4 ms·
Extending a 400k mortgage to a 27 year old should also be rethought. Jesus people, if you’re argument is that “but mortgages have collateral” then at least add
by Spivak 4y ago
Extending a 400k mortgage to a 27 year old should also be rethought.
Jesus people, if you’re argument is that “but mortgages have collateral” then at least address why 20% of someone’s discretionary income over 20 years for federal loans or your lifetime income via non-dischargeability for private loans doesn’t count.
I don’t give two shits about the financial solvency of the lender, if you have to repo the house the system has failed. Throwing a massive amount of money to someone who’s probably on their second big boy job ever betting 15/30 years of income stability to pay it off is insane.
- wodenokoto 4y agoIf you think the house will appreciate and you have the money, I think it’s fine to extent the loan as long as you’re willing to take the risk on the appreciation you don’t really even need to risk assess the 27 year old.
- Retric 4y agoTransaction costs offset significant appreciation in the short term. This makes such loans surprisingly risky even if homes are appreciating.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoRight - this is fundamentally different than the education argument - the house is a tangible asset that can be repossessed. The education is not.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 4y agoSo if, for you, the thing that makes a loan safe is the lender feeling reasonably confident in the value of the collateral then what makes 10% of a persons discretionary income for 20 years feel more risky?
- wodenokoto 4y agoThe ability to collect 10% and the size of their income. But I’m from Scandinavia so I do think 10% of income is a great way to pay for college. Have the government collect it and cut out the bank!
- _fat_santa 4y agoExtending a mortgage isn't that crazy, because you're going off the home value in addition to the repayment ability of the borrower. With student loans there's no collateral so everything rests with the borrowers ability to repay. Student loans are a wild financial product when you stop to think about it, a loan with no collateral, given to someone who often times has no credit, and enforced through it not being dischargeable in bankruptcy.
- phkahler 4y agoMortgages should not be allowed longer than 15 years, maybe 10.
- s1k3 4y agoThis would kill the housing market overnight.
- Spivak 4y agoGenerally speaking I think people are aware that any significant change that drives housing prices down would destroy the market, collapse our economy, and all of western civilization would become as Mad Max. We can still think of what we wish the rules had been in the begging or what to do after unsustainable housing price increases cause Mad Max anyway.
- nephanth 4y agoNot sure this would significantly bring housing prices down, it may simply bring homeownership down (in favor of rental), because only investors would be able to buy.
- anoonmoose 4y agoThe housing market being a core component of the US economy is a bug, not a feature.
- twblalock 4y agoIt is an intentional feature that has been pursued as such by government policy for decades.
- phkahler 4y ago>> This would kill the housing market overnight. So does raising interest rates - see 2008. Look at the fed funds rate spike which set it off (not to say there weren't other problems to make it worse). Also look watch the housing market right now. Housing as a percent of income has been fairly constant for 50 years (there was a recent HN link on this). Lower interest rates mean you can borrow more dollars at the same monthly payment. This combined with an overall decrease in rates since 1980 have fueled the housing market. Long terms loans just mean building equity takes a long time, and people who sell within 5 years really don't have any (it will maybe cover moving costs). The problems with interest rates changing and putting people under water are really a problem of people not having equity in their home. Reducing the length of the loans will reduce that problem significantly.
- LatteLazy 4y agoNot as long as there is a house that can be repossessed on the other end of the loan...
- exabrial 4y agoSecured vs Unsecured credit