9 ms·
> Especially after our company was formed and we want to use the project for ourself too the (A)GPL would make the community working together with this harder (
by bawolff 4y ago
> Especially after our company was formed and we want to use the project for ourself too the (A)GPL would make the community working together with this harder (CLA, dual licensing?)
In this scenario, your company is the thing GPL is trying to protect your community devs from (i.e. the gpl is trying to stop a company from taking contributions donated on the condition they would be open-source, and selling them privately without compensation). You are basically saying the GPL makes it harder to do the thing the GPL was trying to stop.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThe GP wants to donate some software to the community, on the condition that he gets to use any derivative community work on his product. Anybody contributing to the code is clearly informed of that, and decides to do it out willfully. It's a perfectly reasonable arrangement that adds value to both the community and the GP, and that the GPL "protects against". So, yes, the GP's point stands in that there are uses for licenses other than the GPL. All of the complaints about they only being good for people creating proprietary software are true, they just completely miss the point.
- bawolff 4y agoTo clarify, i dont think that GP is morally wrong or anything (as long as they are upfront about what they are doing, although it can get morally questionable fast if they aren't careful). I guess the point i was trying to make is its weird to describe that as a flaw of the GPL when its basically the primary use case .
- marcosdumay 4y agoOh, the GP is in a context of people strongly implying that any permissive license shouldn't be used at all. But if you take too long to reach it and forget the context, it does indeed sound like a weirdo complaining that the GPL is copyleft.
- melagonster 4y agoIf someone published his code under GPL, but then use it in himeself product, is this moral?
- bawolff 4y agoI think yes, obviously. The morally questionable situation is where you publish code under GPL, allow community contributions on the code on the condition that the community contributors sign a document transfering copyright to you (without payment or anything like that) and then also use those community contributions in a closed source product you sell.
- melagonster 4y agothanks your reply, I did not find if this only work when they just want to offer some gifts.
- cxr 4y ago> The GP wants to donate some software to the community, on the condition that he gets to use any derivative community work on his product. wat That's exactly backwards. Releasing your donation under a permissive license doesn't give you that. A permissive license gives others express permission to make derivative works that the original author company might not be able to use themselves—because there's no obligation for others to keep it open...