7 ms·
The sooner we accept RCS is dead, the sooner we can choose the next platform
- LarsAlereon 4y agoI don't want a different platform that functions similarly to SMS/MMS that I have to convince people to use, I want a replacement platform that transparently functions the same way but better. That solution is RCS, even with its flaws and lack of support from Apple.
- threeseed 4y agoWhich RCS would that be: standard RCS or Google's enhanced RCS.
- calvinmorrison 4y agosounds like email, yet we manage along fine
- s3p 4y ago...Google's enhanced email protocol?
- phinnaeus 4y agoOh man Wave was great for the 5 minutes it lasted. It's Apache now right?
- tikhonj 4y agoGoogle certainly has a bunch of extensions in IMAP. I'm not sure about the messages themselves, but I wouldn't be surprised if Google has extra metadata and supports features that only work within the world of GMail and gracefully degrade in other clients—but, unlike IMAP, I haven't worked with that directly, so I'm not confident either way. (Concrete example: GMail has additional integration with Google Calendar just like Outlook has integration with Outlook's calendar, but I'm not sure how that manifests at the protocol level.)
- jamesgeck0 4y agoAMP Email lets you build interactive emails for Gmail users. https://amp.dev/about/email/ https://amp.dev/about/email/
- wyager 4y agoYet another unreliable, overcomplicated piece of machinery managed by incompetent carriers, with terrible security and privacy properties. Our goal should be to turn cell carriers into dumb data pipes. They have demonstrated repeatedly that trusting them with more is a bad idea.
- mike_d 4y ago> I want a replacement platform that transparently functions the same way but better. We have that. It is called iMessage. It replaces SMS, has all the added features, and transparently "just works." You just need to upgrade your phone to one that has it. Google should be asking Apple to release iMessage for Android, not this silly "green bubble" campaign.
- woojoo666 4y ago> Google should be asking Apple to release iMessage for Android I believe people have already been asking this for years, to no avail
- CharlesW 4y ago> I don't want a different platform that functions similarly to SMS/MMS that I have to convince people to use, I want a replacement platform that transparently functions the same way but better. That solution is RCS… Sorry to break it to you, but at least some people consider RCS to be DOA in that respect. "Text messaging used to be a cash cow for carriers, but with the advent of unlimited texting and the commoditization of carrier messaging, there's no clear revenue motivation for carriers to release RCS. The result is that the RCS rollout has amounted to nothing but false promises and delays. The carriers nixed a joint venture called the 'Cross-Carrier Messaging Initiative'¹ in April, pretty much killing any hopes that RCS will ever hit SMS-like ubiquity."² ¹ "Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile kill their cross-carrier RCS messaging plans" https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/04/verizon-att-and-t-mobile-kill-their-cross-carrier-rcs-messaging-plans/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/04/verizon-att-and-t-mo... ² https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/google-enables-end-to-end-encryption-for-androids-default-sms-rcs-app/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/google-enables-end-t...
- Handytinge 4y agoFor the record, the vast majority of Androids lifecycle, Google has also not supported RCS. This is a recent uptake, after they shut down their 8th failed messaging platform. The "RCS" that Google implements does not follow the standards that have been around decades. The interopability and push for RCS is a marketing exercise.
- protomyth 4y agoIn the US, I fully expect the whole "green bubble" thing to escalate into something tragic for some high school students. I didn't think much of it until I saw the bullying and dropping of people because they wanted "their blue back". If you don't get your teenager an iPhone in the US then your kid is going to face some added difficulties.
- supertrope 4y agoKids will always find a reason to bully others. Conspicuous consumption is not a solution to teaching kids about respect. Corporate marketers are eager to exploit insecurity by presenting their product as the solution to your problems, or even create a problem to create demand for their “solution.”
- nemothekid 4y ago>If you don't get your teenager an iPhone in the US then your kid is going to face some added difficulties. If you don't get your teenager Nikes/Birkenstocks then your kid is going to face some added difficulties. Kids will bully kids for not having iPhones regardless; blue texts wont change that.
- CharlesW 4y ago> If you don't get your teenager an iPhone in the US then your kid is going to face some added difficulties. FWIW, I personally don't think this ranks as something today's kids worry about. My sample size is just two, but both are on a bunch of text chains with peers. All chains are a mix of Android and iOS users, and they tell me that nobody cares.
- wahern 4y agoShout-out to Conversations (conversations.im) for their amazing Android XMPP client. Server-side (Prosody) I still experienced plenty of headaches with multi-user chat and push notifications. And the Apple alternative, Monal (monal.im), while functional, is not on par--I've had trouble with the macOS client, and an iPhone friend lost push notifications for a few months for no identifiable reason. But Conversations is amazing, making all the other hassles of self-hosting group chat tolerable.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- etchalon 4y agoWhat percentage of Android phones out there can use RCS?
- ggm 4y agoVery good question. It probably has two parts: % android version can do it, and % carrier config willing to enable it. My MVNO on telstra (RCS enabled) apparently doesn't, and coincidentally doesn't do VOLTE either (which telstra does do)
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoSomebody make an SMS answering machine that just replies to texts with "Hello, this is an automated reply! I don't use SMS for text messages; please download WhatsApp in order to message me."
- mr_toad 4y agoSome people will flat out refuse to use a Facebook property.
- mkeedlinger 4y agoTrue, there are dozens of us!
- fmajid 4y ago70M WhatsApp users signed up for Telegram and 32M for Signal when Meta tried to ram new TOS allowing Facebook access to WhatsApp user data, and that’s why they backed down. That scummy company forfeited the benefit of doubt a long time ago.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago....you could change the text....
- hammyhavoc 4y agoUse Tasker if you want to achieve that.
- pier25 4y ago> That's why it's finally time to push for your iOS-based friends and family to abandon their blue bubble group chats and move to a third-party chat platform. That's what most people do outside of the US. In Mexico for example everyone is on Whatsapp. Even iPhone users don't use Messages. It's pretty amazing users in the US still rely on SMS to communicate between iOS and Android.
- parker_mountain 4y agoIt's absolutely frustrating how Apple is refusing to even come to the table on this. RCS is an unmitigated piece of shit, but Apple won't even propose an alternative. And yes, the burden is on Apple here. They have the lock-in.
- adamdusty 4y agoWhy would they? In the US at least, there is pressure at a social level to have an iPhone. My friend group clowns me on a regular basis for having an android and my green bubbles. What other business has that kind of pressure on anyone, especially teens and young adults?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rjbwork 4y agoSounds like a shit friend group tbqh. I have never had it be a point of contention with anyone I know. Anyone who actually cared about this green bubble, which I'm just finding out is a thing in this thread, would make a swift exit from my life. It's beyond stupid and petty, bordering on absurd and childish.
- parker_mountain 4y ago> Anyone who actually cared about this green bubble, which I'm just finding out is a thing in this thread, would make a swift exit from my life except: it's not irrational as you might expect. seriously! green bubble means that your single android friend has just downgraded your fun, interactive group (or solo) chat (with tapbacks, effects, group features, rich content integration, and cross device syncing) into some weird, featureless set of messages the only solution you have, as an android user, is to convince your friends to use a cross platform chat. I personally try to get people to use Signal. the simple reality is that the default messaging story on android is a hot mess, and apple has done a vastly superior job at the feature set and integration. and, having an android user "drag us down" naturally leads to denegration
- inoffensivename 4y agoCan somebody explain to somebody who's apparently way too old for this stuff what RCS is if it's not Revision Control System?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoRich Communication Services. https://jibe.google.com https://jibe.google.com
- dataflow 4y agoRich Communication Services, I think. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWhoops! Yes! There's the 4am brain in full effect.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoI’m glad I’m not the only one who thought of RCS as the precursor to CVS and SVN and finally…GIT.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ohCh6zos 4y agoAll the alternatives off the top of my head seem worse. WhatsApp, for example, is owned by Meta. Maybe Android could pick up Matrix support out of the box?
- s3p 4y agoThat's what I'm thinking about. They don't want to text people so they move to a Meta-owned service. I feel like we should all use Signal at that point.
- allset_ 4y agoHow about Signal? It uses phone number as identifier so you keep your contacts list, and the app works with SMS (on Android).
- GekkePrutser 4y agoSignal is still a walled garden. Officially you're not even allowed to use a third party client on it. Better to have something both open source and open network (and even decentralized) like Matrix. It's also got a phone number matchmaking service for those who want it I believe, but for me it's a plus that it doesn't use the phone number as ID so you don't automatically have to share your number with everyone you chat with.
- tadfisher 4y agoMoxie's gone though, so there's still hope.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoIndeed, he was the most opposed to third-party clients and federation. I do also hope they will change their stance on these points, it would make Signal a lot more attractive to me.
- heywoodlh 4y ago> Better to have something both open source and open network like Matrix I love Matrix, but non-technical people don't care about these points (I do, though). Matrix needs to have a better official client than Element at its current state before I think it's even worth looking at becoming mainstream. (I run a Matrix homeserver for myself with literally all of my chat communications going through it) Edit: my comment sounds super defeatist, I want to clarify that my hope is that Matrix can become something I can recommend to anyone
- kuon 4y agoA matrix based solution could be cool. With phone number as identifier and home servers hosted by carrier, this way it's not too centralized.
- 29083011397778 4y agoYes and no. Hosted servers for normal people, tacked onto another charge they already pay, thereby making it way easier to get people to pay? Great idea. Getting locked into one carrier indefintely, like with ISP-hosted email? Less great.
- kuon 4y agoISP email are an important factor on why email federation still work. But not all ISP are evil, here we have a lot of city operated ISP with free minimal service.
- fredski42 4y agoThis might force a change for the good: https://www.protocol.com/bulletins/europe-dma-apple-imessage https://www.protocol.com/bulletins/europe-dma-apple-imessage
- dividefuel 4y agoIt's frustrating juggling 5-6 different apps to do basically the same thing. It's effectively impossible for separate social circles to all agree on the same app, and the lack of interoperability means you're stuck. The preferred apps don't even align by the types of people that use it -- that is, I don't have a 'family' app, 'friends' app, and 'personal business' app because they all overlap.
- GekkePrutser 4y ago> I don't have a 'family' app, 'friends' app, and 'personal business' app because they all overlap Umm how do you expect that would work? One man's friend is another man's family :) I agree the fragmentation is super annoying though. I use matrix with protocol bridges now to bring almost everything in one app.
- kmeisthax 4y agoApple: "If you want to sideload, buy an Android" Also Apple: "If you want to text Grandma, buy an iPhone" My read into that: "People who run unreviewed code on their smartphones are so dangerous that we need to socially ostracize them from their parents"
- fingerlocks 4y agoYou can sideload on an iphone for a mere $8.33 a month purchase of a developer profile. This myth needs to end. Yes, there's some friction- you do have to compile the project first- but seriously clone-compile-install can be done in two shell commands. You can even run a coveted JIT compiler and install non-safari browser.[0] [0] https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/main/docs/ios/build_instructions.md https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/main/docs/i...
- Semaphor 4y ago> You can sideload on an iphone for a mere $8.33 a month What a take. Pay us every month to be able to own your device. We’ll take it back if you stop paying. At not even a small payment, that’s over twice what I pay for my, admittedly very cheap, contract.
- fingerlocks 4y agoYou do own the device. You can jailbreak and install whatever you want. The payment grants you software access to system calls that are blocked by apps installed from the AppStore and has nothing to do with the underlying hardware.
- WirelessGigabit 4y ago
- Ekaros 4y agoThat seems horribly expensive so just in 50 years of use I would have to pay nearly 5000 more... Insanity.
- jandrewrogers 4y agoI have several messaging clients installed, by virtue of working and having friends all over the world. Since I use many of them regularly in many places, it has allowed me to come to a few conclusions based on my experience. First, anything that requires a telco to be actively involved in service delivery beyond being a dumb IPv4/6 pipe is going to be terrible. Inserting those dysfunctional companies as man-in-the-middle on a global scale ensures mediocrity. RCS is a bad idea on that basis alone. Second, iMessage is really good. It is consistently the best messaging app I've used in multiple dimensions. I use many other messaging apps on a daily basis and this gap is hard to ignore. WhatsApp is pretty strong in the greater ecosystem of messaging apps, but it isn't up to the standard of iMessage. There are other common apps used around the world are quite a bit worse. Too many messaging apps focus on trite features while underinvesting in a strong architectural core, and it shows. Third, if you are going to have a big tech company orchestrating all of this, you can do a lot worse than Apple. Something being cross-platform or globally popular doesn't absolve it of being run by ethical organizations. Many popular messaging apps are expressly forbidden in some contexts, so they simply can't be used. I've never come across such a case for iMessage (or Signal), though I'm sure it probably exists somewhere. There is a case for a strong cross-platform messaging app, but RCS isn't it. And whatever it is, it needs to be at least as good as iMessage or iMessage people won't use it. Average users just want something that is feature-rich, high-quality, and without a creepy company behind it. Most alternatives to iMessage struggle to clear this hurdle, so they feel like a downgrade to iMessage users. I don't think it is a tall order to produce something to the standard of iMessage but maybe I underestimate the difficulty because it doesn't seem to happen.
- grok22 4y agoI have never used iMessage (I use Android phones). What is the 'really good' part of it? I am used to WhatsApp and it seems pretty perfect to me. Just enough features as a messaging app, but not too much.
- cafed00d 4y agoA few “delightful” features are: 1. When sharing multiple photos a carousel of photos is created instead of a boring boxy grid of photos. 2. You can paste stickers of your Memoji (Apple’s Bitmoji) onto text bubbles. All my friends have discovered that feature through me and they love it! 3. You can send balloons or confetti for “happy birthday” messages. 4. The latest and greatest hardware features always have tight, polished iMessage integration (on-device Siri driven replies, Dynamic Island UI bounciness etc) 5. The UI has a few nice touches like loopy loops for threaded conversations, fun animation when a message is deleted, super tight integration with Siri
- ghusto 4y agoThis cleared up something that's puzzled me for a while. Now I understand the talk over these blue and green bubbles in iMessage, it's a U.S.A. thing. Meanwhile over in Europe, we're trying to get people away from WhatsApp and on to things like Signal. Nobody gives two hoots about iMessage :D
- realusername 4y agoI'm not even sure people know that iMessage even exists in Europe, it looks like an SMS client so it will be considered as such