2 ms·
>Ancient knowledge of usefully precise values of geometric constants, even where not perfect, should not provoke skepticism: they could measure. Building these
by imtringued 4y ago
>Ancient knowledge of usefully precise values of geometric constants, even where not perfect, should not provoke skepticism: they could measure. Building these values into sacred structures need not have been meant to communicate anything but their own piety. Every dimension must be in some ratio to others, and may often be freely chosen. Why would they not choose sacred numbers for sacred constructions?
When I think about Neom the Line I imagine that even in ancient Egypt architects tried to hype up their designs in some way. A pyramid does not leave much leeway to changes in the design. All you can change is absolute dimensions and angles/ratios. Imagine a VC pitch where entrepreneurs are trying to outdo each other on having the best ratio. Architects that have the same idea will compete based on quality, the better approximation will win.
- ncmncm 4y agoMaybe, but things seem much more hierarchically organized as you go farther back, with a progression of autocratic control over a growing area until a collapse or invasion. So, we know about Imhotep, official Architect to (IIRC) two or more successive pharaohs. Presumably, whatever he says goes, subject to the pharaoh's and then the priesthood's non-negotiables. Also presumably, he has underlings who make less consequential decisions. After he dies or falls from grace, his choices might be revisited. Then we have insular groups and guilds, such as the priesthood, the masons they depended upon, post-flood re-surveyors, canal and irrigation specialists, metalworkers, carpenters, navigators, potters, and scribes, each with its own governance conventions.