8 ms·
Is this a US thing? Here's a girl mechanic in China.[1] She's from a small village in the mountains, was able to go to a technical school in Kumming to learn
by Animats 4y ago
Is this a US thing?
Here's a girl mechanic in China.[1] She's from a small village in the mountains, was able to go to a technical school in Kumming to learn hydropower, and came back to her village. She has a popular YouTube channel, so she's making money off of that, as well as repairing broken engines and generators in the village.
Having restored rusty Teletype machines myself, I'm impressed with what she's doing. She routinely rewinds generator armatures, which is almost a dead art in the US. (There's one guy in San Francisco who still does that, and he has a backlog. He never got to the Teletype motors I wanted done. Urgent projects for old freight elevators and industrial equipment keep him busy.) She's an artist with an angle grinder, making parts from sheet steel. She cuts curves with an angle grinder, something usually done with a bandsaw. Her welding is so-so, but she is using a crappy AC welder.
The engines she works on, usually small Diesels in the 5-30 KW range, are very basic and maintainable.
They're a standard design in China from the Mao era. Look up "R175 Diesel engine". Hand crank start, cooling system is a water tank you have to fill when you refuel, no oil pump. You can buy one on Alibaba for under US$200, shipping not included.[2]
There are people who post claiming she's fake. But there are many hours of videos showing her work. Once or twice, there are indications of outside help with heavy lifting, but that's about it. There are more informed nit-picks - getting paint on the mating faces of the cylinder head may cause leaks later, banging on bearings with a claw hammer can damage the bearing races, and those motors really need to go out the door with a motor protection circuit breaker (US$6 on Alibaba) so they don't burn out the windings again. But all this stuff is overbuilt, to survive years of minimal maintenance in agricultural villages.
Although her electrical safety is scary. No strain relief where cables enter boxes, plain wires rather than nonmetallic armored behind walls when remodeling, standing in a stream while holding an outlet strip.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCpPt42tLH5FRk__ytvMsejw https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCpPt42tLH5FRk__ytvMsejw
[2] https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/R175-Diesel-Engine-Engine-Single-Cylinder_60393287578.html https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/R175-Diesel-Engine-En...
- coldacid 4y ago>Is this a US thing? If it is, it's also a Canadian thing, and a western European thing, at the very least.
- Scoundreller 4y agoThis is why I buy Toyotas: someone in the world knows how to fix it and/or makes/warehouses spares for it.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe key component is stuff being one hell of a lot cheaper than labor. This is a natural outcome of a combination of rising wages and dropping prices for finished products, plus, in some cases, increasing standards—for example, single-pane windows with glass held in by paste were really easy to repair but provided almost no insulation—modern windows are really hard to repair, but insulate well. If we want repair-culture to come back we have to make everyone materially poorer first. Everyone who's not crazy-rich would know how to sew if a t-shirt cost $100 new and could be sold used for $50, instead of like $10-15 and $0-3, respectively. Nobody pays a cobbler $150 to re-sole their $50 sneakers—their $400 leather oxfords, maybe. We stopped repairing stuff because stuff is cheap—it's not worth developing or maintaining repair skills to try to get another year out of the odd $20-$150 appliance, or tens-of-dollars pieces of clothing, or paying five times as much for floor trim that can be re-finished or repaired when it gets dinged up, over cheap crap that'll just have to be replaced if it gets damaged, when the labor to replace it's not much different from the labor to repair the nicer stuff. We stopped having experts repair stuff because labor is really, really expensive relative to goods, now. We just throw away the broken thing and replace it. The fix, if we want one, is to make stuff way more expensive.
- soperj 4y ago> Nobody pays a cobbler $150 to re-sole their $50 sneakers—their $400 leather oxfords, maybe. I paid a cobbler $90 to resole(and re-cork) my birkenstocks after 2.5 years. It's been 4 years since I've done it, and they aren't even close to where they were when he did it. I honestly just wish I'd done it sooner. He re-corked them as well, but some of that is now falling apart. Might have to go back.
- DwnVoteHoneyPot 4y agouh, aren't birkenstocks cork sandals... so if you replace the cork and rubber soles, it's pretty much a new sandal? It's like the question: if you replace the handle of an axe one year and then axe head the next year, is it still the same axe?
- Kerrick 4y agoI think it's an urban thing. I live in a rural area in the US, and there are multiple people who make their living maintaining small engine machines (e.g. lawn tools), maintaining tractors, maintaining cars, maintaining roads (gravel roads need at least annual maintenance), maintaining HVAC systems, and maintaining fence lines. Plus, lots of folks do their own maintenance.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoI think so also. I live in a rural area too and the high school here offers Small Engine Repair, Auto Shop and Welding & Manufacturing as electives, to further your point.
- mindentropy 4y agoI love maintenance and salvage videos. It is so addictive especially machines and electronics. I would recommend Diesel Creek videos ( https://www.youtube.com/c/DieselCreek https://www.youtube.com/c/DieselCreek ) which is really fun. I am in awe at some of the old American diesel machines and how resilient they are.
- drstewart 4y ago>Is this a US thing? I like how one counter-example from China means that something is a "US thing". This happens a lot on the internet: "Here's a non-US counter example, that must mean this is US only!" Here's a YouTube channel that restores things in the US: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPygLEFniGZmehxouDK-vbw https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPygLEFniGZmehxouDK-vbw
- aaron695 4y ago