4 ms·
Without commenting on the claims, it's interesting to consider how times have changed. Microsoft originally lost an antitrust lawsuit [1] over little more than
by somenameforme 4y ago
Without commenting on the claims, it's interesting to consider how times have changed. Microsoft originally lost an antitrust lawsuit [1] over little more than tying Internet Explorer into their OS and not readily including alternatives. They not only lost that case, but the initial judgement was that the company was to be broken up.
Microsoft started spending dramatically more money on "lobbying" following that.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
- dont__panic 4y agoAmazing that 20 years on, the USA has essentially given up on anti-trust tech regulation. Facebook acquired and repeatedly copied its closest competitors, no problem. Adobe buys up its competitors, no problem. Google aggressively pushes Chrome and fails to makes its own websites fully compatible with competitors, carry on. Apple refuses to give users the freedom to run their own apps on their purchased phones, no biggie. Was there some kind of official policy shift, or did the government just give up?
- neogodless 4y agoI certainly don't know for sure, but one theory would be the 2010 Citizens United ruling. https://www.history.com/topics/united-states-constitution/citizens-united https://www.history.com/topics/united-states-constitution/ci...
- smoldesu 4y agoMy guess is that the government realized that FAANG makes for better bedfellows than sworn enemies. They can wave economic incentives in front of their face in exchange for international power beyond what other countries can offer. Having Google, Amazon, Apple and Microsoft under your thumb gives you control over ~80% of the internet and <95% of all PII. There is obviously a domestic interest in controlling that, so it would make sense that our intelligence agencies trade surveillance capabilities for SEC mulligans. That also explains our bipartisan indifference towards real data regulation and privacy legislation.
- KerrAvon 4y agodefine "the government" -- who and what exactly is controlling this supposed policy?
- smoldesu 4y agoWell, I guess the NSA makes the most sense. They've been integrated into the corporate structure of FAANG for over a decade now, and they're the primary government entity making demands over this stuff. The who is a lot harder to track down - maybe there is a Wizard of Oz hiding behind one of our administrative curtains, but I think it's more of a bureaucratic process. Judging by what we know about America's surveillance infrastructure (eg. XKeyscore, Tempora, Boundless Informant), it would make sense if most of this software is developed in-house and then passed off to FAANG to implement and obfuscate. Again, all of this is conjecture. There's a lot of strangeness that surrounds the US intelligence agencies though, so I'm inclined to make some sense of it.
- hunter-gatherer 4y agoI'm sure I'll get downvoted for this and not believed by hardly anyone on this crowd so I'll keep it short and without evidence, only testimony: I was a US intelligence officer for some time. Not woth NSA, but did a lot of work with NSA, CIA, and the Bureau. The involvement between the US intelligence agencies and FAANG (in terms of the rough narrative involved) is a lot less impressive and threatening than people here suppose. The reality is that the US government hires some smart people to solve hard problems. When the problems get harder, they higher more smart people. The costs arent completely opaque, either. So at the end of the FY the costs get seen by elected officials and actions get justified and legally scrutinized. As it turns out, the US government is a lot less interested in spying on people who aren't threats to the state, and the intelligence agencies have to be judicial in who they target, because there are limited resources for such activities. The US intelligence service is also a bureaucracy, and people seem to forget that. Just because something is "secret" doesn't mean it is romantic or Bornesque. Context: I have not held a TS clearance or been employed with the US government nor contractor for a little over 3 years.
- mistrial9 4y agono - there are consent decrees and internal legal agreements that you and I will never see, in effect now. Combine that with soft-pressure in thousands of (real) ways..
- themadturk 4y agoYes, the US Government pretty much gave up on meaningful anti-trust regulation along about the Reagan era, as they pretty much gave up on a lot of stuff. The Biden administration via FTC Chair Lina Khan have declared they're trying to turn things around, but it's a big ship with a small rudder. We'll see.
- inetknght 4y ago> Google and fails to makes its own websites fully compatible with competitors More than that: Google actively prevents competitors from working when competitors would work fine without any extra "help"
- izacus 4y ago> Was there some kind of official policy shift, or did the government just give up? It's not just government - every single day I'm seeing Americans being directly hostile against free markets and choice. A lot of people (and media) expect and demand that a single corporation builds all of their things and owns all of their data. Plenty of people get outright hostile and dismissive of anything and everything that might create competition with the brand they're religiously following. Politics is just following the people.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"Plenty of people get outright hostile and dismissive of anything and everything that might create competition with the brand they're religiously following." Do they? I am not aware of many FB, Android or google fanboys. People just use it. But surely would use something better, if avaiable. Religious passion is more happening with apple, but it seems to me, they lost faith quite a bit. People use it and are entrenched in the apple universe, but fanatic worship and praise I am hearing way less nowdays, than back in the day, when Jobs was alive.
- kmeisthax 4y agoIn the 80s a bunch of federal judges adopted the "consumer welfare" standard, which argued that we should only consider antitrust violations that harm, well... consumer welfare. Since this was the 80s and Reagan-style free market rhetoric was in fashion, this became the new law of the land. Problem is, very few antitrust violations actually meet this standard, because most companies aren't buying other companies purely to jack up prices. The harm is a lot more subtle. If you remember the days of "disruptive innovation", that could be looked at as monopolists getting punished for being too large and ignoring new technologies. Now, because antitrust is basically not enforced anymore, incumbents just buy their disruptors and integrate them into the whole. Startups no longer exist to create new products, but to eat up chunks of a big company's M&A budget for that year. I'm hopeful that Lina Khan turns the ship around on this but it will take a decade, at least.
- scarface74 4y agoWhat happens to VC money once they can’t see a big exit via acquisitions? Look at how few YC companies have gone public.
- pwinnski 4y agoBoth! The history is covered extensively and well in Matt Stoller's book Goliath, and ongoing on his substack[0]. The TL;DR version is that the MS case affected things, but so do a shifting emphasis in Congress. 0. https://mattstoller.substack.com https://mattstoller.substack.com
- MichaelCollins 4y agoMicrosoft got smacked because they weren't playing ball with Washington politics, they weren't bribing enough congressmen nor capitalizing on their market dominance to make themselves strategically useful to national interests. Since then, big tech companies have known to grease the gears and befriend power brokers in Washington. They now contribute to political campaigns, and have made themselves useful to the defense and intelligence sectors.
- BeefySwain 4y agoWhile this does align with my beliefs and biases, do you have any proof or evidence to point to that was the case? Specifically that the antitrust suit was due (in whole or in part) to Microsoft not engaging with politics, and that the result has been a trend towards big tech playing ball, and hence future antitrust being unlikely?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe spy shit is hard to back up, due to the inherently secretive nature of spy shit. However I can back up the lobbying aspect of my claims above: Fortune magazine article about it from 2002 (hosted by CNN): > For a couple of embarrassing years in the mid-'90s, Microsoft's primary lobbying presence in D.C. was "Jack and his Jeep." As the software giant's sole in-house lobbyist, Jack Krumholtz, then 33, had to battle endless traffic jams to get from Microsoft's suburban sales office to Capitol Hill. "Early on I spent most of the day in my Jeep Grand Cherokee on my cellphone," Krumholtz says. "I hit an all-time low on the day I was parked on a Capitol Hill side street reading through my mail with the laptop on the steering wheel." > No longer. After the Justice Department filed its antitrust suit in 1998, Microsoft--a company famous for its disdain of government--undertook the largest government affairs makeover in corporate history. The company now boasts one of the most dominating, multifaceted, and sophisticated influence machines around, one that spends tens of millions a year. It's no great surprise that one of the country's wealthiest companies can bankroll a beefed-up lobbying operation when it faces a crisis. But what few people realize is that Microsoft has reached the very highest ranks of lobbying so quickly. Says David Hart, a lobbying expert at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government: "Microsoft has joined the top tier"--with such longtime heavyweights as Philip Morris, Lockheed Martin, and AT&T. https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2002/04/29/321995/index.htm https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2002... Bill Gates quote from 2020: > "I was naive at Microsoft and didn't realize that our success would lead to government attention," Gates said, referring to Microsoft's antitrust challenges from more than 20 years ago. "And so I made some mistakes — you know, just saying, 'Hey, I never go to Washington, D.C.' And now I don't think, you know, that naivete is there." https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/14/bill-gates-i-was-naive-at-microsoft-on-antitrust-scrutiny.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/14/bill-gates-i-was-naive-at-mi...
- scarface74 4y agoThe meme that MS lost the case about bundling IE with Windows is about as false and pervasive as “cable TV was once ad free”. MS won the case on appeal and absolutely nothing changed in the US. Even the cited Wikipedia article says as much. There was never a time since IE was bundled with Windows that IE didn’t come with Windows in the US. There was also no browser choice mandate in the US.
- IshKebab 4y agoNot only that but barely anything changed in Europe either. They were required to show a browser choice screen... for 4 years. Only a tiny fraction of the population will have ever seen it.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoAnd due to a myriad "temporary technical reasons" most users in Europe were never shown that screen at all.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoI wouldn't say nothing. Europe and Korea respectively have, "N" and "KN"versions of Windows from XP onwards that unbundled Windows Media Player and other preinstalled apps.
- nodamage 4y agoThe Wikipedia page does not make this clear but Microsoft did not actually lose on the tying claim. The district court ruled against them but this was appealed and the appeals court vacated that ruling and remanded the case for further analysis (which never happened as the case was then later settled). > They not only lost that case, but the initial judgement was that the company was to be broken up. That judgement was also vacated by the appeals court who concluded that the district court "failed to provide an adequate explanation for the relief it ordered".