4 ms·
> People didn't run away from violence. They ran away from any neighborhood where Black people were allowed to buy houses. Once again, your logic is somewhat t
by lelanthran 4y ago
> People didn't run away from violence. They ran away from any neighborhood where Black people were allowed to buy houses.
Once again, your logic is somewhat twisted: are you really blaming people that left an area for the violence in that area?
You're effectively saying "White people shouldn't have left because the all-black area becomes crime-ridden", which is obviously nonsense.
When people leave an area, regardless of the reason, you cannot blame the leavers for the area getting more violent.
They're literally not there any more to influence things!
- tptacek 4y agoAm I not saying this clearly enough? I'm talking about the 1930s-1950s. If a Black family moved onto your all-white block, everyone would move. It had nothing to do with violence. I can and do blame explicitly racist actions for the economic havoc and concomitant violence they created.
- karlshea 4y agoI'm sort of dumbfounded that your comments are even controversial... this exact same thing played out in dozens of cities in the 30s-50s. In the upper midwest Minneapolis, St Paul, and Milwaukee all had/have exactly the same issues for the same reasons. U of M has a whole website mapping racial covenants[0] here in the Twin Cities, and the Wikipedia article about redlining[1] is pretty thorough, discussing exactly what you're bringing up. Do people just not actually believe how racist everything used to be? And how decades of disinvestment leading to violence just might possibly lead to generational issues? [0] https://mappingprejudice.umn.edu https://mappingprejudice.umn.edu [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
- questionputter 4y agoGiven that the areas they moved out of now have problems with crime, maybe it was a rational decision to move out?
- Sprocklem 4y agoThe movement of white people out of neighbourhoods with black people, and the use of redlining to concentrate a marginalized group within those neighbourhoods led to a disinvestment of both private and public capital in those neighbourhoods, creating and later perpetuating the cycle of poverty that leads people to turn to crime to survive. It does make sense for people with the means to leave a neighbourhood (from a personal safety standpoint) when it starts to have an increased crime problem but that is not what is being described here. Instead, the people left due to the racism that was prevalent in the mid-20th century, well before the rise in crime that resulted from their leaving.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago85% of the people in the redlined neighborhoods were white. That was around of half of all urban households. Why didn't redlining lead to the same cycle of poverty and violence for white people?
- tptacek 4y agoBecause they moved to neighborhoods where they were allowed to get fucking home loans and open businesses.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoThe majority of people who currently live in the redlined neighborhoods are white. Why didn't redlining lead to the same cycle of poverty and violence for those white people?
- tptacek 4y agoWhat the hell are you talking about? The neighborhoods we're talking about are overwhelmingly Black. You can't have set foot on the south or west sides of Chicago and not know that.
- 6figurelenins 4y ago> Do people just not actually believe ... how decades of disinvestment leading to violence just might possibly lead to generational issues? It's a bit fuzzy, yes. It would clarify the argument to replace "generational issues" with a specific concept, and skip the performative hedge. The bailey seems to be "poverty implies violence." What's the motte?
- tptacek 4y agoI'm not making a general "poverty equals violence" argument. I'm saying that you can look at a redlining map and a Chicago crime map and see the pattern plain as day.
- karlshea 4y agoYou can skim the Wikipedia article I linked if you're actually interested in the (heavily researched) consequences of redlining, many of which happened up into the 2000s and all of which urbanists are still trying to mitigate today. My reaction is literally one of confusion, not "performative hedging". The charitable read of most of the comments here is a profound lack of historical knowledge ("these areas were classified as hazardous, and the violence there is why white people left"), and an uncharitable one is thinly veiled racism ("minorities by definition are violent").
- lelanthran 4y ago> Am I not saying this clearly enough? I'm talking about the 1930s-1950s. If a Black family moved onto your all-white block, everyone would move. That still does not make the people who chose to leave responsible for violence that developed only after they have left! Are you happy being held responsible for the development (or lack thereof) of the place you last lived in?
- refurb 4y agoThe "white flight" mostly happened with the riots in the 60's. At least in the mid-West. I think it's fair to say that race caused the riots, but to say that racism caused people to move is just silly. I don't care if black or white people are setting fire in my neighborhood, if I can move somewhere safer, I will.
- kasey_junk 4y agoThat’s not the timeline in Chicago. Racial covenants were deemed unconstitutional in the early 40s. White flight occurred in the 50s. By the time of the riots the neighborhoods that suffered from riots (and landlords burning their property for insurance fraud) were already majority black.
- tptacek 4y agoLate 40s. :)
- wglb 4y agoNot true. Flight happened substantially before the 60s.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI think the problem is that when white people leave a neighborhood, they bring with them their political influence to allocate city funds to that neighborhood. Funds for things like... adequate policing. Huh.
- lelanthran 4y ago> I think the problem is that when white people leave a neighborhood, they bring with them their political influence to allocate city funds to that neighborhood. Funds for things like... adequate policing. Huh. I don't think that makes sense in context of GPs argument, as GP also argues that "more policing" did not help alleviate the violence problem. The assertions "police were defunded, therefor the area got more violent" and "policing was escalated, and still the area got more violent" cannot both be true at the same time.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoRefusing to fund more policing in response to rising crime is effectively the same as pulling out funding. Either way it's "not his problem", he's quite adamant that crime in Chicago doesn't effect his own family, and he opposes more funding to police in neighborhoods his family wouldn't be so safe in.