4 ms·
As a consumer, I don't care. dolby makes money from licensing, but don't ask that much, they innovate constantly, and they do a lot of public education. This s
by anigbrowl 4y ago
As a consumer, I don't care. dolby makes money from licensing, but don't ask that much, they innovate constantly, and they do a lot of public education.
This seems like one corporation flexing on another rather than great sense of mission; it's not like Google doesn't have IP of its own that it prefers to keep locked up. I suspect that this signals a strategic desire to move into the A/V production space, where customers have big demands for storage and computing resources.
- izacus 4y agoCompetition is always good for a consumer, especially here where right now you simply don't have a choice but to pay the rent to Dolby on every TV audio device. C'mon, this is market capitalism 101
- anigbrowl 4y agoLuckily I'm not a capitalist and am not convinced my life will be improved by shaving costs down to nothing until there is only one supplier left standing. Fort that matter I'm not much of a consumer, I'm still using a 10 year old TV XD What's weird to me is how google is selling this as a win for the public, when the marginal costs added by Dolby are so low. Even in the audio production space, Dolby stuff is a little expensive for an individual (surround sound plugins costing hundreds of dollars) but it's not a big overhead for a recording studio. Their product is quality and consistency at industrial prices and imho they deliver on this. There isn't an underground of frustrated audio engineers dreaming of how theatrical sound could be so much better if it weren't for big D. Spatial audio rebels build quadrophonic sound systems for raves, but you didn't hear it from me.
- rodgerd 4y agoHow is one of the richest monopolistic companies in the world deciding to destroy a market segment "competition" that is "good for the consumer"?
- BiometricAndy 4y agoSo like Apple with their ATT? HN news user simping for Apple
- anotherman554 4y agoDolby vision playback effectively doesn't work on PCs, so if you are a consumer that uses PCs, you have a reason to care.
- Seattle3503 4y agoI care because ATSC 3.0 includes AC-4, a proprietary Dolby format. None of my software will play the audio from ATSC 3.0 over the air broadcasts for this reason. ATSC 3.0 is a government standard for how public airwaves should be used. It strikes me as wrong that the government has basically mandated Dolby licensing for hardware manufacturers and software libraries.
- toast0 4y agoWell of course ATSC 3 includes a new proprietary Dolby format, ATSC 1 got AC-3 as a mandatory audio format, too. I'm not sure if ac-4 is mandatory, but it seems like it is? Kind of a big pain indeed.
- kieranl 4y agoAtsc mandates ac-3. Ac-3 audio is actually dolby-d. They just could not call it Dolby in the standard so they renamed it to ac3 instead.
- layer8 4y agoATSC 3.0 doesn’t mandate Dolby AC-4, it also supports MPEG-H. Both require licensing. The thing is, there is no equivalent patent-free technology available (object-based 3D audio).
- izacus 4y agoExactly. Which is why "I don't care" is a very shortsighted and terrible look on a standard that's at least royalty free.
- layer8 4y agoYeah, my point is you can’t blame ATSC 3.0 for making use of the existing standards. And it’s not too different from how a lot of mobile/wireless technology depends on patents.
- anigbrowl 4y ago
- hparadiz 4y agoDolby vision is basically broken on Linux and not great on Windows.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI can't argue with that as I only know about their audio side.
- Melatonic 4y agoFrom what I remember it basically does not work in any browser based setup - have to use Netflix apps or dedicated software?
- brokenmachine 4y agoHDR in general is non-existent on Linux.
- 65934 4y ago