6 ms·
Anyone who has studied aerospace engineering in the last couple of decades was taught that the economics of supersonic travel are unworkable in an environment w
by rayiner 4y ago
Anyone who has studied aerospace engineering in the last couple of decades was taught that the economics of supersonic travel are unworkable in an environment where fossil fuel energy costs what it does and is on the way out altogether. I was hoping Boom had cracked some constraint in that equation.
- bell-cot 4y agoPeeking at Boom's Wikipedia page - their 1/3 scale "technology demonstrator" test aircraft, which they originally said would fly in 2017, has been changed & pushed back & changed & pushed back... And it still has not managed to even taxi down a runway. It doesn't much matter what is/isn't possible, or what could/couldn't be economical, if the company & engineers who say they are working to develop it...are not actually capable of shipping even a puny nerfed toy version of their supposed product. My guess: the RR engineers concluded "maybe it's possible, but these idiots will never achieve it". Then quietly shared that with their colleagues at other engine makers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rjsw 4y agoThe guess in a thread commenting on an earlier article was that Boom expected RR to fund the development of a new engine. Haven't seen any explanation on why Boom can't just buy a few current fast jet engines for their demonstrator.
- mrguyorama 4y agoBecause no existing commercial engine can supercruise. It needs to be a new design.
- bell-cot 4y agoWikipedia strongly suggests that Boom already has bought some of these engines - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_J85 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_J85 - to power the demonstrator. My impression is that Boom was not looking to RR for engines for their demonstrator, but for their full-size production model. Those engines would have to be carefully designed & optimized for economic long-haul supersonic operation. (Vs. existing supersonic military jet engines are basically cost-no-object gas-guzzling hot rods.)
- MichaelCollins 4y agoTheir intent to use GE J85s for the demonstrator is corroborated by the "Boom Fact Sheet" in their press kit: [PDF] https://boom-press-assets.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/BoomFactSheet_220825.pdf https://boom-press-assets.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/BoomFac... Three GE J85-15 engines for the XB-1 demonstrator.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoBoom did buy a current jet engine for the demonstrator, the GE J85. That engine is used on the T-38/F-5 so there are thousands of them on the market. The demonstrator is actually bad for Boom from a business analysis perspective because it is such an easy project that they have not been able to realize after hundreds of millions of dollars. The "small supersonic aircraft" which is what the XB-1 is, is a solved problem. "Advanced composites" is irrelevant, any aerospace firm can make a supersonic-capable aircraft out of "advanced composites". Scaled Composites build SpaceShipOne in three years with about a hundred people in a hangar. But Boom hasn't gotten the XB-1 into the air after five years and tons more cash. Building a new supersonic airframe: easy Building a new supersonic jet engine: hard Literally and actually with no exceptions every single modest-sized aerospace firm can build a supersonic airframe. That problem is solved. Tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of supersonic aircraft have been built and many of them are capable of carrying passengers. This is not an exaggeration. My employer isn't even in the supersonic aircraft business and we could build and fly a supersonic aircraft if some executive got a wild hair up his butt, in less time and money than Boom. Tiny and embargoed firms in a variety of foreign countries with small or non-existent aerospace industrial bases have done it. The research into the aerodynamics and stresses on supersonic airframes is done. Engines are hard. There are only a handful of companies with the expertise and cash needed to develop a supersonic jet engine, especially one that can super cruise. Boom is saying "yah we're gonna build a supersonic passenger jet, uhhh, don't worry about the engine we'll figure that out later, give cash please". What Boom is doing is functionally equivalent to an EV startup saying "Yeah we're going to design a car that can go 300mph (easy, individuals {Bob Dauernheim, for one} in garages have done it) that is powered by electric motors (hard) that don't exist yet and that someone else will design" and then getting hundreds of millions of dollars to design the chassis while negotiating with motor and battery suppliers to do the R&D into the hard bit at their own risk with the promise of profits from future sales to all of the people who want a 300mph EV.
- foobiekr 4y agoBoom appears to be a scam of the Nikola/etc. genre.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thinkingkong 4y agoI havent spent much time digging into Booms plans before but its sort of wild that their secret weapon was just… nothing? We already know we have airframes that can achieve supersonic flight, so why wasnt the engine design the number one priority?
- greenthrow 4y agoTheir secret weapon is that their product is their valuation and the hype surrounding it.
- ghaff 4y agoAnd not just an engine design but an engine design that fundamentally changes the economics of commercial supersonic flight.
- arethuza 4y agoMaybe they could use a SABRE engine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) Mind you, I've been hearing about that since I was at high school and I'm in my late 50s. :-)
- tokai 4y agoI thought noise was the issue with commercial supersonic flight not economics.
- xani_ 4y agoBoth. Noise limits where you can go, and that limits who will want the service.
- ghaff 4y agoNoise is an issue for overland flying (which of course affects the economic viability of a supersonic aircraft). But even if you assume there's a viable transatlantic market for supersonic flight, you probably can't charge all that huge a premium over business/first. If your premium has to be 2x to 3x, I doubt you have a market. Handwaving away noise issues with supersonic flight over land gets you closer to something viable. But you still need economics that aren't that different from an all business-class subsonic. (And my understanding is that British Airways had trouble making all business work on the London to New York route.
- sofixa 4y agoThe economics of supersonic travel using a plane and engine designed in the 1960s (which had a massively upgraded newer version planned in the 1970-80s which was cancelled due to lack of interest) are unworkable. The Concorde was designed before CAD, high bypass turbofans, composite materials, so it isn't that easy to extrapolate to today.
- greenthrow 4y agoModern CAD programs can't bypass the laws of physics. The faster you go in an atmosphere the more the atmosphere resists. It gets less and less efficient the faster you go. That's just how it works.
- sofixa 4y agoYes, but a modern CAD program can make the design faster (to design) and cheaper. Turbofans with high bypass ratios are more efficient than the engines the Concorde used. Of course it would be less efficient than a subsonic jet, but they never claimed the opposite - the idea was for it to be faster, but not (much) more expensive than today's business class on subsonic jets.
- avn2109 4y ago>> "The faster you go in an atmosphere the more the atmosphere resists." This is actually not even approximately true; like many aerodynamic phenomena, drag is super nonlinear in airspeed and not even monotonic, with a bunch of weird outcomes around mach 1. The first chapter of every aero textbook probably includes a variation of this famous chart [0], showing drag coefficient or sometimes drag force (estimated for some famous/classic airframe) as a function of mach number. This is why prolonged supercruise can exist for airplanes without giant comical fuel tanks etc. That said, your main point about CAD/physics definitely stands and is a good one; imho it would be unlikely to design and build e.g. a 10x better airplane than the Concorde today, even with all the fancy computers simulations etc. [0] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Drag-coefficient-as-a-function-of-the-Mach-number_fig18_256292310 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Drag-coefficient-as-a-fu...