3 ms·
Until a new energy technology gains mass adoption (maybe the lawyers will finally let nuclear get away with merely being an order of magnitude safer than coal?)
by roenxi 4y ago
Until a new energy technology gains mass adoption (maybe the lawyers will finally let nuclear get away with merely being an order of magnitude safer than coal?) the only story that matters is energy security. There is currently a war in Europe that is threatening to go the wrong sort of nuclear, and it is at best only tangentially related to climate issues even with motivated reasoning. Add in some economic pressure for the energy crisis and roll the dice a few more times and someone is going to press a button that we all regret the pressing of.
There is no climate issue that can't be barrelled through with cheap energy. Even climate stasis cannot be overcome without cheap energy. The only story here is energy until energy is secure. We've already established that countries with large amounts of cheap energy are going to be fine with climate change.
The top issues:
1) We've got weapons that are far too powerful.
2) Overpopulation.
3) Energy security.
If we could torch the environment and solve those 3 then the sane thing to do is torch the environment. It isn't a top 3 priority.
- viraptor 4y ago> If we could torch the environment and solve those 3 then the sane thing to do is torch the environment. You do say "if" though. We can't do it that way. The climate crisis will cause forced migration of many people once they can't be fed. That will stimulate both armed conflicts and issues related to overpopulation. It's not helping with energy security either if we need more development or living spaces than we planned for. It's all connected.
- roenxi 4y agoThe people who approach this from a perspective of "there is a climate crisis" tend to be centralisers at heart though. I think most people agree that to make a market preserve the environment there needs to be a strong central body that forces them to consider it. This is exactly the strategy that promotes energy shortages, because strong central bodies promote wild over- or under-supply. The right solution is to push for cheap power. The people trying to solve 'the climate crisis' have been fighting against the political lobbies in favour of cheap energy basically forever. That is the entire fight. People who want cheap power vs. people who want to achieve alternative, less useful, objectives.
- boxed 4y agoWe have cheap power. The problem is that this power destroys the basis of our food chain. Slowly, but surely.
- viraptor 4y agoBurning your local forest is cheap power. Fracking is cheap power. Coal plants near existing mines is cheap power. We can easily destroy everything if we go for cheap power.
- germandiago 4y agoI invite you to come to Vietnam. I am spanish (not from VN but lived here long time) Today I had dinner at a small seafood place. Go tell that woman: please do not use coal, pay much more for your energy no problem. See if it works. I would also get some insights about why we should be entitled to force others to these sort of things like telling them what to do. For them it is survival. Alternatively if you are deeply worried about negative externalities like pollution or climate change, I encourage you to subsidize their energy. Not others, or governments or always others.
- bezier-curve 4y ago> We've already established that countries with large amounts of cheap energy are going to be fine with climate change. Are they? I don't think a climate feedback loop cares about human borders and their ability to source cheap energy.
- mantas 4y agoIf you got cheap energy, you can defend from many many climate issues
- boxed 4y agoMany. Not all. Not even enough.
- danielheath 4y agoI mean, it certainly helps rebuild, but it's hardly "not an issue" that there are regular severe storms.
- Sharlin 4y agoIncluding potentially hundreds of millions of climate refugees? I mean, technically yes I guess.
- jghn 4y agoUnfortunately, cheap energy would also allow for a country to turn itself into a fortress
- boxed 4y agoAll those three points are a problem because they threaten the environment. The environment is the thing that enables us to EAT. You can't destroy the underlying ecosystem without killing yourself. I can't believe I am even writing something so super trivial.
- roenxi 4y ago> I can't believe I am even writing something so super trivial. How much can you write about the role of fossil fuels in the food chain? Because this comment reads to me like you're not totally across how artificial our food production is. Nature does not keep 8 billion humans fed. I, personally, think we should have built a lot of dodgy nuclear plants 20 years ago, aimed for too cheap to meter with the occasional meltdown, and try to go for hydroponics. It'd be a better strategy IMO than what we have actually done. I can live with it not working, but the fact that the West choked the nuclear industry with excessive regulation upsets me. I want to be investing in nuclear tech, I see real issues here that we could have solved with technology that is 50 years old at this point. > You can't destroy the underlying ecosystem without killing yourself. I haven't visited a natural ecosystem in months, I live in a city. Now we can argue about how natural the ecosystem is that my food comes from, but I think it is more likely to weather climate change if we have cheap, cheap electricity and fuels. Hopefully solar can provide that because we now have a lot of eggs riding in that basket. We feed ourselves with systems that we create using whatever energy we have on hand.
- boxed 4y ago> I, personally, think we should have built a lot of dodgy nuclear plants 20 years ago, aimed for too cheap to meter with the occasional meltdown, and try to go for hydroponics. Ok? But that isn't what we are talking about now. The cheap energy we have now is fossil fuel. > [lots of things about food production] Yea it's obvious you don't know how modern food production works. We are feeding cities by burning various ecosystems. You being ignorant about it doesn't change it.
- roenxi 4y ago
- Sharlin 4y agoBesides the should-be-obvious -by-now thing that you ABSOLUTELY cannot disengage human wellbeing from what happens to the ecosystem no matter how much people want to believe so – "Energy security" is just an euphemism for "I wanna continue my wasteful unsustainable lifestyle". Sure, things like heating can be real problems, but as long as there are thing like hundreds of millions of personal cars driving around every day, talking about energy security is bullshit. And talking about overpopulation is such a transparent red herring trying to deflect blame and responsibility from the Westerners to brown people in poor countries.
- roenxi 4y agoYes. I want every human on the planet to be living like a wealthy westerner. No euphemisms needed. My machiavellian evil knows few bounds.
- Sharlin 4y agoSure, me too. But that’s impossible right now, and it becomes less possible every second as we continue to lay waste on critical ecosystem services.
- elevaet 4y ago> If we could torch the environment and solve those 3 You say that like we're separate from the environment. If you torch the environment, then yes, you do solve those 3 because we won't be here anymore.
- nathanaldensr 4y ago> we won't be here anymore Fortunately, humans are a lot more resilient and better at adapting than you think.
- elevaet 4y agoWe're biological and we depend on having a functional biological ecosystem to breathe, drink, eat. If we "torch the environment", we saw off the branch we stand on. Food doesnt come from heaven.
- scatters 4y ago3 solves 2. The more energy available to humans, the fewer offspring they have.