10 ms·
Since I'm still gay, I'm not allowed to help, no matter how many times you ask. I get why they do this and I shouldn't let it bother me, but emotionally it fee
by nostromo 15y ago
Since I'm still gay, I'm not allowed to help, no matter how many times you ask. I get why they do this and I shouldn't let it bother me, but emotionally it feels the same as if they just said, "Please become a donor, nohomo." edit: Of course I still wish the very best for Amit.
- darrellsilver 15y agoThis is a huge problems -- been to a couple NYC amit events (thanks, New Work City!) -- and did my best to inform people. Same with donating blood.
- corin_ 15y agoSome progress has been made, in the UK now the (blood) ban only effects men who've had sex with men in the past 12 months, which is better.
- artursapek 15y agoHow do they enforce this?
- corin_ 15y agoThey don't/can't.
- caryme 15y agoAt least in the blood ban in the US, the only enforcement is the honesty policy. The irony with this is that the men who are honest about having sex with men are also more likely to be aware of their HIV status than men who lie at the blood bank. I feel the same as nostromo every time I am asked to give blood. I know I'm HIV-negative. I'm not South Asian, so I couldn't help Amit anyway.
- corin_ 15y agoI don't entirely agree with your irony (unless - and I've only seen this on TV... in fact I think only in the simpsons - do blood doners get paid in the US?) Certainly in the UK, where there is no benefit for giving blood, I can only assume that those who lie about it are doing so because they too know (or 100% believe, possibly incorrectly) that they are clean, and they don't want what they see as pointless policy to prevent them from helping others. Here's the problem with just saying "are you clean?" You could be in a long-term committed monogamous man-man relationship, and therefore believe you are completely safe. However, the fact that you trust your partner not to cheat on you does not mean that health authorities can trust him not to have cheated on you. So even if the person being asked is completely telling the truth, they might be wrong.
- chc 15y agoYou can't think of any reason somebody might lie about being gay if they aren't paid money to do so?
- corin_ 15y agoIf I were in the closet then, on discovering the MSM issue with donating blood, I would (assuming I had peaked far another out of the closet to have a MSM encounter) not donate blood, I wouldn't think "well I was going to, and I don't want people to think I'm gay so I'd better go through with it".
- pyre 15y agoI think you're missing out on the term 'in the closet.'
- rdouble 15y agoYou can get paid for donating plasma.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>men who lie at the blood bank. // Isn't the only real reason to lie because you're doing it for yourself and not really to try and help other people?
- watmough 15y agoInteresting, as a former, non-gay, UK resident, I'm not allowed to give blood in the US, even though I was allowed to obtain a green-card, and screened for HIV by a US doctor in London. I believed at the time this was due to the UK CJD scare. Can anyone confirm? My gf at the time, also reported being denied the opportunity to give blood, after declaring on the form that she was in a relationship with a UK national.
- colanderman 15y agoI think you're right. I remember giving blood not too long after the CJD/mad cow scare, and the "have you been to the UK in the past 6 months" question surrounded by questions about eating beef from various countries.
- mikeleeorg 15y agoI can confirm that. I lived in the UK for a short six months during that scare. Whenever I went to give blood around that time, I was asked that question, then denied. I haven't gone to give blood in a while though, so I don't know if that restriction is still in place or not.
- Mz 15y agoThey did a donor drive at work some months back. My genetic disorder disqualifies me, even though I'm fairly healthy and off all medication at this point. At the moment, I don't think it would be a good idea for me to donate marrow to anyone as I am still recovering my own health, but this means that even in the future when I may well be healthy enough to be willing and (physically) able, I will still be disqualified. Not sure how to feel about it.
- morrow 15y agoI'm not sure why they wouldn't allow some form of in-person registration accompanied by an STD screen at a clinic for people who they are eliminating now for being too "high-risk"? The marrow guys could even cover the cost of the STD screen for people who register for the program. Seems to me this would be an even safer way of ensuring potential donors don't have HIV than just asking them about their sex lives...
- corin_ 15y agoHIV doesn't show up immediately (possibly other STDs are the same, not sure off the top of my head), if I remember correctly most people will test positive within 3 months of being infected.
- kristopolous 15y agoAh very good then. Well since the CDC now says that blacks and women are the most at-risk for HIV, we should probably change the rules with the times then, right? What's that? It now sound horribly offensive, erroneous, and bad policy? Well sorry about that! Gotta be consistent you know.
- corin_ 15y agoYou're wrong on the facts part, as of this month the CDC still states "men who have sex with men (MSM) of all races and ethnicities remain the population most severely affected by HIV", with their estimated stats being that 2% of the US population are MSM, and they accounted for 61% of new HIV infections in 2009. MSM accounted for 49% of HIV infections in 2008. (Those years are most recent available data.) For more details check out their PDF at http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/PDF/us.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/PDF/us.pdf (I'm not black or a woman, but am gay - for my own selfish sake I'd love what you said to be true.)
- mistermann 15y agoGood point. Very few people seem to be aware of the actual statistics on this subject, and not terribly interested in debating it further once once someone links to actual data which is quite frankly unequivocal. A bit ironic considering how self proclaimed enlightened people tend to look down their nose at the "uninformed" masses who think HIV is a "gay disease". I have no issue with gay people at all, and on an absolute numbers basis, infection rates are not terribly high within that overall community. I just find it immensely interesting how people's normal thought processes (even those who are normally extremely logical and data oriented) are fundamentally altered when the subject of discussion is race, gender, sexuality, or culture. Thanks for pointing it out.
- rms 15y agoYou could just check "no" on the box if you did really want to donate.
- tshtf 15y agoKevin, How do you feel about lying?
- corin_ 15y agoI (not Kevin) feel no moral objection to lying for a good cause. If I absolutely know that I am safe, but the policy does not allow me to donate, then I would have no problem lying to save a life. If I (and this is taking extra-wide margins) have not had any sexual contact in the past 12 months (or anything else that leads to something like HIV, such as needle use), and have always tested positive, then any doctor would confirm that, as long as I am telling the truth about this situation, I am definitely clean. And yet I would still be banned from donation. Do you really think that, in that scenario, it would be wrong to lie if I could specifically save somebody's life? A lifetime ban is quite clearly over the top and not neccesary - hell, even with the UK's new 12 month waiting period after MSM activities for donating blood, there is scope for someone to have gone far past the window of "I might have HIV from that person and it isnt showing up yet", without having reached the 12 months required by policy. I absolutely would not endorse lying in this situation, apart from anything it is possible to be 100% confident that you are safe and clean, and be mistaken. But in a certain scenario, I would be willing to lie personally.
- darrellsilver 15y agoWhen I asked friends to donate for Amit, I had a hard time asking them to lie when donating. This is the limit of "lying for a good cause", especially when the person doesn't know Amit.
- rms 15y agoA lot of people have this in-built sense that lying must be illegal and it mostly just isn't except in very specific circumstances. This is a clear cut example of lying for a good cause. I do empathize with the refusal of a lot of gay people to subjugate themselves for the sake of a broken system.
- andyl 15y agoIts all about you, after all.
- dantheman 15y agoI think that even at a certain point the risk of AIDS (I assume this is the reason) is better than death; so they should let in everyone letting both parties know the risks and say, we can wait longer or you can take this chance.
- corin_ 15y agoI'm no doctor/expert so the following is questioning not answering: is there any way to know an exact cutoff, i.e. "if we don't do it this second all is lost". I would assume not. If my assumption is correct, then would you rather take a possibly HIV-infected donation now, that, if it turns out to be clean, gives you x% chance of living, or wait and see if a little more time brings you a donation that is definitely clean, even if the waiting gives you y% chance of living (where y is lower than x). Without knowing what x and y are, and without knowing the probability that the possibly-infected donation is infected, and without knowing how long you might have to wait to get a definitely clean donation... how do you make the call.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- haugstrup 15y agoAll Europeans are also banned from giving blood for forever. I'm a very recent transplant to the US from Denmark. I was a regular blood donor in Denmark and checked up on the US regulations before moving here. Even wrote the local blood bank because I didn't believe that the "if you've lived more than 5 years in Europe, you can't give blood ever" was for real. Sadly, the rule is very much real. The blood bank was also annoyed but there's nothing they can do. I'd write my representative, but as a non-citizen I don't have one.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- plinkplonk 15y ago"All Europeans are also banned from giving blood for forever. " Any idea what the rationale for this is? There must be some reason for making a regulation like this.
- ramblerman 15y agoWell, as a European I'm Offended. But seriously what's the motivation behind this?
- haugstrup 15y agoBSE/Mad Cow fears. Because of the BSE outbreak in the UK in the 80s (and the various smaller outbreaks later) the US authorities were scared shitless at some point. So if you've lived 5 or more years in Europe you're banned from donating blood forever. Not sure I understand the logic... Quarantine for a set period I can understand, but banning for life makes little sense. After all there are many blood donors in all European countries and we don't all end up with mad cow disease when we receive blood transplants. For comparison: After having lived in the US you are banned from giving blood in Denmark for 1 _month_
- thomas11 15y agoIn Switzerland, you're banned if you stayed in the UK for longer than a few weeks, during the BSE years. That seems to make a bit more sense.
- danielna 15y agoHi nostromo, I'm a Level II Volunteer for the National Marrow Donor Program, meaning I've had the training to coordinate and run drives locally. Let me preface my comment by saying I'm in no shape or form someone who is qualified to speak for the organization as a whole, as I've only become a volunteer in the last year. These thoughts are my own. In my limited experience being a part of marrow drives I've come across many people, both volunteers and potential registrants alike, who feel similar sentiments to those that you have expressed -- myself included. There's a lot about becoming a donor that I really wish was better. The policy to not accept homosexuals as donors is created by some FDA(?) policy, so while I also "get it" at face value I wish the reasoning was better substantiated than a blanket ban on a specific group of people. Unfortunately as volunteers we operate on the hope that those that set these medical guidelines have more expertise/experience/knowledge than we do, so we have little choice but to follow them as dictated. There are other shortcomings. As others in this thread have expressed, the registration form is crazy long. There are reasons for that too -- an inability to contact matches on the registry results in over a 50% false-matching rate in some ethnic groups -- but still, it's not ideal. The form is also very personal, and while the NMDP takes confidentiality very seriously perhaps they don't emphasize that enough. Trying to glean bone marrow information off of existing websites can be a very kludgey process, as several of the websites can be difficult to read/navigate. And there's a bias in the registration process for ethnic minorities, simply because they are so underrepresented that there's funding in place to cover their $100 marrow processing fees. White Americans don't have as much funding. 75% of the registry is made up of White Americans, and when we register White Americans we must ask for financial donations to help displace some of those registration costs. As a Korean-American, minority volunteer, it bothers me that whenever a white person comes to the table I must ask for a donation but I don't necessarily need to do so for minorities. It's not because I want to be racially discriminatory. It's solely because of a lack of funds. At the end of the day, despite the parts that I wish were different, I still do my best to recruit donors. I know that the time taken to register every new individual to the registry is really a chance at life for someone who is dying. Being a cancer survivor myself I don't think I'll ever be able to forget the feelings of sheer despair and uncertainty surrounding my health, so I know that to come to the aid of someone in that situation, with no other options, is really an incredible, life-changing opportunity. I really commend you for your honesty, and I don't sense bitterness at bone marrow donation in your comment but sadness at the circumstances. I hope you know that you are not alone in that. Here's to hoping one day bone marrow registration gets easier/more accurate/more efficient, and more accepting.
- tomjen3 15y agoGet tested for a match anyway - if you match you can always say you didn't read the papers very carefully and that as gay person you can't donate. Then when he dies we have somebody to point to and say "this person could have been saved, but for your bigotry".
- echo-unity 15y agoMorbid way of proving a point, don't you think?
- tomjen3 15y agoIf there was a better way, I would take it. But often people don't react until you can point to somebody and say "because of direct consequences of this policy, this person is no longer alive". It is even better if you can show his family crying. Personally I would prefer getting them to fix it without getting anybody killed. But that may be too much to ask.
- Fliko 15y agoYes you save more people in the short term but the risk for disease transmission jumps up quite a lot. I'm sure that not even the doctors really like the fact of the matter but they have to accept it because they must save lives and not take them away for short term benefit.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoYou think the FDA / NMDP are making medical policy based on bigotry and not on statistical analysis of pathogen distribution? FWIW surely the measure is whether you're in a risk group for transmission of disease, like being European (wrt CJD). Also it would be "since I have homosexual sex". It's not your proclivity that's being challenged it's actions which are known to put one at greater risk of carrying certain pathogens that are detrimental to a donee. Of course it could go down differently to how you say: He lies, the person gets a temporary reprieve and then dies from some other pathogen that the donor wasn't aware that they have but that the medics were trying to account for by ruling out those having homosexual sex.
- aarondf 15y agoI'm still diabetic, so I'm not allowed to help either.
- jronkone 15y agoEpileptic here, not allowed either.
- GigabyteCoin 15y agoWell of course, your blood might make somebody seizure. /outdated science
- malux85 15y agoActually, it's because of the anti-epileptic medication that is in the blood. Speaking from personal experience.
- skrebbel 15y agoI don't understand anything about this. In the US, straight persons can't get AIDS and gay persons can? Or, what's the point? Anyone care to explain? It sounds like nothing but Alan Turing-style discrimination based on fairy tales to me (but I might miss a point. like that research that proved that being gay is genetic and the same gene also causes sloppy bone marrow)
- tibbon 15y agoI don't get it either. African-American women are one of the fastest rising HIV+ groups in the US, yet they aren't banned. Yes, anyone can transmit HIV. The policy is ignorant and based upon the idea that all men who have sex with other men are unsafe, promiscuous, and an hiv test won't be effective as they may have had a recent exposure that is essentially untestable. Its a holdover from the 80's when people were afraid of catching the 'gay disease'. In my view, unless there is some test for being gay (there isn't) then just go ahead and register. If you're a match, then make sure you're hiv negative and haven't had any risky behavior in the past few months and you should be good to go.
- jacoblyles 15y agoAnyone can transmit HIV, but MSM are much more likely to have it than any other demographic subgroup. Don't let your ideology get in the way of the facts. The CDC says that 600,000 MSM are living with HIV, that's about 1 in 10 MSM. That's tragic. I googled around for some stats, and I found this quote from a website called the Bay Area Reporter: "According to a 2008 CDC study, one in five MSM in 21 major U.S. cities were infected with HIV, and nearly half (44 percent) were unaware of their infection. The study also found that 28 percent of black MSM were HIV-infected, compared to 18 percent of Hispanic/Latino MSM and 16 percent of white MSM. Of the HIV-infected black MSM, 59 percent were unaware of their infection."
- chimeracoder 15y agoI don't understand it either. I actually wrote a really long post asking for someone to explain this policy to me, and nobody was able to. I won't copy-paste it, but if anyone's interested, it's here: http://bit.ly/q6624N http://bit.ly/q6624N