12 ms·
Should traffic lights be abolished? (2021)
- PaulHoule 4y agoWalt Disney thought so. When traffic is light, traffic lights make you wait a long time for no reason. When traffic is heavy they add insult to injury by taking 2 or 3 cycles to clear out the stack of traffic you're waiting in -- and that's just the immediate intersection, frequently traffic stacks up to the point that traffic flow is impaired in preceding intersections. That's how traffic lights turn a 5 minute drive into a 50 minute drive.
- stop50 4y agoOnly if you have idiots for traffic planning. By now you can have sensors that detects vehycles on lanes and change it depending on the situation. only two lanes are in use: permanent green until a car on the other lanes come.
- Someone 4y agoPermanent red on all lanes until traffic arrives may be better. It allows you to safely switch to green faster on whatever lane traffic arrives from.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhen traffic is light (e.g. at night), the traffic light can be scheduled to blink red in all directions. Then it is treated like a simple stop-sign intersection.
- bombcar 4y agoSome around here blink yellow on the main road and red on the side street at night. Works decently well.
- bell-cot 4y agoI've see a lot of sensor failure modes which that algorithm would handle poorly - complete failure, failure to notice small/light vehicles (especially motorcycles / scooters / bikes), mis-reading which lane a vehicle is in, ... I've also seen fancy sensor-equipped traffic lights where the traffic flow was improved by a power outage turning the intersection into a (legal default) 4-way stop. Major intersections. During rush hour.
- Someone 4y ago> I've also seen fancy sensor-equipped traffic lights where the traffic flow was improved by a power outage turning the intersection into a (legal default) 4-way stop. Major intersections. During rush hour. That fits one of the main points made in this article: traffic lights slow down traffic. Another one is that decreasing speed on intersections increases safety. The magic of roundabouts is that they accomplish the latter without needing the former.
- EricMausler 4y agoThere is one of these on a backroad near me. I wish the sensor were farther away from the intersection so I wouldn't have to come to a complete stop just as it turns green. The general traffic is probably 95% favored to the direction I am going, and I really wish they would just leave it green until the other direction actually needs it. Maybe they have it this way on purpose to indirectly prevent speeding? I wonder if that's a consideration for traffic light logic or not
- bell-cot 4y agoI regularly have to drive in Ann Arbor, MI - by one account the #1 most educated major-ish city in America ( https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2017/07/25/ann-arbor-most-educated-city-america/507748001/ https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2017/07/25/a... ). We are definitely stuck with idiots for local traffic planning. And those clever sensors - there is a huge difference between (A) a traffic light checking that Feature Box in PowerPoint (or Flash, or Microsoft Bob, or whatever software the local traffic planners use), and (B) traffic sensor technology being usefully implemented at the light's real-world location.
- TotempaaltJ 4y agoHere's a good video on why (and where) none of these things have to be true: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KPGVP85WpU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KPGVP85WpU
- LinuxBender 4y agoShould traffic lights be abolished? No. Phased out over time in some places maybe, not abolished. Implemented in some new developments, absolutely. While roundabouts can work more efficiently they require the roads and traffic usage patterns to accommodate them. Additionally existing intersections designed for lights and putting in roundabouts would require cities in many cases to use eminent domain to acquire the land around them or to buy out land/properties from people. The excessive use of eminent domain would lead to endless legal battles that would deplete city budgets. Some existing large intersections could be retrofitted for a roundabout and some small cities are in fact doing this. I've also witnessed this occurring in rural areas that have intersecting highways where the state already owns the land around the highways. This reduces brake dust, engine brake noise and keeps freight moving.
- bubbleRefuge 4y agoDidn't read the article but flyovers maybe expense but can get the job done. Wish there were more of them at major intesections
- andsoitis 4y agoConcur with your thinking. At the same time, I took "abolish traffic lights" as a North Star for future design as well as making changes to existing infrastructure where economically and physically feasible (i.e. stay practical). Not rip out all traffic lights everywhere and replace them with roundabouts or rotaries, as the case might be.
- gpderetta 4y agoAnd then you get roundabouts with traffic lights like in the UK. I'm sure there are good reasons for that, but, as someone that hardly drives in the UK, I was very very surprised the first time I encountered them.
- anyonecancode 4y agoOh, that's nothing. Here in New Jersey, we have what my wife refers to as a "traffic theta". Here's an example: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.7957351,-74.3405952,17z https://www.google.com/maps/@40.7957351,-74.3405952,17z It's a circle, with traffic light, but also still an intersection. Fun!
- aareet 4y agoI've discovered the game Mini Motorways on Apple Arcade recently and this has opened my eyes to how much more efficient roundabouts are in traffic management :) I've been enjoying the game a lot! It's a very enjoyable thought experiment made into a game. If you haven't tried it, I'd recommend it.
- cortesoft 4y agoI am curious at what traffic levels roundabouts stop being more efficient. I know in Cities Skylines, the roundabouts will deadlock over a certain traffic level. Like, would roundabouts work on the 4 lane roads that are always packed with traffic here in Los Angeles?
- bsagdiyev 4y agoDoubtful. The roundabouts placed in some places in the IE still had people going the wrong way and just generally not understanding how they worked. You'd need to do education along with implementation for something like that to help. Personally I doubt it would help traffic in any significant manner but who knows.
- toast0 4y agoRoundabouts are best with a range of traffic from very sparse to intermittent. Always packed from all directions doesn't work because throughput is structurally limited and worst case wait time is infinite. It's kind of like a cloverleaf junction, very functional until you hit capacity limits, then not very functional. In most of the Los Angeles area, there's not room to drastically expand intersections to build usable roundabouts, compressed roundabouts are even worse at throughput. Multilane roundabouts exist, but they're tricky to navigate and would be tough to have high throughput for if most people want to continue traveling in the same direction after the intersection.
- incomingpain 4y agoI wish freakonomics had an rss feed. The thing that's happening right now is that many large cities have more or less enabled the possibility of carless transport. Cycling is now completely viable and even better, costco has a foldable ebike for like $400. Weather sucks? Work from home instead. Gotta go? Taxis and buses exist. What do you pay in car insurance? $1000/year? How many trips in the bus is that? Many! You also dont pay for parking anymore. Cycling is great exercise burning fat instead of money. It's a huge net benefit to society which is 70% overweight. National wealth will certainly increase. Which brings me to traffic lights. Cyclists already don't obey them. Why don't we just abolish them? Traffic lights function just fine when they go out or blink red. If stop signs replacing all traffic lights is an inconvenience for cars... might I recommend a bike?
- alexb_ 4y agoWhy do anti-car people not seem to understand that people don't want to ride a bike everywhere? You can't just tell someone to completely change their lifestyle to avoid potential problems, and then act like they are the insane ones for not wanting to listen. I want a car. I like my car. Demanding that people give up their ability to get in a car and drive somewhere so that all of America's infrastructure can be changed is insanity. >The thing that's happening right now is that many large cities have more or less enabled the possibility of carless transport. I actually like to leave the cities I live in sometimes. Or maybe I don't live in a city, and I want to visit it with my car.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe ability of exurban dwellers to visit a city with their car is of no interest to the people in that city. Why should they care?
- ghaff 4y agoAre you sure? A city that’s unwelcome to commuting workers, local visitors coming in for entertainment, shopping, dinners etc. may not be a city that the city dwellers want. Of course they’re welcome to discourage visitors however they want.
- downvotetruth 4y agoThis is absurd.
- smileysteve 4y agoThe automatic transmission should be abolished first. And all energetic cars should be in golf cart pedal mode. Whether it's on the highway or around neighborhoods with speed bumps and pedxing, you see (and hear) cars speeding away only to endanger the next person at the next stop sign or traffic light, or car in front of them. (I can "1 pedal drive" my manual down a hill in 2nd or 3rd, go a reasonable speed, automatically be slowing to go over a speed bump)
- rhn_mk1 4y agoWhat is "golf car pedal mode"?
- smileysteve 4y ago1 Pedal driving, ie, regen brakes apply whenever there is no pressure on the gas. In a manual transmission this is from engine braking, without gas applied, it immediately starts slowing down. This makes traffic flow better by reducing the need for last minute stopping, predicting when you need acceleration, reducing speed automatically when the driver is cautious, and generally increased attention and awareness.
- 2rsf 4y agoMany electric vehicle can do 1 pedal drive, but what is the gain? I once calculated for my Polestar that it can save something like 1 meter of braking distance or less from 100km/h, so not super impressive.
- trgn 4y agoI have no idea with pedal driving is, but if you mean that traffic lights invite that pathetic type-A kind of driving, accelerating to the next lights only to immediately have to break because the next light is turning red, yes, that's totally dumb and needlessly endangering others. Drivers should totally smooth out their speed, slow acceleration, slow deceleration. When you drive like a gentleman, you'll find out you rarely have to break.
- JetSetWilly 4y ago
- thanatos519 4y agoIt works in some places. This intersection is way, way better to walk and cycle through since the traffic lights (and all signs!) were removed, and I have never seen cars stuck or delayed: https://bikecity.amsterdam.nl/en/inspiration/experiment-traffic-lights/ https://bikecity.amsterdam.nl/en/inspiration/experiment-traf...
- Neil44 4y agoI grew up near Skelmersdale which is a ‘new town’ built in the 60’s without traffic lights, all roundabouts. Traffic is segregated from pedestrians using underpasses and footpaths don’t follow roads generally. Some aspects of it work well. It’s pleasing and efficient not to have to stop much when you’re getting places. The underpasses have become magnets for anti social behaviour though.
- wizofaus 4y agoHow does that work for bicycles? As a cyclist most roundabouts are OK but busy multi-lane ones can be pretty terrifying if you need to turn against the traffic flow (i.e., taking the 3rd exit, right for me, but left if in the US or any country you drive/ride on the right side of the road). I've yet to see a decent solution to that.
- alistairSH 4y agoThe best answer is a completely separate bikeway that crosses outside the roundabout, or passes over/under the road. But, if that's not possible, the bike is either acting like another car (in the roundabout) or a pedestrian (crossing several entry/exit points). Less than ideal, but still better than getting t-boned at >30kph as happens at 4-way stops in the US. Here's an example, but it relies on drivers yeilding to cyclists (they're supposed to but usually don't in the US, regardless of intersection and signage). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wEXD0guLQY0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wEXD0guLQY0
- wizofaus 4y agoYeah even that Netherlands one (which is only possible if there's a lot of space available) relies way too much on drivers actually bothering to look out for bikes. I'd rather have traffic lights to be honest.
- gumby 4y agoThe mistake is that the cars should use the subways/underpasses since they are inherently antisocial already. The antisocial types can then all hang out together.
- KIFulgore 4y agoI live near Carmel, Indiana, the roundabout capital of the US. Small ones, large ones, figure 8's, figure... double-peanut-looking things with elevated crossovers near interstate junctions. They work well and keep traffic moving. But there is a learning curve. Every new roundabout causes a significant jump in crashes for a short time. Though, those crashes tend to be "glancing blows" that cause less serious injuries due to the angle of attack imposes by the roundabout. Smaller cities and towns in Indiana are adopting more roundabouts near congested areas. It's important to introduce them gradually and give drivers time to acclimate. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/20/climate/roundabouts-climate-emissions-driving.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/20/climate/roundabouts-clima...
- mobilene 4y agoI'm near Carmel too. I remember when the roundabouts started going in. They replaced four-way stops that backed up for miles at rush hour. The roundabouts made traffic flow SO much better. Now Carmel is replacing some stoplights with roundabouts. This man's opinion is that they are not always better. But so far, they've never been worse.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThey absolutely suck when a train of cars forms and you can't enter the loop. Those are the dumbest roundabouts in the country. They don't adequately force cars to slow down enough to let gaps develop in the flow.
- lesuorac 4y agoI'm not sure that slowing the cars down would help more. Its much easier to drive literally right behind a car at a slower speed than a higher speed. Afaik, the general trend is to put a stoplight going into the roundabout for the few directions that cause a problem so that the "side streets" get a chance to go.
- smeej 4y agoThe other stupid thing about Carmel roundabouts is where they put them at every 3rd road crossing when it would have worked absolutely fine just to have the traffic going one way stop, because it's a neighborhood with thoroughfares and cross streets, and there is NEVER traffic on the cross streets. It just makes the thoroughfares slower for no clear reason.
- trgn 4y agoYes. We should start everywhere with turning them off and introducing four way stops. Then re-assess which intersections need that light, or need a roundabout. Traffic lights invite aggressive driving because drivers want to make it through the green (or orange) light. Basically, drivers end up accelerating into the intersection, rather than slowing down and be more careful. It's the _exact_ opposite of what should happen. Traffic lights are the result of a misplaced obsession with efficiency and high technology. The idea we can perfectly manage complex systems (very mid 20th century mindset). We need a value shift. Safety is more important than speed.
- rascul 4y agoI've found four way stops to be dangerous and unpredictable with more than two lanes each way.
- trgn 4y agoYes, I'd agree. Let's start with reducing those to two lanes then as well :)
- oangemangut 4y agomostly agree but as other posters have mentioned I would imagine that any crashes that occur in in mulit-lane 4-ways are likely to be less severe/likely to injure people.
- booboofixer 4y agoCame here to comment this. I've seen two-lane stop signs and if you imagine traffic on all four sides, just think of the number of other drivers you have to coordinate with if nobody is sure who has the right of way. I've also seen two lane roundabouts which aren't bad, but now there are roundabouts where you go from two to one, or two to three lanes driving inside the roundabout! Definitely safer than stop signs but the most un-intuitive intersection for new drivers.
- abfan1127 4y agono, traffic lights are efficiency. Traffic is easily modeled as buffers and context switching. As traffic flows through an intersection, the buffer for that direction drains. When it switches, there is a penalty to context switch (the traffic must come to a stop, some traffic must finish through the intersection). The perpendicular buffer (which has been filling), requires the intersection to clear completely before proceeding. Then its buffer can empty. 4-way stop signs introduce context switching for every car (the intersection must clear before proceeding) and you must stop every intersection, buffer stalls. Round-abouts ensure more rapid context switching (only wait for the car to your left to clear), no waiting for an empty buffer to continue to be empty, and fewer buffers per intersection (think left turn buffer, right turn buffer).
- strken 4y agoRoundabouts are great on back streets where you'd naturally be going slowly, and okay on the meeting point between two major roads, but in my extremely limited experience they don't work so well in the case where you have a major road (light would usually be green to let large amounts of traffic through) crossed by a street (light would usually be red, intermittently green for a few cars). Perhaps in that case you're meant to use overpasses, or maybe the data says that roundabouts work fine, but they don't seem to.
- balozi 4y agoThere are tons of roundabouts that have traffic lights too.
- samcat116 4y agoThose are generally rotaries, not roundabouts.
- dncornholio 4y agoThe Netherlands is stuffed with these things. The amount of traffic lights I have to go trough to get to work is: 1. This is a 30km trip from town to town. The only part of my route that I always have to stop, is the traffic light. Roundabouts are awesome. Our complete infrastructure is pretty awesome to be honest. Other countries could learn.
- graton 4y agoOne of the large benefits of roundabouts is the reduction in serious crashes. 90% reduction in deaths, 76% reduction in injuries, and 35% reduction in all crashes. [1] 1) Cars need to slow down to go through the roundabout safely, 2) If there is an accident it is more of a side-swipe type accident than a t-bone or head-on accident. But as others have said they aren't the best solution for all situations but they could be used a magnitude more than they currently are here in the U.S. [1] https://www.oregon.gov/odot/Engineering/Roundabouts/Roundabout-FAQ-How-to.pdf https://www.oregon.gov/odot/Engineering/Roundabouts/Roundabo...
- noobermin 4y agoI think only the netherlands does it better but in the US roundabouts are generally worse for pedestrians to cross.
- bombcar 4y agoThe problem for pedestrians is the flow of traffic never naturally stops, so you are either waiting forever or dodging cars. However, you may only have to cross one lane at a time which may be a bit better.
- jimmygrapes 4y agoPedestrians shouldn't be anywhere near roadways imo, but that's a whole other discussion
- falcolas 4y agoI mean, if you want all your roundabouts to be demolished by semi trucks and other construction vehicles. And the price for the transportation of goods increased due to increased damage to trailers and the semi trucks themselves. Personally, I love roundabouts. They're fun to drive around. But I have seen (and there's lots of reports about) semi tucks crawling over them at 5mph or less because they're all built too small to support a semi with a 50' trailer. My vote is, once we eliminate the need for Semi trucks for deliveries in the city, sure. Roundabouts everywhere. But until then, let's keep infrastructure sane for all the users of it.
- samcat116 4y agoMost roundabouts have a very short skirt around the middle island thats like 10 feet wide just for this reason. Theres a curb so normal cars don't go on it, but it allows wide trailers to cut over them just fine.
- bombcar 4y agoEven those get destroyed in pretty short order. All the smaller ones around here have chewed up kerbs
- falcolas 4y agoThey do indeed. And those still damage trailers and require semis to slow way down. The aprons also get damaged by the heavy trailers since they're not built to the same standards of roadways.
- bilsbie 4y agoI suppose you could make the inner part something safe and non destructive to drive on but still uncomfortable so trucks could still make it through. Maybe Make rumble strips? Still have a structure in the very middle to prevent head on crashes though.
- smm11 4y agoI'm in Southern California, and traffic lights are already ignored. (YT - Fiery, fatal Windsor Hills crash)
- coding123 4y agoI love how people say "abolished" so easily and don't realize the magnitude of change it would require. /aside In any case, Arizona has a LOT of roundabouts. They take considerably more land so it would basically be impossible for the vast majority of existing in-city street corners. Arizona uses them more in rural/not yet developed areas. Definitely help speed up things, but I would say at this point, it will only be useful for new, very spread out cities.
- ahoy 4y agoZero consideration for pedestrians, typical of US traffic engineering. Sucks here.
- autokad 4y agoyeah its 2020 thinking "I believe X so everyone everywhere should always have to do X".
- alistairSH 4y agoA nice visual showing why roundabouts are usually safer than simple intersections... https://nextstl.com/wp-content/uploads/9577583353_3c13fe8144_o-1.jpg https://nextstl.com/wp-content/uploads/9577583353_3c13fe8144... [the triple pedestrian conflict at each entry threw me at first - but if you consider where the driver is likely looking, it makes sense]
- tengbretson 4y agoIt'd be nice if the people installing roundabouts in the United States could stop their habit of splitting lanes of traffic into multiple lanes, each with different rules for which direction you can exit with about 20 feet of notice before you enter.
- JoshuaEddy 4y agoThis is a feature, not a bug. Once you learn the general philosophy, you will be fine. For a 2-lane roundabout: Use right lane if you want to turn right. Use left lane if you want to turn left. Either lane is fine if you want to go straight. It's like when you approach a traditional 4-way intersection, some of which add a left-turn-only lane and some of which add a right-turn-only lane: once you learn the general philosophy, you will be fine.
- autoexec 4y ago> It's like when you approach a traditional 4-way intersection, some of which add a left-turn-only lane and some of which add a right-turn-only lane: once you learn the general philosophy, you will be fine. Those bug the shit out me to too. Sure, you get used to them quickly enough when you drive on those roads all the time, but everyone who hasn't encountered it has to figure it out and depending on how well marked it is even people familiar with the rules have to deal with confused people who haven't figured it out yet. I especially hate those left-turn-only lanes which leaves people who could have turned right on red stuck behind people who just want to go straight. The people who want to go straight would have to wait for a green light anyway, so why not leave them stuck behind the left turners who also have to wait and let traffic flow for the people making right hand turns?
- jsmith45 4y agoI agree with that. I used to be one of VERY, VERY few drivers that ever when straight at a certain intersection with a left turn only lane, and a straight and right turn lane. The other direction was bigger, and there was a relatively long wait for the light to change once a vehicle detection was triggered. I always felt bad for the people behind me because I was blocking from making a right on red. It would have been so much better if it was a right only, and straight+left lane. There is of course an exception to this. If there is a protected left turn cycle, then the left turn lane needs to be its own lane, but that was not the case at the intersection in question.
- ztetranz 4y agoI'm from New Zealand where we have lots of roundabouts. My observation is that they work well, even with heavy traffic except some unbalanced conditions that can happen at rush hours. Imagine this. Driving on the right. Roundabout with four exits. North, East, South, West. Heavy streams of traffic entering from north and west. Most traffic exits at east therefore nothing to slow north enterers. West enterers hopefully get the breaks in north entering traffic. Trying to enter from south is really difficult because north and west enterers keep it full.
- angus-g 4y agoI have seen a few roundabouts with metering traffic lights that are only enabled during peak traffic times to occasionally allow the “blocked” directions in. It seems to be a reasonable compromise.
- palmetieri2000 4y agoKia Ora, Im from a chunk of Australia known for a tonne of roundabouts and observed the same issue. My theory is that this is actually roundabouts working as intended, despite the frustration of the South-Enterers. Basically, if the flow of traffic is both moving too fast and with too great a vehicle density to allow for safe entry (even if slow, like 1 SouthBound Vehicle for 5x Northbound + 5x Westbound) then the traffic organism is actually distributing resources based on need, rather than convenience. The flow WILL automatically correct itself as the population of vehicles diminishes, the question is if the WAIT time for Southbounders (and the population of Southbounders) is sufficiently large that interfering with their flow is actually delaying more people than the North and West routes, but that is more of an issue of roundabout placement than it is the roundabout itself being inefficient. (^^The above is all 100% observation and guesswork, anyone with some education on the matter want to chime in?)
- jimmygrapes 4y agoIt's a good load balancer for sure, but that doesn't help the poor sod who is in the minority who has to wait for ages simply for not needing to go the same direction as the majority.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIn my neck of the world, the traffic cops, for some reason that I can't even fathom, switch off traffic lights after 11pm at a lot of major roads. It doesn't lead to as many accidents as you'd think, but boy is it a nerve wracking experience crossing these roads at night.
- giantg2 4y agoWe have some that turn into flashing yellow for the main road and flashing red for the secondary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Maursault 4y agoBy now designing and mass producing the smart traffic light should be possible for not too much extra beyond the cost of the dumb traffic light. A smart traffic light system could effectively eliminate most traffic. A traffic light that is aware of oncoming traffic or the absence of it will remove the annoying instances of being stopped at a traffic light when there is no cross traffic, or of remaining on a timed green waiting for traffic that isn't there. Some cars nearly drive themselves now. Everything has a computer in it, why not traffic lights and intersections? Why hasn't traffic light technology advanced beyond timers and switches in the road? They need to have eyes and decent logic built into them. Imagine the fuel/cost/carbon savings alone if we had these things widely installed 20 years ago.
- throwaway894345 4y agoSimple things fail less often, require less maintenance, and are less likely to be hacked. I'm not saying these concerns are the most important, but they deserve consideration.
- fl0wenol 4y agoThese exist in many different generations (sensor-based traffic control devices) but as there are state and/or local certifications each solution and implementation must meet to be deployed, plus the additional cost of installing and periodically calibrating sensors, they are not warranted unless the situation calls for it. The inconvenience of waiting an extra minute at a minor cross-street doesn't usually cut it. If you live where there is a light that causes disruption or accidents because it needs sensors based on the traffic flows nearby, you should bring it to the attention of your local government. At the very least you could get them to do a study on it.
- Arubis 4y agoIf you’d like to simulate traffic light abolishment with no replacement, visit beautiful Denver, Colorado, where the sun is strong, the beer is cold, and the red lights are purely decorative.
- throwaway894345 4y ago* Laughs in Chicago *
- giantg2 4y ago"and the red lights are purely decorative." Philly has been notorious for this regarding stop signs.
- randcraw 4y agoAnd the first few seconds of red lights.
- mellavora 4y agoIsn't Amsterdam also famous for its decorative red lights?
- gumby 4y agoCalifornia made a (tiny) push into roundabouts a couple of decades ago, but for some inexplicable reason usually pair them with stop signs. What's the point?
- anonporridge 4y ago"Tell me you don't understand roundabouts, without telling me you don't understand roundabouts." California: "Hold my kombucha."
- professoretc 4y agoThe only roundabouts I've seen in CA with stop signs are the big ones (like the "traffic circle" in Long Beach) where the roundabout is almost a street unto itself.
- gumby 4y agoCome to Palo Alto where they are equipped that way on small residential streets! Massive ones like you describe don’t need stop signs.
- MiddleEndian 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelley_Square https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelley_Square Adding some sort of pseudo-rotary has made Worcester, Massachusetts's Kelley Square go from Massachusetts's most dangerous intersection down to its eighth most dangerous intersection lol Somehow still never had any traffic lights at any point. Before: https://www.wbjournal.com/sites/default/files/2019-10/kelley_square1.jpg https://www.wbjournal.com/sites/default/files/2019-10/kelley... After: https://www.gannett-cdn.com/presto/2020/12/31/NTEG/86da81b0-1c81-4ccd-a116-47da1269064c-LOC_Worcester_aerials_1.JPG?width=660&height=495&fit=crop&format=pjpg&auto=webp https://www.gannett-cdn.com/presto/2020/12/31/NTEG/86da81b0-...
- wolpoli 4y agoIt looks like they reconfigured the intersection into a roundabout, which eliminated the weird geometry of the previous design and reduced the options available to drivers to just entering and exiting roundabout.
- xani_ 4y agoNo wonder, they added a nice straight for cars to speed up before the other cars merge into it.
- giantg2 4y agoIn my area people complain about needing new lights all the time. They theorize that there would be fewer accidents if they put in a light at certain intersections. The real problem are the drivers. Almost all the accidents I see at those intersections are from people being impatient and making bad choices. Those same people are going to do the same stuff by trying to beat the light or make a right on red and screw up. We can try to make the road design better, bit the biggest benefit would be to address where the ultimate responsibility for safety lies - with the driver. Yet the people will complain and get their new light, and we'll impose largely arbitrary restrictions on new drivers while letting the chronic crash causers slide and the people who would objectively fail better testing drive.
- autoexec 4y agoIn what ways do we let "chronic crash causers slide"? What changes would meaningfully alter their behavior? I'd argue that most bad drivers know what they're supposed to do, and can be on their best behavior during a driving test, but don't care about anyone other than themselves. As soon as they can they'll start cutting people off, dangerously passing, running red lights, etc. In the US, the penalties for crashing your car at this point is often being forced to buy a new car since even low speed accidents can total your vehicle, then you also have your insurance rates skyrocket, and you're often on the hook for a lawyer and showing up to court where you can face being responsible for hundreds of thousands in medical expenses. It's a pretty damn punishing system for people who cause accidents. I suspect that most people (alcoholics aside) are not going around getting into one car crash after another after another. It's just vast numbers of assholes each of which thinks it won't happen to them until it does.
- giantg2 4y agoI know a kid who totalled 3 cars before the end of high school and had one or two fender benders. Whether he was physically unable (ADHD) or actually knew what he was able to do but didn't, this is the type of person that shouldn't be on the road. It can be as punishing as you say, but rarely is. People buy cheap used cars so it's not expensive as you might think. Basic liability insurance isn't crazy either. You'll rarely go to court unless you are uninsured. And insurance will typically cover medical expenses, and comprehensive will even help you buy a new car. It would be pretty simple to revoke people's license if they cause more than one accident in 5 years.
- cameronh90 4y agoTraffic lights aren't the main problem: four way intersections are. Roundabouts, offset T-intersections and grade separation all make traffic safer by removing conflict points - it's not the removal of traffic lights that improves the safety. Four way intersections put traffic directly on collision paths at high speed, meaning if anyone makes an error (missing the light or otherwise), you have an awful crash. It's relatively rare in the UK to have four way stops or high speed four way signal controlled intersections. One of the weird things about driving in the US for me was the prevalence of both of those things.
- palmetieri2000 4y agoThis the most salient point to me, it is absolutely unbelievable to me that the US continues to use four-way intersections despite the huge risk, loss of life and suffering they cause. They are exceptionally rare in Australia too, if they do exist it is only on a road with a speed limit of 60km/h (at least in my region). Coincidentally, where I live is known for its many many roundabouts and not only are they safer but they also offer superior cross-way throughput when traffic is heavy. And they allow the "middle" of the intersection to store a chunk of traffic who are protected from full speed impacts while still letting vehicles flow slowly through the perpendicular axis.
- dmz73 4y agoI live in Australia too and while roundabouts are OK for low to medium sized road and even larger roads with even traffic they absolutely do not work for heavy and uneven traffic. I have seen a number of large roundabouts become a congestion point once the traffic became heavy and mostly coming from one or two directions. Once they converted those roundabouts to intersections with traffic lights, the congestion eased significantly. So, roundabouts can work but not in all instances.
- perilunar 4y agoThere's a couple of roundabouts south of Sydney that have traffic lights controlling the entry flow during peak traffic periods. Seem to work well.
- stazz1 4y agoThe goal should be to eliminate waiting
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI find the traffic roundabouts a great solution for seattle residential streets. It allows a slow down through the neighborhood, a way to negotiate the four way intersections, and helps with the narrower than normal roads.
- anotherevan 4y agoI live in Victoria, Australia, and we’ve had roundabouts for ages. I think they are very good for a certain scale of road/traffic. Mostly intersections with moderate amounts of traffic on average, and not high-speed. e.g., the main intersections within housing estates. Having too many of them instead of give-way signs drive you a little batty (I’m looking at you, Warrnambool) while really heavy traffic, major intersections work better with traffic lights. When teaching my kids to drive, they found roundabouts one of the trickier intersections to navigate. You have to read the traffic flow. This person about to enter on your right is going straight ahead, so will block you entering the roundabout[1], but they have to wait for that person coming the other way from you and going straight through, so you can slip in the gap that creates without cutting anyone else off. As with many things it is familiarity and practice that makes them work[2]. I think roundabouts work very well here for the most part. It’s not rocket science[3]. The science of roads and traffic I imagine is a surprisingly nuanced expertise involving a lot of physics and psychology. I find when I cross over the border to New South Wales I feel like a long-tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs. I eventually figured out it was because the signage was a different distance before the intersection compared to my home state. Once I was aware I could adapt. [1] We drive on the left side of the road because Australia is in the southern hemisphere. [2] I bet the first traffic lights caused an uproar. “Why the hell should I stop just because there’s a red light?!” [3] Oh wait, actually, it is rocket science.
- asah 4y agolol, roundabouts in Tokyo or Manhattan... imagine... a skyscraper in the middle... underground entrances to it... mechanicals on the ground floor because nobody wants to have cars coming straight at them...