6 ms·
Tornado Cash and bullets
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoThis was a really quite insidious action taken. No longer innocent until proven guilty or not being judged because of worst case use or misuse. Now we are getting into police state type of mentalities when it comes to money. It's bad and dangerous enough that we treat (force) banks, CC and PPs as pseudo unofficial law enforcement and hold them accountable legally, but now this! Great read.
- machiste77 4y agoIn the analogy provided (comparing a smart contract in a money laundering case to a gun in a murder trial) - wouldn't the responsibility lie with the person who operated the instrument? In the gun analogy, wouldn't the comparison be putting the CEO of Smith & Wesson on trial because someone used one of their pistols in a murder? Like a pistol, the Tornado Cash smart contract has legitimate and illegitimate use cases.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoThe comparison would be the CEO of Smith & Wesson setting up a smart contract which mails a pistol to anyone who deposits 0.5 ETH. I definitely expect he'd go to jail if he did that, even if he explained that actually he just put the pistol in a box and the mail system autonomously caused that box to be delivered.
- woodruffw 4y agoRight. Regardless of any personal position I have about guns, it's clear that one actually had to go out of their way to possess one. Smith and Wesson doesn't make people purchase their guns and so, at least naively, it doesn't make sense to hold them responsible for every murder that happens with their guns. On the other hand, if someone could demonstrate that S&W intentionally sells guns to markets where they know people will go and murder with them, you could draw a connection. And that is something someone could possibly demonstrate!
- soco 4y agoHmm, people in the US market do commit murder using S&W. How is this known fact helping? I think it needs more meat before being used as an argument.
- ARandumGuy 4y agoMaking comparisons with guns in the US isn't a great comparison, because the US has a lot of explicit protection for guns, gun owners, and gun manufacturers. These same protections do not exist for other industries, including banking.
- o_1 4y agoYes they're tools. they have tried suing gun manufacturers (even though they have protection for defense industry reasons). Automobiles are used in DUI fatal crashes every day. Do we condem alcohol or car manufacturers for their use in crashes? Furthermore do we condem auto manufacturers for vehicular homicide? Usage isn't bound to malicious intent.
- throwaway98797 4y agoimagine this thought experiment “You are presented incontrovertible evidence for the fact that your post inspired someone to kill” should we lock you up for murder?
- woodruffw 4y agoI think you meant this to be silly, but we do actually do this. Cult leaders are held responsible for the actions of their adherents, given the degree of control necessary to compel someone to kill on their behalf.
- realce 4y agoOnly if they instruct their followers to actually commit violence though.
- woodruffw 4y agoRight. That's the "incontrovertible evidence" part. The analogy requires each step to actually be true.
- mc32 4y ago…yes?… but it’s more than you were a cult leader and your follower did something bad. You have to have psychologically manipulated them as well -ala Manson.
- woodruffw 4y agoYes, hence "incontrovertible evidence." I think the GP was trying to introduce some ambiguity with "inspired" instead of "manipulated."
- throwaway98797 4y agothis helps the point reasoning by analogy across different criminality is filled with risks i’m hopeful society and eventual the law will catch up with what is reasonable. sadly, i suspect what is reasonable to the majority won’t be reasonable to me. or worse yet the flaw of reasoning will be borne by future generations like the blood letting cures of prior centuries i offer no solution only the occasional comment bordering on full blown troll.
- ballenf 4y agoAnd physical currency satisfies this analogy-test of causation more fully than Tornado cash. It's almost like the establishment of a national currency had as one of its goals fungibility of notes as a priority (over notes from any of hundreds of local banks and trading of IOUs).
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoDespite its name, Tornado Cash was not a currency. There wasn't such a thing as "4.2 Tornado Cash" that you could trade for goods and services. The operations it supported were depositing money in exchange for a secret and using that secret to withdraw that money in full, and the only intended use case was to disguise the source of your funds.
- 3pt14159 4y ago> This seems reasonable from first principles: we don’t sanction rubber band manufacturers for making the bands that hold laundered money together, bag manufacturers for making bankers’ bags used by launderers, &c &c. This is where all the reasoning falls apart. We do sanction these things. We sanction types of paper commonly used for printing different countries currencies. We sanction types of metal alloys that are most useful in fissile material production. We literally sanction guns and bullets. Tornado Cash is a large chamber, fully automatic, machine gun. We should sanction it and remove it because what it is most usable for is mowing down large amounts of people, not helpfully killing a wolf that's about to eat an Albertan heifer. To us programmers language and code and free speech sure seem like all the same thing, but as you zoom out it stops being language and it starts being technology. I don't want gangsters and kleptocrats tornadoing cash. I want order and good government and societies built on peace, trust, and reliable justice.
- tablespoon 4y ago> To us programmers language and code and free speech sure seem like all the same thing, but as you zoom out it stops being language and it starts being technology. Excellent observation. You could claim a gun is just a metal sculpture and therefore protected by free speech, but that's not going to fly because it's an unreasonably expansive interpretation. There are a lot of pretty bizarre ideas tech people often have, because they're too focused on tech and too immersed in the tech subculture to see their blindspots. IMHO, it's pretty useful (especially as a tech person) to start with the assumption that any "techie" idea or attitude that intersects with any non-tech thing is majorly flawed (e.g. using "technical system" mental tools where they're inappropriate, a tendency towards oversimplification or over-consistency, engineer's syndrome and other kinds of ignorant arrogance, etc.).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- junofan 4y ago> I want order and good government and societies built on peace, trust, and reliable justice. I mean everyone wants that. Why give a small group of people so much power to achieve it? Doesn’t the US government have enough power over people’s finances already to achieve those aims?
- bgitarts 4y agoHe said the developers deployed tornado cash. How does he know they did? Maybe they only released the source code and another party deployed the code.
- teknopaul 4y agoMakes no difference, in the analogy this is passing the gun to someone else and telling them to pull the trigger. You still get life for that, it's still considered murder.
- WFHRenaissance 4y agoBroken analogy. Tornado Cash is more like a gun manufacturer than a gun passer in this case.
- TakeBlaster16 4y ago> I believe in privacy and free expression. What I don’t believe is that we can make these things out of computers; they come from norms and law, designed and negotiated by and between free people. When we put it in a computer, all we’re doing is asking for someone to formally circumvent it rather than find a legal loophole. In doing so, we transform a process into a permanent state and fundamentally freeze our ability to make progress. If norms and law were the only tools we had, nobody would have communications privacy. Every large government around the world is constantly battling against privacy. When the government turns against its people, technology can help. The only realistic solution for privacy in today's environment is to "put it in a computer" using encryption. Would you also argue that instead of adopting HTTPS, we should have written a letter to our congressman?
- lottin 4y agoIf the government turns against its people, we have a bigger problem that will not be solved with some made-up currency or money laundering for the masses. Don't be a fool.
- TakeBlaster16 4y agoIt already has turned against us. In the 1800s with the USPS, we had ultimate privacy - nobody could open physical mail without a warrant, under strict legal penalties. In modern times we have the third-party doctrine[1], where the moment bytes leave your network you have "no reasonable expectation of privacy". If you want privacy now, you can never give anyone any data or do business with any third party, including relying on a third party to route your network packets. Or you can take matters into your own hands, with encryption. If someone calls me a fool for using HTTPS and encrypted messaging, I'm fine with that. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine
- lottin 4y agoGet a grip. The fact that you personally or somebody else doesn't agree with a government policy doesn't mean that the government has turned against its people.
- sanxiyn 4y ago> Tornado Cash qua smart contract is the bullet, and Tornado Cash qua entity with developers is the person pulling the trigger. This seems incorrect. Tornado Cash developers have no ability to execute code. Rather, "deployment", is in actuality Tornado Cash developers proposing the code for execution. Ethereum miners execute the proposed code, and they can refuse to execute.
- woodruffw 4y agoI propose that the gun fires, and divine providence can refuse my wish! More seriously: this is actually an interesting point. But I don't think it overrides the argument: nobody would propose a thing if they had a strong reason to believe that it would be immediately refused. The Tornado Cash developers had every reason to believe that the Ethereum network would pick up their code, and that is in fact what happened.
- sanxiyn 4y agoI am not saying Tornado Cash developers are not culpable. Rather, I am saying Ethereum miners are culpable as well as Tornado Cash developers. Consider a case of botnet whose command and control server runs in AWS. Botnet developers are responsible, but Amazon is responsible as well, and Amazon should (and will) shutdown the command and control server.
- irn00b 4y agoPrivacy is a critically important part of our society that has been lost in the advent of digital banking. Recognizing that there are governments and institutions eroding privacy of cryptocurrencies by forcing regulation at the exchanges necessitates other methods for anonymity. By the same argument, guns are meant to kill things, that is their primary function, yet we do not go after the gun manufacturers based on morality. Just because something can be used for harmful purposes, does not mean that it has no useful purpose in our society.
- jdmichal 4y agoPrivacy of the system that has a centralized, open ledger as a primary feature? The only thing private about these systems is who owns any particular address. But once an address is pinned down to an entity, the entire history of that address is an open book.
- RandomLensman 4y agoIf you want different policies, go for the policy not technological circumvention.
- snarf21 4y agoI thought the big promise of crypto is that it is censorship resistant. I think people who are in the crowd of "not your keys, not your crypto" forget that "not your infrastructure (including on/off ramps), not your global decentralized network"
- josh2600 4y agoI want to echo this sentiment: Change in society depends upon privacy. Women’s suffrage would not have happened without the ability for women to meet in secret to plan public assembly. This is also true of the civil rights movement. Gay marriage required gay relationships which were also illegal at the time. Imagine how much more oppressive the in-crowd can be with perfect surveillance of financial transactions. To be clear, I think money and speech are different. I also believe that a fully financially surveilled society is a totalitarian state where free speech is impossible. We have to find a compromise where we retain some semblance of privacy in the digital banking era. To lose any hope of privacy is to accept tyranny. It is possible for us, as technologists, to build systems that both comply with the law and create privacy for the customer, at least in the US as the laws are written today. The danger is the incredibly rapid expanse of surveillance powers as they relate to finance. Please take a moment to research what is happening in the US right now. This is the front page of Bloomberg from a couple days ago: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-09-12/china-s-surveillance-state-will-be-the-west-s-future-too https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-09-12/china-....
- jimcavel888 4y ago
- Test0129 4y ago> This post is solely intended to establish a common-sense argument (and ideally, general intuition) for statutory action by the U.S. Treasury. Every time I hear "common-sense argument" I am expecting to be greeted by partisan nonsense. > No, probably not. The error is apparent: the bullet only traveled because something made it travel. The something that made it travel is the gun, and guns do not make bullets travel unless someone or something pulls their triggers4. For this particular bullet and gun, that someone is the defendant. I don't like this analogy because the area of self-defense law is extremely murky. (a) incontrovertible evidence that someone shot someone else simply proves that, and does not prove or disprove self-defense. Moreover there have been more than enough cases of accidental failure that make this analogy extremely leaky. > For example: Imagine if the defendant were to have forced the victim to put their head in a noose and their feet on a stool, with the stool tied by a rope to the leg of a horse. It would be absurd for the defendant to claim that he were innocent of murder because he “merely” spurred the horse into pulling the rope5; we can recognize that the victim’s death by hanging follows necessarily and foreseeably from the defendant’s action. Basically, that one scene with Tuco in The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. This example should've been the leading example. There's no ambiguity here. > Tornado Cash (as a smart contract) is the clear instrument of action. As designed by its programmers, it necessarily launders money: there is no way to make it not launder money, because it cannot distinguish money laundering from “legitimate” tumbling. This is a hot take with VERY dangerous implications. Using the treasuries own definition [1] > Money laundering involves disguising financial assets so they can be used without detection of the illegal activity that produced them. Laundering is only with illegal money. If I take my legal dollars, convert them to gold, then convert them back to dollars this is "laundering" under the definition of the author. If I deposit money, and then take it out as cash this is also laundering under the definition. > For parsimony: Tornado Cash exists, effectively, to hack around the public and immutable nature of the distributed ledgers it runs on. In other words: it solves a self-inflicted problem, one that regulatory agencies are correct to identify as unnecessary (and can evidence this by pointing to the billions of people who accomplish their financial goals without it). If I have cash that I let sufficiently "age" under my bed and I convert it to gold, is the gold seller responsible if I then use that gold to commit a crime? Billions of people are completely happy using fiat to accomplish their goals. This is dangerous Nanny State level implication. The underlying implication of OPs post is that because something is designed on its principles to evade the tracking system of the "greater" system, then it must be used in crimes. > And if you don’t think sanctions are valid at all, well, fine. This post probably isn’t for you It sounds like my assumption was correct. Yet another "common sense" take that is actually partisan nonsense. While I don't know the entire case of Tornado Cash, or if it's used to launder money any more than a regular cryptocurrency or any other number of ways you can launder money, the idea of punishing an entire idea (tumblers in general it seems) for being used this way is insanely heavy handed. Carefully chosen definitions, and a misunderstanding that so, so many instruments that are not tornado cash can be used for it's purpose weaken the author's arguments for sanctions. It is indeed a hot take, and the only thing common sense here is relying on the readers lack of knowledge of financial systems and the assumption that evading a tracking system implies laundering rather than the other way around. [1] https://www.fincen.gov/what-money-laundering https://www.fincen.gov/what-money-laundering
- coding123 4y agoA lot of people are making really bad analogies: Guns are a generic item and they have more purposes than killing people. A machine gun has more purposes than mowing down people. They are generic items used for defense also. The NUMBER ONE usage of a machine gun, as used by people that are not in law enforcement, daily, a million times a day in the United States is: cash protection. You think those armored car drivers don't think they are USING a machine gun every time they park at a designated stop? The usage is deterrence. That's a highly valuable purpose for a machine gun. Also, if the ONLY people using tornado cash are "the bad guys stealing money" then it would be easy to find that only one person is using them. But no, a lot of people are using it, therefore there's more than one usage than just "bad guys cleaning money". It might be good guys cleaning money or don't want a known transaction to be known publicly, even if the transaction was clean. T.C is a generic item like a bag. edit: Also, don't let them fucking take away your rights.
- UncleMeat 4y agoWhat armored cars have an automatic fire gun located on them?
- Pils 4y agoTo a certain extent, isn't this all a moot point? The sanctioned ETH addresses associated with the Ronin hack didn't use the immutable TC contract, they used the proxy contract[0][1] which can be updated from the Governance address (which is controlled by the Tornado Cash DAO). It appears that the transactions happened after the Treasury Dept. published the sanctions list. To use your metaphor, a person who it would be a crime to sell anything to went to a gun vending machine to buy a gun. Given the nature of gun vending machines, it would be difficult, but not impossible for the vending machine company to prevent this scenario. However, in terms of assessing whether a legal violation occurred, it doesn't matter that the item the person bought was a gun, if the gun was then used to commit a crime, or if the item was instead a rubber band or a brown paper bag, or if the gun vending machine company designed the gun/band/bag or produced the gun/band/bag. [0] Proxy contract: https://etherscan.io/address/0xd90e2f925da726b50c4ed8d0fb90ad053324f31b#code https://etherscan.io/address/0xd90e2f925da726b50c4ed8d0fb90a... [1] sanctioned address using Proxy contract: https://etherscan.io/address/0x4bf2c2956942b2dd40517bce423917311f564d16 https://etherscan.io/address/0x4bf2c2956942b2dd40517bce42391...