8 ms·
I'm sad that free markets are viewed as an "extreme" position.
by WalterBright 4y ago
I'm sad that free markets are viewed as an "extreme" position.
- liotier 4y agoFree markets indeed is an extreme position: efficiency in trade requires regulation.
- WalterBright 4y agoFree markets require a government to enforce contracts, property rights, and ensure there's no force or fraud in the transactions.
- Test0129 4y agoRegulations? You mean the same mechanism ISPs, food companies, "sin taxable" companies, etc use to capture entire segments of the market and price fix their way to a billion dollar profit? Or the regulations that nearly sank Tesla in the cradle that existed for no reason other than politicians are as corrupt, if not more, than the worst CEOs? 99.9% of the time regulation is unnecessary. Over-regulation is a huge problem and one that only an actual theoretical free market could address. I see people on HN complaining about last mile politics often. Yet people seem hard pressed to look to the free market for a solution. I'd rather deal with a corrupt CEO whose power will end when their life does, rather than a politician whose power will continue for centuries until someone with a few more brain folds steps in and stops it.
- astrange 4y agoIf you didn’t have regulations you wouldn’t be able to consume or produce any modern product. It’s not worth making electronics if your users all have randomly shaped random voltage power sockets installed by whoever built their house, uncontrolled RF emissions, and want to pay you in private bank currencies you can’t spend. This is an example of the article - libertarianism requires people to replace how things actually work with brief inaccurate summaries of how it works they fit in their heads, and the smarter you are the more incorrect information you can fit in your head and the more wrong you are.
- WalterBright 4y ago> It’s not worth making electronics if your users all have randomly shaped random voltage power sockets installed by whoever built their house, And yet nearly all electronics standards arose through voluntary cooperation. Ever notice the USB socket on your computer? The audio jack? The HDMI port? etc. Did you know that Edison standardized the Edison lightbulb socket, not the government? > uncontrolled RF emissions, Again, the free market does not allow one to interfere with other peoples' property. > and want to pay you in private bank currencies you can’t spend. Banks solved that problem long ago. The free banking system worked. BTW, we still mostly use PRIVATE BANK CURRENCIES all the time! Amazing, but true. They're called credit cards, bank checks, paypal, venmo, wire transfers, money orders, cashier's checks, etc. Even store coupons are private currency. > libertarianism requires people to replace how things actually work with brief inaccurate summaries of how it works they fit in their heads, and the smarter you are the more incorrect information you can fit in your head and the more wrong you are. Have fun debating with me. Good luck!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Test0129 4y ago> Banks solved that problem long ago. The free banking system worked. BTW, we still mostly use PRIVATE BANK CURRENCIES all the time! Amazing, but true. They're called credit cards, bank checks, paypal, venmo, wire transfers, money orders, cashier's checks, etc. Even store coupons are private currency. To reiterate this point the current US dollar is a private dollar issued by a private bank and funded (essentially) by congress and the treasury. The last time the US had a public dollar was prior to the American revolution. A lot of people make the mistake of conflating The Fed with the government but it is federal in name only. It is owned by private shareholders no different than any other corporation.
- WalterBright 4y ago> the current US dollar is a private dollar issued by a private bank LOL. The Federal Reserve System is a sham "private" bank used to get around the Constitution that does not empower the government to print money. You should check to see who appoints the people that run the Fed.
- aeternum 4y agoPurely free markets also have some very well-known failure cases: tradgedy of the commons, ability of a large participant to drop prices to eliminate competition then raise prices, inability of market forces to handle extreme tail risk like major natural disasters.
- WalterBright 4y ago> tradgedy of the commons, Communal ownership is not free market, hence the tragedy of the commons is not a failure of the free market. > ability of a large participant to drop prices to eliminate competition then raise prices, Has never happened successfully. > inability of market forces to handle extreme tail risk like major natural disasters. The free market does very well at rushing supplies into disaster areas. At least until the government put a stop to that with anti-gouging laws. So now, disaster victims have to wait around until the government gets its act together, which takes a lot longer.
- aeternum 4y ago>Communal ownership is not free market, hence the tragedy of the commons is not a failure of the free market. Ah yes so in this free-market utopia shall we purchase bottled air from Nestle for our breathing needs? Shall all aerospace companies pay a toll to the estate of Yuri Gagarin whenever they launch a rocket? He was the first in space so must have the most logical claim to the ownership rights. His estate could then help us avoid Kessler syndrome.
- WalterBright 4y agoIsn't climate change the result of communal ownership of the air? As for space, the orbits are full of dangerous space junk. A classic tragedy of the commons.
- aeternum 4y agoMuch of the most heavily polluted land in the US is privately owned, so I don't see how that eliminates the issue. I'd be much more concerned with issues like groundwater contamination, seeping gasses, and toxic waste dumping.
- imtringued 4y agoWhen people buy apples it is considered absolutely normal that apples go bad and spoil over time. If your unit of measurement is a golden apple that never rots, then it is only natural that the return on a spoiling apple is negative. The moment people talk and think about money, they consider the mere concept of a negative return as some kind of monstrosity going against nature itself, despite the fact that money is a claim on labor and labor spoils just like an apple. The saver expects a reward for idleness, while the laborer without a job is getting punished by his enforced idleness. Money without negative return obligates men to become golden statues that never age, a world view that is obviously in dissonance with nature and reality. Whenever the economy isn't growing, people will prefer an asset that bears a 0% return at no risk over any real investment. In other words, there is no such thing as a free market without a monetary reform that allows negative interest rates or simply allows money to expire, the same way people age. Here is another problem, eternal private landownership has the same problem. Let's assume you have a perpetuity that returns you $1 per year. At a zero interest rate its value is infinite and no, that isn't a problem with the concept of zero interest, the obvious problem is that a perpetuity cannot exist, even the planet itself has a finite lifespan, meaning the value of a single plot of land will only amount to billions of dollars. What's worth more? Money that works according to supply or demand or land that doesn't? Of course people are going to pick land. If landownership was eternal, then owning all of the land on the planet is equivalent to turning everyone else into illegal aliens that merely have been granted permission to exist on the planet and whose permission can be withdrawn at any time. In the face of these two forces there cannot be something like a free market. It would always be a coercive market in one form or another.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y ago>When people buy apples it is considered absolutely normal that apples go bad and spoil over time If you don't eat it, yes. >then it is only natural that the return on a spoiling apple is negative. my return on the regular apple is 95 kcal. If I sell it, my return is what I sold it for. Why would I compare it to a golden apple that never spoils? >The moment people talk and think about money, they consider the mere concept of a negative return as some kind of monstrosity going against nature itself Can you point to some economists who hold this poition? >despite the fact that money is a claim on labor and labor spoils just like an apple Money can be a claim on labor. It can also be a claim on something else, but aside from that, it seems like you are comparing the negative return from the apple comapred to the golden apple to labor which gives an absolute negative return. >The saver expects a reward for idleness (I assume by "saver" you mean investor) Do you mean "expect" from a moral or economic perspective? either way it isn't true. An investor does not nessesarily expect a return on his investment. Either way what the saver expects does not matter. >while the laborer without a job is getting punished by his enforced idleness. If the saver instead was in some way obligated to reward the laborer despite providing a negative return then it would reduce the efficency of the total output. The number of laborers rewarded for providing a negative return would increase until there would be a total negative return. whether or not the laborer has no job depends on the ability of the laborer to provide a function that he is paid for. His idleness is forced by not returning any value. Even if he was rewarded for providing a negative return he would still be idle in an economic sense. >Money without negative return obligates men to become golden statues that never age, a world view that is obviously in dissonance with nature and reality. Fortunatly money itself can bring a negative return, both by faulty investment and by the devaluation of the money itself comlared to other assets (including other money) >Whenever the economy isn't growing, people will prefer an asset that bears a 0% return at no risk over any real investment. False, even when the economy isn't geowing, there is still money to be made by investment at an idividual level >In other words, there is no such thing as a free market without a monetary reform that allows negative interest rates or simply allows money to expire, the same way people age This conclusion does not follow your statements above. But money can already expire only not idividual notes but the entire value shrinks such that some of it has expired. For example, if the economy has 1,000 eggs and 1,000 jars of milk, and 1,000,000 dollars and 10 eggs spoil then the value of the 1,000,000 dollars has shrunk by 10 eggs worth. >Here is another problem, eternal private landownership has the same problem can you site any examples of land that has been held privatley from the time it was first held until now? >At a zero interest rate its value is infinite it isn't infinite because that land takes an infinite amount of time to return an infinite value which is not possible. (compared to investing many other ventures it produces a negative return. Like the apple case except it does not expire). >What's worth more? Money that works according to supply or demand or land that doesn't? Of course people are going to pick land Real estate acounts for a large percentage of GDP in the US. But money is a liquid asset, land is not. Banks do not to forclose on houses from the first moment they can because then they have to sell them. But if they wait until the borrower gives them money they don't need to sell anything. >If landownership was eternal, then owning all of the land on the planet is equivalent to turning everyone else into illegal aliens that merely have been granted permission to exist on the planet and whose permission can be withdrawn at any time. Can you expound on this point? >In the face of these two forces there cannot be something like a free market. It would always be a coercive market in one form or another. There can never be a completly free market but there can be something like a free market. >It would always be a coercive market in one form or another. coercive in the sense that people will do things they don't want to such as working.