8 ms·
Two hundred years ago, the Rosetta Stone unlocked the secrets of ancient Egypt
- ncmncm 4y agoYou can still walk right up to the Rosetta Stone in the British Museum. It always has a big crowd around it. Don't bother taking a picture of it, there are lots. There are certain rockfaces in Australia covered with authentic hieroglyphs, discovered last century sometime. Some of the glyphs used only appeared in dictionaries in this century. Experts who have examined it date the vocabulary used to late period, close to 2000 years ago, just a few centuries before hieroglyphs were abandoned and forgotten. People in antiquity did get around. Just not always on an industrial scale.
- TSiege 4y agoNever heard of these glyphs in Australia before, but they seem to have been debunked as fake pretty quickly. (Sources 1, 2) That being said, Indigenous Australians of New South Wales (where these phony glyphs are) have done a lot of impressive things themselves and have an amazing history to learn an appreciate all their own. The most famous I'm aware of was the complex societies built upon massive fishery management. (Sources 3, 4) Sources: 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gosford_Glyphs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gosford_Glyphs 2: https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/blogs/tim-the-yowie-man/2021/03/the-gosford-glyphs-debunked/ https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/blogs/tim-the-yowie-... 3: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brewarrina_Aboriginal_Fish_Traps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brewarrina_Aboriginal_Fish_Tra... 4: https://asia.nikkei.com/Life-Arts/Life/Ancient-Aboriginal-fish-traps-refocus-Australian-history-debate https://asia.nikkei.com/Life-Arts/Life/Ancient-Aboriginal-fi...
- ncmncm 4y agoIt is always easy to claim things are a hoax. You don't even need to look at them. How the hoaxers found out about glyphs that had not been published yet seems to need explanation. And that they actually spell words and sentences not about gods or pharaohs, as sequences copied would have. The Ceruti mastodon butchered near San Diego 130,000 ya is one people tried really hard to debunk, and are now forced to admit is real. Nobody has a clue if it was H.s, H.n, H.e, or "others".
- wl 4y agoIf you copy signs from a Greco-Roman period inscription, chances are good you'll copy a sign that's missing from some Greco-Roman sign lists. There are just so many more signs used in that period than the earlier periods—and the work of cataloging them is still ongoing. Looking at various pictures, I see many mistakes and the signs are badly copied. Even assuming Egypt sent their worst scribes to Australia, why would they be copying fragments of standard funerary texts—for example—on random rock walls far away from anything resembling an Egyptian burial?
- ncmncm 4y agoWhat funerary texts?
- wl 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gosford_petroglyphs.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gosford_petroglyphs.jpg ꜥnḫ ḏt n ḫꜣt... I mean, I'd need more context to do a real translation, but there's the "living forever" thing (ꜥnḫ ḏt) that comes after the name of the deceased, or maybe it's di (sign before is cutoff) ꜥnḫ ḏt ("given life forever"). There's the ḫꜣt relating to a corpse. That text is talking about a dead guy.
- TSiege 4y agoI'm all for accepting evidence when it's there. I do believe humans have been highly mobile for our entire history. Hell, the ancestors of Aboriginal Australians migrated to both Australia and Madagascar, proven by the fact that Madagascans are genetically much more closely related to Aboriginal Australians than Africans. The debunking of these glyphs are quite thorough, and looking at them as a lay person they look quite fresh. There's even a local known nearby aboriginal site that is 250 years old and looks it. As for the mastodon, it's news to me, but I'm highly suspect of any positive findings. I believe humans were in the Americas before the widely touted 14,000 year mark. There's solid evidence that Monte Verde in Chile could be 30,000 years old, but maybe just 14,000 years ago. But either way that's far into southern Chile begging the question of when did humans really first arrive in America. But as I said, 130,000 years ago? I'm skeptical, and so are most anthropologists from what I'm seeing
- lock-the-spock 4y agoI believe up to a few years ago it was the original Rosetta stone, but when I last visited 2-3 years ago it was just a copy (with a sign explaining why).
- bobsmooth 4y agoSo glad I was able to see it when I went to the British Museum.
- lordleft 4y ago> (For a sense of just how long ancient Egypt thrived, writes Dolnick, consider this: “Cleopatra came at the very end of Egypt’s imperial run, 13 centuries after King Tut, 20 centuries after the golden age of Egyptian literature, 26 centuries after the Great Pyramid.” To put it in another context, the reign of Cleopatra is closer to the year 2022 than it is to when the pyramids were built.) The scale of ancient civilization is always astounding to me.
- retrac 4y agoAs another bit of trivia, when Cleopatra and Caesar were together, they toured Egypt. They almost certainly made a stop at the Pyramids. (As much of a must-see in Egypt then as now!) But they wouldn't have known, not with certainty, who built them and when.
- tiffanyh 4y ago> But they wouldn't have known, not with certainty, who built them and when. Are you referring to the long held contemporary debate on whether or not Khufu built the pyramids? https://www.gaia.com/article/book-of-enoch https://www.gaia.com/article/book-of-enoch
- alrlroipsp 4y agoOr rather the fact that they were like 1800 years old by then.
- retrac 4y agoBy the time of Cleopatra, written Egyptian had been dead for hundreds of years. No one could read the old inscriptions. Herodotus, some ~400 years before may have had some access to records in some way, or oral tradition, and he wrote an account of Cheops (Khufu) and the construction of the Great Pyramid. An event more than 1000 years before Herodotus himself. How much of Herodotus was myth and how much history was already under debate while he was still alive, and it still is. Being able to read Egyptian gave a whole new perspective in the 19th century: Khufu's name is on the king's list at Abydos.
- wildpeaks 4y agoSeeing it in person at the British Museum is still one of my fondest childhood memories.
- quercusa 4y agoAnd one of my not-so-childhood memories.
- pseingatl 4y agoChampollion's achievement was bad news for Joseph Smith. See, *The Book of Abraham."
- scrapcode 4y agoSo, basically, it showed that he was completely making up his 'translations' of hieroglyphs to say what he wanted them to say while pinning them as words of God?
- wl 4y agoThat's the conclusion most people with the relevant knowledge (hieroglyphs and Demotic) and no dog in the fight come to. On the other hand, there's plenty of apologetics arguing that the extant Joseph Smith papyri aren't actually the ones Joseph used to do his translation of the Book of Abraham. The mistranslation of the facsimiles doesn't really have an even marginally plausible apologetic explanation.
- scrapcode 4y ago> The mistranslation of the facsimiles doesn't really have an even marginally plausible apologetic explanation. It has always interested me that these possibilities are there and potentially just ignored in something so crucial as religion to ~15 million LDS worldwide. Thanks for the introduction.
- wincy 4y agoI have a friend in the church and he’s like “dude why ask so many questions? What am I gonna do, leave the church and become a pariah to my family and friends?” He knows it’s BS but to him if they’ve got a good thing going, why not stick with it. I grew up in the church and left because of similar things and honestly he seems happier than I do. As I get older I think maybe it’s better to be happy than to be right. Most people unconsciously just naturally do this, and those of us with “engineer mindsets” where we can’t abide by obvious falsehoods for the sake of the tribe are the weird ones.
- keepquestioning 4y agoWhy didnt Egyptians get industrial revolution or electricity?
- danschuller 4y agoWhen the same is asked of the Romans a common reply is that they had a mass of slave labour and that removes some of the incentives for automation. But the Egyptians didn't even have much knowledge of making iron until very late - contemporary with ancient Greece or Rome. This is a question I find fascinating too.
- lordnacho 4y agoAre there coal deposits there? And some kind of use for the energy?
- rightbyte 4y agoI guess you need mines that are being constantly flooded to need steam machines in the first place. Wind mills were probably good enought for seed?
- a3w 4y agoAncient greeks did have steam powered toys. It has been discussed elsewhere, that you need a need for revolution to get the progress made on the labour force and market that emerged in the UK to get a first "industrial revolution" started. Egyptians did have batteries, BTW. Another angle, with the TL;DR of "There was no such thing a industrial revolution, ever": Also, if you look at the numeric history of the combined agricultural/industrial throughput of mankind, there was no such thing as a time period for a single industrial revolution. The logarithmic scale of aforementioned output show no peaks, but rather that we made so far made the same speeding up slope in growth every year for all the history we can guess an estimate for.
- pvaldes 4y agoThis depends on what we define by industrial revolution. Building the pyramids must involve a lot of advanced techniques in a cooperative effort involving a lot of specialists. They didn't have gas or petrol but managed to develop an advanced technology on glass, quarrying, agriculture and bureaucracy. They had literature, and this is an huge step. Any advance towards making machines or doing science would be diverted towards supporting war and religion and kept secret probably
- The_suffocated 4y agoIt was Joseph Fourier, the Fourier in Fourier transform, who showed the then 11-years-old Jean-François Champollion a copy of the Rosetta stone.
- wl 4y agoThomas Young, who made many important contributions to the decipherment, was an influential physicist and mathematician. He's largely responsible for the wave theory of light. Young's modulus is named for him.
- danschuller 4y agoThat is a great factoid
- jonnybgood 4y agoThe British Museum has free ~20min tour guides scattered throughout the museum who begin at set times. I stumbled into the one for the Rosetta Stone and it was really informative.
- ourmandave 4y agoThere's been a bunch of articles lately about the British Museum under pressure to return artifacts to their original owners / nations. The argument being they don't need the original and could make a near perfect copy with 3D printing and display that.
- fknorangesite 4y ago> The argument being they don't need the original and could make a near perfect copy with 3D printing and display that. Well, also the argument that they were looted and stolen in the first place.
- adastra22 4y agoIt’s a controversial argument. Many of the chief pieces on display were officially purchased from the country in question.
- suzzer99 4y agoJust like a lot of land in the United States was purchased from some Native American chief who may have been bought off, or under duress to save his tribe.
- adastra22 4y agoSo can we reverse any trade because X centuries down the road we don’t like the outcome? I said it was controversial, not wrong. There are two sides to the argument.
- a3w 4y agoEveryone in germany after 12 years of school: what's a rosetta stone. But the internet does teach you the cultural meme of something being a rosetta stone, so I can infer.
- xwolfi 4y agoIn France, we all know it ! Champollion was my hero when I was a little boy going through the egyptian phase (with Theophile Gautier).
- robotvert 4y agoFor people that understand French, radiofrance has a really good 5 hour long podcast series about Champollion, from childhood to death: https://www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/grande-traversee-champollion-courir-contre-le-temps https://www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/grande-tra...
- xwolfi 4y agoThanks !!