3 ms·
Could this be used to make some variant of an ion drive?
by hedora 4y ago
Could this be used to make some variant of an ion drive?
- marcosdumay 4y agoYou would do better with a proton accelerator.
- noobermin 4y agoNo, because the total accelerated charge is tiny as of now, so you don't get a lot of total thrust. You'd need to scale up which hasn't really been considered yet. I'm not sure if the plasma bubble will be stable if it is larger (which I think is one way to up the total charge).
- adrianN 4y agoTotal thrust matters a lot less than how efficient it is.
- ben_w 4y agoCould? Sure. Should? Nope. Ion drives are an excellent way to make very little reaction mass go a long way. While something like this could do that, for very high energy particles you rapidly get relativistic effects, and the ultimate relativistic effect — zero reaction mass having finite momentum — is from using light. This can be as simple as a warm bit of the vehicle[0], but if that heat energy comes from solar then you might as well make it even simpler by replacing the PV with a mirror and suddenly your space ship is propelled by a solar sail. But you could use this if you really wanted. [0] the most recent explanation I've heard of for the Pioneer anomaly
- pfdietz 4y agoThe general problem with ion engines is that the exhaust velocity is too high. This makes them energy inefficient. Ideally, you want the exhaust velocity of a rocket to start out very low, then increase as the vehicle goes faster. That way, the ejected reaction mass is left stationary in the initial reference frame, with no kinetic energy (or, nearly stationary, with low kinetic energy). All the energy therefore goes into the kinetic energy of the vehicle. This is also part of why using liquid hydrogen in the first stage of launchers is dumb, vs. using hydrocarbons.
- ben_w 4y agoGiven all frames of motion are relative, I thought it was more about gravitational potential than kinetic energy?
- pfdietz 4y agoAny frame of reference can be chosen, and energy is conserved in each. So choose the reference frame in which you are initially at rest.
- hedora 4y agoHmm. So maybe using this to accelerate protons would be better. (I also wonder what happens if a spaceship bleeds a measurable fraction of its weight in electrons, then tries to coast away from the resulting negatively charged cloud.)
- ben_w 4y ago0.05% of your total mass is electrons[0], so you can't do that even if you removed all of them. Well before you even get that far, your electric field strength exceeds the binding forces of the molecules you're made of, so you explode. Well before you get to the point of exploding, your net electric charge is too strong for you to eject more electrons, and any electrons in the ambient environment will fly towards you, producing a shower of deadly radiation when they hit your hull. [0] assuming you're mostly hydrogen; a bit less than half that if you're mostly made of heavier elements like Uranium
- perihelions 4y agoFor designing relativistic rocket engines, there's no point in using lasers to accelerate ions to close to the speed of light. You can just use the laser directly -- the other stuff is extraneous. A relativistic electron has no more momentum than a photon of the same energy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket
- moffkalast 4y agoThe photon rocket is the most widespread type of rocket these days, eclipsing both ion thrusters and traditional chemical rockets. ...flashlights ;)
- pmayrgundter 4y agoAs an indirect mechanism for triggering more powerful reactions that could be used as the primary drive, I think so. My dream spaceship has a fusion engine and VASIMR drive, a kind of variable ion thruster, for variable thrust from takeoff to ~.1c speeds. But fusion reactions are hard to ignite and sustain. Putting a tokamak in a spaceship might be possible, but they weren't really designed to scale down. Fusion reactions require energies in the MeV range to ignite, but that's with perfect conversion. I'd like the flexibility up to GeV range, or many small 100 MeV units in parallel like this accelerator or the BELLA & kBELLA at Berkeley[kBELLA]. These can also be chained. Cascading wavefront accelerators appear to be the most compact way to achieve scale for high energy particle beams, perhaps combined with lattice-confinement-based fuels[lc-fusion]. Berkeley is also developing software to model "multi-TeV high-energy physics colliders based on tens to thousands of plasma-based accelerator stages."[warpx] Cuz your spaceship needs a laser gun too, right? [kBELLA] https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2021/12/06/fiber-lasers-poised-to-advance-berkeley-labs-development-of-practical-laser-plasma-accelerators/ https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2021/12/06/fiber-lasers-poised-to... [lc-fusion] https://www1.grc.nasa.gov/space/science/lattice-confinement-fusion/ https://www1.grc.nasa.gov/space/science/lattice-confinement-... [warpx] https://www.exascaleproject.org/research-project/warpx/ https://www.exascaleproject.org/research-project/warpx/
- pfdietz 4y ago> Putting a tokamak in a spaceship might be possible, but they weren't really designed to scale down. It would be senseless. I mean, ITER, if it could run continuously (it can't; it will run a few weeks before materials reach radiation limits, and it can't breed tritium) would take 300,000 years to fuse its own mass in fuel. Smaller tokamaks are not much better. There's no application in space for controlled DT fusion where fission wouldn't be superior.