5 ms·
Apple: we'll pay no more for this item than ____ TSMC: you'll pay _____ or you can go to the other fab, oh right, you'll pay _____ -------- vendorSellingToBi
by dylan604 4y ago
Apple: we'll pay no more for this item than ____
TSMC: you'll pay _____ or you can go to the other fab, oh right, you'll pay _____
--------
vendorSellingToBigBox: we would like _____ per unit of our product
bigBoxBuyer: that's nice. we'll pay 40%______ per unit. you'll sell extremelyLargeNumberOfUnits, and make it up in volume. oh, if you don't sell a minimum number, you have to buy all of the unsold items back from us. you'll also get the worst shelf space available compared to your competitors. i'm sorry you thought this was a negotiation.
- bombcar 4y agoYou can actually deduce the vendors that have influence on the big box buyers if you look carefully enough. And some of the vendors will tell Walmart/Costco to take an airborne intercourse course against rolling pastries. Others will sell a white-label or generic brand to them. After all, it's just business.
- sbaiddn 4y ago"take an airborne intercourse course against rolling pastries" Ill have to steal that one
- nebula8804 4y ago>You can actually deduce the vendors that have influence on the big box buyers if you look carefully enough. How? I'm coming up blank. Is there a way to compare prices or quantity against other big box stores?
- bombcar 4y agoLook for large big box stores that conspicuously have a product line absent, or only have a very defined subset of the product available. For awhile iPhones were just completely missing from some larger stores, but it seems Apple has the upper hand there now and they're back in business. And even now Apple holds a very right reign on the prices charged (Best Buy seems to have the most leverage here, as they often sell new MacBooks for a bit lower than the Apple Store). This is one of the reasons Apple started the stores; gives them leverage against the retail giants. There are a number of brands you'll never see at Costco; they don't play the game.
- nebula8804 4y agoHmm how do you differentiate between supply chain shortages and this scenario?
- captainredbeard 4y agoNice Vonnegut bastardization
- plasticchris 4y agoIt can get worse. At one point Walmart mispriced a product then came after my company for the loss. That was an awkward moment. Edit: even worse, now customers expect the lower price, eroding your pricing power.
- AaronFriel 4y agoWalmart will also do this intentionally to their vendors, or engage in what I call temporal arbitrage. It hurts Walmart as a business very little to stop selling Vendor X goods on their shelves when there are substitutes available. However, for Vendor X it's often the case that Vendor X cannot adjust their output as quickly as Walmart can take the product off shelves. That action, taking them off the shelves for even a short period of time while Walmart presses for renegotiating terms can result in layoffs, loss of revenue could result in lines of credit drying up. It's an existential threat to a company because they can't scale up and down at the speed Walmart demands. If I recall correctly there's a record of this happening with Rubbermaid, and they responded to Walmart's demands for prices by cutting costs, cutting corners with quality, and ultimately sullied their brand name.
- cptskippy 4y agoThere's a book called The United States of Wal-Mart that details a lot of the damage that Wal-Mart has done. I wouldn't be surprised if there's a follow up for Amazon. https://www.amazon.com/United-States-Wal-Mart-John-Dicker/dp/1585424226 https://www.amazon.com/United-States-Wal-Mart-John-Dicker/dp...
- fckgw 4y agoI often think about the pickle story about how Wal-Mart can bully companies and their quest for always low prices have ripple effects. https://www.barnesandnoble.com/readouts/the-wal-mart-effect-how-the-worlds-most-powerful-company-really-works-and-howits-transforming-the-american-economy-2/ https://www.barnesandnoble.com/readouts/the-wal-mart-effect-...
- ComputerGuru 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ras3022 4y agoThere’s no way it’s that simple between Apple and TSMC. Apple also has something TSMC desperately needs too: the ability to pay upfront and guaranteed volume. Turning these lines on and off is basically impossible so guaranteed volume is a way to smooth out demand and is needed for planning. These factories are tremendously expensive and getting cash upfront is basically a zero interest loan in a time of high interest rates.
- cogman10 4y agoThe TSMC fabs aren't idling. Between AMD, Intel, nVidia, Broadcom, Google, Amazon, etc. They've got customers with more demands for their chips than they have capacity to provide. If apple doesn't go to them, I think the only other option is Samsung? But I don't know that Samsung's fabs are open to third parties.
- scarface74 4y agoNvidia just announced they have a glut of unsold inventory. They are the last company that is going to make up the slack.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoWell, the facts are a little different. Apple is 25% of the volume on the latest nodes and Intel just had an awkward conversation with TSMC saying "Oh, those orders, no, we actually meant the year after", so Apple very much has TSMC "by the balls". Samsung has produced parts for others for a Very Long Time, most famously NVIDIA (not "nVidia" since many decades) use(d) them.
- adventured 4y ago> If apple doesn't go to them, I think the only other option is Samsung? Shorter-term that's true. Apple is well known at times to think longer term on logistics, strategy. If push comes to shove, there are two additional options for Apple. 1) Political. Taiwan not being China depends on the support of the US. Apple is a economic security prize for the US, a strategic asset. Apple can get powerful politicians in the US to lean on Taiwan, which can dictate TSMC's behavior to an extent. This would prompt increased compromise from TSMC (3-4% hike, not 6%). 2) Apple starts investing into fabs and builds a TSMC competitor from the ground up, perhaps in alignment with ASML (Europe very much wants an improved semiconductor context) and a few US partners (build the fabs in the US and Europe for national security purposes). Apple is one of the few companies where you have to take this potential seriously, they can safely bankroll it entirely by themselves if necessary.
- outside1234 4y agoRemember that Intel's fabs are waiting in the wings and that I would bet dollars to donuts that Intel is talking with Apple. TSMC's position in that context is less strong than you'd imagine, especially since Apple has to be thinking that they want to diversify away from Taiwan and China to avoid "Russia risk" of having their supply shut off to zero suddenly when China does something crazy.
- vineyardmike 4y agoNo way they could switch in under 5 years. TSMC provides design guidance and knowledge that will be deeply embedded in the design of their chips. It’s not like a print shop where you can send over a pdf. I agree with the diversity angle though. Tim Cook seemed really slow to recognize it, but the last few years apple has accelerated shifting manufacturing. India will now be joining China in producing their latest phones (14), which is a big first.
- davidf18 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 4y agoApple is famous for pre-buying and covering upfront costs for new node processes at TSMC. TSMC has the best tech, but apple has the biggest purse. Even apple deciding to stay on existing nodes and not fund the latest one can probably affect their finances, especially when apple is 25% of their income
- UncleOxidant 4y ago> TSMC: you'll pay _____ or you can go to the other fab, oh right, you'll pay _____ It wouldn't be easy for Apple to just go to another fab. They'd have to find another vendor with the capacity and then they'd have to tweak things to match the new fab's design rules. Not trivial for something like M* chips. I suspect Intel would be happy to have Apple in their nascent foundry biz, but not sure they would have the capacity right away and also suspect the design would require a good amount of tweaking to get it in production in an Intel fab.
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago
- dylan604 4y agoThat's the point of the comment I made. TSMC knows that Apple can't just jump ship to another vendor. There isn't another vendor that can do what Apple needs. Currently. As long as that is true, Apple is stuck at TSMC. Apple could say that they will accept the 6% increase, but then lower their investment in new fabs 6%. I honestly don't know which number is bigger.
- fomine3 4y agoI wonder why iPhone 14 non-Pro continue using A15 is related to this price negotiation, instead of supply shortage of 4nm