4 ms·
I was always partial to the aphorism "The only stupid question is the one we don't ask." I used to participate in StackOverflow, quite a bit (not so much, thes
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I was always partial to the aphorism "The only stupid question is the one we don't ask."
I used to participate in StackOverflow, quite a bit (not so much, these days).
They have a culture that really doesn't like asking questions, which is weird, as they are the raw materials of the site.
Just look at the question counts of the high-numbered folks. It's usually a single-digit number, with that digit frequently being "0."
It's fairly obvious that people that actually ask questions are treated badly.
- leetrout 4y agoLots of questions get deleted too. I asked this question on the math site https://mathoverflow.net/questions/373993/is-the-haversine-function-a-norm https://mathoverflow.net/questions/373993/is-the-haversine-f... I am not a "math person" and was struggling to understand how these various functions fit into "norms" or not. I think by-and-large none of these communities are helpful or welcoming to most people. And that is a shame.
- henrydark 4y agoTo be fair, mathoverflow.net has always been for professional mathematics, mostly for professional mathematicians. Though these days even professional questions are sometimes treated poorly.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI remember asking a question[0] on Webmasters Stack Exchange. They nuked it, and told me to ask it on regular StackOverflow. Apparently, you are not supposed to ask non-SEO questions on Webmasters SE. [0] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52060900/strange-behavior-of-chrome-print-css-fix https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52060900/strange-behavio...
- adamc 4y agoStackOverflow is kind of horrible. I keep waiting for someone to disrupt that market with a less awful product.
- BizarroLand 4y agoYeah, I would love for there to be a new StackOverflow where newbies could ask questions ad nauseum without being blocked for not having answered enough questions or received upvotes from others. It has turned into a walled garden where the people who got in early have the credentials to participate and get help while also risking losing the clout that got them there and everyone else has little opportunity to get help overcoming their personal hurdles in becoming competent programmers.
- Attrecomet 4y agoIf you ever find out how to make that product but not be flooded with newbie questions when you search professionally useful answers you could turn that into a lot of money.
- marcosdumay 4y agoI wonder if it's viable to have a site where you pay for asking questions (there are thematic sites like this, we call them "support forums", but AFAIK, no generic one). Volunteer based answering will always lead to some kind of reputation economy, and those seem to attract assholes.
- BizarroLand 4y agoWould people pay though? Say it costs $0.75 USD to ask a noob question. The answerer receives $0.50 USD of that. The asker gets to pick the person who answered them best, and failing that, upvotes would decide whom the spoils go to. It would be easy to game such a system. Ask your question, get the answer, have a sock puppet account also post that answer, pick your sock puppet as the winner, only pay $0.25 for your question to be answered and stiff the person who actually put the work in to solve your problem. If it were upvote based, people would have multiple sock puppet accounts to upvote their sock puppet answer. Adding money into the mix makes it more difficult by a massive order of magnitude. Stack Overflow could open a paid noob question area and profit immensely from it, but a newcomer would first have to build the audience, get participation, and then introduce the payment system while working constantly to guard against sock puppets ruining the system.
- mistrial9 4y agoearly unix culture was overtly hostile about beginner'ish questions and other fumbling. The advanced practitioner was marked with extra awd sed chops while those questioning poor man pages were essentially spanked publicly. This happened repeatedly in different contexts that I saw.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoawd = awk?
- coryfklein 4y ago> They have a culture that really doesn't like asking questions, which is weird, as they are the raw materials of the site. I totally disagree! I have 50k rep on StackOverflow, and roughly a quarter of that comes from the questions I've asked (I have 213 questions, 166 answers). In fact, that is my favorite way to interact with the site; I personally get excited when I find a question of mine that isn't answered on StackOverflow. That said, writing a good question is an art. The impression that SO has a culture of not asking questions I think is at least partly impacted by the aspects of the culture that came into existence to deal with the huge deluge of really bad questions that it gets literally every second of every day. Then, even if you put in the time and effort to actually write a well researched and thought out question, it's not uncommon to get close votes and downvotes. This is unfortunate, but it also usually comes from a small fraction of users who see your question within its first 5 minutes of posting. Once that time has passed, and folks start arriving at your question from Google, the upvotes come in as a steady stream.
- dpkirchner 4y ago> Once that time has passed, and folks start arriving at your question from Google, the upvotes come in as a steady stream. Only if your question is common, and possibly common enough to already have an answer. That's rarely the case for me, and this issue is why I've stopped using SO beyond just reading.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> I totally disagree! Well, I guess we'll just have to "agree to disagree," then... I have "only" about a 4.5K rep, but almost twice as many questions as answers. Most of my rep comes from questions. My SO tagline is "Judge a man by his questions rather than by his answers." I have become quite good at writing really good, well-researched questions, which usually get ignored. I generally end up answering them, myself. Instead, simple ones get answered; often with a somewhat passive-aggressive "slap." I've learned to ignore the insult, and still be nice and thankful for the answer. It's been a valuable resource for me, but is now a lot less valuable.
- 4y ago