8 ms·
One day, I believe car design regulations will be amended to allow fully electric braking (ie. no hydraulics, drums, rotors, or pads). At that point, the moto
by londons_explore 4y ago
One day, I believe car design regulations will be amended to allow fully electric braking (ie. no hydraulics, drums, rotors, or pads). At that point, the motor can be moved into the wheel (unsprung mass = bad, but weight savings from not needing an axle or gearbox will outweigh this). Suspension and steering design is then far easier, because there is no axle to need to keep straight.
Braking redundancy will be achieved by having motors/brakes on all four wheels, and within each motor 3 independant phase coils with independant controllers, such that there are effectively 12 brakes on a car. Normally the controllers work together for smooth braking, traction control, software differential, etc. But even after 3+ failures braking performance should still be satisfactory for an emergency stop.
Obviously braking energy needs to go somewhere. In the happy case, it's regen'ed into a battery. If the battery can't accept it, it gets dumped into dump resistors. If the dump resistors fail, it gets dumped into motor coils (of which there are 12 remember). Obviously the motor coils will heat up very fast, so this is probably a one-use-only failsafe, like airbags.
So the whole system (except the pedal itself) is 12 way redundant.
- ComputerGuru 4y ago> Obviously the motor coils will heat up very fast, so this is probably a one-use-only failsafe, like airbags. Replacing airbags (at least individually) is cheap enough. Having your entire engine-equivalent need a replacement just to reduce the sprung weight?
- ben_w 4y agoI don't claim any physical engineering skills, but don't you need a mechanical (non electrical) system for parking breaks?
- hollywood_court 4y agoNope. Many modern vehicles have push button electric parking brakes.
- KingJulian 4y agoI would think so too. Any parking brake has to be a fail-safe type brake which has to function in the absence of electricity. Hence, as you mentioned, purely mechanical.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoIt only has to remain engaged, engaging it in cars with push button parking brakes requires electricity to drive a small electric motor at each wheel.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoThey need to be able to remain applied without power, but the application can require power. In my Tesla, I push a button and I can hear an electric motor engaging the brake.
- londons_explore 4y agoYou do, yes. But that can be a metal pin the size of your pinky finger. It's a super easy engineering challenge compared to the regular brakes that slow down the car, which, when emergency braking a 2 ton car from 100 mph, needs to briefly absorb nearly 1 megawatt. Thats the power used by 1000 houses, which is a lot to absorb in a lightweight system that needs to still work if part of the system fails.
- thatcat 4y agoThe parking brake is the emergency brake, cant be a pin
- 2III7 4y agoYou don't, many modern cars have electronic parking brakes with small electric motors mounted on the rear calipers which push the brake pads against the discs when activated.
- nicoburns 4y agoIf it's using brake pads, then it's still a partially mechanical suggestion. The comment at the top of the thread was suggesting doing away with brake pads entirely!
- forgetfreeman 4y agoI am very glad you commented here as my initial skepticism of your claim lead me to do a spot of research that answered several unresolved questions I'd had about one of the most obnoxious features I've ever seen in a new car. My mother in law has a car with (apparently) electronic parking brake and I have loathed everything about it from the moment I first sat down in the car. This at least explains why an utterly unintuitive double toggle button replaced the "standard" mechanical lever on the center console and what notional benefits (hill holding) come with this system. I'd hate this a lot less if the manufacturer had included a tell-tale of some kind to visually indicate if/when the ECM thinks the P-brake is engaged.
- jasode 4y ago>, but don't you need a mechanical (non electrical) system for parking breaks? To some of the replies... I think some clarification needed because the wording caused folks to think of something else such as electronically _controlled_ physical brake pads: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_parking_brake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_parking_brake I think the gp was trying to ask about feasibility of electric _powered_ magnetic field resistance braking ... similar to an exercise bike ... which would require constant electrical power source. (Similar to : https://www.google.com/search?q=magnetic+resistant+braking+of+exercise+bike https://www.google.com/search?q=magnetic+resistant+braking+o...) Magnetic field resistance brakes is practical for regenerative braking but not safe for parking brakes on an incline if the batteries run out of juice. The context is the gp's premise of no physical friction brake components via "(ie. no hydraulics, drums, rotors, or pads)."
- whiplash451 4y agoNot a mechanical engineer. This design is interesting. Do you think regulation is the only reason this did not happen yet? Why is nobody building this otherwise?
- londons_explore 4y agoThe main reasons against this are: * Regulation. Plenty of countries are very specific about the exact mechanicals of brakes, in laws that are 100+ years old from when runaway cars killed people. * Unsprung mass. Cars handle better if the wheels are very light and all heavy bits are in the body of the car. * Large diameter motors are harder to design - there is no opportunity for a gearbox, so you lose one design parameter, and need the motor magnetics to be right around the rim of the wheel to make up for it. * Difficulty of making the air gap within the motor very thin at such large diameters - you end up needing super large diameter roller bearings. However, I think despite those downsides, the benefits outweigh them.
- meragrin_ 4y agoWhat about potholes? Wouldn't they lead to the premature death of the motors if not the wheels themselves?
- 3pt14159 4y agoThat's an awesome idea! I'm looking forward to the day where beamed power (e.g., MASER) will allow us to ditch most of the batteries too, with a tow trailer battery pack for trips into the deep country. It makes no sense to me to accelerate and decelerate over a ton of battery pack and have to deal with so much regeneration loss when we could just have overhead beamers optically track vehicles and cut power whenever a stray bird enters the picture.
- bilsbie 4y agoThe government will turn off the MASERs on hot days though …
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt probably makes more sense then a huge infrastructure build of giant maser units that would have to be able to simultaneously track hundreds of vehicles on every dense street corner and then you would have to put up mitigation for all the reflective power losses going through windows into peoples houses.
- jackmott 4y agoGearbox serves more purpose than just getting the power to the wheel, it also improves the efficiency of the motor and\or expands and optimizes the usable speed range of the motor. Also cars can stop way harder than any regen can, massive amounts of energy will be at play and likely any solution is more complex than just grabbing a rotor, which is a more direct way to heat dump
- lelanthran 4y ago> Suspension and steering design is then far easier, because there is no axle to need to keep straight. I don't understand what you mean by this. Isn't independent suspension already a thing? Each wheel has independent up/down movement because there is no axle that remains straight (driveshafts are independent from each other in both FWD and RWD).
- VLM 4y agoThere are no up-down movements in full size cars and trucks, some kids toys maybe. Everything bigger moves an arm along a radius, which is "close" to up and down but not up and down. Tire friction usually works on a vector-like system so being able to move more up-down rather than along a radius means maybe you'd get a couple percent more friction forward and back if not moving a little side to side when moving up and down. Which sounds useless, but 5% more usable tire friction means an improvement in braking and cornering performance which either makes the car safer or could theoretically make it cheaper/lighter to compensate.
- ryukafalz 4y agoThis is interesting because it also potentially solves the problem of particulate pollution from brake dust. There’d still be pollution from tire wear so it’s not a perfect fix but it gets partway there!
- mvgoogler 4y agoIs the Aptera doing this? I remember them talking about having the motors in the wheels but I'm not sure if it's what you're proposing.
- sbradford26 4y agoSo a big reason why this probably wouldn't fly is that it has a common mode failure which is loss of power. Most EVs don't use permanent magnetic motors so it needs power to be able to use the motors for regen. So lets say the relay fails from the main battery pack suddenly you have no power, and no way to energize the coils in the motors to use them to regen. This could be mitigated by using permanent magnet motors but you still have the issue if control power is lost the vehicle cannot stop. The beauty of hydraulic brakes is that they work really well with power, but still function without it.
- crgwbr 4y agoInteresting. Is there no way to design the circuitry so that when given no input, it defaults to a fully brakes-engaged mode? I’ve only worked with PM motors, so I know how that sort of h-bridge could be designed, but my knowledge of non-PM motors is fuzzy at best.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoHmmm. So you're travelling along the interstate at night, you lose power and your car screeches to a stop in the middle of high-speed traffic and your lights are off. I would love to be present at the DFMEA (Design Failure Modes Effects Analysis) meeting when this came up!
- Bilal_io 4y agoIf you're driving 75 mph and one or more motors suddenly lose power and it fully brakes, that's a certain death in my opinion.
- extrapickles 4y agoI could not find anything that would prevent this in my brief skim of FVMSS 105 (US car brake regulations). The regulations are mainly about the performance of the braking system (eg: needs to stop car 10x from 60mph in under a specific distance) and only care a little about the specific technique. You should see what you propose on cheap cars if motor pricing becomes less than the cost of regular hydraulic brakes. FVMSS 105: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2011-title49-vol6/pdf/CFR-2011-title49-vol6-sec571-105.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2011-title49-vol6/pd...
- Kon-Peki 4y ago> S5.1 Service brake systems. Each vehicle must be equipped with a service brake system acting on all wheels. What is a "service brake"? Notice that the regulation you linked to includes requirements for EVs that have braking regeneration as a component of their "service brake". It turns out that the top-level of FVMSS [1] says that "service brake means the primary mechanism designed to stop a motor vehicle." So I think you are exactly right. There is nothing in the law that says you can't use a 100% brake regen system in an EV. It just has to work and meet the performance standards (and perform regen on all wheels). But I'd guess that you aren't going to see the traditional brake system disappear unless it starts getting in the way. They don't cost a lot (relative to the price of the car), don't weigh a lot, are really reliable, and work really well. [1] https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/subtitle-B/chapter-V/part-571 https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/subtitle-B/chapter-V/p...
- manholio 4y agoYou should take into account that regen braking (even with resistors) only works at high rpm. The final phase of the braking you need to put even more energy into the coils on top of what the they already must dissipate for braking the car. Electrically, you would need to run the engine in reverse to come to a full stop.
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> You should take into account that regen braking (even with resistors) only works at high rpm. It's note even with resistors it's only with resistive braking that this applies. If this is an electric car then the inverter can be programmed to give pretty much any braking force you desire just by altering the phase of the driving waveform. This can be done at any rotational speed. My Model S can dump 50 kW back into the battery so long as the battery is not fully charged. At 60 km/h the kinetic energy of the car is about 300kJ so the car can be brought to a stop in about six seconds purely by regenerative braking. In the final phase of braking the car has hardly any kinetic energy left so the huge 250 kW motors can easily bring the car to a halt and hold the car still just by balancing the magnetic forces in the motor against the motion of the car or gravity. In fact this is exactly what it does when running on traffic aware cruise control in stop go traffic, whether on level ground or on steep slopes.
- afiori 4y agoMost importantly it would also allow to go away with the steering wheel and make cars with Tank Controls* as god intended. I jest, of course, but I would kind of like to drive a car with steampunk levers more in theme with the giant spider in Wild Wild West. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_controls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_controls
- bilsbie 4y agoThis could vastly improve ABS too. Right? We wouldn’t have to deal with pulsating pads and could adjust force in milliseconds. And maintenance would be way cheaper. Just remove the wheel and put a new one on.
- OJFord 4y agoWith no axle it'd also be a lot easier to allow them to turn 90 degrees (or 360(+), I'm just not sure there's any point), and have all-wheel turning, for optimal (and stupidly easy) parallel parking. I used to make Lego vehicles like that (well before I could drive), because it felt so silly as a passenger being parallel parked I suppose.
- thallium205 4y agoMost higher end electric stand-up scooters are actually setup this way.
- theluketaylor 4y agoHub motors will be common on scooters and other small electric vehicles, but it will never make sense on full sized cars. The size of motor required to move a car with the acceleration and speed modern traffic demands just won't work in a hub. Reduction gearboxes and axle-shafts already represent a pretty tiny fraction of the total mass of drive units on EVs and there are no mass savings coming on motors that will somehow get them into the range of acceptable unsprung weight, even axial flux motors. The whole industry is working on tighter integration of the drive unit components to reduce things like cooling circuits, length of high voltage cable runs, and the total mass of the components required to move the car. No one is working on splitting the motors out into the hubs. As you point out, unsprung mass is bad. Especially for something like a motor it's beyond bad, it's a complete killer of ride quality and reliability. As sprung mass the entire drive system can be isolated from all the knocks and oscillations that happen from driving around. A hub motor will get crashed and bashed around and have a miserable MTBF. The occupants will hate the car since it will have awful handling and hitting even moderate-sized bumps will be terribly unpleasant. Lighter stuff like scooters can get away with hub motors since there just isn't that much mass to begin with, but cars are huge now. Aptera is planning to use hub motors, but their car is the vapourist of wares and relies on being counted as a motorcycle under regulations. Their basic engineering just doesn't work when scaled to a 3500 pound car and beyond.
- mechanical_bear 4y agoI love when people make broad sweeping assertions of impossibility, they are often proven wrong.
- sdk16420 4y agoHub motors are in development for cars too, e.g.: https://lightyear.one/articles/lightyear-and-elaphe-develop-the-most-efficient-production-powertrain-in-the-world https://lightyear.one/articles/lightyear-and-elaphe-develop-...
- jonfw 4y agoModern brake systems are so good though, they're cheap, powerful, reliable, and easy to service. I am not sure that the juice would be worth the squeeze