriends of mine, having romantic dinner on their terrace, had bird shot land into their dinner plates. Bird shot is so small, it's no more deadly than raindrops when it falls back down, but it's a startling seasoning for a nice dish. The bird hunter who'd shot was in sight, they caught up with him, and he just didn't deem it to be a problem...
- matt-attack 4y agoFun fact: bird shot is the only item you’re allowed to *remove* from your mouth when dining with the Queen of England.
- zach_garwood 4y agoHow would one dine with her? Is she a zombie now?
- yc-kraln 4y agoAll of the infographics on that site don't show bullets being fired, they show whole cartridges. It's also talking about bullet weights and speeds, and completely skips the concept of "energy" (i.e. Joules) which is what actually matters for this analysis. Additionally, they seem to assume that the trajectories are always perfectly ballistic, and that the projectile never begins to tumble or otherwise present any sort of wind resistance. It just screams that the people involved in the process have never actually been anywhere near any firearms. This makes it extremely difficult for me to believe that any sort of intellectual rigor went into any of it. Not that I believe firing guns in the air is a good idea, mind you, but this is lazy.
- fogof 4y agoThey address this at the end of the article > Our calculations account for air drag and the effects of gravity. > While the return velocity is dependent upon a number of factors, firing angle is extremely important. Bullets fired at an angle maintain their angular ballistic trajectory and are less likely to tumble, allowing them to pick up more speed on the way down. You make a good point about the infographic showing a cartridge being fired, but as far as I can tell there is only one infographic on the page that actually shows this. These factors make me suspect that you didn't actually read the article to the end before criticizing it. "Intellectual rigor" indeed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- orangepurple 4y agoNobody is talking about celebratory ground shooting which is even more dangerous to everyone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AI9qRmWCEJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AI9qRmWCEJw