24 ms·
HN seems like the sort of audience who can tell me. This is a serious question: Why would anybody listen to Jean-Louis Gassée? What I see is a career of failur
by tialaramex 4y ago
HN seems like the sort of audience who can tell me. This is a serious question: Why would anybody listen to Jean-Louis Gassée?
What I see is a career of failures, at Apple, at Be, at Palm, JLG was dealt good hands and some bad hands but played each indifferently. Did I miss something important ?
- abrichr 4y agoThis is not uncommon amongst executives. It’s often described as “failing forward”.
- MBCook 4y agoThat never stopped John C. Davorak. JLG is known and was at Apple. That makes him incredibly qualified. Somehow. I don’t know. He doesn’t seem worse than many other random columnists.
- kalleboo 4y agoDvorak was always just a troll, Gassée tries to be some kind of visionary
- B1FF_PSUVM 4y agoA critic, ou analyst, does not need to be a good practitioner to provide the public with interesting insights. The "you can't cook/compose/etc, how dare you criticize the food/music/etc" line is rather crass.
- kevingadd 4y agoThis criticism doesn't seem like it fits for the actual content of the article. I read through it and didn't see much appeal to authority going on here, it's arguments mixed with opinion and justification/examples.
- tialaramex 4y agoIt wasn't really about this article in particular, I was wondering if I've just missed a reason why and the answer seems to be no.