5 ms·
If they'd inflated the valuation of some crypto thing, they'd have the crypto crowd cheering them on. But they did it with something people understand, a deli.
by Animats 4y ago
If they'd inflated the valuation of some crypto thing, they'd have the crypto crowd cheering them on. But they did it with something people understand, a deli. So it's obvious the value was inflated.
The SEC brings the hammer down on about two crypto scams a month. This month, Sparkster, Ltd., and Chicago Crypto Capital, Inc. Last month, Dragonchain, Bloom, and Crypto Crusaders.
The SEC is still working on the crypto scams of 2018-2019. Remember Initial Coin Offerings? There's a big backlog of those. So they haven't gotten to NFTs and DeFi yet. Soon, though. The SEC just doubled their crypto enforcement staff.
With NFTs, if you sell something that already exists, it's a collectable. That's probably OK. If you sell something that doesn't exist yet, such as metaverse land for a metaverse that isn't running, that's probably not OK. That's a security offering. See "Howey Test".
- wmf 4y agoThe SEC is still working on the crypto scams of 2018-2019. One problem with this narrative is that they managed to kill off Kik/Kin and Telegram TON before they launched but they let other pump and dumps play out. Clearly it's possible for the SEC to do their job effectively but they just aren't doing it. (Not to mention Libra/Diem which was an outlier.)
- HWR_14 4y agoAlternatively, the SEC can do their job but don't have the necessary tech-savvy manpower to do it enough.
- TakeBlaster16 4y agoIs it tech-savvy people they need? The Howey test doesn't say anything about tech or computers. I would have guessed they need finance-savvy lawyers.
- HWR_14 4y agoI assume that you need a tech person and a lawyer to go after crypto. The lawyer lacks knowledge (and the ability to give expert testimony) of exactly how the coins work and therefore how the law can be applied. I could be wrong, I'm just extrapolating from my experience that normally the limit of tech talent and lawyers is whichever came second.
- josefx 4y ago> that they managed to kill off Kik/Kin and Telegram TON before they launched Going by this[1] SEC complaint from 2019 Kik had already illegally sold $55 million worth of tokens to investors in 2017. I am not sure how you can look at these dates and get a "before" out of it, especially since it seems that some sort of launch did happen. [1] https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2019-87 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2019-87
- wmf 4y agoBefore mainnet launch, which is when the VCs and whales dump on the public. I'm not sure what's going on with Kin specifically because they lost the SEC case in 2020 but their website makes it look like it's still happening. (If you define constantly switching blockchains as happening.)
- ajross 4y agoI don't follow the logic. Isn't the fact that the SEC got wise to crypto scams and started enforcing them belatedly a good thing? Better late than never, right? From your tone it seems to me like you think the injustice here is that Kin and TON should have been allowed on the gravy train too?
- wmf 4y agoSorry, I wasn't clear. I want the SEC to shut down all crypto and I want them to shut it down as early as possible, not years after the dump. I think they are competent to do this but they're prioritizing their resources poorly.
- ajross 4y agoI don't see the timing as significantly different than the linked article about the deli, though. It's a civil infraction, not a life-and-death violent crime case. It happens with lawyers and injunctions and it takes time. The goal of SEC enforcement isn't to prevent scams mid-fraud, it's to make fraud unattractive as a moneymaking endeavor.
- spamizbad 4y agoWeb3 is built on the blockchain; Web4 is built on the deli counter.
- mosdl 4y agoproof of yummy
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoI know not with what weapons web3 will be fought, but web4 will be fought with salami and hard cheeses.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoGives new meaning to the phrase, "That's a load of Bologna."
- seibelj 4y agoThis article has nothing to do with crypto. HN never fails to bring up crypto whenever possible. Stock fraud? Wow should have done crypto. Guy got murdered? I wonder if the hitman was paid in crypto!
- dontknowwhyihn 4y agoThe top comment on this site will never be pro-crypto. That’s how you get shadow banned here.
- ahmed3883 4y ago
- paulpauper 4y agoShows how big and important crypto is even if it still has little mainstream adoption. $1 trillion total market cap. Coinbase alone has millions of users just in the US.
- Tenoke 4y agoFor some people here everything is about how crypto is bad.
- roflc0ptic 4y agoIt’s a tech site; there’s a whole tech industry devoted to what is basically securities fraud, and it’s annoying. I work in smart contracts trying to build an ambitious global network, so I’m not exactly some Luddite afraid of the future. If I read an article about people artificially inflating the price of something in a pump and dump scheme, I pattern match that to crypto. I’m tired of hearing about it, too, but I to stop hearing about it because someone regulated the fraudsters out of business, not because defrauding unsophisticated people became a norm we don’t criticize.
- jahsome 4y agoJust replace "crypto" with "human nature" or "capitalism." Fraud is not exclusive to crypto, it's just laughably easy.
- acjohnson55 4y agoNah, only 95% of it. Look, there are plenty of technologists who are very into crypto. You can find lots of them here. But to many, it reeks of some long-reviled parts of the tech scene: vaporware and marketing hype. And that's before you get into the astounding levels of fraud and waste. At this point, crypto is much more of a social phenomenon than a technological one. That's not a problem in itself. The issue is that foundation is one where legimately interesting technology is neither necessary nor sufficient to solve very many real-world problems, but the financialization at the core of it facilitates these collective delusions that it is. Everyone's LARPing the original dotcom bubble, but the world's entirely different. The dotcom bubble certainly had its crackpots, but it also had a lot of people who accurately saw that pervasive networking was going to unlock massive opportunity. But the low hanging fruit has been plucked over the past 25 years. Web3 people are trying to tell the world that a decentralized permissionless log is as the same magnitude of technological impact, and it simply isn't.
- anyfactor 4y agoSeriously what happened to ICOs? Like even "Silicon Valley" the tv-show had an ICO arc. The money gathering process for crypto ventures is now NFTs. Seriously, what is the current state ICOs? How are the ICO coins or importantly the ICO-backed ventures are doing?
- TillE 4y agoThat scam got tired, everyone moved to NFTs. Gotta keep your TLAs fresh.
- heavyset_go 4y agoYou ever shine a bright light on a roach infestation? They'll scurry away and hide in places they can't be seen within seconds.
- Animats 4y agoMuch better version than the long explanation I posted.
- Animats 4y agoWhat happened with ICOs is that the SEC sent a letter to each of them asking why they hadn't registered their initial public offering with the SEC. Most of them backed off and gave the money back. A few did register for an IPO. Some outside the US stopped selling to US persons. Some qualified as "utility tokens", but for that the issuer has to redeem them for something, like a Starbucks drink or an iTunes download. To issue utility tokens, you have to also make something that has some utility. NFTs were an attempt to evade the rules on public offerings. If an NFT represents a real thing, even a silly real thing such as a Bored Ape picture, then it's probably a collectable, which the SEC does not regulate. But if an NFT is tied to something that doesn't exist yet, it's an investment. Also, once huge "NFT collections" and "fractional NFTs" became a thing, they started looking more like securities. There's a a long history of attempts to evade security registration by claiming your new thing is different. It hasn't worked in the past. The "Howey test" came from a 1949 attempt to sell the right to harvest oranges from orange groves in Florida to large numbers of people nowhere near Florida. The process for simply registering an IPO with the SEC isn't what holds back crypto issuers from doing it. It's that you have to file a prospectus, explain who you are, who's involved, their backgrounds, and what you're going to do with the money. Under penalty of perjury. What crypto people call a "rug pull" quickly results in felony charges.
- EMM_386 4y ago> Remember Initial Coin Offerings? Pretty much everything that had become regulated on on Wall Street had found a new home. "Pink sheets! Got your pink sheets `ere!" Far too many to keep track of, many simply walked away winners.
- subsaharancoder 4y agoBloom ICO "investor" here, let the SEC crack down on them!
- Animats 4y agoThe SEC brought the hammer down on Bloom last August.[1] "The SEC's order finds that Bloom violated the registration provisions of Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933. In its offer of settlement, Bloom is undertaking to register the Bloom Tokens with the Commission and conduct a claims process to compensate investors who purchased the tokens. Bloom agreed to pay a $300,000 penalty, and the order includes a provision for an additional springing penalty, up to the value of the offering proceeds, for a total possible penalty of $30.9 million, if Bloom fails to complete the claims and registration processes." There's a slow process, but there should be refunds at the end of it. [1] https://www.sec.gov/enforce/33-11089-s https://www.sec.gov/enforce/33-11089-s