7 ms·
I would be shocked if they didn’t issue all employees YubiKeys.
by saagarjha 4y ago
I would be shocked if they didn’t issue all employees YubiKeys.
- bombcar 4y agoI my experience, prepare to be shocked. And even if they do, they likely have a “backup” for people who never seem to be able to use the Yubikey right.
- pm90 4y ago
- metadat 4y agoThis is false, a gross oversimplification. Every organization has complexities, it doesn't reduce to a common idiocy. Even when the net result is idiotic in hindsight.
- kirbys-memeteam 4y ago
- metadat 4y agoIt sounds like you're experience has been at a small firm. At scale, 2fa and yubikeys are a no brainer with regard to risk vs reward/ safety. Do you think all security engineers or whatever you want to call them are total incompetent idiots? If yes, I can't help you. If no, then you don't need further explanation from me. Security requires a complex balancing act, and in this case they got it wrong, end of story. As stated elsewhere in this thread, there are only those who've been breached and those who don't know they've been. End of story.
- kirbys-memeteam 4y ago
- metadat 4y agoThe bigcorps don't make exceptions for Tiny Tony's. If you work at these sorts of firms, you should probably start an anonymous exposé blog, it would be enlightening for the rest of us. It would also probably help get things fixed so they could avoid further embarrassment before it becomes a real problem (like in this case). I bet you could make a fair sum from the ad impressions alone, and feel good knowing you were acting as the force multiplier for positive change. Edit: Your personal jabs aren't in the spirit of a collaborative or curious conversation. You've revealed yourself as just another 007 wannabe. Boring.
- kirbys-memeteam 4y ago
- smegsicle 4y ago
- kirbys-memeteam 4y ago
- michaelt 4y agoCorporate security teams are built on three different traditions: 1. The policy/compliance tradition - the kind of people who looked at PCI-DSS and decided that was what they wanted to devote their life to. The accountants of the tech world. You've got resources and want to roll out U2F? That's not in the policy document, we'd rather spend the resources on this great audit of our suppliers' compliance that I've been planning.... 2. The be-lazy-be-popular tradition - for the team that hires a guy to reduce other people's workload, not increase it. Resources to roll out U2F? I won't stop you if you've got the money to spend, but what we've got is probably enough - a lot of companies don't use U2F, you know. 3. The hacker tradition - the kind of people who see every real, exploitable vulnerability they find as proof of their 1337 status. They don't care if a policy document says you should disable paste, that's bad advice, don't do it. Rolling out U2F sounds like a great idea - but a lot of corporate environments will chase these types out, or curb their enthusiasm by ignoring their reports. Perhaps kirbys-memeteam worked in companies with security teams that tended more towards traditions 1 and 2, while your employer's security team had more of tradition 3?
- staticassertion 4y agoExplain why what is false? You're just making vague claims about anecdotal experiences. It seems unlikely, in general, that a security team would not support a Yubikey rollout. Even one that only cares about compliance would likely support it because it will make compliance easier - auditors care a lot about phishing and if you can say "OK, yeah, we had some users fail the phishing test again BUT our 2FA is phish-proof" that's an easier conversation. I'm sure there are truly lazy and incompetent security teams out there but it makes no sense that they would be the majority or even particularly prevalent. Maybe you're just unlucky and ran into one, or maybe there were real reasons why a Yubikey rollout wouldn't work; a) Who's going to ship the keys? Yubico provides services for that, will you use those? Pay for them? b) Who's paying for this? Did your infra team ask the security team to pay for it? Who's paying for replacements and support? c) Is this a high priority for the team vs other issues? d) Do all of your vendors support Yubikeys or are you going to have to have a hybrid solution? What will migration from vendors configured for some other FMA solution to Yubikeys look like? I support a rollout at any company, for the record, but these vague statements with the conclusion of "security people don't care" leave a lot to be desired.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd even when you do get it setup you end up having to make all sorts of exceptions for various people who can’t be told “no”.
- pm90 4y agoPainfully true. And once that exception is made, its easy to poke holes for more requests, until the security systems becomes somewhat pointless.
- BarryMilo 4y agoWhat? Security is the one domain I found where you can't just waltz in because you've heard of a computer. You need to do the work upfront with Sec+ or the like, it would take months for a newbie. Past that point, what more guarantee can you have? Even work experience can be meaningless if they weren't in the right team/role.
- kortilla 4y agoSecurity is a cost center, not a profit center. Most companies cut that investment to the bone, which means paying the bare minimum that lets them check boxes. This is true for basically any non-tech company, and is true for like 75% of the tech companies. > You need to do the work upfront with Sec+ Sec+ is part of the paper mill parent is referring to. A book of terms to memorize for 3 months and then call it good.
- vishnugupta 4y ago+100 Not only is it a cost center it’s also seen as a hindrance to the fast progress. Rarely will you come across an exec who takes security seriously. For them it’s just a checkbox at best and an obstacle at worst. I’m speaking about application security though. It’s possible that IT sec, physical security etc are taken more seriously.
- tyingq 4y agoCuts both ways, of course. There are terrible IT Security departments that don't understand the concept of false positives, create approval flows for critically needed items with 2 week SLA turnarounds, topple the network with poorly designed endpoint security scanners and tons of useless telemetry and so on.
- softveda 4y agoThat is why government intervention is needed. Australia is proposing significant changes to its cyber security framework and legislation. https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/reports-and-pubs/files/strengthening-australia-cyber-security-regulations-discussion-paper.pdf https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/reports-and-pubs/files/streng... Mandatory cyber security obligations backed by penalties and direct government intervention for critical national security companies. https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/reports-and-pubs/files/exposure-draft-bill/exposure-draft-security-legislation-amendment-critical-Infrastructure-bill-2020.pdf https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/reports-and-pubs/files/exposu...
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Security exists just to check boxes at most firms And then you get the bullshit solutions that the OP was complaining about. Nobody serious ever claimed that SMS based MFA was secure. Large companies implemented it anyway, and pushed it into unknowing developers nonetheless.
- sullivanmatt 4y agoA lot of people still have legacy Yubikeys floating around, and these are replayable. What you need now is something like the Google Titan FIDO2 key or one of the Yubikey FIDO2 keys. Transitioning an entire company to these, getting everyone to self-enroll, and then removing the ability to use all the less safe options across the employee base, contractors, etc is not cheap nor easy, and of course requires a massive amount of retraining. It's not as trivial as just buying them, sadly.
- metadat 4y agoWhat retraining? You install the yubikey by plugging it in, registering it, and using it by tapping it as needed. What is complex? There was literally no training involved for this during my time at ElGoog. One wiki page covered it adequately.
- fphhotchips 4y agoFor someone who claims to have worked in big corporations and accuses others of not having worked in them, you sure are optimistic about the capabilities of the average user. Not every company is Google. For starters, how do you register the Yubikey? On Okta, this is a multi-step process with at least one non-obvious step, and one easy way to screw it up.
- saagarjha 4y agoThe people who work at Google are not smarter than the people who work at Uber, or any other tech company. Getting people to understand 2FA might take a little bit of work but it's not hard.
- allset_ 4y agoWebAuthn (well, U2F, but that's essentially WebAuthn with a slightly different browser API and WebAuthn is backward compatible with U2F only devices) support has been on the YubiKey since the Neo in 2014 [0]. It's basically impossible to have a YubiKey that does not support WebAuthn. You do not need FIDO2 on-key resident credentials to benefit from WebAuthn. [0] https://www.yubico.com/blog/neo-u2f-key-apps/ https://www.yubico.com/blog/neo-u2f-key-apps/
- junon 4y agoThey did for a while but it was too expensive. Uber uses OneLogin, who I'm sure is also investigating. We had apps on our phones that received as "is this you trying to log in?" notification. You had to consciously hit "Yes" in order to continue the login flow. It wasn't offline 2FA like Authy or something. There _was_ a much higher standard of security there. This was _social engineering_, something that even the finest MFA algorithms don't guard against.