3 ms·
What Western feminists can learn from Iran
- PaulHoule 4y agoIran's society is generally supportive of women, it is the religious institutions that enforce strange ideas on people. I think most of the population has been complacent about fighting them. I worked for a year at a research institute in Germany which had several female Iranian students. It was simultaneously true that: (1) women could get undergraduate degrees in Iran in subjects like physics and (2) many of them wanted to get the hell out of Iran. Instead of staying and pursuing collective change they take care of themselves and leave. It's an interesting question in general if immigration from repressive or unequal countries (say South Korea) stabilizes local politics enabling regimes that would otherwise be unsustainable to lumber on.
- geraneum 4y ago> Instead of staying and pursuing collective change they take care of themselves and leave. Extending this to majority of Iranian women/men is wrong, as evidenced by what is happening in Iran right now. Most of them are in Iran, in the forefront of this "collective change". Only 4M out of 88M [1] are out for various reasons. I think this is a kind of survival bias, where you talked to the ones, who wanted to "get the hell out of Iran". Even many of those who live outside, dream about coming back sooner or later. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_diaspora https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_diaspora
- ss108 4y agoAdjacent/related to the issue of brain drain as well, I suppose
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> Meanwhile, in the West, where feminism has proved more successful than anywhere else, anti-male grievance dominates the mainstream, with solidarity between men and women replaced by a desire for polarising identity politics. As America’s feminist movement collapses under the weight of it its own divisiveness, I can’t help but find its Iranian counterpart far more inspiring: men and women standing together, speaking up for each other’s rights. How much better this is than the violently woman-hating Taliban or the petulant privilege of so many Western feminists. What a strange argument. edit: strange too that there seems to be a shout-out to the 1970s feminist Kate Millet, who was like the Anita Sarkeesian of her day, and worse, bisexual. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/07/kate-millett-obituary https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/07/kate-millett-o... > And the well-respected critic Irving Howe wrote that Sexual Politics was “a farrago of blunders, distortions, vulgarities and plain nonsense”, and its author guilty of “historical reductionism”, “crude simplification”, “middle-class parochialism”, “methodological sloppiness”, “arrogant ultimatism” and “comic ignorance”. ... > That December, Time outed Millett as bisexual, and claimed that “[the] disclosure is bound to discredit her as a spokeswoman for her cause, cast further doubt on her theories, and reinforce the views of those sceptics who routinely dismiss all liberationists as lesbians”. > At the time the women’s movement was divided over the issue of lesbianism – Betty Friedan, author of The Feminine Mystique (1963), had labelled lesbians the “lavender menace” – and many liberal feminists turned against Millett.