10 ms·
If the people who advocate addressing climate change actually believed this, they wouldn’t constantly be trying to tie it to other unpopular issues. They’d be w
by rayiner 4y ago
If the people who advocate addressing climate change actually believed this, they wouldn’t constantly be trying to tie it to other unpopular issues. They’d be willing to compromise on everything else to gather the broadest possible support base for solutions.
I personally think climate change is a lot more important than it’s advocates treat it as, though it’s a stretch to say it’s “the most important” issue. Based on my understanding of “the science” economic development in the third world will still leave those people better off even accounting for climate change impacts.
- eganist 4y ago> If the people who advocate addressing climate change actually believed this, they wouldn’t constantly be trying to tie it to other unpopular issues. They’d be willing to compromise on everything else to gather the broadest possible support base for solutions. Question of the strawman variety: if a bill comes about that passes meaningful climate change reform but bans abortion (in the united states) altogether, is your position that such a bill should be accepted by the climate change advocacy groups?
- bombcar 4y agoArguably if they are single issue advocacy groups they shouldn’t care about the associated riders (and this would go for the anti abortion side too). But all too often you find that they are NOT actually single issue groups and instead just basically a portion of a political side.
- pas 4y ago"obviously" no one is really a walking talking voting caricature. yet still there are big groups that care only about a handful issues meaningfully. eg. they usually don't vote, and very few thinfs might move them to do so. but those who vote usually are already well motivated to care for things the parties carry.
- NhanH 4y agoYou need to ask that question to the climate activists. GP didn't mention himself being one, it might not be applicable to him.
- rayiner 4y agoI think climate change is a very important problem, too important to be left to “climate activists.” The environmental movement totally screwed us in the 1970s by lashing climate-change activism to anti-nuclear and degrowth. The only politically feasible way of addressing climate change is to grow and engineer our way out of it. Even leaving aside people in the developed world, people in India and China will not accept that the solution for them is to delay or avoid industrialization and remain subsistence farmers.
- zeckalpha 4y agoOne aspect of climate change is overpopulation. These issues may be more related than you think.
- gruez 4y agoThat might be true in principle but practically speaking whatever population increase caused by abortion bans in the US is going to be dwarfed by the population boom happening in africa/asia.
- zeckalpha 4y agoSoon: abortion wars. The US could invade any nation without an abortion ban to liberate fetuses.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoIt's ok, hookup culture already fixed that, western societies are below replacement rate. We need to worry about disappearing instead.
- anemoiac 4y agoYou think that “hookup culture” is the reason for the “West’s” low birthrates? This is a well-studied topic and I haven’t heard anyone else making that claim…
- yucky 4y agoWhy wouldn't it be related? Women would rather not have kids with random hookups so if they're all having random hookups with everyone on Tinder/Bumble/Whatever then when exactly would they be having kids? Of course it's related. Also, look at the levels of estrogen-related compounds in our drinking water due to all of the birth control and think of what effect that might have on male fertility, which we know is the lowest in recorded history...
- 4y ago
- rayiner 4y agoIf someone believes that climate change is an existential threat this would seem to be a utilitarian no brainer.
- staticman2 4y agoAnd what if someone is not a utilitarian?
- wyager 4y agoThen I don't care much about their analytical process except insofar as I can steer it.
- staticman2 4y agoA funny (to me) parody of Utilitarian thinking is in this comic strip: https://existentialcomics.com/comic/420 https://existentialcomics.com/comic/420
- wyager 4y agoIt's a reasonable parody of EA-style uniform utilitarians, but has nothing on hedonic/non-uniform utilitarians. I also don't take EA-style uniform utilitarianism seriously (specifically because of the type of thing in that strip - I care more about my family/friends/community than random people I don't know or have any relation to).
- JamesBarney 4y agoWhat if someone feels so strongly about a woman's right to choose they are willing to see the world burn? I would not call that person a climate change advocate, I would call them a fanatical abortion rights advocate.
- staticman2 4y agoLet's change the scenario to explore the framework of your argument. Suppose Vladimir Puten says he'll nuke the planet tomorrow unless every Apple employee dances naked outdoors then burns their headquarters to the ground. Apple does not burn their HQ down and the employees refuse to dance outdoors, naked. Are they "fanatical Apple computer advocates and/ or fanatical prudes?" Or does game theory suggest responding to threats is a bad idea?
- RyEgswuCsn 4y ago> if a bill comes about that passes meaningful climate change reform but bans abortion (in the united states) altogether, is your position that such a bill should be accepted by the climate change advocacy groups? If the world ends tomorrow and the only way to avert it is to ban abortion then almost certainly yes, otherwise the baseline deal ought to be better.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago
- andrew_ 4y agoAdvocates for and against are equally bought and paid for. Some of the loudest voices warning of climate change are still cruising around in some of the most inefficient, dirtiest vehicles on the planet. Hypocrisy is rife, orgs like the WEF are capitalizing on fear, and an industry around climate change has developed around it to bring in billions. If you think pointing the finger at one group explains it all, I suggest you haven't looked deep enough. People have done to the noble quest against climate change what they always do to noble movements; it's been co-opted and corrupted.
- blooalien 4y ago> "If you think pointing the finger at one group explains it all, I suggest you haven't looked deep enough. People have done to the noble quest against climate change what they always do to noble movements; it's been co-opted and corrupted." I've long wondered why this oh-so-blatantly-obvious fact is so hard to grasp for so many. Right alongside the oft-ignored fact that your favorite politician couldn't care less about you as an individual, or as a group, except insofar as your existence as a statistic (your vote) gives them access to more power and / or money.
- ericd 4y agoDoes it matter? It’s still extraordinarily important, regardless of the virtue of its current political advocates. That they’re aligned with it doesn’t invalidate the underlying cause.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cagenut 4y agoYour 'understanding' is rear-view-mirror/past-performance logic and the whole point of "the science" [1] is to communicate that that WILL NOT HOLD. A 3.5C world is one in which large portions of the tropics (central america, northern africa, the middle east, india and large parts of china) will simply be depopulated. They can leave as refugees or stay as bodies. At 2.5C thats still largely true but say its only half the populations. Nobody is "better off" living through the droughts, famines, and conflicts that lead to that level of depopulation. Essentially at 3C and above we're doing an irish-famine/holodomor to somewhere between an eighth and a quarter of humanity. To imply they might be 'better off' for it is so grotesque I'll assume you're not a monster and simply don't grasp the 1.5<->3.5C consequence ranges and timeline. [1] just as one example here's the 'multi sector risk' indexed by (poor) population: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2018/11/Figure_3.18.jpg https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2018/11/Figu... Those are the people who are being hit the hardest. Many more good graphs in that report: https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/graphics/ https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/graphics/ Probably most important of all is to really deeply memorize that first one to understand the most important variable in the whole conversation: TIME
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoThere’s some non-zero risk of this happening, conceivably, although I would contest it. But there is no way that you can frame it as a certainty and call that science.
- cagenut 4y agoI very literally linked to the scientific reports. The explanatory text next the graphic I mentioned explains how the bands between the lines represent the 33rd to 66th% confidence intervals. Its worth noting SR15 is the older report and AR6 has since tightened the bands/confidence-levels. They just didn't redo the graph so I still link to the SR15 one.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoAgreed. Climate panic adherents look to fallible and flawed scientific models for confirmation of their beliefs the same way Judeo-Christians look to the Bible for theirs.
- scythe 4y ago>If the people who advocate addressing climate change actually believed this, they wouldn’t constantly be trying to tie it to other unpopular issues. Unfortunately, those of us who do believe this are a small minority. That's why it gets tied to other issues: it's coalition-building and the dynamics of advocacy. That's also a big reason why my other favorite cause is election reform, because it can help climate-change targeted reform become less partisan. >Based on my understanding of “the science” economic development in the third world will still leave those people better off even accounting for climate change impacts. If we had had economic development to the degree we now think of as "normal" in the third world starting in the 1960s, we would be looking at a very different, less frightening situation. But something went wrong. Currently, and particularly considering the events of this year, we don't seem to have solved geopolitical instability in the general case. Hopefully, the third world keeps developing. I'd still like to have a plan B.
- germandiago 4y agoBalanced comment. I do not find many when talking about this topic.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoSince when is building a strawman "a balanced comment"? "the people who advocate addressing climate change" - who? "constantly be trying to tie it to other unpopular issues" - which? " lot more important than it’s advocates treat it as" The commenter builds up a profile of a "foe" to argue against, but it's all broad strokes and intimation. Each person who holds an opinion about climate change and policy possibilities around it has their own reasons and positions. Lumping them all together and building a strawman out of them doesn't serve any healthy discourse. The comment author evidently has their own opinions and feels like there is some consensus that leaves them out. They'd be better off making those assumptions about what other people apparently think explicit and their own alternatives explicit as well. Point by point. So they can be reasoned about. Instead generalizations are made so they can "win". Because this is just a rhetorical drive-by.
- germandiago 4y agoI do not mean the contents are right or wrong. I mean it is a balanced comment. Nothing else.
- rayiner 4y ago> Each person who holds an opinion about climate change and policy possibilities around it has their own reasons and positions. I agree, but that’s my point! If the people who support addressing climate change really believed it is an existential issue, that wouldn’t be the case. They wouldn’t be treating it as one bullet point on an overall agenda.
- ericd 4y agoI fail to see how continued economic development in the third world and more material wealth will counteract famine due to reduced global population capacity. It’s a great recipe for massive scale unrest and warfare, which is extremely effective at destroying material wealth. Enlighten me?
- ricardoplouis 4y agoIt's worth asking what made issues surrounding climate change so unpopular in the first place. Advocates and activists are working against decades of misinformation from oil execs. Even something as straightforward as replace coal with renewables is deeply unpopular in large parts of the country because there's the stigma of job loss associated with it. While it's easy to take aim at climate advocates, why not take aim at the ones who actively profit off the destruction of the planet?
- evandale 4y agoFor me it's unpopular for a few reasons: 1. The activists are hypocrites: buying beachfront properties when you think every coast in the world will be swallowed up by 2050 is very telling. Flying around in jets to tell people to stop flying and eating meat is also infuriating and condescending. 2. It's frustrating to live in Canada and be told we're the biggest problem in the world with our 2% of all emissions. All because of our per-capita emissions are high due to a small population and our economy relying on industry everyone else in the world needs. Yet China continues to increase their emissions every year (and plan to till 2030, fat chance, but that's a different discussion) by more than all of Canada's emissions.
- danhor 4y ago> It's frustrating to live in Canada and be told we're the biggest problem in the world with our 2% of all emissions. It's frustrating to live in china and told we're the biggest problem in the world, even we're responsible for less than 15% of carbon in the atmosphere. Wealthy countries like Canada and the US have profited from blowing carbon in the atmosphere over centuries and got wealthy from it, but now refuse to lower their emissions and blame us for wanting to get rich too. It's all a question of framing.
- evandale 4y ago> Wealthy countries like Canada and the US have profited from blowing carbon in the atmosphere over centuries and got wealthy from it It was done at the scale of 30m and 300m populations, not a population 1.5b so it's hardly a fair comparison. We have cleaner methods now, and my province doesn't even have any coal plants left. Our energy costs are through the roof because of that effort to save the planet. Meanwhile China continues to pollute more and more yoy, undoing any progress the rest of the world makes, at a mind boggling scale using outdated technology with no regard for the rest of the world.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoUltimately, climate change will be a fight for resources. As more people are pushed out of areas that can no longer produce food and safe shelter others will try to stop them. We are seeing that with the influx of migrants into the U.S. and Western Europe. We are headed in to a societal crisis the world has never seen due to climate change. It's started and it will only get worse. Most of the current population will not see its affects but the crisis is real and it will be harsh for future generations. In the past, the way people have dealt with extreme resource scarcity has been war. There's nothing to say that won't happen again. It really is what should be at the top of people's minds. We need to reduce its affects and get ready for the changes that are coming.
- redeeman 4y ago> We are seeing that with the influx of migrants into the U.S. and Western Europe dont be ridiculous, we are seeing ECONOMIC migrants. Im not saying we will not see climate/disaster migrants, but the overshadowing majority of migrants are economic opportunists, that are eying the possibility of a better life in Europe/USA. This is why in Europe they overwhelmingly seek to the countries with the largest welfare schemes. I dont blame them, why wouldnt they do this? but dont fall for the obvious lies about WHY they come.
- danhor 4y agoMany people believe that climate change can't be "solved" in a vacuum and has to be approached with broad measures to be palatable or even "solvable". I haven't checked for America, but at least in Germany it's pretty obvious that with the expected transition to electrical vehicles, it will not happen fast enough to reach the climate goals. But at the same time, electric vehicles have significant pollution in the manufacturing stage, so just making them a lot cheaper might not be a solution (and lead to more demand for vehicles, since they're suddenly much cheaper, leading to unintended emission). Additionally vehicles are getting larger (increasing energy usage) and more miles get driven. This means car mobility has to be reduced or at least kept at the same level. This is certainly not an easy problem and probably has to be associated with vast changes across society, like rezoning, changing work & mobility. And that's just a single example. It's also pretty obvious (IMHO) that SAF won't available in a large-enough scale to make much of a difference to flying emissions in the next decades. But flights are booming around the world (with a small damper due to covid) and could make up as much as 10% of global warming contribution in 15 years which (IMHO) looking at the benefits is way too much. What do you do there? Housing is difficult (how do you incentivize moving to efficient heating based on electricity without people dying because they need to save on heating), adoption to climate change is difficult (sorry, you can't live/build new houses here anymore), ... . How do you avoid that pricing emissions hurts poor people the most and thus discourages/punishes politicians? These are all topics with no simple answers and possibly unpopular solutions with no great alternatives. But "solving" climate change is a very multidisciplinary problem, with many unpopular issues associated with it. It's very easy to tie something to climate change, even if it might not make much sense when looking at it in greater detail. But it's also very easy to surface level say "What's that to do with climate change?" even though for almost any measure you can argue for at-least some benefit.
- yongjik 4y ago> If the people who advocate addressing climate change actually believed this, ... They’d be willing to compromise on everything else to gather the broadest possible support base for solutions. "If anyone believes X is the most important, they must acquiesce to my every demand, otherwise they're lying!" Seriously, why are we even entertaining this level of discourse?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JamesBarney 4y agoThere's a difference between most important and existential. If you truly believe the world will end unless you solve a specific problem. You should be highly motivated to solve that problem and willing to make even extreme sacrifices to get that done. For instance I grew up in the Catholic church and knew plenty of single issue voters. Pro-life voters would vote for anyone, no matter how much they despised them or disagreed with all their other politics, as long as they promised to try to ban abortion. I don't really see this on the climate change side. They say it's existential threat but they don't act like it.
- rayiner 4y agoThe pro life folks are a good example. The pro life movement has worked with everyone from free market republicans to labor democrats to black nationalists. Whatever you think of their policy, they believe their cause is existential and they act like it.