10 ms·
Columbia whistleblower on exposing college rankings
- GavinMcG 4y agoBut they do start to create a feedback loop. Even if the underlying data is completely made up, as long as the “best” students are going to an institution, there’s at least some value to future students to be associated with them.
- prottog 4y agoAs they say, hedge funds with a degree-granting school attached.
- CobaltFire 4y agoSo maybe HN can help someone with a question related to this: I’m retiring from the military in the spring with a state college STEM BS (3.79 GPA; done on active duty) and a whole lot of experience. I was looking at ranking as a possible way to help decide where and if I would do a graduate degree; I want to further my education but am geographically limited. What other signals can I use that are relevant to the tech world? I’m still undecided on a STEM Masters vice something more like Liberal Arts or MBA and don’t completely understand the signaling there in tech either, aside from the MBA pushing to management. I’m open to any advice either here or via my contact info in my profile. Really at a loss on how to proceed and hope someone around here might have good advice!
- debacle 4y agoGraduate degrees are a different animal, but one thing you could do is look into who you might be under at the school, and what kind of work they're doing.
- bee_rider 4y agoAre you looking to do a thesis? If so, I'd suggest that it is more important to find a professor who is well regarded and working on a problem that you care about.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThat’s something I’ve been thinking about. Doing a degree on Active Duty means a lot of late nights and weekends and no real time to explore anything not directly related to the degree. Further, my son has cancer and autism and with the relative stability of my pension I have thought that I’d like to make the world a better place in some way that my experience can be leveraged. Unfortunately that combination leaves me with little hope of being admitted to a more classical MA or PhD because I just didn’t do the coursework that is needed to apply and distinguish myself. Perhaps a terminal MA at a state school? I’m in CA and can move to any school in the state; I can’t really leave the state for a few reasons to do with my sons care.
- bee_rider 4y agoFWIW, I did a MS with a thesis, I really liked it. Currently I'm working on a PhD, and honestly -- I dunno, with the MS I was working on more of a little refinement to something that my professor had done, it was pretty cool. With the PhD, there's almost too much freedom and the expectations are much higher, haha. The MS felt more much more practical. Some of that could be related to the specifics of the projects, but... I dunno, there's something to be said for restricting scope.
- CobaltFire 4y agoAs a project/program manager I feel that last sentence in my bones.
- adamsmith143 4y agoWell it's not like there is shortage of great schools in California. Basically anything in the UC system is great, there obviously Stanford and USC as well. But certainly Berkeley, UCLA, UCSD, UCSB are all world class and UCI, UCSC, UCR and UCD are nothing to sneeze at either. Cal State also has some great programs particularly in Engineering at Poly San Luis Obispo As far as the degree itself it really depends on what you want to do. Work in a business? MBA will be fine, work as an Engineer? Get an MS. Be a Lecturer at a CC? Any Master's will probably work.
- Calavar 4y agoRankings aren't a bad place to start, they just shouldn't be where you finish too. Keep in mind that there really isn't too much difference between the #2 versus the #10 school or the #30 vs the #50. If two schools are in the same general neighborhood in ranking, that's when you should start putting more weight on the intangibles and how the school meets your needs specifically as opposed to just generally having a good reputation.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThanks for this. I know there is a lot of compression in rankings, so it's kind of like IQ ratings: you can't tell the difference in normal day-to-day stuff until they get fairly large. It's also like them in that it's a less than rigorous ranking it seems!
- etempleton 4y agoLook at where you might want to end up and see if they have any connections to specific schools / programs in schools. Beyond the education and the prestige attached to a school / program, the big benefit of graduate school is making connections. This is not nearly as present in online programs, but it can still be there.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThis is another aspect of a school's program I hadn't considered, thanks!
- clusterhacks 4y agoI applied to and got into a bunch of good universities to study for my MS in computer science. My biggest mistake, BY FAR, was not visiting all those schools, talking with prospective advisors and current students, and using my gut instincts on those conversations to guide my decision. I picked the school that I felt was the best but wound up poorly matched with an advisor. I had been a very proactive and driven undergrad (returned to undergrad in my late 20s) but reverted to a passive approach in grad school - it was a terrible mistake. By the end of my first year, I was completely demotivated and very unhappy. I turned it around my second year by dropping my advisor and taking some control in the process back. But I also totally punted on a PhD and settled for a MS. But it left me very unsatisfied in the process and in a position of asking "what if" in many ways. One big part of why I was dissatisfied is that in hindsight, many of the professors I interacted with were simply not very friendly or considerate of students. Maybe they were used to being able to be more dismissive of undergrads coming straight to grad school, but as an adult I expected adult interactions. That experience was partly my fault - there are always people who are prickly to deal with. I should have been a little more self-directed about making sure I was working with better people even if it meant maybe doing thesis or research work in an area that was slightly less interesting to me personally.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThanks for this. It’s a stretch to hope any real grad degree will accept me, but I’m thinking all they can do is tell me no. The advice about advisors I keep hearing repeated, so I will have to listen (if I can get in anywhere).
- clusterhacks 4y agoYour chances of admission are probably significantly better than you think. I did my BS in computer science at a mid-lower-tier state school - it wasn't like I was all-world Stanford/MIT/CMU or anything. I did a bunch of GRE practice tests and have always been a very strong standardized test-taker so I had that going for me. I also had cultivated strong references at my undergrad institution. My references were professors I had multiple classes under and that I had actually spent time with during office hours. You may have those sources available to you but I would guess that a decent fallback might be former commanding officers? The school where I got my MS also had stories about active duty Air Force students coming in full-time for a PhD, mowing through the check-lists of to-do work, and finishing their PhD in the three years the AF gave them to do it. Your military background may be a strong point in your favor. Also, I vaguely remember that military retirees often had some tuition assistance programs. Grad schools LOVE students with external funding sources. Look into this. Lastly, it sounds like you have a good story to tell. Tell that story in your application letter!
- josh_fyi 4y agoIn the US, if you can get accepted to a PhD, you get full scholarship, especially in STEM, but also in other fields. You can drop out in a year or two and get your masters. (I got my master's this way at Harvard, though I also finished the PhD. Nothing was required but the first year of course work and a language test. Far less expensive and possibly less work than going directly to masters. But if you do want to pay for a professional masters', then unlike undergrad, the specific program may be more important than the reputation of the university as a whole.
- smogcutter 4y agoAs others have said, grad school is a very different animal from undergrad. People choose undergraduate schools for all kinds of reasons, but a graduate degree should be 100% focused on what’s best for your career. I think you’re looking at things from the wrong direction, and flipping it around will help a great deal. It seems like you’re going from the idea that you want to further your education, to thinking about potential degrees, and only then what you might do with them. This is how you wind up in a masters program that turns out to go nowhere or be a bad fit. Instead, turn it around! Set a goal for yourself and plan backwards from there. What degree do you need? Do you need one at all? What kind of advisors and faculty should you be looking for? All questions that you can only answer sensibly with a goal in mind.
- CobaltFire 4y agoIn my case my career is done and it’s time to find a new one. I have a decent amount of fixed income, and have been considering using my second career for something more fulfilling I suppose, hence the possibility of a degree that makes no financial sense but might make me happy or allow me to contribute to society in some way.
- tristor 4y agoMy advice is that you get a civilian job /before/ you start your MS. There's a few reasons why: 1. Your employer may sponsor you and pay for some/all of the cost, or otherwise support you financially while attending. 2. #1 may be contingent on which school you attend. 3. Your coworkers who are mentors to you (at whatever level that may be) likely have connections and can steer you towards the right school to further your career. Ultimately, to a large degree, your career should decide if, when, and where you attend graduate studies if you aren't going to go into academia. A lot of people do Georgia Tech in the FAANG world and it's pretty great, but some companies have an internal (and often unspoken) preference for particular schools if you're trying to rise in the ranks.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThis is a path I’m pursuing as kind of a default, with graduate applications to a full time program being what I’m asking about here in particular. Georgia Tech or CMU are two I’ve been recommended if I go this route, so it’s nice to hear that wasn’t necessarily bad guidance!
- influx 4y agoWhat is your ultimate goal? To be employed in tech? If so, what type of positions? What is your MOS (or equivalent)?
- CobaltFire 4y agoLike many people leaving the military I'm not 100% sure what I want to do, simple because I haven't been exposed to the breadth of what I have the options to do. I'm institutionalized, for lack of a better word. Tech is what I'm most familiar with, so that's what I default to. The more I think about it the less I care about making all the money and the more I want to do something that fulfills me and lets me make society a better place. I am an Aviation Electronics Technician, previously a Nuclear Reactor Operator. Also have experience with Lean Six-Sigma (Black Belt), physical and IT security, was an instructor, and lots of QA experience. It's been an interesting ride, and I took every opportunity afforded me.
- influx 4y agoMy advice is to look at the programs that Amazon offers to veterans: https://hiring.amazon.com/our-team/military#/ https://hiring.amazon.com/our-team/military#/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- debacle 4y agoThey're not worthless, but they're certainly not objective. My son missed an Ivy because of an admissions deadline SNAFU. It was his top choice in schools, and he was pretty upset about it. Two family members employed at the school told us it was the best thing that could have happened to him. They didn't allow their children to apply there, because they see what is happening at the school. This mirrors the trajectory of a local university, once a pretty prestigious school (circa 1980s/90s), now near last in enrollment and falling fast. If you were older and didn't have school age children (or weren't school age yourself), you would never know. Schools' prestige has a lot of momentum behind it, and it could take 20 years before a once prominent school tanking becomes common knowledge.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIf you're studying a technical field, an Ivy is probably not a great decision, but if you're going for a liberal art or if you are looking for a prestige signal, they are unparalleled.
- kevinventullo 4y agoHighly depends on the field. Among the top mathematicians who attended undergrad in the US, a large proportion went to Harvard.
- valarauko 4y ago> If you're studying a technical field, an Ivy is probably not a great decision Sadly that's not really the case in the biological sciences, especially when you're looking for a tenure track job. If you look at people who enter tenure track jobs at even state schools, they invariably have pedigrees from Ivy schools, including postdocs.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe main value add of undergrad is networking and prestige, not education. That's why Ivys are still an unparalleled value proposition, even if their education is similar to the rest of the top 50 schools.
- bredren 4y ago> “It means that our educational programmes have to be run to some degree as money-making ventures. That is the secret that can’t be openly acknowledged,” he said. Was this really a secret? Also, this truth can’t be told without also discussing student loans, which schools have departments designed to help students enroll in.
- seti0Cha 4y agoThey aren't worthless, they're a measure of prestige, which is what students are largely paying those huge fees for.
- DalekBaldwin 4y agoPrestige is informal and unmeasurable. Columbia's prestige will remain high even if the quality of its education declines. But people expect the top-ranked schools to be roughly the same as the top-prestige schools, which is one of the reasons for these kinds of shenanigans. The rankings are probably more meaningful at the bottom of the list than the top.
- gersh 4y agoCan Columbia students sue the school for being defrauded on what they were buying?
- woodruffw 4y agoI think this would be difficult, since it would require students to claim (or admit) to buying prestige rather than paying for an education. In other words: Columbia can (and probably still does) provide an excellent education, even if their ratings are rightfully lower.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- macspoofing 4y agoI think 'worthless' is too strong a statement. The rankings are a subjective score, but it does correlate to some measure of merit. A school ranked in the top-20, will probably be a 'better' school than one ranked in the bottom-20 spots. For undergrad, the reality is that you can get a good(enough) education from almost any accredited university in the country. For degrees fields like CS, or Engineering, it almost doesn't matter. You will get a quality education from most institutions.
- pastor_bob 4y agoI think Columbia is a bit of an anomaly. As someone who knew a lot of people who went to grad school and considered it myself, Columbia grad programs were known as a notorious money-pit/cash grabs unlike any other school in its range. I was always confused how they got away with it. The only other school in NYC that competed with it in this regard was the New School, which is ranked all the way at 127.
- barry-cotter 4y agoCome now, taught Master’s are always cash cows. They exist to allow the university to cash in on the prestige of its undergraduate or professional programmes. Just as true at Oxford or the LSE as at Columbia or Chicago.
- sparc24 4y agoPrecisely. There is big difference between undergrad and masters at Columbia. For CS MS was a cashcow - extract money from international students. It's actually a great deal for both parties.
- clusterhacks 4y agoFTA "... all university rankings are essentially worthless. They’re based on data that have very little to do with the academic merit of an institution . . . " While I strongly believe that a motivated university student can maximize their ROI at any institution, it would also be nice if there was an easier way for prospective students to identify schools that would offer the best opportunity for students. But campus visits don't tell you much about actual classroom teaching experiences from the learner perspective. Any ideas out there? When I talk to high-achieving parents of kids picking schools, the parents seem to say that choosing a school was mostly a matter of coming up with some arbitrary evaluation function (eg, "wanted a small school with a few hours of home", "interested in a big flagship state university", "wanted an Ivy", etc).
- Bakary 4y agoThe high-achieving parents aren't wrong to do this because the value a student gets from a school is largely self-directed and based on the people they meet there. It makes more sense to evaluate based on the student than the school. Is your kid vulnerable to social anxiety and mental pressure? They would be better off being a bigger fish in a smaller state pond than developing suicidal ideation at a big name institution. You can come up with solid criteria based on knowledge of the world and intuition. None of the criteria you cite are truly that arbitrary if you inspect them a bit more closely.
- collegecomments 4y ago> the value a student gets from a school is largely self-directed and based on the people they meet there. For this reason, rankings (unfortunately) have more value that OP suggests. The "best" students will cluster around the "best" institutions. Does the average student differ muchst between #1 and #5? Probably not much. But the difference between 10 and 100 does, by a lot, and the difference between "unranked LAC" and "top 50 CS" is difficult to overstate. If you're measuring is "how good is my peer group", rankings are often a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy. Not so much at fine granularity, but more so if you measure in terms of "20-50 position overlap equivalence classes". This is particularly true in fields like CS, where there are huge differences in curriculum between the top schools and the not-so-top schools.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoPreviously in US News and World Report malfeasance: "Students Find Glaring Discrepancy in US News Rankings". Specifically about how they rate Reed College, my alma mater and a school that has famously opted out of participating in the ranking system for years. It looks like the report artificially punished Reed for that giving them a lower rating than their statistical model would have. It's very similar to what Columbia is reporting. https://www.reed.edu/reed-magazine/articles/2019/usnews-discrepancy.html https://www.reed.edu/reed-magazine/articles/2019/usnews-disc...
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoCouldn't help but draw parallels to startups with "fake it till you make it" mentality. If you're Columbia, you might start off gaming a few metrics, hoping that as you rise in the rankings you attract better students, better instructors, more funding, thereby fulfilling the prophecy. Many startups do the same (pretend to have success with the hope that that will attract talent, funding, customers which then does lead to success). Of course there's never an excuse for misleading people via outright fraud.
- toss1 4y ago>>Of course there's never an excuse for misleading people via outright fraud. Pretty fine and yet hazy line you're drawing there... If you are having to fudge numbers, you are doing it wrong. You are playing with the symptoms and ignoring the causes of success. Get the fundamentals right - the a product, a product-market-fit, and then build. If you have to fake it, you are very unlikely to actually make it, at least honestly. (and yes, you can point to fakers who have even had a successful IPO, but I still don't consider the likes of Uber to have made it - $$billions of investment and still searching for a profitable model - a massive waste of capital and talent, and we still don't have our flying cars)
- sjkoelle 4y ago1) prof thaddeus is the man 2) here is a good paper on something similar https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1400005 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1400005
- immigrantheart 4y agoAnecdata, I’ve some students from Columbia in my circles. While they aren’t the brightest of the bunch they certainly are some of the wealthy ones. One student actually admitted that she chose Columbia just for the prestige, even when she has to pay $200k. Maybe that’s the goal? Then the system is working as intended.
- game_the0ry 4y agoNowadays college is less about high quality education and more social signaling of prestige among peers. From that perspective, your student who is paying $200k is making a rational decision in her mind. When she graduates, she may get a prestigious high paying job (investment banking or management consulting) and that will validate her decision. If instead she gets an "ok" job and most of her peers are form lower-ranked colleges, she will feel like she is top of the social / prestige hierarchy, thus validating her decision, bc social prestige has its own unquantifiable value.
- strikelaserclaw 4y agoReally depends on the field. If you are a law firm, then they want as many ivy league graduates as possible because that is attractive to prospective clients (regardless of the individual merits of people working at said law firm) but if you are google, it makes no economic sense to pick person A from Harvard when person B from community college is much better. I look at my own company (in a "hard" field like google), we got our fair share of top college grad's at all levels but there isn't a large correlation between position and where someone went to school. Our interview process for engineering is 100% technical and people who pass can join regardless of things like education background. As for social heiarchy, people at my company demonstrate their worth by delivering things (that is how the status at my company is determined, what did you do?), you'd get laughed out of the room if you wanted respect because you went to some prestigious school.
- game_the0ry 4y agoAgreed - certain prestige-driven fields highly desire high-ranked academic pedigree, but not all fields. I'm just saying people are willing to borrow the amount equal to like half the median home price for that prestige.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fullshark 4y agoIf the primary (not sole) purpose of college is to land a premium entry level job that sets you on a significant wealth acquisition trajectory as a laborer then they are not worthless at all and may be the primary thing you care about. Everyone knows this in these institutions but the kayfabe is that this is not the primary purpose of college, despite it so clearly being the case for the vast majority of students.
- snowwrestler 4y ago> If the primary (not sole) purpose of college is to land a premium entry level job that sets you on a significant wealth acquisition trajectory College will look like a huge waste of time and money measured against such a short-term goal. The primary purpose of college is to get an education, which confers life-long benefits (financial and otherwise).
- wyre 4y agoIn what way is it a waste? When I graduated HS 15 years ago the statistic was the average college grad made a million dollars more than the average HS grad over their lifetime.
- dgfitz 4y agoThe primary purpose of a college education is to network. Have you ever seen Good Will Hunting?
- fullshark 4y agoThat's a purpose but not primary, if that were the case the hyper competitive college admissions process would cease to exist, as there's plenty of reasonable substitutes in terms of education provided, in some ways these less prestigous places even offer better educations than the places with the top published professors. It's primarily about acquiring economic opportunity, full stop.
- snowwrestler 4y agoThe vast, vast majority of college students do not attend hyper-competitive institutions, but receive lifelong benefits nevertheless.
- ParksNet 4y agoDefund Universities: pull Government-backed student loans. Let people pay out of their own pocket if they find it valuable.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIf you cannot define something, you cannot measure it. Since there is no one universal definition of a good university, how can there be a measure? So anyone offering a measurement (Columbia is 9.4, Harvard is 9.25 etc) is by definition lying. The core issue here is that people really want a simple universal scale. The fact that doesn't exist doesn't stop them wanting it. And instead of accepting that it makes them MORE ready to grab whatever rating sounds good based on some repetitional BS around the person offering it.
- 2b3a51 4y agoThe UK is big on league tables. Hospitals, schools, universities, police, ambulance and fire services and so on. The paper below explores some of the statistical questions that ranking organisations on outcome measures of some kind raises. https://www.bristol.ac.uk/media-library/sites/cmm/migrated/documents/statistical-issues-for-league-tables1.pdf https://www.bristol.ac.uk/media-library/sites/cmm/migrated/d... I'm working my way through Dr Thaddeus's paper now to see if it fits with or dis-confirms the framework of Goldstein and Spiegelhalter.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI would argue that the exact rankings are worthless, but the general tiers or positioning, is not. In other words, whether #1 is Stanford or Harvard, or whether Columbia is #5 or #9 makes zero diff and shouldn't factor into anyone's decision. But whether your school is ranked 20 or 150 does make a big difference in terms of job perception once you leave school. It may be unfair, but if you apply for a job post-college with a CSE degree from CMU the hiring manager is going to look at it much differently than the applicant from LSU. But college probably won't matter between applicants from CMU and MIT, for example, regardless of those college's respective exact rankings.
- jeremysalwen 4y agoProfessor Thaddeus was the best math professor I had at Columbia, glad to see him popping off like this :)
- jimt1234 4y agoThe most shocking thing to me here is that "US News & World Report" still exists. Do they offer anything other than the phony college rankings? I'm being serious. I was interested in "US News & World Report" back in the early-90s when I was shopping law schools, and haven't thought about them since. Not once.
- bigbacaloa 4y agoGet an engineering or science degree - wherever - it beats prestige in terms of earning power.
- g9yuayon 4y agoMany parents seem have forgotten that kids are supposed to get top education instead of getting into "top" schools. As a results, we see kids take 15+ APs in high school, even though they leetcode into a FAANG after graduation (yes, I'm talking about your kids, parents in the bay area). Or worse, the kids burn out in high school. We see kids build novel clubs to "be a world leader" in high school and only abandon the idea once getting admitted. We see parents focus so much on rankings without thinking twice what exact a highly ranked university would offer to their kids. On the other hand, we see universities game the ranking systems. We see universities inflate their GPA scores. We see universities try every shady way to lower their admission rate. I'm still hopeful, though. Eventually good education wins. Life is a marathon, not a 100m dash. Getting into college or not is merely the beginning of one's adult life. In larger scheme of things, which college one goes to or how many APs one takes hardly matters.
- Dowwie 4y ago> We now have about 4,500 administrators on the main campus, about three times the number of faculty, and that’s a new development over the past 20 years
- mazelife 4y ago> [he] described an expanding and self-replicating bureaucracy that is growing ever more expensive to maintain This seems to me a key piece of the problem. Rises in tuition have massively out-paced inflation while salaries for tenured professors have not seen anything even close to that kind of growth in the same time period. In fact most institutions actually employ fewer full-time faculty than they did 20 or 30 years ago. The answer to the question "where is all this money going?" doesn't have a mono-causal explanation, but an ever-expanding self-perpetuating bureaucracy is a significant factor. And it's not just academia; I've heard similar concerns from physician-acquaintances about healthcare. The astonishing growth of middle and executive managers at Johns Hopkins has been an ongoing topic of discussion with department-chair friend of mine for years. I think we've barely begun to reckon with the costs the MBA-ification of major institutions has had on the overall welfare of the US public.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIf only US News would rank by Admin/faculty ratio. They could single-handedly fix this nonsense.
- jstrieb 4y agoWhen I was picking colleges a few years ago, I made my own rankings. At the time, I knew more about what I didn't want than what I did want, and none of the tools I found supported searching that way. The US department of education collects extremely comprehensive data on colleges every year, and makes the data public. I loaded these CSVs into SQLite and made a bunch of queries to filter schools out, then dumped the rest to a spreadsheet. In the spreadsheet I weighted each column and sorted the rows. The weights were tunable so I could emphasize different factors in the sorting. The process was successful in that it turned up some surprising results I wouldn't have otherwise considered! I've wanted to write a post on my website about this process for a while, but haven't gotten around to it. In the meantime, for anyone looking to do something similar, the data is here: https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data
- geoelectric 4y agoI'm certainly very curious about your surprising results. I hope you write the post (and I somehow find it again when you do!)
- nyokodo 4y ago> it turned up some surprising results > I've wanted to write a post ...but haven't gotten around to it Now you have to write that post ASAP because you can't leave us hanging like this.
- amilios 4y agoFor anyone looking for schools for CS, https://csrankings.org/ https://csrankings.org/ is an excellent site that gives you an overview of departments' research output, filterable by subfield, geographic location etc. A very nice system if you're intending to get involved in research in your undergrad, but especially good if you plan on continuing to a Master's or PhD in CS.
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoLike many "metrics", college rankings appeal to people because all you have to consider is a single number. One result is that it eliminates the anxiety associated with having to make a choice. You have a single axis and you just aim for the top without having to go through some process of research and prudential evaluation or worrying that you will regret your decision later (you might end up hating your school, but you can rationalize your bad experience by appealing to your school's rank to soothe the pain). Rankings also appeal to people who are excessively concerned with prestige, and these rankings, interestingly enough, generate and reinforce that prestige. The more people believe the ranking, the more it reinforces the perceived prestige. Above all, rankings appeal to human pride because they give us a tool by which to say "I am better than you" in an unambiguous manner, regardless of whether it is true. When people apply to graduate school, the situation is a bit different. You typically apply based on the people in the department you're interested in or the faculty member you want as an advisor. People aren't so concerned about rankings here as they are when applying to undergraduate programs. I am not denying quality is variable across schools. It is. Student bodies can also vary, and rankings can concentrate people of a certain mindset (for better or for worse) in one place. But rankings are not as meaningful as the numbers would seem to indicate. At the very least, the precision is far too high and too reductive (what's the difference between a school of rank 4 and 5? of 4 and 10?). The methodologies used also don't necessarily indicate what you think they do. There's a game these schools play, as this article touches on, to increase and maintain rank. My general feeling is that college education, and education in general, isn't that great, generally speaking, and the costs are preposterously high. There's too much of Dewey's influence. Classically, universities were not meant to be job training centers and glorified trade schools (we can debate how good they even are as job training centers). The reigning paradigm is being challenged, however, especially with rising tuition and conspicuous ideological presence on campus.
- musicale 4y ago> “It’s clear that the growth of university bureaucracies and administration has been a major driver of the cost of higher education growing much, much faster than inflation. We now have about 4,500 administrators on the main campus, about three times the number of faculty, and that’s a new development over the past 20 years,” he said. This has been going on for decades at many universities. As he notes, administrative organizations are primarily expanding for their own sake, at the expense of students.
- throwaway1851 4y agoThe central problem with yearly university rankings is that they have no raison d’être. US News is financially motivated to keep all of the stakeholders glued to its “50 most beautiful people of the year” list, but institutional quality and reputation don’t actually fluctuate that much.