5 ms·
This is an indication that Google underestimates the value of data stored by users. E.g. if this was about storing monetary data, this would never have happene
by amelius 4y ago
This is an indication that Google underestimates the value of data stored by users.
E.g. if this was about storing monetary data, this would never have happened.
- anotheraccount9 4y agoDo you have any suggestions for a secure/private option to store photos? I'm not sure what would be best. (Dang, I really want to move away from Goo now)
- slazaro 4y agoYour own devices, with a proper backup solution (which you should already have with or without your photos in it). Nobody can mess with your data then. Personally, I use Syncthing to sync between devices, including a NAS as a target, which regularly backs up to Backblaze.
- lostlogin 4y agoThis sounds a bit like what I do. I r-sync two different libraries to NAS then upload them to Backblaze B2. Post r-sync success result to a muted Slack channel and failure to an unmuted alert channel. rsync -av /Source /Destination rsync -h
- victorbstan 4y agoiCloud
- celsoazevedo 4y agoiCloud may be secure, but private? No end-to-end encryption and Apple scans the user's content. It's no better than Google Photos in that regard.
- deepersprout 4y agoI'm using Nextcloud. Works great.
- yawz 4y agoDo you self-host it? Do you access it with Android and iOS?
- woleium 4y agoAmazon photos is pretty good as a like for like alternative
- khimaros 4y agoPhotoprism
- kijin 4y agoAs a starter, look for a "dumb" service that doesn't treat photos differently from any other type of binary blob. No thumbnails. No grouping by date or location. No tagging other people. The storage service should only concern itself with safekeeping the binaries you upload, not analyzing and processing them. Use your own machine to do the latter.
- lostlogin 4y agoBackblaze B2.
- 29083011397778 4y agoI stood up a pair of QNAP NAS for both my parents and I, and encrypt-then-backup their photos/documents to my NAS, and vice-versa. RAID 5 or 6 keeps hardware failure at bay, and keeping them tucked away in our respective homes makes fire or flood irrelevent (for this). QNAP or Asustor has standalone apps my parents can use as well. Without getting your parents involved, you could either pay for remote hosting for your off-site, or trade RAID space with a friend.
- hedora 4y agoDefinitely use client side encryption, if only because it defeats attempts to "repair" image data or rewrite exit headers, etc. Another good test: upload your photo collection, then download it and binary diff the two sets of files.
- layer8 4y agoManaged Nextcloud hosting in the EU is an option.
- SkyPuncher 4y agoDropbox, Box, a Microsoft service.
- tmpz22 4y ago> E.g. if this was about storing monetary data, this would never have happened. Let’s hope none of the images were NFT “assets” then haha
- wan_ala 4y agoBut with nfts don't you legally own them?
- Hendrikto 4y agoIf you subscribe to the cypherpunk mantra that ”code is law“, then yes. Otherwise, if you stick to the law that lawyers and judges apply, then mostly no. NFT ownership does not come with any rights to the underlying asset, unless specified in an accompanying contract.
- milosmns 4y agoIt's naive and/or biased to think that. Everyone makes mistakes, everywhere, all the time.
- ouid 4y agoThat's a fairly serious accusation to level. Google's bad behavior here is not that their compression algorithm ruined users photos. Google's bad behavior is running a compression algorithm at all.
- mgraczyk 4y agoEvery photo sharing and storing site compresses photos for view. The originals are still there (read further down in the issue).
- amelius 4y agoThat's not the point. I doubt that the engineers who worked on the compression algorithms would store their own precious photos using the same techniques. Also, when was the last time you heard a banker say that everyone makes mistakes all the time.
- mgraczyk 4y agoHi, I work on the processing algorithms at Google like the one here (not sure about this particular issue) and I use Google photos for all my old photos. People at Google read Hacker News and fix things, they just don't comment on specifics for things like this.
- johnywalks 4y ago> This is an indication that Google underestimates the value of data stored by users. That becomes apparent if you ever had any issue with a google product. There's no way to resolve issues outside of canned answers from "AI" systems and public forums.
- ztqejq 4y agoOr maybe you overestimate the data of users?
- amelius 4y agoNo doubt the average value of data is not very high. That doesn't mean it also holds for the most valuable data stored.
- Jabbles 4y agoThis story from last week seems to indicate that that is not true, though it hardly makes Google look perfect! https://twitter.com/samwcyo/status/1569897392560050178 https://twitter.com/samwcyo/status/1569897392560050178 Discussed in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32835190 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32835190
- type-r 4y agomost users aren't paying for Google Photos. sounds to me like they're accurately estimating the value.
- fdewrewrewf 4y ago>Google underestimates the value of data stored by users. Of course they do. How can they possibly put any value on endless PB of holiday snaps? They only care that you are now reliant on them to store your memories.