4 ms·
> If someone is a member of a group, it is almost not worth listening to their arguments, especially arguments in support of views held strongly by that group.
by lapcat 4y ago
> If someone is a member of a group, it is almost not worth listening to their arguments, especially arguments in support of views held strongly by that group.
Who isn't a member of a group? We're all members of a number of groups.
It's refreshing that Kahneman honestly admits that he doesn't change his mind either, and his tastes were formed when he was relatively young. He's not putting himself above the rest of humanity. He could easily say, "Well I'm a famous and distinguished scientist, so obviously my beliefs are rational, unlike everyone else", but he doesn't.
- ekianjo 4y ago> who isn't a member of a group? We're all members of a number of groups. Not everyone is brainwashed to accept group think no matter in what cirles they have to evolve in. There are individuals and then there are the parrots who mindlessly repeat what the group says.
- nelsondev 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/610/ https://xkcd.com/610/
- ekianjo 4y agonice strawman that has nothing to do with the point being made
- drekk 4y agoBeing aware of cognitive biases doesn't render you immune to them. Others shape and inform our beliefs about the world just as our own experiences do. You might be a "rational, fully self-realized, and atomized" individual but your behaviors and thoughts are certainly influenced by those around you. Here's a simple example: https://dictionary.apa.org/social-facilitation https://dictionary.apa.org/social-facilitation
- didericis 4y agoThe issue isn't group membership. It's what's being prioritized. If you prioritize truth over group membership, you are more likely to see your own flaws, the flaws in others, and prevent yourself from making catastrophic errors in your inevitable ignorance. If you prioritize group membership over truth, you are more likely to fall prey to lies that have only short term benefits for one or more members of the group and eventually lead to catastrophic errors. The best groups are the groups of people who are legitimately pursuing the truth, even if they are temporarily ignorant, which again, is inevitable due to information constraints. We've become so saturated with power dynamical thinking we've forgotten that it is possible to be motivated to try to see the world accurately so as to best cooperate with it regardless of power differentials.
- eloff 4y agoMaybe I'm uncommon in this aspect, but I don't feel like I'm a member of many groups. I'm not religious, but don't really consider myself an atheist. I'm not for any particular party. I don't care about sports. I'm Canadian, but don't live there and don't feel like I belong there either. I suppose you could say I'm part of the group of Caucasian males by birth or part of the group of software engineers by trade, but I don't think those are "real" groups with many ideas in common. Maybe I just am not aware of which ideas I get from those groups.
- tmnvix 4y agoI think this is not at all uncommon. I am largely in the same boat and assumed this was the 'de facto norm' amongst my peers as a teen (90s NZ), but it's interesting to consider that groups are often defined by what they are not.
- sooyoo 4y agoThose with most priviledge are usually the least aware of it. I've come to realize that "white male software engineer" is one of the groups with the highest ratio of priviledge versus priviledge awareness. (Disclosure: I belong to that group as well.)
- astrange 4y agoIn Canada? Software engineers are traditionally not well paid there. Plus I assume gangs of other kinds of engineers are always beating you up for calling yourself an engineer without an iron ring.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoThis discussion is about ideas (or opinions), not privileges.
- mattsahr 4y agoYou're right, it's about ideas, but the original article handles the interesting case where we fail to form or handle our ideas using "reason." > The power of reasons is an illusion. The belief will not change when the reasons are defeated. So privilege plays an interesting role. Unaware privilege - failing to see ones own circumstances, failing to assess how we fit in the world - is almost the same thing as non-reason. I suppose there could be a class of people who are like, "I am totally privileged, and somehow I delude myself and don't notice, but in every OTHER way I am totally reasonable." That could be a subgroup. But probably not a big one?