3 ms·
The problem is that there is no money printing beyond the physical printing of bank notes. Money in your bank account isn't created through printing. It is cre
by imtringued 4y ago
The problem is that there is no money printing beyond the physical printing of bank notes.
Money in your bank account isn't created through printing. It is created through accounting and the entire point of this accounting is to make sure that every liability (deposit) in your bank account is backed by an asset (the debt contract).
The entire point of this is to keep a mathematical identity. The net worth of the bank does not change when it issues deposits, deposits/savings and debt add up to zero. The only thing that changes is that the bank becomes more leveraged and less solvent which is why there are capital requirements which mandate a minimum quality of the assets that are being used to create deposits and there used to be a minimum reserve ratio to put an upper bound on the amount of leverage a bank can take on.
If you want to complain about the money supply growing or deficit spending or debt growing out of control you are free to do that but if you talk about money printing you are basically ignoring all of that and just think that there is this obvious element that everyone is overlooking. If the government bans cash it stops printing money but does it get rid of debt? Does it get rid of inflation? Not really.
When people save money, the currency goes up in value, to prevent deflation, the central bank loosens reserve requirements, lowers short term interest rates or if it can't do anymore it will do open market operations aka quantitative easing which is more or less just trying to replicate what a lower interest rate would have done.
Since there is a net increase of savings in real terms, either the interest rate must go down, perhaps even go negative to discourage people from saving too much, or more debt must be created to soak up those savings. This means if the private sector keeps accumulating more and more savings, the public sector must go more and more in debt if it wants to maintain a positive interest rate. If you don't like that, then you must somehow stop people from accumulating too much money and get them to spend it. Saved money isn't being lent on, not even in the case of a certificate of deposit, where it would kind of make some sense, it is just sitting there and waiting to be spent. Any time the bank "lends your money" it actually doesn't and instead creates new money in proportion to the debt.
- mr_toad 4y ago“Increasing the money supply through open market operations” is a bit of a mouthful. I don’t think most people mean that that government is literally printing bills when they say “printing money”.