10 ms·
Amazon deleted my Final Space digital purchases of season 1 and 2
- antonymy 4y agoThis is the exact reason I have never "bought" digital "copies" of anything. A subscription service is one thing, but selling a "digital copy" is basically a scam.
- thot_experiment 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but the only things we can really do to combat this increasingly absurd breakdown of intellectual property law is to teach people how to safely and effectively pirate things, and raise awareness that the problem is copyright itself. The only way I see this changing anytime is through a massive cultural shift in our views toward intellectual property, and I think the only way we can make that happen is by bringing it to the forefront of people's minds. I'm not sure, but I think making piracy easy and appealing is essential to taking the wind out of the sails of the enormous entrenched interests that seek to lock down IP. Ultimately copyright is a tool that serves those who can buy up copyrights a whole lot more than it serves artists, and that fact is very corrosive to our society. Artists and creatives still need protection and support, but Disney and Amazon can go fuck themselves. Basing our economic system in the digital world on artificial scarcity doesn't make any sense and artificial scarcity itself is morally incorrect. P.S. Since people may ask if I have any concrete solutions. No, not really other than I think everyone would be better off if copyright and patents were limited to something sane like 10 years with no option to extend that time.
- __s 4y agoConcrete solution is an HDMI adapter splice that can record to a USB drive whatever passes through it
- rolobio 4y agoThis may not always work, data going through HDMI is frequently encrypted. If you try to capture the data between a Blu-ray drive and a TV (for example), it will be encrypted.
- f1shy 4y agoBut there must be a point, where you still have full digital original signal, but decoded. It has to be possible.
- xeromal 4y agoI believe the private keys are in the TVs themselves. Not sure how accessible the keys are.
- everforward 4y agoI could be wrong, but I was under the impression that you can get cheap Chinese HDMI splitters that strip the encryption. I would think it has to be relatively easy to decrypt given that the Blu-Ray player has to either send a decryption key to the TV via the HDMI cable, or the TV has to already have a decryption key that could presumably be skimmed.
- tehwebguy 4y agoFrom what I can tell the splitters essentially convince the playback device to play by relaying whatever HDCP messages the TV sends: Playback Device (Roku etc) | | Splitter ------ Unauthorized Player (Recorder) | | Authorized Player (TV) Without this the Playback Device will show a black screen, an HDCP error message or something similar, but even with the splitter & an authorized player it seems the content can be encrypted. Since the TV obviously has the capability of decrypting the content it seems like there should be a way to split the signal somewhere between the main TV board and the display panel(s), which sounds like a big deal. Or maybe someone could make an incomplete splitter / recorder that just needs a legit Samsung board attached to it?
- everforward 4y agoI did a Google because I was curious, and some of them do indeed strip the HDCP. I think what you're saying is basically what's happening. The HDMI splitter pretends to be a display/TV, so the playback device sends encrypted data to the splitter, which decrypts it and forwards the decrypted part over the HDMI connections. From what I could find, it's usually the cheap HDMI splitters that emit unencrypted data over the HDMI ports. That kind of makes sense; they implement HDCP inbound because they have to, but they leave HDCP off the output ports because it reduces their manufacturing cost. I think you can't just "forward" the encrypted packets, because then both outputs on the splitter would try to communicate back to the player, causing issues. The splitter has to MITM the connection. https://www.tweaking4all.com/home-theatre/remove-hdcp-hdmi-signal/ https://www.tweaking4all.com/home-theatre/remove-hdcp-hdmi-s... has some cursory info, and links to HDMI splitters that strip HDCP (not an endorsement of whatever you do with them, just an interesting device).
- CabSauce 4y agoThis is often suggested on HN anytime there's some minor issue with streaming. Piracy isn't a solution to anything. Yes, there are issues with intellectual property, but most of the issues aren't with movies/TV/art. Without people paying for these things, studios won't invest vast sums of money in them and we wouldn't have the vast amount of high quality content we have today.
- nickthegreek 4y agoPirating is the solution if you want to watch Final Space in the year 2025.
- CabSauce 4y agoSure. I guess in this very narrow situation where the content is no longer available, I don't have an issue. But the person I responded to seemed to be suggesting stealing content as some sort of broad solution to an undescribed issue.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoThe problem is that you don't know which things need to be downloaded until they disappear.
- megous 4y agoAnyone can also do both if they like. Buy and download to have an archival copy.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoAll three seasons are available for streaming on hindilinks4u and probably a lot of other places so it's not yet lost.
- virtual_void 4y agoI think you’re presenting a false dichotomy here. Piracy has always been there and studios still make a lot of money. People are still willing to pay for things, they just want a copy of the thing that they paid for so that it cannot be stolen from them later. The only answer here IS piracy.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> The only way I see this changing anytime is through a massive cultural shift Solutions like that or, "if everyone would just _", or "everybody needs to _" will never happen. Just my own rule of thumb.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoNever? Like universal suffrage, civil rights, (mostly universal) education, the Montreal Protocol, seatbelts, airbags, anti-lock braking. Nah, you know what, forget it, give up, shits fucked and people are dumb. /s Edit to add: unleaded fuel, catalytic converters, emmision standards, one third of owner-occupied homes in Australia have rooftop solar, the widespread acceptance of anthropogenic induced climate drivers.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoYou're talking about issues solved either through a critical mass of people wanting change or legislation. I'm not saying do nothing.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoThey're the same thing. Cristal mass is "if everyone would just". Legislation largely works because those subject to it largely agree to abide. If everyone would just agree to stop using the old thing / start doing the new thing.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI'm not following. Everyone agrees that smart (surveillance) TVs suck but nobody is willing to take their money elsewhere. I'm the only person, in my social circle, who cares about this issue. How do we get to a critical mass of people when we are starting from essentially 0? I think it takes time.
- MrPatan 4y agoCritical mass is "if enough people would just" Other stuff, like communism, really requires "if everybody would just". An arbitrarily small number of defectors will make the system tip towards collapse.
- vasco 4y agoIn Europe you can vote for the Pirate Party in several countries, including for European parliament. There are problems with such parties at the local level because it's hard to unite on other issues, but at the EU level, the Pirate Party representatives consistently have presented (in my view), the most technically correct interpretations of internet laws and regulations for example, all the topics around data privacy, etc. They are not "hurr durr I wanna get free stuff" at all, and most other representatives remind me of my grandpa that had no clue what a computer even was. To me, donating and voting for people who are technically correct is a way better way to effect change than just trying to have some mass coordination around piracy / boicots, those never work. Outside of Europe I have no idea what something effective would be. Unfortunately the patent / copyright apparatus is very very strong and the political pressure US groups put on the world is very hard to combat. A good book about the subject of patents and this apparatus and how they basically muscled the world into abidding to US lobbies, including massively fucking poor countries with respect to pharmaceutical patents is "Information Feudalism: Who owns the knowledge economy?" https://thenewpress.com/books/information-feudalism https://thenewpress.com/books/information-feudalism
- slim 4y agoUS pirates https://uspirates.org https://uspirates.org
- User23 4y agoUS Copyright law explicitly protects your right to create backups.
- _siis 4y agobut it does not protect your right to bypass any digital security mechanism to do this, or to disclose how you did this to anyone else by threat of law. They lobbied for laws to explicitly prevent this, and given the strict constructionalist nature of the current courts, its unlikely we'll regain or be able to enforce these rights in this capacity without significant intervention by policy makers.
- User23 4y agoIf anyone has Lexis I’d love to know if there’s any caselaw on the intersection of the right to make backups vs the anti-circumvention provisions. One could certainly argue that making a lawful backup isn’t a circumvention.
- 29083011397778 4y agoNot a lawyer, but have been curious about this before. Last I checked, format shifting is legal in Canada. Breaking even the known-broken DVD encryption, however, is illegal. We also appear to still pay a blank media tax. Considering I back up important documents to blank CDs every few months, the Music And Film Induatry of America [0] is still being paid, and so I pirate with a (relatively) clear conscience. [0] Not the real acronym, but this one allows me to call the media conglomerates the MAFIA for a bit of a giggle
- dickfickling 4y agoasking for a friend: what's the safe and effective way to pirate things in 2022?
- glitcher 4y ago> ...teach people how to safely and effectively pirate things > ...making piracy easy and appealing is essential This sounds a little too naive to me. Every platform that has made significant progress towards these goals has run into massive legal opposition. And then it becomes an ever changing, moving target cat and mouse game between opposing sides. Not to mention the dangers of malware, etc lurking within sought after content - how can you guarantee safety? I agree that copyright itself needs reform, but looking back over the last ~25 years and how big corporations have become more advanced at fighting online piracy, I don't see piracy as the central mechanism to create the big cultural shift you speak of.
- dumpsterdiver 4y agoHow would you teach people to safely and effectively pirate content when you can't ensure that all participants are benign actors?
- charlesrocket 4y agoYep, this model went off the rails. Its not enough I limited to where I can consume it, you can just take it away from me. MO drives making the best noise so I am down listening it all day long.
- muffinman26 4y agoThere's an even simpler solution: Prefer physical media that plays on systems that can be repaired. You only have to buy a DVD once. There's no subscription fee. You can easily lend it, (or borrow one from the library). You don't have to download any untrusted software or learn how to configure it, and the creators still get paid.
- TimJRobinson 4y agoThis is where I see NFT's being beneficial. Instead of 1M people spending $10 on a piece of content, they all get it for free, and 10k people spend $1k to become VIP fans with additional perks, maybe royalties on merch sales, and the ability to re-sell that VIP status. This is IMO the most internet native way to produce content. Copyright on digital media is a legacy technology that we don't need in world where distribution is basically free and unstoppable.
- compsciphd 4y agoexcept there's no need for blockchain to do that, if it was desired, it could be done entirely by the IP owner (think owning ultraviolet / movies anywhere rights and being able to transfer them to another account).
- TimJRobinson 4y agoAnd then you miss all the composability with existing tools and platforms which is most of the point. It's like saying why use stripe when you could just build your own payment system. Crazy that HN still misses that permissionless composability is the key benefit of blockchains.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoyou can buy physical media?
- namelessoracle 4y agoThey plan on de-anonymizing the internet and making you have a unique id that identifies you to get on. They can then leverage that to punish you for piracy. This is the long term plan, and pretty much nothing is being done to oppose this, and many people on this site who work for big tech are working to accelerate it.
- bombcar 4y agoThis has been the case for as long as people can remember. There's various tiers but it happens on all digital platforms. Steam, for example, will let you still download certain games if you bought them before they were delisted but others just entirely disappear.
- inanutshellus 4y agoYour example doesn't jive with the problem. Steam, in your example, is still giving you access to the delisted content you bought, but, since Steam itself has lost the license to sell, they no longer let new purchases happen. That seems fair. What doesn't seem fair is buying something and then it going away for me because of a licensing expiration between other parties.
- bombcar 4y agoYes, Steam was smarter about licensing (though I do believe they've completely pulled a few games entirely) than Amazon was. And sadly, nobody is going to ever really care.
- GauntletWizard 4y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2013/12/30/steam-removes-game-order-of-war-challenge-from-user-libraries/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2013/12/30/steam-remov... Citation on "Removed a few entirely". I'm not sure what the most recent example is, since this was a while back, but it has happened and could happen again.
- staticman2 4y agoSo Steam removed an online- only game after the servers were closed by Square Enix. While online only games are certainly a problem it doesn't appear Steam's actions made the problem any worse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- programmer_dude 4y agoIsn't Final Space available on Netflix?
- kalupa 4y agoThat's probably exactly why it's no longer available on amazon. I wouldn't be surprised if the OP's content was pulled because amazon lost access to the license.
- ceejayoz 4y agoHow is that relevant?
- programmer_dude 4y agoJust curious why would anyone want to buy it.
- OriginalPenguin 4y agoHe paid $5 a season. Assuming he doesn't want to watch anything else on Netflix, it's better to just buy it outright.
- ubertaco 4y agoFor now, but the network that owns it notified the creator that they have plans to let Netflix's license expire, and then not license it elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33012167 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33012167
- f1shy 4y agoLately I've seen posts of people who lost a "free" mail account. And people said "you don't own anything". But here, after paying... you still don't own anything. I must be too old. I do not understand how can they take it away without refund. If somebody could illuminate me, please?
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoTheir is a clause in their ToS which says when you buy something your are only renting it for the amount of time Amazon is happy to serve said content This is why we need to educate people on how to pirate effectively and safely so big tech will have to listen to what the markets actually demands and what will be in the best interests of society
- nsxwolf 4y agoAs long as that poor woman is still on the hook for millions of dollars over some CDs or whatever I’m not pirating anything no matter how “safe” it is promised to be.
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoAre you saying you don't commit tax fraud on a regular basis?
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's the effect they were looking for. It's a basic terrorist tactic (in the original asymmetric warfare sense, not the "calling you a terrorist is an announcement that we're willing to violate our own professed norms to kill you and people like you" modern sense.) They found a sympathetic working class single native mother who had done relatively little filesharing to attack brutally, so average people could see and say "if they're willing to do that to her, they're certainly willing to do it to me." And the government announced with its verdict "and we'll help them do it." My aging father, who has gone from a math-major programmer to nearly computer illiterate in 40 years, won't even take a file from me directly, out of fear. I think of that fear as a bit hysterical, but he uses Windows and an iPhone, so who am I to say that his devices won't report that file to the proper authorities some day in the future, after a forced update? Who am I to say it's not somehow doing it now, and flipping a flag at the NSA or Amazon marking him for special attention? I obviously believe something like that at some level, with my insistence on FOSS and control over my devices. The avenues for pirating have narrowed in an extreme way over the past five or so years. There can be no one professionally interested in piracy who isn't aware of all of them. The government could just choose a week where they decide to contact and charge everyone associated with piracy, and pull down every pirate site. They could show PR-style grace by giving 98% of people a symbolic fine in return for the destruction of all of their digital storage, and give the other 2% brutal prison sentences. Everyone would then be placed on a public blacklist to encourage ISPs to ban them. Entirely possible, and entirely consistent with centrist values. So I'm no smarter than people who don't pirate.
- anvic 4y agoYou mean they revoked the licence that you purchased from them.
- danjoredd 4y agoThis is why I always either buy my shows/movies physically, or I pirate them. Ever since Amazon pulled 1984 from their shelves due to a copyright issue(they later put it back) I have avoided buying digital items ESPECIALLY from Amazon. Even games I try to not buy digitally anymore unless its from a DRM-free source like GOG or something.
- shiftpgdn 4y agoEnd users should also keep in mind that artists and studios will frequently republish media to change or edit things on streaming services. Famously Kanye West spent many months making changes to the "Life of Pablo" album after its release: https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes
- iggldiggl 4y agoAnd sometimes they just needlessly mess things up – for Bob Dylan's Bootleg Series, for a few years now online they've managed to lose the pre-gap material from the physical CDs, so instead of a seamless live album you now have some less-than-smooth track transitions and are also missing out on all the funny (Vol. 6) respectively infamous (Vol. 4) interaction with the audience.
- digitallyfree 4y agoStar Wars (the original trilogy) is also a classic example of this. The studio added drastic CGI changes for the 1997 release and still continues to make small fixes in subsequent releases. I believe the only way to watch it now in its original state is via old VHS tapes or bootleg scans of the original 35mm film.
- userbinator 4y agoThat 1984 incident never fails to amuse me. Of all the books that it could've happened to, it had to be that one.
- disillusioned 4y ago
- josephcsible 4y agoIs there any moral framework under which this isn't considered stealing, but illegal downloading is?
- donatj 4y agoI mean yes. Like it or not, all parties involved agreed the terms. That's not true under piracy.
- ipaddr 4y agoBy releasing a product into the public does a business agree to some piracy in the social contract?
- wl 4y agoThe terms of service here are too intricate and contain provisions contrary to the average "purchaser's" expectations. There was no agreement here.
- donatj 4y agoEveryone by now is well aware this is the situation. This has happened so many times over the last 20 years that feigning ignorance is just silly.
- pessimizer 4y agoPeople aren't "feigning" ignorance. The terms of service are long, in legal language, and not meant to be read. The ignorance is by design.
- donatj 4y agoIt's feigning ignorance when everyone already knows something though. "Oh I didn't read the terms" doesn't apply when it's common knowledge.
- 4y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI remember a story (I think it was last year, but may have been longer), where someone had an Apple account, and deleted it. Apparently, $25,000 worth of media went with it, and he sued. Not sure how that turned out, but I am pessimistic about his chances of prevailing.
- scarface74 4y agoHere is a link https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/04/apple-faces-class-action-lawsuit-over-its-definition-of-the-word-buy/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/04/apple-faces-clas...
- Gregioei 4y agoI tried to open the link to understand the reason but I was not able to do so. I would definitely not like if my digital fully bought think would be unavailable for no reasons. Independent of this I actually stoped caring to much owning all of the digital stuff I consumed over the years. I love movies and tv shows but there is soon much and I seldom rewatch them, it's just not important to me anymore. I'm still getting much more much better content for much less than 10 years ago. And Im pretty sure there are still enough collectors out there who will make sure aaaal of this stuff will be kept for much longer as we all expect.
- ubertaco 4y agoWith apologies for linking to Facebook, the creator of Final Space (Olan Rogers) has posted publicly about the news he was given that Final Space was being removed from all platforms, with licenses not being renewed, and (if he's to be believed, which...he's been trustworthy in the past) that the show was basically produced for "tax write-off" purposes: https://www.facebook.com/olanrogersofficial/posts/pfbid02fuCC57SqRKjFZZX9dtMvBPewAS3ZKmMALqsiHwcoxdNWdrwwyGXnRhSYo3Sto7hil https://www.facebook.com/olanrogersofficial/posts/pfbid02fuC... Relevant bits: Five years of my life. Three seasons. Blood, sweat, and tears... ....became a tax write-off for the network that owns Final Space. Yup. That's it. That's why it's disappeared everywhere in the USA. Five years of work vanished. When the license is up internationally, Netflix will take it down, and then it will be gone forever. There are no more physical copies of S1 and S2, and no physical copies of Season 3 were ever made. Your memory of Final Space will be the only proof it ever existed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 4y agoHow does the "tax write-off" work here, does anyone know?
- mrguyorama 4y agoIt's called "hollywood accounting". You play games with contracting around IP rights and services as part of the content creation process into such a way that a specific entity you want reports that they took in $X for the IP rights of the content, and then spent $Y > X to actually produce the content. If you own or have significant sway over enough of the legal entities involved, you can arbitrarily set the price of "rights" over certain parts of the process to make everyone look like losers. Like yeah, the entity that sold the film reels to the cinemas made a billion dollars off those sales, but they had to pay a billion plus one dollar for the right to distribute from one of the other entities, who paid a billion plus 2 dollars to other entities invented for this purpose, and so on. You take gains exactly where it's most convenient for contracting to, and put losses everywhere that had a contract based on royalties or similar. The vast majority of the numbers can be whatever you want, within huge bounds, so you can optimize however you want. This is how famous actors for large productions still end up getting screwed out of a paycheck.
- MrWiffles 4y ago...and they wonder why piracy is a "problem"... YARR motherfuckers.
- Alupis 4y agoI really, really think we need to move away from using the term "purchase" with these sorts of things. You are not buying the title, you are buying access to the title so long as the title rights owner feels like you should have access to the title. Amazon isn't alone, Valve/Steam has a similar issue, all music services, eBook platforms, audio books, etc. I think the war has already been lost on that front... you do not own anything and that's not going to change unfortunately. For me, describing this as a "lease", perhaps with an explicit renewal date (that may or may not be free maybe) would make a lot more sense. For Example: Lease "Final Space" for 10 years (Renewal Date: 9/28/2032): $29.99 Or: Lease "Final Space" until 12/31/2022 (Non-Renewable): *Reduced Rate* $7.43 This would give platforms a predictable end-date, and the possibility to charge a reduced amount as the title's contract expiration date nears... plus charge a reduced fee for "renewing" a lease (and giving them future revenues on the same titles).
- caiomassan 4y agofor games, u can buy the games on GOG ( RED PROJEKT plataform) whenever they remove a game they warn you, so you can download your copy before the game gets delisted.
- okasaki 4y agoDoes GOG remove bought games? Is there a list?
- arvonle 4y agoGOG has removed some games from the shop - an infamous case being the three Fallout "Classic" games upon release of new and inferior versions by Bethesda. However at least in this instance the games are still in my library years after. Of note Steam despite its reputation has done the same with LOTR War In The North and Hentai Loli vs Pedobear (don't ask, it was a gift by a deranged friend I swear ;))
- okasaki 4y ago
- desindol 4y agoI don’t know Usenet is still running fine for over 20 years for me.
- zac23or 4y agoOn the website the button does not say "rent", but "buy". That's theft. The theft pure and simple, ancient, which has been around forever. Nothing new. If you SOLD something and somehow REMOVE it or the ability to use it, it's theft. Whether it's done using modern technology (software) or old technology (crowbar) is not important. The TOS do not override the law. Amazon and others use the technology to commit very old crimes.
- paxys 4y agoAll these companies figured out how to get around the legal issues of this a long time ago. They aren't selling you the movie/song/game/book, they are selling you a license to it. And they can revoke the license whenever they want.
- fzeroracer 4y agoThis hasn't been legally figured out, it all exists in a gray area because they've never really been challenged on it. Most cases settle out of court because surprise, companies really, really don't want a proper legal answer to these questions. It's the same with stuff like Terms of Service contracts. 'Buy' and 'Rent' are two very ironclad terms in terms of consumer purchases though and I reckon if a case made its way to court they would likely rule in favor of the consumer. There was the case someone else brought up earlier of Andino v Apple arguing just that.
- jbombadil 4y agoAgree!. I'd love to live in a world where if the button I click reads "buy" then by law I actually own that: * It can't be taken away [1]. * I can lend it to anyone I want [2]. * I can sell it to whomever I want, for whatever price I want. If a company doesn't want to do this, then the button and all UI pieces MUST say "rent". Not just some minor line in the EULA. [1] Maybe the service where I downloaded it wants to go down? Great, then let me download it in a non-DRMed format to use forever. [2] And not having available to use myself during that time. Sure.
- 4y ago
- gertrunde 4y agoWhy not legislate that the vendor must provide a refund in these cases?
- bakugo 4y agoBecause that's not a solution. If someone breaks into your house and steals your TV it's still theft even if they leave behind the same amount of money that you originally paid for it. And the same should apply here.
- gertrunde 4y agoAbsolutely right, but it's not intended to be a solution, it's intended to make the dodgy the tax scheme more expensive, and hopefully no longer economically viable. (Ideally in these situations all rights should also revert to the original creator).
- tantalor 4y agoThe accountants would love that. Consider what that would do to a company's balance sheet. Every revocable "purchase" would become a perpetual liability which will almost never be collected. What happens when the company goes bankrupt? Do all the former customers line up for their refunds as creditors?
- gertrunde 4y agoThat's kind of the point - shift the burden back to the vendor and make the cost of pulling the rug from under their customers more expensive. Or re-engineer their product delivery mechanisms such that the customer can retain the product. Which is the desired outcome.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KIFulgore 4y ago"Purchases."
- skhameneh 4y agoI "bought" an award-winning film and never got to watch it before it was removed. No notice, no refund. I went to watch it one day and it was gone.
- barbariangrunge 4y ago
- xupybd 4y agoYou will own nothing and you will be happy
- pessimizer 4y agoSharecroppers all.
- zerocrates 4y agoPresumably here what happened is that WB revoked Amazon's license but they really should have a system for dealing with this... either having the contract such that they retain the right to provide access to previous buyers, or putting the company on the hook for refunds. I wonder if the situation is the same at other vendors or if Amazon's handling of taking something off the platform is uniquely bad. Surely there are people who own this through Apple or Google or Vudu or something (as I believe it's been equally pulled from all those platforms) who could weigh in.
- qintl55 4y agoNot all streaming providers do this. For example, if you buy a movie on Apple TV, you can download it. To me, that makes good on the "buy" agreement. Based on my last experience, I was trying to buy a movie that was available both on Amazon and Apple for the same price. The amazon version is bound by the EULA, and they don't let me download or play on non-DRM protected devices/apps. But Apple's was good. So I don't buy movies on amazon anymore.
- tpxl 4y agoCan you sell it to a friend after you've watched it, like it's 100% perfectly legal to do with a CD? If not, then you haven't bought it.
- staticman2 4y agoApple won't let you download or play a movie on non- drm protected devices/ apps either. And you can't play anything you bought until you obtain Apple's permission to link the device you want to play on to your Itunes account. This isn't exactly a traditional definition of ownership.
- post_break 4y agoApple bans your Apple ID you lose everything. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/04/apple-faces-class-action-lawsuit-over-its-definition-of-the-word-buy/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/04/apple-faces-clas...
- riddlemethat 4y agoDRM manages rights like jail manages freedom. It's time for legislation to change the "Buy" or "Purchase" button on these pages to "License". People need to be aware they are making an exchange of money for a long term license that can be lost/suspended/deleted at anytime. If you want to own a copy you need to physically buy a version without DRM or at least with a DRM that has been defeated.
- toddm 4y agoI buy Mission Impossible like once a year from Amazon. I think I've bought all of John Wick twice. I kind of read the fine print at some point and it turns out "buying" is just renting for some arbitrary time until Amazon decides you have to pony-up again. Maybe DVDs will make a comeback?
- itronitron 4y agoA DVD is typically the price of a movie ticket and it's not uncommon for the DVD to be available while the movie is still in theaters.
- eranation 4y agoWhy do people share screenshots of tweets instead of linking to a tweet, on twitter? I believe the tweet, but I can't find the original, was it deleted? https://twitter.com/TedVillavicenc/with_replies https://twitter.com/TedVillavicenc/with_replies EDIT: found it! https://twitter.com/TedVillavicenc/status/1573833123380412418?s=20&t=uKc3_LsTCsewrqOHbdZWqg https://twitter.com/TedVillavicenc/status/157383312338041241...
- teh_klev 4y agoMany reasons including: the tweet author closes their account, or deletes the tweet, or locks down their account or the tweet gets reported, etc etc.
- Zigurd 4y agoThat you are prevented from easily defeating any "copy protection" on content means the device one which you download and view that content is not fully controlled by you. Content publishers can reach into systems owned by you and relied on by you for financial transactions and health care information and mess around with data on your system. This is a designed-in security defect. This does not meet the plain English meaning of "equal protection under law." Your property, your data, access to your money, your health records, etc. is not controlled by you in what should be a symmetrical and equal way. In some contexts, like game consoles that are heavily subsidized by content revenue, content protection is a fair element of that deal. But not on systems you paid full price to own outright. Acts like deleting purchases should be treated as unauthorized access, and punished accordingly, no matter the click-through "agreement."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gooseyman 4y agoI remember reading this term years ago about the digital content and licensing. No where did the BSC content I was interested in “purchasing” list how long it would be available. I realized after that buying something digital isn’t really yours (unless you persist it elsewhere).
- MrPatan 4y agoWill there be a time when media is "done"? If I say "If tomorrow everybody stopped producing new books, series, music or movies, I could just start catching up to what's already been produced and it'll last me a lifetime", it may be not true today (is it?). But, will it be true at some point? When? In centuries? Months?
- compsciphd 4y agoI've argued that digital media should only be allowed to be called a "sale/purchase" if they have the license to continue to provide it in perpetuity. That doesn't mean they have the license to continue to "sell" it in perpetuity, just that people who "purchased" it can continue to access it. Conversely, I shouldn't be able to license you the right to "sell" a digital good and then take away your ability to provide it to your customers who already purchased it. If, I as the IP holder, don't want to provide that right, I shouldn't be able to license this "right of sale" and my "middle-man" licensee shouldn't be able to market it as a "purchase/sale".
- BizarroLand 4y agoYeah, Netflix screwed the pooch on this when they didn't negotiate for perpetual & time-limited exclusive / non-exclusive rights to the IP they started with. They could have thrown in some re-negotiation clauses to make people happy, but the thing is that letting someone keep a digital copy of something costs the copyright holder nothing other than the opportunity to bilk the customer out of a second purchase (which should be as illegal as selling someone a car and then making them re-buy it at a later date). Peacock had every right to put The Office on their own platform and had no need to take it down from Netflix other than knowing that without their own strong & exclusive content no one would have made the switch.