4 ms·
An app downloading on behalf of the user isn't a privacy issue. Are their servers acting as a proxy? Whether that's a privacy issue depends on how they config
by Dylan16807 4y ago
An app downloading on behalf of the user isn't a privacy issue.
Are their servers acting as a proxy? Whether that's a privacy issue depends on how they configure/limit/audit their servers.
- xvector 4y agoThat is a naive view. If/when the app devs go malicious, it will be Meta on the legal hook for users' "stolen data." The press and users will blame Meta, not the developers of this app, or the users that unwittingly handed over their data. The headlines will say "X million Facebook users' data leaked," or "X million Facebook users hacked." Meta is acting in an entirely reasonable manner for a company under such regulatory and press scrutiny.
- Thorrez 4y agoBlocking the app from accessing Instagram is one thing. Permanently banning the Facebook accounts of all the employees is another.
- josephcsible 4y agoDoes Microsoft get blamed every time credentials get stolen from a Windows box? Why would this be any different?
- cortesoft 4y agoIf Microsoft provided a public API where you could download all the credentials for both the user and all their friends, then yes, Microsoft would be blamed.
- stevewatson301 4y agoBecause FB was blamed for the Cambridge Analytica scandal, which, at its core, was simply an issue of providing Oauth2 logins to third parties.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's a potential privacy violation. Distinguishing "it violates privacy" and "it could violate privacy if the code was changed" is not naive.
- xvector 4y agoAre you seriously saying it should be Meta's job to continuously reverse engineer a third party client (that doesn't even have a privacy policy) to figure out if it violates users' privacy? That's absurd. Far more sensible to just ban it and call it a day.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI didn't say that. What I said is that the two scenarios are very different. ipsum2 is accusing the devs of already violating privacy. Also their privacy policy is here: https://www.theogapp.com/privacy https://www.theogapp.com/privacy
- likpok 4y agoAn app downloading data on behalf of the user is basically what Cambridge Analytica was doing. The problem is that data ownership is complicated. If I know your phone number, can I share it with other people? That was CA (me downloading data about all my friends). Here the issue is private messages — is it okay for me to share the messages you sent privately to me? A lot of people will get quite upset if you do that!
- josephcsible 4y agoIf I send you something, you should be able to copy and distribute it as you see fit, no matter what I wish you would and wouldn't do with it, and my recourse should be limited to not sending you more things in the future.
- kredd 4y agoWhat if you make me sign some sort of NDA/ToS?
- josephcsible 4y agoTo be clear, I'm not saying that there should be no consequences if you distribute a message that I didn't want you to. I'm just saying that I shouldn't be able to stop you from doing so. If you signed a contract saying you wouldn't, and then you do, I should still be able to sue for that, but the existence of such a contract shouldn't let me control your technology to prevent you from breaking it in the first place.
- joshuamorton 4y agoI'm confused, what's the point of the contract that says "you can't do this" if not to legally enforce that you can't do that?
- josephcsible 4y agoI'm distinguishing between two different meanings of "can't": not allowed vs. not capable. You should be capable of violating NDA/ToS's, but possibly suffer legal consequences if you choose to do so.
- bagels 4y agoThe FTC consent decree disagrees with this take.
- cortesoft 4y agoHow is Facebook supposed to know how they configure/limit/audit their servers? Are they just supposed to take their word for it? Cambridge Analytica said they weren't abusing their access, too.
- phendrenad2 4y agoSomeone didn't read the GDPR...