3 ms·
I encourage all those who care about this but do not work in medical research to join the government or get a PhD or MD and be prepared to solve the next proble
by dekhn 4y ago
I encourage all those who care about this but do not work in medical research to join the government or get a PhD or MD and be prepared to solve the next problem that crops up. Then, you will have some more context on the challenges faced during public health emergencies.
In the meantime I'd love to see a truly non-partisan, fact based, recognizing limits of human knowledge postmortem of the US response and how it could have been improved, given the information that was available at the time. The vast majority of postmortems I read of COVID assume knowledge today was avaialble then, that the data is unambiguous, and the conclusions trivially follow from the data, and start with a conclusion, rather than starting with data and forming a collection of hypotheses, and attempting to produce reasonable estimates on the probabilities of those hypotheses. I don't know quite who would be capable of doing this.
- drivebycomment 4y ago> In the meantime I'd love to see a truly non-partisan, fact based, recognizing limits of human knowledge postmortem of the US response and how it could have been improved, I share your sentiment, but I won't be holding my breadth. I'm afraid we don't have any existing organizational structure that can produce something like that, and thus I suspect something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Commission_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Commission_Report for the pandemic would be necessary, yet it's probably too soon to start one since the pandemic isn't quite "over" enough yet. Even then, we'd need someone like Feynman in the committee, and that's far from guaranteed. That said, no doubt we'll get an endless stream of research studies and books going forward on this topic from multiple angles in the decades ahead.
- throwaway22032 4y ago> The vast majority of postmortems I read of COVID assume knowledge today was avaialble then Eh? I remember vividly thinking about a month or so into the first lockdown in the UK that we need to open up now. Sure, we didn't know immediately before we even did anything, but after March/April/May we had very solid statistical data. We have different approaches _even now_. That's not based on a lack of data, it's based on different value systems. Japan, Taiwan, obviously China etc are all still gung-ho on masks (and from what I can tell parts of the US are as well - super weird watching videos of conferences).