4 ms·
Right. It's "wrong" in the sense that Apple pays another company to deal with horrifying working conditions in their absence.
by smoldesu 4y ago
Right. It's "wrong" in the sense that Apple pays another company to deal with horrifying working conditions in their absence.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s not really what’s going on ether, the CCP doesn’t let foreign companies setup and run factories inside of China. So Google, Microsoft, Samsung, Apple, Nintendo, Nokia, Sony etc all end up using Foxconn to manufacture electronics at scale. Foxconn is actually slightly above average for Chinese manufacturing, but that’s really saying more about working conditions in China than anything positive about Foxconn.
- sneak 4y agoFoxconn is a foreign corporation that set up and runs factories inside China; they are from Taiwan.
- Retric 4y agoNot quite, the corporate structure is a little complicated but they are sort of made up of separate companies. Which is why “Foxconn Industrial Internet Co Ltd” for example has it’s own stock and is located at “2F C1 Foxconn Technology Park 2 Donghuan 2 Road Longhua Stre Shenzhen, 518109 China” https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/601138:CH?leadSource=uverify%20wall https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/601138:CH?leadSource=uverify... China isn’t going to let a foreign company operate an ISP in China, but a China/Foreign partnership is acceptable.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoThis whole Foxconn suicide net thing is really screwed up. I was there in person working for another US tech company, not Apple, but in the same Shenzhen factory compound during the big hubbub. It wasn't nearly as bad as the news reported. 1. Foxconn at its worst was having fewer suicides per-capita among its workers than most populations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn_suicides#Analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn_suicides#Analysis (sourced from ABC News and The Economist) The rest is anecdotal first-hand data from me, so feel free to ignore it: 2. The working conditions were bad, but not THAT bad. It was a shitty factory job where you were under a lot of scrutiny, but probably not as much as working at Amazon today. 3. The pay at those Foxconn jobs was great. People were making multiples of what they could earn back home for way less effort. Foxconn factory workers thought of themselves as hot shit, much like factory technicians used to think of themselves in the USA before all those jobs disappeared. It looked like there was a nice corporate ladder you could work your way up, too, since they'd filter things through multiple layers of increasingly-elite technicians/engineers on their way to me. The place looked like a lot like a college campus when I was there. Tons of young, happy-looking people working hard and getting paid well for it. IMO this all stems back to that debunked and retracted NPR report talking about armed guards and a prison-like atmosphere. The worst thing I had to deal with in Shenzhen was there not being enough butter in the cakes at the factory's onsite bakery when I bought my coworkers a couple of big birthday cakes.
- newtritious 4y agoThe working conditions are not horrifying. That’s the misinformation. The suicide rate at Foxconn when the suicide nets were installed was lower than the average at US colleges. Everything about this story is just sensationalism.
- smoldesu 4y agoThe horrifying working conditions are more of a reference to the children and political prisoners of China who are forced to work in factories for Apple suppliers.
- Dylan16807 4y ago...so a completely separate accusation from the suicide nets this subthread is about?
- newtritious 4y agoNo, you said it in reference to suicide nets. Nobody mentioned children and political prisoners before now. Children and political prisoners may be used as forced labor in China, but pretending that has something to do with Apple in particular is more misinformation. Apple have programs in place to try to prevent this.
- dkonofalski 4y agoSo now you're just moving the goalposts of this discussion because it's been shown that what you've said is, in fact, misinformation? It's really fruitless to engage with you.