14 ms·
I should probably make that a blog post, as it would get overly long here. Here, one wee little hack for you: next time you get asked for salary history, just
by patio11 15y ago
I should probably make that a blog post, as it would get overly long here. Here, one wee little hack for you: next time you get asked for salary history, just repeat verbatim "As a matter of professional courtesy, I'm going to respectfully decline to answer any questions about specific policies of my previous employers. Someday, someone is going to ask me about yours. When that happens, you can trust me to keep your confidences."
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- silverbax88 15y agoWe've had people say that. Just letting you know, we don't hire people who say things like that. You can decline to say, that's fine, but don't feed us a line of bullshit.
- edw519 15y agowe don't hire people who say things like that I don't work for people who don't hire people who say things like that. but don't feed us a line of bullshit And I certainly don't work for people who refer to a candidate's concern for confidentiality as a "line of bullshit". There are plenty of prospective employers who actually respect their candidates. Let's just stick with them and save everyone a whole bunch of time and trouble.
- vacri 15y agopatio11's line is pure wank, and will be recognised as such by anyone worth working for. It's not the denial of the request that's the problem, it's the overly dramatic reason - similar to "what's my greatest flaw? well, I can't stop myself from working long hours for my employer!". Bravura below has better alternatives.
- silverbax88 15y agoNo, you don't work for people like us. We expect that respect is a two way street.
- dpritchett 15y agoHow is aggressively undermining your potential employee's bargaining power a show of respect? The job offer is the single highest point of any worker's negotiating leverage and you seem to feel entitled to control the situation.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Peroni 15y agoCould not agree more. My salary isn't indicative of my ability, my experience is. Judge my worth based on my experience and its value to your business and we'll take it from there.
- bravura 15y ago"Sorry, that information is covered under my previous job's NDA." is a more direct, less bullshitty version of patio11's suggestion. It's also probably true. Alternately: "My previous salary has no bearing on this discussion."
- billybob 15y agoI would much prefer your to say "that doesn't matter." It's more honest than trying to invent a reason why I can't tell you, and it's true - it doesn't matter. The question is how much are my services, with my current skill set and experience, worth to you in your unique business. What my skill set of a few years ago was worth to somebody else in a different business is irrelevant. Apples and oranges.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoIt's also probably true. Unless it's verifiably false. Which would be just as bad, and probably worse, than patio11's statement. (Part of the design of patio11's tactic is that it isn't actually a lie: "I don't think it's polite to talk about stuff that feels like a private issue between my former employer and myself" is, itself, a fact.) "My previous salary has no bearing on this discussion." This is little better than saying "no". That's not merely somewhat abrupt and confrontational, but it also doesn't necessarily shut off the conversation. Instead, it could threaten to escalate the conversation. As your questioner, I can respond "but I think it does", or "tell me why you think so", or "yes, I tend to agree, but I have this form that my HR department makes me fill out and I need to put something in this blank". And then you have to keep talking. You don't want to keep talking. People seem to be misunderstanding how diplomacy works. There's no requirement that a diplomatic answer be a direct answer to the question. Quite the contrary. The goal of the answer, in this case, is (a) to refuse to answer the question; (b) to hint, but absolutely not say out loud, that you understand what the questioner already knows, namely that the question was a deliberate, standard-issue negotiation tactic designed to place you at a disadvantage; (c) to politely refuse to overtly acknowledge point (b); (d) to draw an end to the conversation; (e) to end on a positive note and provide an opening to change the subject.
- reuven 15y agoWhy should your salary offer depend on what the candidate has previously made? When I hire people for my consulting company, I consider how much I can bill them out for, and then how much I can pay them based on that. Their salary history is irrelevant to me, and their salary expectations are only important insofar as it's less than or equal to what I can pay (and that they're up to the job). Obviously, as an employer, I'd rather pay people less than more. But I'm also in a business that requires skilled, independent, smart people, and those are pretty rare. I'd rather pay someone a lot and bill them out for a lot, than not have access to such people. Asking for salary history strikes me as a sneaky way to ensure that you can pay someone as little as possible, and leads to similarly sneaky and/or dishonest behavior on the part of the candidate, as well.
- rmc 15y agoWhy should your salary offer depend on what the candidate has previously made? Because companies will use this to offer less and take advantage of employees.
- wyclif 15y agoYou win. I would decline to ever work for your company.
- bmelton 15y agoWhat's bullshit to you is absolutely serious to me. I would say that line, or something similar, and mean every syllable of it. That you don't share my ideals of professionalism isn't particularly my problem.
- bphogan 15y agoIt sounds like your company misses one of the most important things about hiring - that both parties are supposed to benefit from the arrangement. You don't get "the upper hand" just because you have the job offer. If you lowball someone, and they find out, they're going to move on, and you get to spend your time hiring a replacement. When I'm hiring, I want to find someone who will stick around a bit. Hiring is hard.
- billswift 15y agoHe didn't write anything about getting "the upper hand" (your bogus quote). He just said not to hand them a line of bullshit.
- bphogan 15y agoI wasn't using quotes for quoting. What I read for the statement was "we're offering the job, we decide the terms." And that's totally valid. But it's not mutually beneficial and I don't think it's a good way to hire people.
- deskamess 15y agoCan I ask why you asked the question about salary? What did you plan to do with the number he/she gave you?
- _delirium 15y agoI thought that dates of employment and salary were the two things that even the most secretive employers are willing to confirm?
- larrik 15y agoConfirm, yes, but not simply reveal. I would imagine the salary piece of that is intended for credit checks, not for the next employer. (If you are thinking "maybe they should only give it to certain people," people lie. Oh boy do they lie about who they are on the phone.) I worked in HR for a while, so I actually am somewhat knowledgeable about this one (for once).
- gaius 15y agoWarning: this is geographically specific advice. Here in the UK, when you start a new job, they are going to want to see your P45 so they can deduct tax correctly. There is zero point in trying to conceal your salary. And if you have, ahem, exaggerated it, that will be spotted too (and counts as lying in your application).
- patio11 15y agoI'm just a cynical colonist, but I can't help thinking that an employer asking for that form prior to giving you a job offer is just borrowing the implied authority of government to convince you to compromise your own negotiating position. There absolutely is a point to concealing your previous salary until after they give you a job offer with defined terms. If they learn your salary history subsequent to that, it won't cause them to suddenly renegotiate your compensation package. So yes, find a different excuse, but find an excuse.
- petercooper 15y agoThat isn't true, although it's how most people go about it. While a new employer will request pages from your P45, it is not mandatory to hand them over. You can send them to the tax office who will notify the new employer of your tax code. The instructions to do this are on the back, I believe (I recently got bored while processing a new employee and read it all! It was news to me too :-)).
- alinajaf 15y agoAlso, this is only mandatory _after_ you've secured a position. I've always concealed past salaries and never had to present my P45 until I've actually started work. I can only second patio11's point here. My salary expectations have doubled over the past few years by just shopping around and keeping my mouth shut about previous salaries.
- vladd 15y agoIf they insist, just say you've signed a confidentiality agreement regarding salary with your previous employer.
- afterburner 15y agoOr just lie. Seems like you'd be less likely to annoy the interviewers and your potential manager. EDIT: OK, it's clearly not a good idea to even remotely suggest lying is a possible option, even as a counter to patio11's frankly far more risky suggestion. And perhaps in the name of building a better society this is the correct approach (and certainly helps prevent anyone potentially sabotaging their networking efforts on HN, which clearly is something I'm not concerned about). I hate dishonesty in general, to be clear. However, my first full time job deliberately boasted about underpaying its employees. Luckily I didn't have to state my previous salary at the next job, just my expectation. But if they had, you know what, I would have probably have inflated it 20%. Why should my first job being underpayed screw me at my next job?
- billybob 15y agoI think that's a bad idea. If you are found out, it will really damage your credibility.
- afterburner 15y agoThis is assuming they can even find out your salary accurately. And they don't know what kind of bonus you might have received. Inflating your salary a bit is just a negotiating tactic. Considering they are sitting across from the table, trying to screw you, is it going to look that bad that you're fighting back? There's plenty of misrepresentation going on at an interview. Of all the things to fudge, previous salary seems the least unethical. I mean after all, the potential employer isn't compelled to match or better it. That said, I hate to lie. But man do I see it happen often.
- dpritchett 15y agoThe easiest way to assert control over this portion of the negotiation process is to refuse to focus on base salary. There's a great passage in "Being Geek" [1] that coaches you on presenting a full spectrum of compensation-related data that declaws would-be salary minimizers. In fact, the hiring company's common insistence on focusing on base salary is a bit of a shell game, much like the classic four-square worksheet seen at a used car lot [2]. Once they can get you to agree to one number, they still have room to pressure you on some of the other parts of the deal. Luckily you can do the exact same thing to them by presenting a range of demands (base, bonus, vacation, perks) without tipping your hand and letting them know which ones mean the most to you personally. It's especially helpful to be able to weigh their benefit details against your current position without having to directly disclose your salary. [1] http://www.beinggeek.com http://www.beinggeek.com [2] http://www.edmunds.com/car-loan/four-square-basics.html http://www.edmunds.com/car-loan/four-square-basics.html
- bphogan 15y agoAndy Lester's book "Land The Tech Job You Love" (http://pragprog.com/titles/algh http://pragprog.com/titles/algh) covers this topic in exactly the same way. I highly recommend this book. It's excellent advice, and it really is important to keep in mind - some companies use this information not to just lowball you, but to ensure they stay "with the market" in their salary ranges. Consider the salary a secret of your employer. You can give a range, but never tell anyone what you make right now.
- davidcuddeback 15y agoThanks for the recommendation. I just bought a copy to see what tips I can pick up.
- Timothee 15y agoYou can give a range, but never tell anyone what you make right now. Instinctively, I have a hard time giving out a range too. Mostly because I would tend to give a range centered around what I'm making, which I feel beats the purpose of not revealing the amount. Shifting the range to be on the higher side feels like lying or something. Let's say I make $100k. Saying "I make between 90-120k" feels wrong to me, because I instinctively think to myself "well, this is technically true, but what's the point of giving a range if it's not accurate?" And even suggesting 90 would feel like a bad idea because I wouldn't want less either… The other part is how wide should the range be? Too narrow or too wide and it's really useless.
- bphogan 15y agoOh I'd say make the range start at a couple thousand more than you really want, and make the top more than that. If you give a number first they're going to try to go down from there so you want to start higher. To get what you think is fair you have to pad the low number. But make sure you are realistic. What are your peers making? What's the going salary, not only in your field, but your area? But if you can, get them to move first. It might get awkward but they are the ones that know how much they can pay. My Dad's old rule was this: "You can afford a house that is two times what you make, gross, in one year. So if you make $80,000, you can afford a $160,000 house. If you want a bigger house, ask for more money." Just be sure you're worth it. There's no shame in being good and getting a fair pay for it. The right company would probably still be getting a bargain :)
- ahi 15y ago"Obviously not enough" is my usual reply with a grin and wink. If they push I'll give them something like "Salary is one of many factors I consider. Once I know more about the position I will be able to provide a number." Moves the discussion from salary history to salary expectations with the underlying message that they need to impress me not vice versa.