6 ms·
When folks talk about hyperinflation, they often think it is just a case of governments printing too much money. And while that's of course part of it, nearly a
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
When folks talk about hyperinflation, they often think it is just a case of governments printing too much money. And while that's of course part of it, nearly all cases (maybe all?) of hyperinflation are marked by supply destruction - the economy is no longer able to produce the goods and services needed by the population, so you have the same amount of money chasing fewer goods, and from there things can spiral. Cases in point:
1. In the Weimar Republic, Germany's productive capacity was devastated by WWI.
2. In Zimbabwe, which was "the bread basket of Africa", farm productivity famously plummeted due to the land redistribution policies of Robert Mugabe.
3. Looking at the current crisis in Sri Lanka, the forced switch to organic farming similarly destroyed farm productivity.
4. Though I wouldn't call it "hyperinflation", the COVID pandemic clearly caused shortages throughout the economy.
My point is that hyperinflation is rarely just caused by governments living beyond their means - the trigger is nearly always a supply shock, and then it's what governments do in the face of that supply shock that gives you hyperinflation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fzzt 4y agoYeah, it's usually a combination of these two factors. You live beyond your means for a decade or five, and then something else goes wrong: natural disaster, war, crop failure, sanctions, whatever. Situations that could be survivable otherwise trigger a downward spiral because you were pushing your luck before.
- tenpies 4y agoThat's the very dangerous game that Biden is playing with the SPR releases to buy Democrats votes, while simultaneously being very hostile to domestic oil and gas. If there is any sort of supply disruption in oil domestically, it's going to be the perfect storm. OPEC+ will be all too happy to have "maintenance issues" that same week and boom, $300 barrels of oil for the US, a functionally empty SPR, and we get to witness that mix of incompetence, desperation, and power that results in catastrophic ideas. For maximum devastation, this happens close to the Presidential elections.
- ericmay 4y agoLots of conspiratorial theories here but the best way to mitigate this very dangerous game is to not rely on oil for your day-to-day needs - so instead of driving to Costco for gas in a giant SUV and living in the suburbs, you change your way of life. This applies at the personal level and also nation state level. Germany shutting down nuclear reactors and relying on Russian fossil fuels is another dangerous game that was placed and lost. Or don’t. And then regardless who is president this happens anyway because there is no economic policy in existence that will give you forever cheap gasoline and oil unless we have some miracle breakthrough technology like fungus growing oil or something. OPEC+ won’t have “maintenance issues” because while they have a stranglehold on oil production, there is a pain point where malfeasance would result in US military action to get oil flowing again.
- prottog 4y ago> instead of driving to Costco for gas in a giant SUV and living in the suburbs, you change your way of life. The most urban dweller who hasn't seen the inside of an automobile in 20 years will find his way of life changed dramatically with crude oil at $300 a barrel. Not to mention the billions of people around the world who would like to maybe have a chance at driving to a Costco one day who will instead suffer and die young. There is some good to come out of cheap energy.
- fspeech 4y agoBut in the end it's a monetary phenomenon and it is the government's choice to have inflation instead of other (painful) measures to address a distribution problem. I would say the truly necessary component to the hyperinflation phenomenon is the existence of privileged borrowers. When inflation is high, market interest rate is also high. To benefit from inflation one must be able to borrow at below inflation rate. With credit money borrowing is what creates new money. Often it's the government that chooses this over taxation for its own funding. Other times there may be other entrenched private interests who enjoy such privileges.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y ago> But in the end it’s a monetary phenomenon Its a psychological phenomenon. Lock people up for 2 years and they will want to go crazy when they get out. Its the same reason why alcohol consumption is up and so is smoking for the first time in some years. Drug consumption is also up. Appetite for debt is also up, anecdotally I have been thinking a lot recently on how being debt free causes me to leave lots of potential consumption, experiences and general quality of life on the table. All those things could be financed with debt. Never had such thoughts in the 2008-2019 decade All sorts of violence is also having an uptick on a chart which is secularly going down. I will go to my grave thinking that Putin would have never invaded Ukraine had he been able to host his monthly “kiss my ring” cerimonies/parties with his cronies. Instead he self isolated for 2+ years and he still mostly is. Social isolation creates all sorts of pent up energy of all kinds
- CamperBob2 4y agoI will go to my grave thinking that Putin would have never invaded Ukraine had he been able to host his monthly “kiss my ring” cerimonies/parties with his cronies. Instead he self isolated for 2+ years and he still mostly is. That does seem to have some acceptance among people who (seem to) know what's going on. During the worst of the pandemic, nobody could meet with Putin without undergoing significant quarantine time first. Some reports say it was a matter of weeks. As a result only the most hardcore of the hardcore yes-men were granted an audience with the Little Czar. Competence, economic and military knowledge, and sound judgement were complete non-factors.
- Gtex555 4y agoLet me correct you on whole Zimbabwe point, the implication is oh the white farmers were so good and Mugabe ruined it by giving the land to the incompetent or uneducated locals and while there is some truth to that its definitely not the whole story. In truth the whites were stealing minerals and precious metals from the country on the cheap and laundering that money as farming proceeds giving the impression of this bread basket cause it was all funded by illicit funds. When they were kicked out they continued to steal these minerals through bribing the top officials but the only difference was there was no-longer an incentive to send the money back into Zimbabwe and hence the farming was no-longer supported by illicit funds and it collapsed. tl:dr its easy to run a successful casino when you are funding it with drug money. Zimbabwe only ever had two options get robbed or get robbed, at least now the locals actually owned the land. The inflation was retaliation for standing up to the bullies!
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoCan you please post some sources? I would like to learn more.
- ur-whale 4y agoFirst I hear of this. Could you provide sources?
- beebeepka 4y agoCritical thinking? Try to look at this from a their point of view and it will make a ton of sense. They were royally fucked but all we heard was the corporate (white farmers) side. Just try to imagine if the sides were reversed What is more likely: 1. stupid Africans just can't get things done 2. they tried to get some control of their production and their white friends abroad didn't like it one bit It was so obvious.
- ur-whale 4y agoAll critical thinking will ever yield is theories. To have value, theories must be met with reality. This is why providing actual sources is useful.
- WalterBright 4y agoSet this theory against the fact that there was zero net inflation in the US from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation since. What changed in 1914? The US switched to a fiat money system. Clearly, it has something to do with fiat money. (The Revolutionary Government also had massive inflation, and the Confederacy, too. What characteristic did they share? Fiat money.) If shortages caused inflation, then one would expect to see corresponding deflation when those shortages eased. But that doesn't happen.
- digdugdirk 4y agoThe most inflationary currency in history, pegged to a gold standard: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_peng%C5%91 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_peng%C5%91 Economies are complicated dynamical systems, I think we can all agree that there are many possible variables in the inflation equation.
- WalterBright 4y agoHere's the critical sentence from your cite: "It was valued at 12,500 korona, and defined as 3,800 to one kilogram of fine gold – which meant that the pengő was pegged to the gold standard, but without exchange obligation." Which means it can be inflated at will. The US did the same thing, pegging the dollar to gold, then inflating the paper money. The result was fiscal collapse leading to the Great Depression. The fix was to make it illegal to exchange dollars for gold, making the "gold standard" a complete fiction.
- neffo 4y agoI think you are conflating a few things. What you have to remember with the gold standard is that the supply (or probably more correct, holdings) of gold determine the money supply when a gold standard is in place, as does the price of gold (the conversion rate). A reduction in the money supply (fear of deflation, leading to bank runs) and a massive withholding of production are generally the two key events cited as causes of the Great Depression. The later being the reason for the massive public works programs of the time were started. The inflation of the US currency happened much later. Roosevelt banned private holdings of monetary gold and gold certificates, incentivized gold imports and gold production which lead to the inflation. That was nearly 5 years into the depression though.
- csomar 4y agoHere is another one: Velocity of money. Say you have an economy (ie: Turkey) where people only use the local currency as a bridge and converts their revenue to EUR/USD as soon as they receive it. The currency will get into an inflationary spiral as the stocks of savings turn into available supply of currency.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, the most common way to get to live beyond your means is to have your means pulled up from you before you have any time to react. That doesn't mean the productivity crisis is directly creating hyperinflation. As an idea it doesn't even make sense, because productivity crisis are bounded, but hyperinflation isn't.
- MrPatan 4y ago"Supply shock" may be just a fancy way of saying "The government wants more stuff but can't pay for it". Which tends to apply everywhere, every time. So we're back to "if they print money, you get inflation". There is another supply to consider, which rarely suffers a shock: The supply of "economists" that want to be close to the government, and are all to happy to tell it what it wants to hear: "Print, print, don't worry, I have a spreadsheet that says that sometimes you print money and there's no inflation, so go for it. Am I getting invited to the next party?"
- strken 4y agoIsn't a better interpretation of that kind of supply shock "The government can no longer pay for the same stuff it used to"? That's a much different scenario to "The government wants more stuff but can't pay for it," because telling the public that you don't have the money to pay for reliable electricity or hip replacements is the kind of thing that causes regime change. People hate losing stuff more than they like gaining stuff.
- michaelt 4y agoIf my country's farms used to produce 2 billion calories per day which kept up with demand, and they drop to only producing 1 billion calories per day and now we have a food shortage - does the nation "want more stuff" because we want to import more food, or do we merely want the same amount of calories as before?
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoSupply shock isn't an acceptable explanation within neoliberal economic dogma. You get hyperinflation when a country's balance of payments tilts so far to imports it falls over. Supply destruction is one common route to this. But - for example in Weimar - the burden of reparations also played a part. (Not officially exports, but a loss of capital nonetheless.) However - through a mysterious neoliberal process the oil shocks of the 70s and 80s, during which the oil price tripled creating massive inflation in economies that relied on oil for almost everything, became a tale of greedy workers forcing up pay and prices. We're seeing this very clearly in the UK where most workers have barely had a significant pay rise for more than a decade, but the chair of the BoE is encouraging "restraint" - while the energy companies price gouge their customers to make astonishing profits and banker bonus caps are being lifted. Combined with the supply and export destruction wreaked by Brexit, the prospect of hyperinflation is a real concern now.
- ogogmad 4y agoSupply shocks can lead to inflation, but hyperinflation seems to always result from bad monetary policy (specifically, money printing). To prove this point, all hyperinflation episodes have taken place on fiat currency. Usually, the bad monetary policies are a response to general chaos in the economy, but the policies themselves seem to create the hyperinflation. I'm not an expert, but this is my conclusion from reading the article.
- eggestad 4y agoNot just a supply shock. Supply shock of food and/or fuel(energy). These are the absolutely need to have that you can't stop buy no matter what. Demand can't go down. Prices of food and fuel going up, you stop buying nice-to-have to keep up with food and fuel prices. You can actually find food/fuel scarcity in every case of hyperinflation where we have some kind of statistics (which in less than 2 centuries). Scarcity of nice-to-have goods and services will not trigger hyper inflation.
- silent_cal 4y agoMainstream financial media rarely blames inflation on money printing, in my experience. Even though it's the primary cause.
- panarky 4y agoSupply destruction causing inflation seems like another monetary phenomenon. If inflation is caused by printing more money at a faster rate than the economy grows, then when the economic growth rate is negative then money would need to be destroyed to avoid inflation. It's not the supply destruction that caused the inflation, it's rate of monetary expansion being greater than the rate of economic growth. (With velocity held constant of course, MV=PQ).