5 ms·
Your post is an example of forced rationality. You're ignoring the fact that it's not just one production. I would consider your position if there was one cont
by copperx 4y ago
Your post is an example of forced rationality.
You're ignoring the fact that it's not just one production. I would consider your position if there was one continuous production with small to no variations.
Why are you ignoring the following?
- the sounds have the length of a yell or a moan.
- the silence between them is not fixed or related to any other sound that we can hear on the plane.
- there are no artifacts, except the weird pitch going up artificially in one of them, which might point to a prerecorded and manipulated sound
- if this was a electromechanical issue, it would have to mimic a significant part of the human anatomy, including a tongue (there are a few productions that sound like the throat is constricted and the tongue is rolling slightly).
Sure, a random electromechanical issue could have these characteristics, but isn't that extremely unlikely? You would expect other noises, not just the vocal-like sound.
- 20after4 4y agoAlso I'm pretty sure I heard the sound of clearing the throat and spitting in the recording. Too many distinct categories of human-sounding sounds to be random electro mechanical or electromagnetic phenomena.