6 ms·
> Today, you’d probably have to schedule an electrician to fix what some children back then knew how to make: electric bells, buttons, and buzzers. "Some" is d
by whimsicalism 4y ago
> Today, you’d probably have to schedule an electrician to fix what some children back then knew how to make: electric bells, buttons, and buzzers.
"Some" is doing a ton of work in this sentence describing 19th century children.
- osrec 4y agoAnd is probably as applicable to a geeky subset of 21st century children.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt seems like basically the same problem, really. The "some" is a small chunk of the population maybe, but it is the chunk that is interested in this sort of stuff and would normally use this as a stepping stone on the path to designing the next thing. The hope is that our abstractions are not too good, and the clever kids manage to bash them into something that does what their imagination wants.
- amelius 4y agoAnd the "normal" children just visit YouTube and search for "how to fix a doorbell".
- karaterobot 4y agoI also strongly suspect the number of people who were freaked out by buttons in the 19th century is approximately in that "some" range. Mistrusting electricity is a different story, but that's not the title of the article.
- tiagod 4y agoYeah, I'm pretty sure there's way more children today with electronics/electricity skills than back in the day...
- mikewarot 4y agoI'm pretty sure there were way more children back then who had practical skills, now everyone is pushed into "college prep" and discouraged from having practical skills, as they are associated with the lower class workers. The people who keep us all alive are viewed as less worthy... that's our problem in a nutshell.
- noirbot 4y agoIs that true? I feel like the drumbeat I constantly have heard for the last 10 years is that the trades pay really well and are easier to get into. Most of the electricians I know are definitely not "lower class". That said, they're harder jobs physically. They're not particularly good for your body a lot of the time.
- veltas 4y agoClass isn't all about money.
- B1FF_PSUVM 4y agoAnd being a clerk instead of a workman isn't a ticket to the aristocracy either ...
- lupire 4y agoGetting a paid a lovit wage to stand around in air conditioning is pretty good if you can get it.
- veltas 4y agoThere are more levels to class than 'aristocracy'. A lot of it is just perception and known rules, and so the fact you know to compare a clerk and a workman means you already know there's a perceived or known difference in status.
- lisper 4y ago
- hilbert42 4y agoWell, I'm of 20th C. origin—not 19th—and the first electrical things I played with as a young kid were electric bells, buzzers, batteries, flashlight globes and reels of bell wire—lots and lots of it. (Experimenting with such items wasn't an unfashionable activity when I was a kid.) Bell wire, which usually came in the form of two single-stranded copper wires twisted loosely together and insulated in red and white PVC plastic, was installed under the house, in ceilings, in wall cavities and elsewhere by yours truly to enable us perform all sorts of electrical tasks—door bells, for mother to signal us to come to dinner, etc. Isn't that standard kids' stuff anymore? The thought of an electrician being called to fix these Rube Goldberg/Heath Robinson-type installations would have been preposterous. If No.-1 son wasn't about say to change a battery then my parents would do it themselves.
- whimsicalism 4y ago> Well, I'm of 20th C. origin—not 19th This already is a massive difference. Large majority of children in the 19th century did not have any access to electricity, let alone knowing how to fashion an electric bell.
- hilbert42 4y agoYes, there's a huge difference between the amount of information that 19th C. and 20th C. kids had access to, but then this is a broad generalization and it requires qualification. In fact I'd argue that some 19th C. kids (albeit few in relative numbers) would have had access to more information than many of their 20th C. counterparts. Broadly, the reason for why some 20th C. kids would have had access to less information is that they were more protected from dangers than those in 19th C. (and in some ways that's problematic when it comes to learning). Also, clearly, the types of information available in each era would have been different—and this difference would have been accentuated depending on which part of each century we're referring to. The 19th C.—being the height of the Industrial Revolution—change came thick and fast, so it's almost superfluous to say kids' knowledge of electricity at the turn of the 20th C. would have been much greater than at the beginning of the 19th however this difference wasn't anywhere near as stark at other times throughout the 19th C. This is best illustrated by example and for that I'll use a book published in 1858 by Elisha Noyce titled The Boys Book of Industrial Information. https://archive.org/details/boysbookofindust00noyc https://archive.org/details/boysbookofindust00noyc So by 1858 enough information was known about electricity to include technical aspects about it including its industrial applications such as electroplating, p129, and the telegraph, pp273-280 in a kids' book. I'd also posit that some 20 years later (by say 1880) with the coming together of electrical engineering—telephone, electric motors, generators, transatlantic cables, theory by Maxwell, Wheatstone et al, that much more information about the subject would have been available to kids. Noyce's book was a true eye-opener to me when I came across it some two to three decades ago, so much so that I now truly regret not having a copy of it as a kid. I know I would have gained a great amount of useful knowledge from it despite the fact that it was published a century before my time. Whilst I had access to more modern texts they didn't provide the information in such a useful and meaningful way. Moreover, much of that information is still very relevant and valuable today. For instance, I refer you to pp57-58 on the dangers of lead and lead poisoning, therein Noyce issues a stark warning especially so with respect to white lead as used in paint. (This advice would have been invaluable to boys who would have gone into industries where they'd be exposed to such dangers. It also infomes us that knowledge of and concerns about bad and dangerous working conditions of the era may have been better understood at the time than some modern history books would have us believe.) Keep in mind this warning was in a book for boys written to provide them with practical and useful information—not published in some erudite scientific publication. The fact that by 1858 the dangers of lead had filtered down not only to ordinary people but also to their kids makes the failure of governments and those knowledgeable of the facts to act in a decisive way over the forthcoming century all the more tragic (when I first read Noyce's warning I was quite horrified that so little action had been taken until recent decades). As you see, with actual information to hand things seem a little more nuanced.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoI know it's a joke, but "some" children in the developed world give their parents stuff they made themselves... like macaroni "images", clay pots and ashtrays, painted rocks, etc. In china, those children can give their parents smartphones and other electronics :)
- corytheboyd 4y agoAn inspector refused to come look at our house because there is a power line near it. People are still afraid of electricity. It's funny because he probably uses a cell phone, drives a car, lives in his own house, uses a microwave, owns a computer, all situations in which ghasp electricity is close to his body! We're just glad we didn't actually hire him.
- pitaj 4y agoI assume he was talking about a high voltage line? Aboveground power lines are quite common.
- rasz 4y agoMIT graduates cannot power a light bulb with a battery. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIhk9eKOLzQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIhk9eKOLzQ
- sarchertech 4y agoI'm always skeptical of those man on the street interviews. How many students did they interview to find the handful who couldn't do it? And how many of those were just flustered by the situation.
- lupire 4y agoWell they found a MechE not an EE. They also made them do it standing up with an awkwardly shaped bulb, and only a single wire, so the task was basically impossible, without a cutter and/or some tape. Still, people should know why they are failing. Of course, they are being caught out of context and are guessing the "rules" of the "game".
- quelltext 4y agoThe task was impossible because they gave them light bulbs that simply cannot light up with a low V battery. The one scene where a student appears to succeed (this clip is spliced in after the segment where the professor says "it's not the case [it's not a trick question]") is not with the light bulb they were given (they essentially say "here, I can show you, see, with a small bulb I would do this and it works", laughing which to me indicates they didn't get it done with the initially given large bulb). But maybe not? Maybe they were given several bulbs to choose from. And yeah some people clearly didn't figure out the basics ("I need two wires"). The others, unclear, they showed short cuts of them fumbling around (possibly after failing a few times) but they might have already tried the right approach before that. The core issue with the video is that it doesn't establish a base line. What is it they expected from the students? That they identified they cannot do it with just any bulb or any battery before saying yes? I don't think so, based on the professor interview that really seems to imply that the folks should know how to do it (and get it done). If there was a way to do it they should have shown. They just go on to folks saying "see, we need to teach the basics better" and I still don't know how it connects to the "experiment". The way it stands it really does seem to be designed to make the graduates fail the test without making clear (to the viewer at least) what the test really was. I mean at this point I'm not even clear if the reporters were the stupid ones not realizing it cannot be done. Again, they didn't show it. It's more likely they did actually make it impossible / pose a trick question. I am not doubting the professor as much. They probably conducted an actual experiment that showed a significant number of subjects (was it MIT grads though) weren't able to accomplish it despite feasibility. It's just that the adhoc on-video tests there seem to provide a false hook into the story, like all these types of on the street interviews.