3 ms·
Whenever I see a scheme like this, I want to ask "what's the quality of the beam?" Particle physics experiments, particularly colliders, need beams that are no
by pfdietz 4y ago
Whenever I see a scheme like this, I want to ask "what's the quality of the beam?" Particle physics experiments, particularly colliders, need beams that are not just energetic, but also extremely bright, so the particles can be focused down to tiny spots to get sufficiently high collision rates. The particle energies must also be within a narrow range, the narrower the better.
The proton bunches in the LHC are just 2.5 microns wide. They have to be to get the luminosity high enough.
- PaulHoule 4y agoYep. It is true for colliders and also a big issue for heavy ion fusion, which on one hand seems more feasible than laser fusion because of the very low efficiency of laser drivers in comparison, but boy you need a huge (kilometer scale) machine and probably 100 or so independent beams that are very high quality and well synchronized.
- pfdietz 4y agoA major problem with laser fusion is getting the final optics to survive. The designs I've seen put grazing incidence mirrors at considerable distance from the target, causing the entire thing to be large, much larger than the containment building of today's PWR power plants. https://fti.neep.wisc.edu/fti.neep.wisc.edu/aries/JUN2001/optics_lae.pdf https://fti.neep.wisc.edu/fti.neep.wisc.edu/aries/JUN2001/op... Heavy ions, being charged, can be deflected by magnetic fields, so nothing need be in line of sight of the target.
- marcosdumay 4y agoI don't think this kind of technology will ever create the kind of beans particle physics use. There is a hard limitation, because once the particles move fast enough, the only known source of the "light" needed to accelerate them further is particle accelerators. Instead, it looks like something laser focused on materials science and engineering. Think about what you can make with a $10k tabletop cyclotron light source.