11 ms·
How one of America’s last piano manufacturers stays alive
- tunesmith 4y agoMason and Hamlin is great - a cool flowering "American" sound with rich tones, good sonority in the bass... but they're not the only two American piano manufacturers, are they? Last I checked, Charles Walter is still around and they're very good.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Wistar 4y agoThere are quite a few great rebuilders out there, too.
- Qworg 4y agoInteresting point! The linked article contains a PDF link to the "state of the industry" from 1999 (https://www.usitc.gov/publications/docs/pubs/332/pub3196.pdf https://www.usitc.gov/publications/docs/pubs/332/pub3196.pdf) - page 3-2 has a list of US producers (and they misquote it in the OP, saying 9 instead of 7). Of those, as you've rightly pointed out, at least one more remains. What about Story & Clark? Astin-Weight?
- impendia 4y agoI've read that it's just the three -- Steinway, Mason and Hamlin, and Charles Walter. Astin-Weight seems to have quietly gone out of business, see for example their Yelp page: https://www.yelp.com/biz/astin-weight-piano-mfg-salt-lake-cty https://www.yelp.com/biz/astin-weight-piano-mfg-salt-lake-ct... Story and Clark now apparently outsources their manufacturing: https://www.pianobuyer.com/story-clark https://www.pianobuyer.com/story-clark This is a pretty common scenario. For example, Baldwin used to be a huge piano American manufacturer, and there are plenty of used American-made Baldwin uprights still around. They still make pianos, but as of 2008 they have outsourced all of their manufacturing to Asia. https://www.pianobuyer.com/baldwin https://www.pianobuyer.com/baldwin Companies like Steinway and Mason & Hamlin also have similar arrangements, but only for their lower-end pianos.
- Joeri 4y agoDo those companies that outsource still do their own design? Apple outsources their production to Asia, but they are seen as an American company because they do their own designs. If the same is true for these piano companies I would argue they are still active American piano makers.
- aczerepinski 4y agoI think there's far too much skilled craftsmanship in a piano to call it American based on design alone. With Apple the company's DNA is the designers and programmers working in California. With Steinway and M&H it's the workers holding the chisels and hammers.
- gandalfian 4y agoAnd presumably little old Steinway struggles on in Queens?
- tomcam 4y agoBand instruments were also a huge industry in bygone days. Every town had multiple bands. The center of town always had a bandshell. In the late 1890s you pretty much couldn’t walk through a city without hearing a band rehearsing somewhere. Elkhart, Indiana hosted dozens if not hundreds of musical instrument factories for a period of about 100 years.
- midoridensha 4y agoThey didn't have smartphones and video games back in those days, so people kept themselves occupied with other pursuits...
- toast0 4y agoOr easy access to recorded music, although it was starting. Music via the radio wasn't available yet either.
- tablespoon 4y ago> They didn't have smartphones and video games back in those days, so people kept themselves occupied with other pursuits... In other words: there were fewer lazy, low-effort distractions, so people had to develop more skills, more frequently.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoAnd interact with each other. In meatspace. No wonder more babies were being born.
- mellavora 4y agoso people engaged in activities which built real community and required frequent, sustained interaction with their neighbors, AND which involved manipulating real-world objects rather than fantasy objects. #1 is generally correlated with increased mental health, something which makes sense when you recognize that we are a social animal. #2 would make for some interesting research
- 4y ago
- bosky101 4y agoAs an owner of two refurbished upright pianos I just wanted to let folks know that after buying them and then starting to learn via ear and YouTube - in six months - it all becomes worth it. The tone and sounds with a pedal cannot match an electronic one( which I detest). I hope to one day donate one to the local airport to become the first public good free to play airport piano in India.
- antiterra 4y agoI love a great piano, but: My digital piano sounds way better than any of the uprights my family had, being made from samples of a $100k+ grand. It models sympathetic resonance of unplayed strings. It never goes out of tune and I can play it any time of day with headphones. The key action is acceptable, the pedal feel is good. I can’t see buying a real piano making much sense for me.
- j7ake 4y agoAlso one can quickly switch between baroque tuning, Pythagorean tuning, to modern tuning at the touch of a button. You have access to a wider palette of sounds. Key actions can be just as good as uprights or grands, it’s a matter of how much you want to pay. Kawaii in my opinion has best actions for electric.
- ludston 4y agoSwitching tuning systems is an exciting gimmick but it isn't really a concern for 99% of piano players. Not to mention the majority of non musicians that cannot hear the difference anyway.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoThe difference between Pythagorean and equal temperament is as much as almost 1/3rd of a half step. You don't need to be a musician to hear that.
- 4y ago
- jbarham 4y agoFor anyone interested in contemporary piano reviews, Stu Harrison does fantastic reviews for both acoustic and digital pianos on the Merriam Music YouTube channel (https://www.youtube.com/c/MerriamPianos https://www.youtube.com/c/MerriamPianos).
- aczerepinski 4y agoI would love to support American manufacturing and buy a Steinway or M&H piano, but it's hard to imagine ever being in that position financially. Who knows, maybe in 10 or 20 more years. My other instruments (trumpet and bass guitar) are from small American makers, but a 6'4" M&H costs $80k and a Steinway more than that. In the price range that I was comfortable with (a bit less than half of American made), the options were Japanese or Eastern European. Still very fine pianos. The next step down in price from there would be Chinese/Indonesian.
- j7ake 4y agoAlso in some cities space is limited. Having space for a 6 foot piano in NYC should account for the increased rent that would cause.
- aczerepinski 4y agoIn my last house I couldn't fit even a baby grand piano and got a quote to add a modest addition to the house just for that. The cost was so high (this was Boston area) that it prompted us to immediately put our house on the market and move back home to the Midwest. It's fair to say that buying a Steinway concert grand in the midwest would be cheaper than the world's cheapest piano plus a room to house it in tough housing markets :)
- AdamN 4y agoPeople spend $250k on home audio systems???? Is it even possible to spend that much?
- bombcar 4y agoI’ve seen pictures of custom poured concrete foundations for subwoofers. $250k should be easy to hit.
- doubled112 4y agoThe answer is always that you can spend whatever you'd like on home audio gear. If you have 20 dollars, you can find yourself something that makes sounds. If you have 2 million dollars sitting around, I bet these sounded some amount better: https://news.softpedia.com/news/Transmission-Audio-039-s-Ultimate-2mil-for-the-World-039-s-Most-Expensive-Speaker-System-118692.shtml https://news.softpedia.com/news/Transmission-Audio-039-s-Ult... Those were 2009 dollars.
- wedowhatwedo 4y agoSome spend $1,000 on a power cable. Something that can make absolutely no difference in sound quality but swear it is worth it. They don't spend a second thinking about the cheap power wires in the wall that feed their $1,000 power cable.... https://parttimeaudiophile.com/2020/12/06/the-best-cables-power-and-racks-buyers-guide-2021/ https://parttimeaudiophile.com/2020/12/06/the-best-cables-po...
- babypuncher 4y agoThe audiophile community is an interesting one. It is often incredibly easy to empirically demonstrate that most of the snake oil they dump thousands of dollars in does nothing of value. But they spend that money anyways. They are like more boring versions of flat earthers. My favorite recent discovery was a device that shaves a bit of plastic off the edge of your CDs to improve the sound quality. The manufacturer makes lots of claims about it improving how the light interacts with the polycarbonate, none of which makes any sense. But we don't need a materials scientist or a physicist to explain why their science is bunk, we can just make a hash of the CD before and after "shaving" it to see that the data is still identical.
- zefhous 4y agoI’m a musician who went to a music school that had a lot of nice pianos. I love playing piano but I don’t consider myself a pianist. My wife is a pianist who studied piano performance. We own a refurbished 1924 Steinway and we love it. I’ve gotten the chance to play and hear many Steinways and a few Mason and Hamlins. My favorite piano I’ve ever heard was a 1920s Mason and Hamlin that was owned by my wife’s piano professor. For us it seemed like the only way to get the kind of piano we wanted to own was to find one of the “golden era” pianos from the 1920s and refurbish it or find one that had been refurbished. It’s a lot of work so it’s expensive to do, but still a ton cheaper than buying a newer piano, and the sound and quality of the 1920s pianos can be excellent. There is a notable lack of great piano technicians and tuners. We have an amazing one, but everyone else we have tried cannot make the instrument sing like he can. Some have been downright terrible. There is such an art to really getting the individual strings within a note in tune with each other to the level where the sound waves line up and sustain one another rather than canceling each other out and killing off the note quickly. My tuner says that most tuners don’t even know the difference or that it’s even a thing, and I believe him. I hope the art of piano tuners and technicians doesn’t completely die off. It would be easy to see that happen.
- brettnak 4y agoI would highly recommend that you check out the documentary ”Pianomania” if you haven’t seen it already. It follows a Steinway piano tuner as he tunes instruments for a few famous pianists doing exactly the kind of thing you mentioned.
- kwindla 4y agoRelatedly, the book "Grand Obsession" tells the story of one pianist's truly obsessive search for a piano with a particular sound. I found it fascinating, moving, and a little terrifying. https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Grand-Obsession/Perri-Knize/9780743276399 https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Grand-Obsession/Perri...
- prirun 4y agoThe next big problem on the horizon for the piano is that piano technicians are also a dying breed. Sure, you can get someone to tune it, but that's fairly easy to do myself. The problem comes when a damper is stuck, some notes need voicing, etc. Even the old geezers that know how to do this stuff don't want to bother. They just want to come to your house, do an electronic tuning, and leave with $140. Even if you're able to spend obscene amounts of money on a fantastic grand, who wants to do that if there's no way to maintain it?
- mistrial9 4y agoyou have this service done once in how long? and you call the technician rude names and complain, yet you pay that much for four visits to the gas station, casual indifference, disrespect and basically stupid accounting on your part
- collegeburner 4y agoyeah, the last person i knew who tuned by ear died probably 5 or 6 years ago now and i haven't found anyone who hits the same sound. the same electronic cut-and-paste approach does not seem to be quite as good across every single piano. don't get me wrong, it's very good, just tiny differences spotted because i knew the piano's sound when tuned by ear very well beforehand.
- hilbert42 4y agoReckon you're right about piano tuners/techs being a dying breed. I used to know a tuner who both tuned and repaired concert grands (in fact I occasionally used to watch him work). He sent his son (who eventually followed in his footsteps) to train at Steinway and even then he didn't reckon his son was good enough to do the top league without lots more experience. These days, most people haven't the patience to acquire hands-on skills to that depth.
- tzs 4y agoThat was already a big problem in 1995 [1] for concert pianists. I wonder if it is now worse, better, or about the same as it was when that essay was written? [1] http://performancerecordings.com/essay.html http://performancerecordings.com/essay.html
- dsr_ 4y agoThere are only two prices for a piano these days: new is quite expensive, and used is free, as long as you can move it yourself. (This is slight hyperbole, but Craigslist currently shows 8 free pianos in my area, ranging from beaten-up uprights to two really beautiful baby grands, one of which has apparently just been tuned. The folks looking to get a few hundred dollars for their pianos are effectively delusional. The going price of a decent used electronic keyboard, on the other hand, is about half the price of a new one.)
- zwieback 4y agoYeah, my experience as well. Pianos are one of the instruments that don't get better with age so even a top brand instrument will eventually be pretty cheap.
- ben7799 4y agoGood article but it glosses over other factors.. like the piano mostly losing it's popularity as an instrument in the 20th century. Guitars really rose to prominence in the mid 20th century. And then there is the general demise of playing instruments (including guitar) or performing music at all. Fewer people even sing today, and singing has the lowest barrier to entry of anything. And then there is the rise of electronic music. Really I think anything to do with manufacturing difficulty or things being too expensive is completely a side show compared to the general loss of popularity of piano and instruments in general. I took 3-4 years of piano but then eventually switched to guitar. At one point I rented an acoustic but I was generally stuck with digital. My digital piano was more expensive than any guitar I've owned, but it still felt like an artificial instrument compared to the acoustic piano whereas all the guitars feel like the real thing. Could just be me though, my learning curve was much steeper on guitar but in the end I took to it more and enjoy it more. But the entry point for very high quality instruments being so much less expensive and the easy maintenance of a guitar versus a piano and the portability difference was obviously a significant thing. There's still a ridiculous amount of nuance and connection with any analog instrument. Acoustic pianos and string instruments have it in a way that's still challenging for anything digital.
- hilbert42 4y ago"Guitars really rose to prominence in the mid 20th century." I think that's very true and I reckon that's because the guitar is easily/quickly learned—that is to learn and play badly. If your learning curve was much steeper with the guitar than the piano then your expectations must have been to play it properly (and that could be because of your piano experience). I learned the piano for while and later gave up on the guitar because I found it too difficult to play every note on it as one does on a piano. Strumming a guitar and playing chords suits many and that's fine but I wanted to do what the likes of Segovia and John Williams do and that was pretty much beyond me. So I sympathize with your steep learning curve.
- scrapcode 4y agoI have done the inverse of you, learning to play the piano for the past year via lessons after playing guitar for most of my life. It really brings together music theory for me in a way that I just couldn't grok on the guitar. I refurbished what used to be a higher-end electric piano on my own, and just recently played on an acoustic piano for the very first time after studying piano for over a year now. It felt and sounded like an entirely different instrument that would take me plenty of practice just to translate the feel of what I have learned over to it.
- Decabytes 4y agoI feel like these types of businesses can stay alive by just enduring until they are the last one left. For example the one the other day about the only person still selling floppy disks. When you become the only game in town you become a de facto monopoly.
- iancmceachern 4y agoThe Book "Small Giants, companies that choose to be great instead of big" covers Steinway well. Good book, good company.
- Maursault 4y agoYou can never have enough pianos.[1] [1] https://www.searchcraigslist.net/results?q=free%20piano https://www.searchcraigslist.net/results?q=free%20piano
- notjustanymike 4y agoI highly recommend taking the Steinway factory tour if you're in NY. It's $10 and the pre-covid waiting list was 6 months. Steinway had a massive impact on the economy and infrastructure of Queens. Both pubic transport and movie studios were a direct consequence of the local factory.