3 ms·
> More importantly, everyone can see that nothing useful is coming out of particle physics, it’s just a sink of money. So is most of botany.
by amelius 4y ago
> More importantly, everyone can see that nothing useful is coming out of particle physics, it’s just a sink of money.
So is most of botany.
- stdbrouw 4y agoThat's not what the author means by "useful". If you spend a year describing a particular kind of plant, then you know that much more about it and that's a useful contribution to science if not society. If you keep coming up with zany theories and predictions that do not just turn out to be wrong (that's fine, "I've successfully found 10,000 ways that will not work") but where there's really no reason to even suppose they might have been right, then that's scientific busywork.
- quantum_mcts 4y agoI'd suggest you read on scientific outputs of collider experiments. They do perform precision experiments and detailed measurements of particle properties and fundamental parameters of the settled fundamental models. The picture you are painting of "some theorists come up with crazy ideas and then we spend billions on colliders and then nothing" - is completely bogus. And that is very illustrative of the harm that Dr. Hosssenfelder does as a popularizer.